Functional Impact of Transoral Surgery and Risk-Based Adjuvant Therapy in Human Papillomavirus–Associated Oropharyngeal Cancer: Swallowing Outcomes From ECOG-ACRIN E3311
PURPOSE The ECOG-ACRIN E3311 phase II trial demonstrated outstanding disease control (90.6% 54-month progression-free survival) after transoral surgery (TOS) with de-escalated, risk-based postoperative management in resectable human papillomavirus–associated oropharyngeal cancer. The goal of de-escalation was functional preservation. The objective of this work was to evaluate clinician-graded modified barium swallow (MBS) studies from E3311 over time and across arms for (1) aspiration and high-grade pharyngeal residue rates, (2) differences in swallow safety and efficiency, and (3) accuracy of site clinicians reporting against central MBS review. METHODS Eight hundred eighty-five MBS studies were performed on 314 patients from 50 of 59 sites at baseline, post-TOS, and 6 and 24 months postradiotherapy (RT). Swallow outcomes (aspiration, high-grade residue) were recorded by site clinicians. A subset of 414 MBS studies was centrally graded using penetration-aspiration scale scores and the Dynamic Imaging Grade of Swallowing Toxicity (DIGEST) scale. RESULTS Aspiration, residue, and dysphagia rates significantly increased from baseline to post-TOS ( P < .01) and then decreased modestly at 6 and 24 months. At 6 months, swallow outcomes favored the 50- versus 60-Gy arm, with significantly lower aspiration and high-grade dysphagia rates, but this difference was not maintained at 24 months. MBS results reported by site clinicians demonstrated substantial agreement with those assessed by the central laboratory (PABAK, 0.75-0.84; P < .01). CONCLUSION Swallowing worsened after TOS but improved by 6 and 24 months despite adjuvant therapy. De-escalated adjuvant RT at 50 Gy reduced acute aspiration. Site-reported MBS metrics strongly aligned with DIGEST, showing potential as an accessible metric in cooperative group settings.
Updated report of a phase II randomized trial of transoral surgical resection followed by low-dose or standard postoperative therapy in resectable p16+ locally advanced oropharynx cancer: A trial of the ECOG-ACRIN cancer research group (E3311).
6010 Background: Definitive or postoperative chemoradiation (CRT) is highly curative for human papillomavirus-associated (HPV+) oropharynx cancer (OPC) but induces significant toxicity. As a potential deintensification strategy, we studied primary transoral surgery (TOS) and, in intermediate pathologic risk patients, reduced dose postoperative RT (PORT). Methods: E3311 is a phase II trial with randomization to reduced- or standard-dose PORT for resected stage III-IVa (AJCC7) intermediate pathologic risk HPV+ OPC, stratified by smoking history. Primary endpoints have been reported; we now present updated 3-year PFS and patient-reported outcomes (PRO), including head and neck-cancer specific quality of life (FACT-H&N) and swallowing perception and performance (MDADI). Results: Of 519 enrolled patients, 495 underwent TOS. The primary oncologic endpoint was 2-year PFS for 50 Gy (Arm B) or 60Gy (Arm C). Among 360 eligible and treated patients (ETP), Arm A (observation, N = 38) enrolled 11%, Arms B (N = 100) or C (N = 109) randomized 58%, and Arm D (66Gy + weekly cisplatin, N = 113) enrolled 31%. With 35.1 months median follow-up, 3-year PFS Kaplan-Meier estimate is 96.9% (90% CI [91.9%, 100%]) for Arm A; 94.9% (90% CI [91.3%, 98.6%]) for Arm B; 93.5% (90% CI [89.4%, 97.9%]) for Arm C; and 90.7% (90% CI [86.2%, 95.4%]) for Arm D. Recurrences and death without recurrence were 4 and 1 in Arm B, and 5 and one in Arm C. Smokers ( > 10 pack-years) did not have worse 3-year PFS in Arms B or C. Treatment arm distribution and outcome for ineligible patients who started adjuvant therapy mirrored the 360 ETP. A comparison combining arms B/C versus arm D in the proportion of patients stable/improved in FACT-H&N total score, from baseline to 6 months post-treatment as a pre-specified endpoint, was 56% vs. 38% (p value = 0.011, one-sided Fisher’s exact test); however, underlying differences in treatment and risk may be confounding. An exploratory comparison between Arms B and C revealed improvement in FACT H&N (63% in Arm B vs. 49% in Arm C had a stable/improved score, p-value = 0.056). Conclusions: Primary TOS and reduced PORT retained outstanding oncologic outcome at 35 months follow up, with favorable QOL and functional outcomes, in intermediate risk HPV+ OPC. Clinical trial information: NCT 01898494.
E3311 trial of transoral surgery for oropharynx cancer: Implementation of a novel surgeon credentialing and quality assurance process.