PURPOSE Detection of bone marrow disease has been a major component of rhabdomyosarcoma (RMS) staging with bilateral bone marrow aspirates/biopsies (BMAB) from the iliac crests considered the diagnostic gold standard. This study's goal was to determine if 2- 18 F-labeled fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography/computed tomography ([ 18 F]FDG PET/CT) or PET/magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) may replace BMAB in RMS staging. METHODS Patients were recruited in Europe and North America. Medical records, FDG PET/CT or FDG PET/MRI (PET), and BMAB reports were collected retrospectively. Images were re-reviewed by nuclear medicine physicians at the patients' home institutions if PET reports indicated increased FDG uptake at bone/bone marrow sites or if tumor cells were detected in bone marrow samples. RESULTS PET imaging and BMAB were performed before chemotherapy and tumor resection in 301 patients with FDG-avid RMS. Bone marrow metastases were detected by PET and BMAB in 54, by PET only in 24, and by BMAB only in one of 301 patients with FDG-avid primary tumors. Absence of bone marrow metastases was confirmed by PET and BMAB in 222 of 301 patients. These observations translated into 98% sensitivity and 90% specificity for PET in detecting bone marrow metastases when BMAB was considered as gold standard. FDG-avid marrow disease was patchy (1-5 foci) in one third of cases. Patients with marrow disease indicated by PET and BMAB had more FDG-avid bone marrow foci, more metastatic sites, and lower survival than those with marrow disease indicated by PET only, suggesting more advanced disease stages. CONCLUSION Bone marrow sampling may be omitted in patients without evidence of FDG-avid bone marrow disease by PET. If there are FDG-avid bone marrow lesions, further investigation by MRI and/or biopsy should be considered.
Interrater Variability in the Application of the Goldman Criteria to Medical Autopsies
Context.— The Goldman criteria are widely used to categorize diagnostic discrepancies in autopsy reports for hospital quality assurance. Despite their adoption, little is known about how consistently they are applied across institutions. Objective.— To evaluate the interrater reliability among academic pathologists applying the Goldman criteria to classify missed diagnoses in autopsy cases. Design.— Thirty autopsy cases from 2 academic hospitals were reviewed by 5 experienced autopsy pathologists. Each reviewer independently assigned Goldman classification scores (class I–IV) to missed diagnoses based on the original 1983 definitions. Consensus was defined as at least 60% agreement (≥3 of 5 raters). Fleiss κ and Gwet AC1 were calculated to assess interrater reliability. Results.— A total of 196 missed diagnoses were identified by at least 1 rater. Only 26% (51 of 196) achieved a consensus Goldman classification, and just 4% (8 of 196) had unanimous classification agreement. Most diagnoses (65%; 127 of 196) were not identified by at least 3 raters. Among consensus classification ratings, 49% (25 of 51) were class IV. Fleiss κ was 0.176 (slight agreement) while Gwet AC1 was 0.390 (fair agreement). Collapsing major (classes I–II) and minor (classes III–IV) categories modestly improved agreement. Conclusions.— Interrater agreement in applying the Goldman criteria is only fair to moderate, suggesting significant subjectivity in their application. As the criteria are used for institutional comparison and quality metrics, efforts to standardize definitions and provide reviewer training are warranted to improve reproducibility and utility.
Supporting the Deceased, Their Families, and Their Communities – Part 2: Practical Guidance for Building an Office of Decedent Affairs
Context.— After-death care can be complicated and time-consuming for clinical staff, and frustrating for bereaved families. Delays and errors can have damaging legal and reputational consequences for hospitals. Offices of Decedent Affairs (ODAs) have been proposed as a solution, and their potential benefits have been described in several single institution reports. The literature lacks a contemporary and comprehensive review of existing ODAs and their approaches. Objective.— To describe the process of establishing a new ODA and to provide a snapshot of the spectrum of structure, function, and impact of existing ODAs in the United States. Design.— A survey was administered to 11 established ODAs spread across the continental United States. Programs were identified through the College of American Pathologists Autopsy Committee and a Medical Autopsy Listserv. Results.— Eleven ODAs returned the survey, representing more than 190 cumulative years of experience in decedent care in the hospital setting (median, 10 years). There was a wide range in staffing (both staff size and background) as well as scope of services offered. The median ratio of hospital deaths to full-time equivalent (FTE) staffing was 360 deaths per FTE. Respondents reported that ODAs unburden clinical providers and facilitate decedent management. Some respondents reported a quicker turnover of hospital beds and shorter intervals between pronouncement of death and autopsy. ODAs increased autopsy rates when the autopsy services were part of the ODA. Conclusions.— This survey provides practical information for hospitals considering establishing a new ODA and useful benchmarks for existing ODA programs.
Supporting the Deceased, Their Families, and Their Communities – Part 1: Why Establish an Office of Decedent Affairs
Context.— Decedent Affairs Offices and Programs can serve as an avenue to assist medical centers in facilitating efficient and comprehensive decedent management, despite a paucity of literature on their roles, establishment, and efficacy. Objective.— To characterize the motivations and rationales for establishing Decedent Affairs Offices. Design.— A survey was administered to 11 established Decedent Affairs Offices/Programs, identified through the College of American Pathologists Autopsy Committee and a Medical Autopsy Listserv. The questions comprehensively cover establishment, operations, and outcomes data available by institution. Results.— Survey respondents reported the rationale for starting their programs and the benefits such offices can have. Conclusions.— Decedent Affairs Offices and Programs provide a useful option to medical centers to navigate the increasingly complex task of comprehensive decedent management. The present survey helps to delineate the similarities and differences between these programs at 11 institutions, to aid nascent programs in their establishment and growth over time.
Immune checkpoint dysregulation in COVID-19 pathogenesis and disease severity.
Abstract Accumulating evidence suggests dysregulated immune checkpoint (IC) signaling can exacerbate COVID-19 severity, but the role of these molecules in the pathogenesis of fatal COVID-19-related diffuse alveolar damage (DAD) remains elusive. Understanding how IC proteins influence acute lung injury due to COVID-19 can provide insights into potential therapeutic strategies to modulate immune responses and improve patient outcomes. Here, in a single-center autopsy cohort, we determined the cellular localization of ICs in lung tissue from cases of fatal COVID-19, DAD-comparators, and non-fibrotic controls by using immunohistochemistry, and investigated their association with clinical outcomes. We expanded our findings by performing analyses of publicly available single-cell RNA sequencing datasets from patients with fatal COVID-19 and non-fibrotic controls. We demonstrated the presence of protein-protein interaction networks of ICs in the lung cellular niche by performing transcriptomic profiling of lung tissue-derived RNA counts from patients with fatal COVID-19. Further, we leveraged data from the largest international, multi-center COVID-19 autopsy cohort and validated that, among patients with fatal COVID-19, those with higher PD-L1/CD274 expression in lung endothelial cells had more rapid clinical deterioration. Lastly, in a cohort of individuals with early COVID-19, IC plasma protein levels were elevated in those with persistent SARS-CoV-2 RNAemia and adverse clinical outcomes. Collectively, our data provide unique pathological insights into the role of IC dysregulation and differential disease severity in COVID-19.
Rhabdomyosarcoma with isolated lung metastases: A report from the Soft Tissue Sarcoma Committee of the Children's Oncology Group
Abstract Background To determine outcomes of children with rhabdomyosarcoma (RMS) with isolated lung metastases. Methods Data were analyzed for 428 patients with metastatic RMS treated on COG protocols. Categorical variables were compared using Chi‐square or Fisher's exact tests. Event‐free survival (EFS) and overall survival (OS) were estimated using Kaplan–Meier method and compared using the log‐rank test. Results Compared with patients with other metastatic sites ( n = 373), patients with lung‐only metastases ( n = 55) were more likely to be <10 years of age, have embryonal histology (embryonal rhabdomyosarcoma), have N0 disease, and less likely to have primary extremity tumors. Lung‐only patients had significantly better survival outcomes than patients with all other sites of metastatic disease ( p < .0001) with 5‐year EFS of 48.1 versus 18.8% and 5‐year OS of 64.1 versus 26.9%. Patients with lung‐only metastases, and those with a single extrapulmonary site of metastasis, had better survival compared with patients with two or more sites of metastatic disease ( p < .0001). In patients with ERMS and lung‐only metastases, there was no significant difference in survival between patients ≥10 years and 1–9 years (5‐year EFS: 58.3 vs. 68.2%, 5‐year OS: 66.7 vs. 67.7%). Conclusions With aggressive treatment, patients with ERMS and lung‐only metastatic disease have superior EFS and OS compared with patients with other sites of metastatic disease, even when older than 10 years of age. Consideration should be given to including patients ≥10 years with ERMS and lung‐only metastases in the same group as those <10 years in future risk stratification algorithms.