AbstractBackgroundIn 2018 we presented the Computational DESH (CDESH) metric (DOI:10.1016/j.nicl.2018.11.015), a machine learning measure of abnormal CSF space patterns commonly observed on MRI in Disproportionately Enlarged Subarachnoid‐space Hydrocephalus (DESH‐type) NPH. We have shown that CDESH positive individuals often have discordant CSF and PET amyloid measures (DOI:10.1016/j.jalz.2019.06.4921). Positive CDESH scores are predictive of cognitive decline (DOI:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2021.117899, DOI: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000008616). The score is calculated from regional CSF volumes in a sulcal atlas and within the ventricles using a support vector machine (SVM). The Mayo Clinic Study of Aging (MCSA) changed scanner platforms (GE to Siemens) and T1‐weighted image resolution (1.2mm x 1.05mm x 1.05mm to 0.8mm isotropic) in 2017. We refer to these as “isotropic” or “anisotropic” scans. Our objective was to assess the dependence of a machine learning method (specifically CDESH) to image input variation and, if necessary, determine what needed corrections.MethodAll data considered is from the MCSA or Mayo Clinic ADRC. The SVM was trained on anisotropic images with laboriously labelled ground truth. We resampled the isotropic data from a crossover study (N=112, typically scanned same‐day with both platforms/resolutions) to match the anisotropic resolution. Two approaches to correction were evaluated (Figure 1). In Figure 2 we compare of the score with and without correction cross‐sectionally in 998 MCSA participants. In Figure 3 we present longitudinal series from 23 participants with multiple scans using the isotropic resolution protocol and at least one prior anisotropic image.ResultsComparisons of data from the crossover study are presented in Figure 1. Matching voxel resolution to the data used to train the SVM is critical and a subsequent mild linear score adjustment may be warranted. Cross‐sectional comparisons (Figure 2) confirm improvement matching voxel resolution with a possible mild linear score adjustment. After matching voxel resolution CDESH score trajectories (Figure 3) are markedly more stable across this scanner/protocol change.ConclusionThe SVM‐based CDESH score is sensitive to voxel resolution. Corrections are needed in image processing and possibly in the scalar output score to achieve stability across protocol and scanner changes. The resulting correction supports coherent long timeseries data and longitudinal extension of previous work.
Analytical Validation of the Quanterix Neurofilament Light Chain (NfL) Advantage Assay in Plasma
AbstractBackgroundNeurofilament light chain (NfL) is an emerging blood‐based biomarker useful for assessing neuro‐axonal injury in several neurological conditions. Plasma NfL concentrations reflect the extent of axonal damage, making it a general marker of neurodegenerative disease progression. This study evaluates the analytical performance characteristics of the Quanterix NfL Advantage method in EDTA‐plasma.MethodThe assay was performed per manufacturer’s instructions on the Quanterix Simoa HD‐X Analyzer. Analytical validation included analyte stability, imprecision, lower limit of quantification (LLOQ), analytical measurement range (AMR), accuracy, and interferences. One‐sided reference intervals were established using quantile regression methods among 1100 cognitive normal individuals, age 20 to 95 years without known chronic kidney disease, stroke, or myocardial infarction.ResultNfL was stable in plasma three days ambient, seven days refrigerate, 90 days frozen (‐20C), and over 3 freeze/thaw cycles. Intra and inter‐assay imprecision, expressed as % coefficient of variation (%CV), ranged from 3.4 – 6.0% and 5.9 – 11.6% respectively. The LLOQ was evaluated using patient plasma pools at concentrations of 1.7 and 3.6 pg/mL. %CVs were 16.8% and 9.7% respectively, and the LLOQ was set at 3.0 pg/mL. Accuracy was assessed by spiking 5 plasma samples with NfL calibratoran 87% average recovery (range 81‐94%) was observed. The AMR of 3.0 – 1500 pg/mL was verified with a regression slope of 0.93 and r2 > 0.99. Additionally, plasma admixtures covering the AMR showed acceptable linear response (slope of 1.02 and r² >0.99). The assay was not affected by icterus to 100 mg/dL, lipemia to 1000 mg/dL, hemolysis to 1000 mg/dL at NfL concentrations >30 pg/mL or to 200 mg/dL at NfL concentrations ≤30 pg/mL. NfL increased with age but did not differ by sex. The data supported age‐based reference intervals broken down into 10‐year intervals. The 97.5th percentile limits were: 20s: ≤8.4 pg/mL, 30s: ≤11.4 pg/mL, 40s: ≤15.4 pg/mL, 50s: ≤20.8 pg/mL, 60s: ≤28.0 pg/mL, 70s: ≤37.9 pg/mL, 80+: ≤51.2 pg/mL.ConclusionThe analytical performance characteristics of the plasma Quanterix NfL advantage assay were deemed acceptable for clinical laboratory implementation. The establishment of NfL reference intervals will aid in the clinical interpretation of patient plasma NfL concentrations.
Comparing cerebrovascular disease diffusion MRI markers using post‐mortem and longitudinal imaging data
AbstractBackgroundDiffusion MRI (dMRI) based quantification of microstructural changes in white matter (WM) are increasingly proposed to measure cerebrovascular disease (CVD) related changes. Our objective was to compare the proposed dMRI markers using postmortem neuropathologic CVD data and then evaluate the predictors of longitudinal dMRI markers using serial scans.MethodWe identified n=51 participants (mean age: 83.8 years, 63% males) with ante‐mortem dMRI and postmortem CVD evaluation and n=718 participants (mean age: 71.1 years, 56% males) with at least two dMRI scans from the population‐based sample of Mayo Clinic Study of Aging. We computed dMRI measures proposed for measuring CVD: Free Water (FW), Fractional Anisotropy (FA) adjusted for FW (FAadj), Peak width Skeletonized Mean Diffusivity (PSMD), and FA of the genu of corpus callosum (Genu‐FA). We used the FW and PSMD (PSMD release 1.8.1) kits from the MarkVCID consortium.Using weighted linear regression models with adjustments for MRI scan time to death, we evaluated associations between the baseline dMRI and two pathology CVD scores: Strozyk (represents the presence and number of macroscopic lesions) and Kalaria (represents the summary score of vessel wall modifications) scales. We ran linear mixed effect models with all available serial dMRI measures as outcomes and vascular risk (measured by the number of cardiovascular and metabolic conditions‐CMC), baseline imaging measures (amyloid and white matter hyperintensities (WMH)) and their interaction with time as key predictors.ResultMost dMRI markers were predictors of postmortem CVD pathology (Table 1). In longitudinal dMRI models, terms associated with amyloid explained little variability in dMRI (<1%) (Table 2). WMH was a significant predictor of baseline and decline in dMRI measures with WMH explaining a considerable percentage of variability in FW (34%) and PSMD (28%). Vascular risk measures were significant predictors of three out of the four dMRI measures.ConclusionThe diffusion measures proposed as surrogate markers of CVD map reasonably well to CVD pathological scales and do not change substantially as a function of baseline amyloidosis. Our findings shed light on variability in the proposed diffusion markers using postmortem data and longitudinal imaging data. Further work is needed to evaluate their clinical utility.
AbstractBackgroundCerebral Microbleeds (CMBs) are tracked in anti‐amyloid drug safety monitoring. T2*GRE or SWI MRI images are visually assessed for the presence of CMBs. Automated methods tuned for sensitivity often have unacceptably high false positive rates requiring extensive human cleanup.MethodAssume contemporaneous T2*GRE and T1‐weighted images. CMB detection (Figures 1,2) has three steps: 1) Segmentation outputs from the T1‐weighted image are resampled into the T2*GRE image voxel raster; 2) Normalized cross‐correlation of the T2*GRE with a CMB template identifies “candidate CMBs”; 3) a neural network using voxel patches centered on each candidate CMB rejects false positives. Patches presented to the network are 4D and include five contrasts drawn from the T2*GRE, correlation, T1‐weighted, WM probability and CSF probability images. The simple network architecture consists of convolutional blocks followed by dense blocks. The system is trained using images from ADNI, ARIC, MCSA, and the Mayo Clinic ADRC that have been previously visually graded for CMBs (Table in Figure 3). Importantly, we include participants with and without CMBs in our data reflecting the fact that the majority of people (even the elderly) have no CMBs. Data is split 70:10:20 by subject for training, validation, and testing. Various network configurations were evaluated.ResultHigh candidate detection sensitivity can be achieved at the expense of presenting hundreds to thousands of false positive candidates per input image to the rejection network. Our best performing network configuration to date has AUC 0.982 (95% bootstrap CI 0.971 to 0.990 based on the 10% validation subset). Choosing an operating point with 95% sensitivity in the validation set and admits, on average, 0.6 false positive CMB candidates per input T2*GRE image. Sensitivity is hindered by a small number of obvious errors in the ground truth visual assessment. Validation loss tracks training loss with no indication of over‐fitting. Example patches are shown in Figure 4.ConclusionExcessive false positive detection requires significant human correction and effort, preventing automated CMB detection from being widely adopted. We have an automated detection system that is sensitive (95%) and provides excellent false positive rejection (<1 false positive CMB/input image) reducing needed human effort.
Temporal Association of Imaging Biomarkers of Cerebrovascular Disease and Alzheimer’s Disease
AbstractBackgroundAlzheimer’s disease (AD) pathologic changes (e.g. amyloid and tau aggregation), and cerebrovascular disease often coexist, and it remains unclear whether these are mechanistically linked processes (Graff‐Radford, Brain 2019; Provenzano, JAMA Neurol 2013). Most studies evaluating these associations are cross‐sectional; however, establishing temporal relationships may provide additional insight into potential mechanistic associations. One method to assess the temporal evolution of a biomarker is the Accelerated Failure Time (AFT) model, which assumes a common pattern of progression for a given biomarker that is shifted earlier or later in time for each individual (Therneau, Neuroimage 2021). In this work we investigate the relationship of disease trajectories of cerebrovascular disease (via white matter hyperintensity, WMH, volume) and AD biomarkers (via amyloid and tau PET).MethodsWe included Mayo Clinic Study of Aging (MCSA) and Mayo Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center (ADRC) participants with amyloid PET, tau PET, and MRI, age > 50 years, and a clinical diagnosis of cognitively unimpaired (CU), mild cognitive impairment (MCI) or Alzheimer’s disease dementia. The AFT model was fit with amyloid PET (PiB) global meta‐ROI SUVR, tau PET (flortaucipir) temporal meta‐ROI SUVR, and WMH volume as the tri‐variate endpoints, with APOE genotype, sex, education, total intracranial volume, and referral/population subject as covariates. A per subject/endpoint random effect represents individual adjustments for each biomarker to indicate if the subject's biomarker became abnormal earlier or later relative to their demographic peers, accounting for the covariates.ResultsThe study included 1144 participants (Table 1). There was a strong correlation between earlier onset of amyloid and earlier onset of tau (r=0.64, CI=0.60‐0.67) (Figure 1, Table 2); early/late amyloid timing explained nearly half (0.642 = 41%) of the variation in tau onset. There were only weak associations between an individual’s WMH and amyloid PET onset adjustments (r=0.10, 1.0%) and WMH and tau PET onset adjustments (r=‐0.07, 0.5%).ConclusionThis analysis supports a strong mechanistic relationship between amyloid and tau aggregation, as reported by others. However, our findings do not support a mechanistic association between WMH and amyloid or tau PET.
White matter health in the context of Alzheimer’s disease pathophysiology
AbstractBackgroundMulti‐compartment modelling of white matter (WM) microstructure using Neurite Orientation Dispersion and Density Imaging (NODDI) can provide information on WM health through the neurite (axons and dendrites) density index and free water measures. We hypothesized that cerebrovascular disease (CVD), Alzheimer’s disease (AD), and an FDG pattern suggestive of TDP‐43 proteinopathy would be associated with distinct NODDI readouts of WM damage which would be informative for identifying the substrate for cognitive impairment.MethodWe identified two independent cohorts with multi‐shell diffusion MRI, amyloid and tau PET, and cognitive assessments. One, were participants from the Mayo Clinic Study of Aging, a population‐based cohort of 347 elderly randomly sampled from the Olmsted county, Minnesota. The second were 61 amyloid positive AD participants from the Mayo AD Research Center.ResultWe observed an increase in free water and decrease in neurite density in the genu of the corpus callosum associated with vascular risk factors, which we refer to as vascular WM component (Figure 1). Tau PET signal reflective of 3R/4R tau deposition was associated with worsening neurite density index in the temporal WM where we measured parahippocampal cingulum and inferior temporal WM bundles. Worsening temporal neurite density was associated with (antemortem confirmed) FDG TDP‐43 signature. Post‐mortem neuropathologic data on a small subset (n=9) of this sample lend support to our findings. In the population‐based cohort where vascular disease was more prevalent, the vascular WM component explained variability in global cognition (partial R2 of free water and neurite density = 8.3%) and MMSE performance (8.2%) which was comparable to amyloid PET (7.4% for global cognition and 6.6% for memory) (Table 1). In the AD dementia clinic‐based cohort, tau deposition was the greatest contributor to cognitive performance (9.6%), but there was also a non‐trivial contribution of the temporal WM component (8.5%) to cognitive performance. The differences observed between the two cohorts were reflective of their distinct clinical composition.ConclusionWhite matter microstructural damage assessed using advanced diffusion models may add significant value for distinguishing the underlying substrate (whether CVD versus neurodegenerative disease caused by tau deposition or TDP‐43 pathology) for cognitive impairment in older individuals.
Underlying cerebrovascular pathology in Subjective Cognitive Decline: A systematic review and meta‐analysis
AbstractBackgroundSubjective cognitive decline (SCD) implies self‐reported cognitive complaints in absence of objective cognitive impairment. SCD has been postulated as an early marker of Alzheimer’s Disease (AD). However, longitudinal studies have linked SCD to future vascular dementia. Thus, we conducted a systematic review and meta‐analysis aiming to synthesise and analyse the available data on the association between SCD and the presence of underlying cerebrovascular pathology measured by MRI.MethodOur study was performed following the PRISMA statement. The search strategy included terms for “subjective cognitive decline” and “white matter signal abnormalities”. It was conducted in 3 databases (PubMed, Scopus and Web of Science) from origin by December 8th, 2021. Two authors screened the studies in a 2‐stepwise approach. Primary studies including cognitively unimpaired adults with subjective cognitive complaints meeting the SCD‐I criteria for SCD that evaluated cerebrovascular pathology based on white matter signal abnormalities (WMSA) on MR images were selected. Study quality was assessed using the FLC 3.0 tool. Meta‐analysis comparing case‐control mean difference of WMSA was performed.ResultOf 240 articles identified, 16 research articles were selected. Of those, 8 case‐control studies were selected for the meta‐analysis. The sample size of the SCD group across the studies ranged from 8 to 906 participants, with age ranged from 40 to 84 years. All eight studies comprised a total of 2.637 SCD individuals. Study quality was deemed moderate (n=6) to high (n=10). The meta‐analysis showed a significant overall effect‐size between the mean WMSA burden of SCD and the controls, that was not significantly heterogeneous (Q(gl=7)=14.20; p=0,04; I2=42,5%). SCD was significantly associated with higher CVP burden based on neuroimaging measures.ConclusionThis is the first study to synthesise and analyse the current evidence on the association between SCD and WMSA. Our findings show the usefulness of SCD as a marker of underlying cerebrovascular pathology. Thus, the potential role of SCD as a preclinical stage of vascular cognitive impairment needs further investigation. Changes in lifestyle (e.g. exercise, diet, smoking cessation), cognitive stimulation or pharmacotherapy may be key to avoid an evolution towards cognitive deterioration in SCD.
CSF proteins involved in neuroplasticity are associated with altered whole brain connectivity in prodromal AD
AbstractBackgroundIndividuals with prodromal Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) and higher gray matter connectivity measures show slower decline, suggesting resilience to AD. However, the precise biological processes underlying preserved brain connections remains unclear. Here, we studied this question using cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) proteomics.MethodFrom the ADNI we selected 78 individuals with MCI and abnormal CSF amyloid (i.e., prodromal AD) and 34 with normal cognition and normal CSF amyloid levels for whom MRI and CSF proteomic data was available. For each T1 MRI scan we constructed gray matter networks using an automated pipeline (Tijms, Series et al. 2012) and calculated degree, connectivity density, clustering, path length and small‐world measures (i.e. gamma, lambda and small world coefficient). Linear models were used to test associations between each connectivity measure and CSF protein levels while correcting for age and gender. Proteins showing associations of p < 0.1 were selected to find groups of proteins that are associated with biological processes according to Gene Ontology (GO). Proteomic profiles for each connectivity measure were compared to investigate overlap. Finally, we tested for enrichment of potential upstream drivers with the Enrichr tool.ResultIn total, 115 proteins were associated with altered connectivity in prodromal AD subjects (figure 1). The majority of proteins (n = 93, 80%) showed higher levels with stronger (i.e., resilient) brain networks characterized by increased degree, connectivity density, clustering, path length, gamma, lambda or small world coefficient values. In controls, 80 of these 93 proteins showed an opposite relationship, with lower levels relating to higher values for these connectivity measures, which suggests that increased levels in prodromal AD may indicate a compensatory mechanism to maintain strong brain connectivity. According to a pathway analysis in GO, these proteins associated with stronger brain networks were mainly involved in neuroplasticity pathways. A subsequent Enrichr analysis suggested involvement of upstream divers SUZ12 and REST, which are known to regulate neuroplasticity processes.ConclusionWe observed that higher CSF levels of neuroplasticity associated proteins were associated with higher brain connectivity values in prodromal AD, suggesting that plasticity mechanisms may play a role in resilience to AD pathology.
Synthesizing Images of Tau Pathology from Images of Glucose Utilization
AbstractBackgroundIn vivo tau‐positron emission tomography (PET) is an attractive biomarker for Alzheimer’s disease (AD) diagnosis and treatment. However, tau‐PET is less widely available than other modalities. In this study, we tested cross‐modality synthesis of tau‐PET brain images from fluorodeoxyglucose F‐18 (FDG)‐PET using a deep convolutional neural network (CNN).MethodParticipants (n=1,192) who had brain FDG‐PET with 18F‐FDG and tau‐PET with Flortaucipir (F‐18‐AV‐1451) were included for training and testing. This cohort spanned normal aging (ages 26‐98), pre‐clinical, and clinical AD and related disorders including the FTD and DLB spectrum. External validation was done using ADNI (n=288). The PET scans were co‐registered to the corresponding MRI and subsequently warped to Mayo Clinic Adult Lifespan Template (MCALT) space. Tau‐PET images were SUVR‐normalized to the cerebellar crus, and FDG to the pons. A 3D dense‐U‐net model was utilized as an architecture. Cross‐validation experiments were conducted using 5‐fold validations (60% training set, 20% validation set, and 20% test set) with mean squared error as the loss function.ResultOur dense‐U‐net model successfully synthesized tau‐PET from metabolic images with good correlation and low prediction error for regional SUVRs (Figure 1A‐C). The model showed a robust prediction ability, performing accurately in an independent, external ADNI cohort (Figure 1D‐F). The model‐imputed tau‐PET significantly improved performance in classifying tau positivity (mean AUROC(±SD)=0.78±0.04 and 0.85±0.03 for FDG‐PET and synthesized tau‐PET, respectively) and diagnostic groups (cognitively unimpaired with abnormal amyloid‐PET vs. cognitively impaired with abnormal amyloid‐PET) compared to the original input FDG data (mean AUROC(±SD)=0.89±0.04, 0.85±0.05 0.91±0.04 for actual tau‐PET, FDG‐PET and synthesized tau‐PET, respectively) (Figure 2), suggesting enhanced clinical utility for metabolic images. The ADNI cohort also showed similar results (for tau positivity: AUROC=0.66 and 0.78 for FDG‐PET and synthesized tau‐PET, respectively; for CU A+ vs. CI A+: AUROC=0.86, 0.62, and 0.73 for actual tau‐PET, FDG‐PET, and synthesized tau‐PET; Figure 3).ConclusionWe showed that using a CNN model to predict tau‐PET from FDG‐PET is feasible. The synthesized tau‐PET can augment the value of FDG‐PET, facilitating the multi‐modal diagnosis of AD.
A global functional network biomarker across aging and dysexecutive Alzheimer’s disease
AbstractBackgroundDisruption of the default mode network (DMN) is thought to be a common feature of aging and across Alzheimer’s disease (AD) clinical phenotypes, while syndromic variability could be reflected in selective degeneration of macro‐scale networks optimally supporting specific mental abilities (Fig 1). As part of a collaborative effort between Mayo Clinic and the Human Connectome Project‐Aging (HCP‐A), we aimed to delineate a biomarker of global network failure across aging and the dysexecutive (dAD) and amnestic phenotypes of AD, and biomarkers of focal degeneration specific to each AD phenotype.MethodWe used a regression framework to assess the relationships between a marker of DMN dysfunction, the network failure quotient (NFQ), and factors relevant to AD such as age, cortical thickness (global cortical thickness, inferior parietal lobe), hippocampal volume, and cognition (episodic memory, cognitive flexibility) in the HCP‐A cohort, which consists of 725 non‐demented older adults. We then fit centile curves to the HCP‐A cohort to assess whether the NFQ and focal degeneration markers could distinguish dAD (n=10) and amnestic AD (n=8) patients from the HCP‐A cohort at the group‐ and individual‐level. Participants were scanned using the HCP‐A protocol, allowing for the acquisition of high‐resolution multi‐echo structural images and longer resting‐state connectivity acquisition time compared to traditional protocols.ResultThe NFQ related to age, cortical thickness, hippocampal volume, and cognition in the HCP‐A cohort. It also strongly discriminated dAD and amnestic AD from the HCP‐A cohort but did not discriminate between AD phenotypes. In contrast, markers of focal degeneration were phenotype‐specific; parieto‐frontal areas yielded largest effect sizes for dAD patients, and hippocampal and temporal areas best discriminated patients with amnestic AD (Fig 2).ConclusionThe NFQ may reflect shared system‐level pathophysiological mechanisms across aging and the dysexecutive and amnestic phenotypes of AD whereas focal degeneration markers highlight distinct pathognomonic processes across AD phenotypes. These findings suggest that inter‐individual variability in cognitive impairment in AD would be closely tied to modular, phenotype‐specific network degeneration combined with a common global functional disruption of the DMN. Such information has crucial implications for clinical biomarkers and to provide a deeper understanding of heterogeneity in AD.