Back to Authors

Dunbar, Nancy M.

https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8601-5438

Mayo Clinic

Dartmouth–Hitchcock Medical Center

Citations 9

Epidemiologic Study of Transfusion-Related Alpha-Gal Syndrome
Kaufman, Richard M., Hoen, Anne G., Khan, Jenna, Knudson, C. Michael, Romero, Andres E. Mindiola, Mo, Allison , Takanashi, Minoko , Collaborative, UPTICK Study Group; for the Biomedical Excellence for Safer Transfusion (BEST), Cardigan, Rebecca, Stanworth, Simon J., Commins, Scott P. , Scherer, Emily A., Davenport, Robertson D., Afraz, Sajjad, Andrews, Jennifer , Casey, John, Sullivan, Jensyn Cone , Cousins, Clara C. , Giorgi, Valeria De , Delaney, Meghan, DelBaugh, Regina M. , Gilstad, Colleen W. , Gofton, Alexander , Hill, Kate, Hogan, Keenan , Humbrecht, Catherine , Ikeda, Kazuhiko, Javanbakht, Ayda, Juskewitch, Justin E, Wojtowicz, Monique M. Menzies, Miller, Maureen J., Mills, Georgia, Nelson, Anna C. , Pauly, Marie C., Poisson, Jessica , Raval, Jay S., Samy, Nikitha, Sato, Tomohiko, Takeda, Yoshinori , Thibodeaux, Suzanne R. , Nunen, Sheryl van, Virk, Mrigender S., West-Mitchell, Kamille, Yamanouchi, Jun, Yoshihara, Satoshi, Zheng, X. Long, Ziman, Alyssa, Cone Sullivan, Jensyn , Kaufman, Richard Max , Hoen, Anne Gatewood , Knudson, Charles Michael , Metcalf, Ryan A. , Schäfer, Richard , Dunbar, Nancy M. , Cardigan, Rebecca A. , Stanworth, Simon J., Scherer, Emily A. , Cervinski, Mark A , Arai, Yasuyuki , Brugnara, Carlo , Allen, Elizabeth S. , Aurich, Konstanze , Casey, John , Cohn, Claudia S. , Crowe, Elizabeth P , Delaney, Meghan , Hendrickson, Jeanne E. , Hill, Kate, Ikeda, Kazuhiko , Jacquot, Cyril , Javanbakht, Ayda , Juskewitch, Justin E. , Lu, Wen , Wojtowicz, Monique Menzies , Miller, Maureen J. , Nelson, Anna , Pagano, Monica B. , Pauly, Marie-Christin , Saifee, Nabiha H , Sato, Tomohiko, Takeda, Yoshinori, Tiberghien, Pierre , Nunen, Sheryl van, Virk, Mrigender , Wood, Erica M , Yoshihara, Satoshi , Zheng, X. Long, Ziman, Alyssa

JAMA Internal Medicine | August 24, 2026 | Volume: No volume available | Issue: No issue available | Pages: No page available

10.1001/jamainternmed.2026.3983 Get It

Importance Recent case reports suggest that B antigen–containing blood products may be associated with anaphylactic transfusion reactions in recipients with preformed immunoglobulin E to galactose- α -1,3-galactose (alpha-gal). Objective To test the association of local alpha-gal syndrome (AGS) prevalence and allergic transfusion reaction (ATR) in patients with blood type O. Design, Setting, and Participants In this international, multicenter, retrospective cohort study at academic medical centers, sites were assigned to AGS high- or low-prevalence clusters based on the known geographic distribution of AGS. Data were collected on platelet or plasma transfusions and ATRs during 2020 to 2024. Consecutive patients receiving platelet or plasma transfusions were included. Exposures Patients with blood type O who received B or AB units and patients with blood type O who received O units (reference group) in AGS high- and low-prevalence clusters were compared. Main Outcomes and Measures Before data collection, the hypothesis was that if transfusion-related alpha-gal syndrome (TRAGS) is a true clinical entity, excess ATRs to group B or AB units would be detected in AGS high-prevalence regions exclusively. The main measure was the overall risk ratio (RR) for ATRs to B or AB plasma or platelets in AGS high- vs low-prevalence clusters. Results In total, 558 823 platelet and plasma transfusions at 40 sites in 5 countries were analyzed, of which ATRs occurred in 1744 transfusions (0.3%). In the US AGS high-prevalence cluster (9 sites), significantly more ATRs of any severity occurred among patients with blood type O who received B or AB units vs patients with blood type O who received O units (overall RR, 3.93; 95% CI, 2.96-5.21; P < .001). In contrast, in the primary analysis of the AGS low-prevalence cluster (15 sites), excess ATRs to B or AB units were not detected. In subgroup analyses among patients with blood type O receiving B units, the RR for moderate to severe ATRs was 9.14 (95% CI, 5.39-15.52; P < .001) in the AGS high-prevalence cluster vs 2.15 (95% CI, 1.34-3.47; P = .002) in the AGS low-prevalence cluster. Outside the US, a signal consistent with TRAGS was not detected. Conclusions and Relevance This cohort study provides provocative epidemiologic evidence that TRAGS may be a unique manifestation of AGS and a previously unrecognized risk associated with transfusion. In AGS high-prevalence regions, blood collectors and hospital transfusion services should consider approaches to preventing severe ATRs from B or AB plasma or platelet units.
Survey of cryoprecipitate production and cryoprecipitate and fibrinogen concentrate utilization in North America: Variable practices observed from July 2016 to June 2021, The BEST Collaborative Study
Lu, Wen , Ziman, Alyssa , Vassallo, Ralph R. , Poisson, Jessica , Grandoni, Jessica, Jacquot, Cyril , Germain, Marc , Young, Pampee P. , Collaborative, The Biomedical Excellence for Safer Transfusion, Ziman, Alyssa , Vassallo, Ralph R , Jacquot, Cyril , Dunbar, Nancy M , Cohn, Claudia S , Young, Pampee , Lu, Wen , Singh, Umesh Pratap , Shih, Andrew W. , Raval, Jay S. , Dunbar, Nancy M. , Cohn, Claudia S. , Collaborative, The Biomedical Excellence for Safer Transfusion

Transfusion | September 29, 2025 | Volume: 65 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 2091-2104

10.1111/trf.18434 Get It

Abstract Background Cryoprecipitated antihemophiliac factor (cryo) is primarily used to replenish fibrinogen in acquired coagulopathy. Little has been reported about its usage patterns within hospitals with respect to patient population, frequency of use, and dosing. Study design and methods Cryo production and usage data were collected over 5 years from July 1, 2016, to June 30, 2021, from nationally based blood collection centers in the United States (U.S. n = 2) and Canada ( n = 2) and from eight large academic hospitals, respectively. Usage data for a similar product, purified fibrinogen concentrate were also collected from four hospitals. Results Two U.S. blood collectors reported increases in cryo production normalized to total whole blood collections from 17.4% in 2016 to 22.3% in 2021 and from 16.4% in 2016 to 20.2% in 2021. In contrast, in Canada cryo manufacturing increased slightly in one region (11.3%–12.9%) and decreased (8.0%–2.0%) in the other. Cryo utilization, defined as numbers of patients treated normalized to the inpatient census, and dose administered per patient did not consistently increase and differed significantly between hospitals participating in the study ( p < .0001). Likewise, the departments that most frequently transfused cryo varied between hospitals. Similarly, variations in practice were observed for fibrinogen concentrate usage. Conclusion While much of Canada and Europe have moved towards using fibrinogen concentrate, two large U.S. collectors have increased cryo distribution. The lack of standardization and variability in the clinical practice regarding the use of cryo and fibrinogen concentrate reported by study sites may be attributable to practitioner preference, availability, and/or cost rather than adherence to published evidence or guidelines.
Why do people still make anti‐D over 50 years after the introduction of Rho(D) immune globulin? A Biomedical Excellence for Safer Transfusion (BEST) Collaborative study
DelBaugh, Regina M. , Murphy, Michael , Staves, Julie , Fachini, Roberta , Hands, Katie , Bub, Carolina Bonet , Cohn, Claudia S. , Cox, Cody A., Ziman, Alyssa , Fermon, Erica J., Peters, Jessica, Collaborative, BEST foRmation of Anti‐D After Rhogam (RADAR) Study Investigators and the Biomedical Excellence for Safer Transfusion (BEST), Callum, Jeannie , Murphy, Michael , Wendel, Silvano , Bonet-Bub, Carolina , Cohn, Claudia S , Jacquot, Cyril , Hasan, Rida A , Lu, Wen , Juskewitch, Justin E , Raval, Jay S , Fung, Mark K , Ziman, Alyssa , Dunbar, Nancy M , Kutner, José Mauro , Cox, Cody A., Jacquot, Cyril , Hasan, Rida A. , Lu, Wen , Juskewitch, Justin E. , Raval, Jay S. , Rollins‐Raval, Marian A. , Gorlin, Jed B. , Dunbar, Nancy M. , Collaborative, BEST foRmation of Anti‐D After Rhogam (RADAR) Study Investigators and the Biomedical Excellence for Safer Transfusion (BEST)

Transfusion | March 10, 2025 | Volume: 65 | Issue: 5 | Pages: 957-967

10.1111/trf.18202 Get It

Abstract Background Rho(D) immune globulin (RhIg) is used to reduce RhD alloimmunization in pregnancy. This study describes potential causes for RhD alloimmunization after the development and implementation of RhIg. Study Design and Methods This retrospective descriptive study investigated RhD‐negative patients born in 1965–2005 with anti‐D newly identified during 2018–2022. Transfusion, pregnancy, intravenous drug abuse, and transplantation were considered potential alloimmunization sources. Results There were 1200 study patients (852 females; 348 males) at 30 institutions in 5 countries (USA, Canada, UK, New Zealand, Brazil). Most patients had a single potential source of alloimmunization identified (857/1200, 71%), most commonly pregnancy among females (537/852, 63%) and transfusion among males (180/348, 52%). When multiple potential sources were included, males were more likely than females to have a history of transfusion (235/348 [68%] vs. 149/852 [17%], p < .0001) and confirmed or suspected intravenous drug abuse (100/348 [29%] vs. 138/852 [16%], p < .0001). Among females with a history of pregnancy, 119/718 (17%) had healthcare access issues, 120/718 (17%) had pregnancy in a country where they may not have received RhIg, and 21/718 (3%) refused RhIg. Among patients with a history of transfusion, males were more likely than females to have received RhD‐positive red blood cells or whole blood (143/235 [61%] vs. 30/149 [20%], p < .0001) and/or platelets (84/235 [36%] vs. 19/149 [13%], p < .0001). Discussion Pregnancy was the most frequently identified potential source of RhD alloimmunization among females. Transfusion was most frequent in males. Intravenous drug abuse as a common potential source among patients with RhD alloimmunization merits further study.
Management of coagulopathy among patients with cirrhosis undergoing upper endoscopy and paracentesis: Persistent gaps and areas of consensus in a multispecialty Delphi
Tapper, Elliot B. , Shah, Rajesh P. , Emamaullee, Juliet , Poston, Jacqueline N. , Soto, Robin J., Pillai, Anjana , Reyner, Karina, Mehta, Shivang , Ghabril, Marwan , Morgan, Timothy R. , Caldwell, Stephen H. , Ghabril, Marwan S , Warner, Matthew A. , Dunbar, Nancy M. , Sholzberg, Michelle , Sarwar, Ammar

Hepatology | April 1, 2024 | Volume: 80 | Issue: 2 | Pages: 488-499

10.1097/hep.0000000000000856 Get It

Patients with cirrhosis have abnormal coagulation indices such as a high international normalized ratio and low platelet count, but these do not correlate well with periprocedural bleeding risk. We sought to develop a consensus among the multiple stakeholders in cirrhosis care to inform process measures that can help improve the quality of the periprocedural management of coagulopathy in cirrhosis. We identified candidate process measures for periprocedural coagulopathy management in multiple contexts relating to the performance of paracentesis and upper endoscopy. An 11-member panel with content expertise was convened. It included nominees from professional societies for interventional radiology, transfusion medicine, and anesthesia as well as representatives from hematology, emergency medicine, transplant surgery, and community practice. Each measure was evaluated for agreement using a modified Delphi approach (3 rounds of rating) to define the final set of measures. Out of 286 possible measures, 33 measures made the final set. International normalized ratio testing was not required for diagnostic or therapeutic paracentesis as well as diagnostic endoscopy. Plasma transfusion should be avoided for all paracenteses and diagnostic endoscopy. No consensus was achieved for these items in therapeutic intent or emergent endoscopy. The risks of prophylactic platelet transfusions exceed their benefits for outpatient diagnostic paracentesis and diagnostic endosopies. For the other procedures examined, the risks outweigh benefits when platelet count is >20,000/mm 3 . It is uncertain whether risks outweigh benefits below 20,000/mm 3 in other contexts. No consensus was achieved on whether it was permissible to continue or stop systemic anticoagulation. Continuous aspirin was permissible for each procedure. Clopidogrel was permissible for diagnostic and therapeutic paracentesis and diagnostic endoscopy. We found many areas of consensus that may serve as a foundation for a common set of practice metrics for the periprocedural management of coagulopathy in cirrhosis.
Update to the ASFA guidelines on the use of therapeutic apheresis in ANCA‐associated vasculitis
Balogun, Rasheed A. , Sanchez, Amber P. , Klingel, Reinhard , Witt, Volker, Aqui, Nicole A., Meyer, Erin , Padmanabhan, Anand , Wu, Yanyun , Zantek, Nicole D. , Connelly‐Smith, Laura , Zantek, Nicole D , Connelly-Smith, Laura , Dunbar, Nancy M , Pham, Huy P. , Schneiderman, Jennifer , Schwartz, Joseph E. , Dunbar, Nancy M.

Journal of Clinical Apheresis | August 8, 2020 | Volume: 35 | Issue: 5 | Pages: 493-499

10.1002/jca.21820 Get It

AbstractSince 1986, the American Society for Apheresis (ASFA) has published practice guidelines on the use of therapeutic apheresis in the Journal of Clinical Apheresis (JCA) Special Issue. Since 2007, updated guidelines have been published every 3 years to reflect current evidence based apheresis practice with the most recent edition (8th) published in 2019. With each edition, the guidelines are reviewed and updated based on any newly published literature since the last review. The PEXIVAS study, an international, randomized controlled trial comparing therapeutic plasma exchange (TPE) vs no TPE and standard vs reduced dose steroid regimen on the primary composite outcome of end stage renal disease or death in patients with ANCA‐associated vasculitis (AAV), was published in February 2020. This study represents the largest study on the role of therapeutic apheresis in AAV published to date and prompted the JCA Special Issue Writing Committee to reassess the current AAV fact sheet for updates based on this newly available evidence. This interim fact sheet summarizes current ASFA recommendations for the evidence‐based use of therapeutic apheresis in AAV and supersedes the recommendations published in the 2019 guidelines.
Seasonal variability is not observed in the rates of high anti‐A and anti‐B titers in plasma, apheresis platelet, and whole blood units tested by different methods
Harm, Sarah K., Yazer, Mark H. , Jacob, Eapen K., Mair, David , Raval, Jay S. , Shaz, Beth H. , Ziman, Alyssa , Collaborative, on behalf of the Biomedical Excellence for Safer Transfusion (BEST), Dunbar, Nancy M , Shaz, Beth H , Ziman, Alyssa , Raval, Jay S , Bub, Carolina Bonet , Cohn, Claudia S. , Kutner, José Mauro , Dunbar, Nancy M. , Collaborative, on behalf of the Biomedical Excellence for Safer Transfusion (BEST)

Transfusion | December 12, 2018 | Volume: 59 | Issue: 2 | Pages: 762-767

10.1111/trf.15083 Get It

BACKGROUNDABO‐incompatible platelet transfusions are common, and transfusions with ABO‐incompatible plasma are increasing with the use of group A plasma and group O whole blood (WB) in emergencies. Many centers screen blood products for anti‐A and/or anti‐B titers to help prevent hemolysis from ABO‐incompatible transfusions, yet titer methods and definition of high titers are not standardized.STUDY DESIGN AND METHODSThis international multicenter study collected data on anti‐A and anti‐B titer practices for plasma, apheresis platelet (AP), and WB units from January 2015 through December 2017 to determine the prevalence of high‐titer units using local definitions.RESULTSA total of 87,701 plasma, AP and WB units were screened for high‐titer anti‐A and/or anti‐B. High‐titer detection rates for group A plasma ranged 0%–13.6%; group A AP 2.7%–9.3%; group O AP 2.3%–65.7%; and group O WB 6.4%–20.7%. At the one center that collected group B AP, the high‐titer rate was 10.9%. High‐titer rates varied from month to month, as well as between years for a given month. There was no clear pattern of when high‐titer units were donated.CONCLUSIONThe prevalence of high‐titer plasma, AP, and WB units varies by titer method and local definition of high titer. Even at the lowest titer threshold of 50, a significant proportion of units had a high‐titer antibody, although the clinical relevance of this finding needs further investigation.
Extracorporeal photopheresis practice patterns: An international survey by the ASFA ECP subcommittee
Dunbar, Nancy M. , Raval, Jay S. , Johnson, Andrew D. , Abikoff, Cori, Adamski, Jill , Cooling, Laura , Kim, Haewon C., Morgan, Shanna, Schmidt, Amy E. , Sloan, Steven R. , Su, Leon , Szczepiorkowski, Zbigniew M. , West, F. Bernadette, Wong, Edward C.C. , Schneiderman, Jennifer , Grossman, Brenda J. , Marques, Marisa B. , Dunbar, Nancy M , Raval, Jay S

Journal of Clinical Apheresis | July 21, 2016 | Volume: 32 | Issue: 4 | Pages: 215-223

10.1002/jca.21486 Get It

AbstractBackgroundAlthough many apheresis centers offer extracorporeal photopheresis (ECP), little is known about current treatment practices.MethodsAn electronic survey was distributed to assess ECP practice internationally.ResultsOf 251 responses, 137 met criteria for analysis. Most respondents were from North America (80%). Nurses perform ECP at most centers (84%) and the majority of centers treat adults only (52%). Most centers treat fewer than 50 patients/year (83%) and perform fewer than 300 procedures/year (70%). Closed system devices (XTS and/or Cellex) are used to perform ECP at most centers (96%). The most common indications for ECP are acute/chronic skin graft versus host disease (89%) and cutaneous T‐cell lymphoma (63%). The typical wait time for ECP treatment is less than 2 weeks (91%). Most centers do not routinely perform quality control assessment of the collected product (66%). There are device‐specific differences in treatment parameters. For example, XTS users more frequently have a minimum weight limit (P = 0.003) and use laboratory parameters to determine eligibility for treatment (P = 0.03). Regardless of device used, the majority of centers assess the clinical status of the patient before each procedure. Greater than 50% of respondents would defer treatment for hemodynamic instability due to active sepsis or heart failure, positive blood culture in the past 24 h or current fever.ConclusionThis survey based study describes current ECP practices. Further research to provide evidence for optimal standardization of patient qualifications, procedure parameters and product quality assessment is recommended.
Routine bacterial screening of apheresis platelets on D ay 4 using a rapid test: a 4‐year single‐center experience
Dunbar, Nancy M. , Kreuter, Justin D. , Marx‐Wood, Cynthia R., Dumont, Larry J. , Szczepiorkowski, Zbigniew M. , Dunbar, Nancy M

Transfusion | January 24, 2013 | Volume: 53 | Issue: 10 | Pages: 2307-2313

10.1111/trf.12083 Get It

Background The platelet (PLT) P an G enera D etection test ( PGD ) is a rapid bacterial detection system used to screen PLTs for bacterial contamination. We report a single center 46‐month experience with secondary screening of apheresis PLTs by PGD testing. Study Design and Methods Existing testing records of apheresis PLTs screened by PGD from J uly 2008 to A pril 2012 were reviewed. All PLT units were initially screened by routine postcollection culture methods. Secondary screening using PGD was performed for indated PLTs on PLT storage D ay 4 and for outdated PLTs on D ay 8. Results A total of 8535 apheresis PLTs were available in inventory during the study period. Of these, 5030 (58.9%) were dispensed and transfused before PGD testing and 3505 (41.1%) underwent PGD testing on D ay 4. Twenty‐five units tested on D ay 4 were PGD initial reactive (0.71%). All were confirmed to be false positive by repeat PGD testing in triplicate (n = 20) or by confirmatory culture (n = 5). An additional 364 units that were PGD nonreactive on D ay 4 were approved for transfusion on D ay 6 or D ay 7 due to urgent clinical need. A total of 371 outdated units underwent repeat PGD testing before discard on D ay 8; all were nonreactive. Conclusion Secondary PGD testing of culture‐screened apheresis PLTs results in low yield in a medium‐sized transfusion service. Use of PGD testing on D ay 4 may allow for extension of the apheresis PLT shelf life to D ay 7 for hospitals that face supply constraints.