Citations

Mayo Clinic

Clear

1994 citation(s) found for "Vu, Joshua".

Examining crossover and postprotocol therapies in first‐line immunotherapy trials in non–small cell lung cancer
Desai, Aakash , Smith, Caleb J. , Leventakos, Konstantinos , West, Howard , Pritchett, Joshua C. , Desai, Aakash P

Cancer | February 14, 2024 | Volume: 130 | Issue: 16 | Pages: 2807-2811

10.1002/cncr.35250 | PMID 38353476 Get It

AbstractBackgroundImmune checkpoint inhibitor (ICI) therapy has led to significant improvement in outcomes for patients with nononcogene‐driven advanced non–small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). The rate of crossover and receipt of postprotocol ICI in frontline trials for advanced NSCLC has not been systematically evaluated.MethodsClinicalTrials.gov was used to identify phase 3 studies evaluating the use of immunotherapy or combination chemoimmunotherapy against chemotherapy alone in the frontline management of advanced NSCLC. Data on outcomes, rate of crossover and/or subsequent post‐protocol receipt of immunotherapy, and the start dates of these clinical trials were then extracted.ResultsTwenty‐three frontline trials in nononcogene‐driven advanced NSCLC were identified. Six trials with ICI monotherapy/dual ICI therapy and 17 trials evaluating chemotherapy/ICI in first‐line advanced NSCLC were included in the analysis. The crossover rate ranged 0% to 54% in ICI monotherapy/dual ICI trials and 0% to 52% in chemotherapy/ICI trials. Nineteen of 23 trials provided information on subsequent postprotocol therapies. Among the trials not allowing crossover, postprotocol ICI was administered to 17% to 45.8% of patients. Information regarding the eventual receipt of ICI therapy was available for 22 of 23 trials. Of 6631 patients, 2507 (37.8%) randomized to the control arm eventually received ICI therapy.ConclusionThe rate of crossover and postprotocol ICI use was low in frontline trials for first‐line NSCLC incorporating ICI. Given the proven improved overall survival of ICI in a broad population, there is a need to ensure availability of this life‐prolonging therapy in future trials, either by crossover treatment or postprotocol administration.
Institutional Variability in Anesthesia Time for Mehta Casting in Early-Onset Scoliosis (EOS)
Bonsignore-Opp, Lisa , Malka, Matan , Simhon, Matthew E. , Matsumoto, Hiroko , Sturm, Peter, Vitale, Michael G. , Group, On behalf of Pediatric Spine Study, Ball, Jacob R. , Pahys, Joshua M. , Larson, A. Noelle , Roye, Benjamin D. , Group, On behalf of Pediatric Spine Study

Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics | February 14, 2024 | Volume: 44 | Issue: 5 | Pages: 297-302

10.1097/bpo.0000000000002644 | PMID 38353100 Get It

Purpose: Mehta casting is a potentially curative intervention for early-onset scoliosis (EOS) that typically requires multiple anesthetics. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) reported that >3 hours of anesthesia under the age of 3 years old may alter brain development; however, no standard exists for the duration of anesthesia during casting. The purpose of this study is to quantify the variability in anesthesia during Mehta casting. We hypothesize that significant institutional variability exists and may be attributed to modifiable factors. Methods: An EOS registry was used to identify patients who underwent at least one Mehta casting procedure. Anesthesia exposure was quantified, and site variability was assessed by patient characteristics, cast placement, procedure type, and equipment used. Results: Our cohort consisted of 208 patients from 5 institutions (age 2.6±1.4 y). There were 1097 Mehta casting procedures, with 5.4±3.6 castings per patient. Of these patients, 106 (51%) were female, with an average age of 2.11±1.29 years old at the time casting was initiated. Patient etiologies included 154 idiopathic (74.0%), 22 syndromic (10.6%), 18 congenital (8.7%), 11 neuromuscular (5.3%), and 3 unknown (1.4%). Anesthesia time was 69±31 minutes and varied significantly between sites (59±14 to 117±46 min; P<0.001). Cumulative anesthesia time for patients under 3 years was 320±197 minutes with 120/161 (74.5%) patients exceeding 3 hours. Anesthesia time was lower after the FDA warning in 2016 compared with pre-2016 (71±30 vs. 66±32, P=0.008). Conclusions: Patients undergoing Mehta casting are at significant risk of exceeding 3 hours of anesthesia, which the FDA has stated may be harmful for children <3 years. Significant site variability indicates that standardization protocols should be developed to encourage best practices and minimize anesthetic times. Level of Evidence: Prognostic Level II.
Association of Socioeconomic Status With Life's Essential 8 in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey: Effect Modification by Sex
Williams, Amaris , Nolan, Timiya S. , Luthy, Jacsen, Brewer, LaPrincess C. , Ortiz, Robin , Sánchez, Eduardo , Nawaz, Saira , Garner, Jennifer , Joseph, Joshua J. , Brock, Guy , Garner, Jennifer , Walker, Daniel M , Joseph, Joshua J , Brewer, LaPrincess C , Nolan, Timiya S , Luthy, Jacsen, Venkatesh, Kartik Kailas , Brock, Guy , Gray, Darrell M.

Journal of the American Heart Association | February 13, 2024 | Volume: 13 | Issue: 4 | Pages: No page available

10.1161/jaha.123.030805 | PMID 38348807 Get It

Background Higher scores for the American Heart Association Life's Essential 8 (LE8) metrics, blood pressure, cholesterol, glucose, body mass index, physical activity, smoking, sleep, and diet, are associated with lower risk of chronic disease. Socioeconomic status (SES; employment, insurance, education, and income) is associated with LE8 scores, but there is limited understanding of potential differences by sex. This analysis quantifies the association of SES with LE8 for each sex, within Hispanic Americans, non‐Hispanic Asian Americans, non‐Hispanic Black Americans, and non‐Hispanic White Americans. Methods and Results Using cross‐sectional data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, years 2011 to 2018, LE8 scores were calculated (range, 0–100). Age‐adjusted linear regression quantified the association of SES with LE8 score. The interaction of sex with SES in the association with LE8 score was assessed in each racial and ethnic group. The US population representatively weighted sample (13 529 observations) was aged ≥20 years (median, 48 years). The association of education and income with LE8 scores was higher in women compared with men for non‐Hispanic Black Americans and non‐Hispanic White Americans ( P for all interactions <0.05). Among non‐Hispanic Asian Americans and Hispanic Americans, the association of SES with LE8 was not different between men and women, and women had greater LE8 scores than men at all SES levels (eg, high school or less, some college, and college degree or more). Conclusions The factors that explain the sex differences among non‐Hispanic Black Americans and non‐Hispanic White Americans, but not non‐Hispanic Asian Americans and Hispanic Americans, are critical areas for further research to advance cardiovascular health equity.
Revisiting Injectable Estrogen Dosing Recommendations for Gender-Affirming Hormone Therapy
Hamnvik, Ole‐Petter R. , Davidge‐Pitts, Caroline , Ariel, Danit , Abramowitz, Jessica , Soe, Kyaw , Sarvaideo, Jenna , Kelley, Carly E. , Hamnvik, Ole-Petter R , Iwamoto, Sean J , Rothman, Micol Sara , Safer, Joshua D. , Tangpricha, Vin , Irwig, Michael S. , Iwamoto, Sean J.

Transgender Health | February 12, 2024 | Volume: 9 | Issue: 6 | Pages: 463-465

10.1089/trgh.2023.0209 | PMID 39735380 Get It

Injectable estrogens are options for gender-affirming hormone therapy per guidelines, which suggest intramuscular dosages of 5–30 mg every 2 weeks or 2–10 mg weekly with estradiol cypionate or valerate interchangeably. Data among transgender and gender-diverse patients are limited due to local unavailability and concerns around laboratory assay variability and estradiol (E2) level fluctuation. We note a concerning trend where patients are prescribed high-dose injections based on the guidelines leading to serum E2 levels well above the range recommended in the same guidelines. Our review indicates that 5 mg weekly or lower should be prescribed when initiating injectable estrogens to avoid supraphysiologic E2 levels.
(395) Safety and Efficacy of Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum in Peyronie's Disease Men with Ventral Curvatures
Larson, Henry, Brearton, K, Warner, R, Ziegelmann, Matthew , Köhler, Tobias , Trost, Landon , Savage, Joshua S. , Helo, Sevann

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | February 6, 2024 | Volume: 21 | Issue: Supplement_1 | Pages: No page available

10.1093/jsxmed/qdae001.380 Get It

Abstract Introduction Limited data are available on the efficacy of collagenase clostridium histolyticum (CCH) on Peyronie’s disease (PD) in men with ventral curvatures. Our team previously published a limited series of outcomes of 25 men with ventral curvatures who underwent CCH. Given the paucity of data available, we sought to provide an updated series of outcomes in this important cohort. Objective To report outcomes of men undergoing CCH injections for PD based on initial direction of curvature, including absolute and percent improvement in curvature, adverse events (AE), and other subjective outcomes. Methods A prospective registry has been maintained of all men undergoing CCH injections since 2014. All men underwent curvature assessments and subjective questioning at the time of initial evaluation and prior to each subsequent series of injections. The method of injection and subsequent protocol have changed in a stepwise fashion since 2014 and currently include injecting 0.9 mg (diluted to 0.8 mL) on back-to-back days, injecting into the point of max curve with an erection on day 1, performing in-office modeling on day 2, utilizing Restorex traction beginning on day 2, and wrapping for 4-8 days depending on results. To review outcomes, clinicopathologic data were abstracted from the registry including relevant history, exam, and data obtained at the time of penile ultrasound and curvature assessment. Outcomes are reported using a “Most Recent” definition (most recent data point used, regardless if the patient continues or finished treatment) and “Completed 8 or Satisfied” (only included if the patient indicated that they were done with treatment or had finished the full 8 injections). Results A total of 560 patients (mean age 57 years) were identified from March 2014 through Feb 2023 and comprise our study cohort. Overall, 85 men had a ventral component to their curvature and 475 non-ventral. Baseline demographics and clinical factors were similar between groups, with the exception of penile length (ventral 14.0 cm, non-ventral 12.0 cm, p&lt;0.0001), Psych and Physical subdomain of the Peyronie’s Disease Questionnaire (10 vs 12, p=0.03), and prior treatment with CCH (3% vs 16%, p=0.03). Following treatment, men in the ventral cohort exhibited possibly greater improvements in curvature (Most Recent Definition: -25 degrees vs -24, p=0.08; 45% vs 34%, p=0.03; Completed 8 or Satisfied Definition: -35 vs -25, p&lt;0.05, 48% vs 38%, p=0.11). However, all other outcomes were similar between cohorts, including differences in subdomains of the IIEF and PDQ, use of traction therapy, and adverse events including ecchymoses, hematomas, and popping sensations. Importantly, no urethral complications were experienced in the ventral group. Conclusions Men with ventral PD may be effectively treated with CCH with similar AEs compared to other directions. Ventral curvatures are likely associated with greater overall curvature improvements compared to other directions. Disclosure Any of the authors act as a consultant, employee or shareholder of an industry for: Endo - Matt Ziegelmann.
(371) Comparison of Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum to Surgery for the Management of Peyronie’s Disease: A Randomized Trial – 1 Year Outcomes
Larson, Henry, Brearton, K, Warner, R, Ziegelmann, M., Köhler, Tobias , Trost, Landon , Savage, Joshua S. , Helo, Sevann

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | February 6, 2024 | Volume: 21 | Issue: Supplement_1 | Pages: No page available

10.1093/jsxmed/qdae001.356 Get It

Abstract Introduction Since the FDA approval of Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum (CCH) for the treatment of Peyronie’s Disease (PD), there has been significant debate as to its role and comparable efficacy in relation to surgical therapies. We have previously published results comparing the two therapies at 3-months post-treatment. Objective To compare various objective and subjective outcome measures at 12-months post-treatment between men undergoing CCH or surgery for PD. Methods A randomized, controlled trial (NCT04786106) is ongoing. Participants were randomized 1:1 to receive either CCH + traction (RestoreX) + sildenafil or penile surgery (plication and/or incision and grafting) + traction + sildenafil for PD. Objective, standardized (International Index of Erectile Function [IIEF] and Peyronie’s Disease Questionnaire [PDQ]), and non-standardized assessments were obtained at baseline, and post-treatment at 3, 6, 12, 24, 36, 48, and 60 months. Key outcomes included differences in standardized questionnaires, penile curvature, penile length, subsequent interventions, and non-standardized questionnaire responses. Curvature was measured in two planes and summed to provide a composite curvature. Penile length was measured from pubic symphysis to corona. All adjunctive therapies were stopped at 3-months post treatment completion (i.e., traction and sildenafil). Results A total of 40 men were randomized, with 38 completing treatment and 12-month data available on 28 men (CCH=12, surgery=16). Mean age at enrollment was 54.7 years, PD duration 37.4 months (mo), composite curvature 73.1 degrees (deg), and penile length 12.7 cm. All baseline variables were statistically similar between cohorts. Regarding primary outcomes, at 12-months post-treatment, CCH men reported being very satisfied 36%, satisfied 27%, and neutral 36% with none dissatisfied. Men in the Surgery cohort reported 14% very satisfied, 64% satisfied, 0% neutral, and 21% dissatisfied (p&lt;0.01). For secondary outcomes, the median differences between CCH and Surgery were: IIEF-EFD (+2.0 vs +2.0, p=0.82), PDQ-physical (-5 vs -5, p=0.77, note, lower is better for PDQ scales), PDQ-pain (-1 vs 0, p=0.92), PDQ-bother (-7 vs -3, p=0.12), length change (+1.0 vs -0.13 cm, p&lt;0.05), curvature absolute change (-37.5 vs -53.8 degrees, p=0.17), and curvature % improvement (55% vs 82%, p=0.15). Compared to 3-month data, Surgery men experienced greater curve recurrence (objective: Surgery +5 degrees vs -5 degrees CCH, p&lt;0.05), decreased subjective penile length 62% vs 9% CCH (p&lt;0.01) and decreased sensitivity (54% vs 27% CCH, p&lt;0.05). Both groups reported similar rates of improved sexual function (CCH 82% vs 64%, p=0.30) and change in erectile function (CCH 55% improved, 9% worsened; Surgery 62% improved, 8% worsened, p=0.53). Both groups were also equally satisfied with their curvature (CCH 55% vs Surgery 54%, p=0.97), despite greater overall curve improvements in the Surgery arm. 75% of CCH men reported improved indentation/hourglass vs 56% Surgery, p&lt;0.05. Both groups reported similar rates of being willing to do their treatment again (CCH 73% vs 77%, p=0.64), while 91% of CCH men would recommend it to a friend vs 77% Surgery (p=0.35). Conclusions Preliminary data suggests that when compared to surgery at 12-months, CCH men were more likely to be very satisfied, experience penile length increases, and less likely to experience dissatisfaction, curvature recurrence, and decreased penile sensation. Disclosure Yes, this is sponsored by industry/sponsor: Endo Pharmaceuticals. Clarification: Industry funding only - investigator initiated and executed study. Any of the authors act as a consultant, employee or shareholder of an industry for: Matthew Ziegelmann - Endo Pharmaceuticals.
(134) Efficacy of a Novel Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum Protocol for Peyronie’s Disease Among Prior Non-responders: A Randomized, Controlled, Single-Blinded Study
Palmer, Bruce, Brearton, K, Warner, R, Ziegelmann, M., Köhler, Tobias , Trost, Landon , Palmer, B, Savage, Joshua S. , Helo, Sevann

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | February 6, 2024 | Volume: 21 | Issue: Supplement_1 | Pages: No page available

10.1093/jsxmed/qdae001.128 Get It

Abstract Introduction Limited data currently exist on the role and efficacy of additional series of collagenase clostridium histolyticum (CCH) injections among Peyronie’s disease (PD) men who have previously failed a first series of injections. We have previously published outcomes of men undergoing a novel protocol for CCH injections and which demonstrated significant improvements compared to original IMPRESS I and II techniques. We therefore sought to evaluate results of men who had previously failed CCH injections to determine if they would respond to a repeat course using a more aggressive protocol. Objective To evaluate outcomes of a novel protocol for CCH injections among men who had previously failed 6-8 CCH injections using a traditional approach. Methods A randomized, controlled trial (NCT05108558) is ongoing. All participants had previously failed to achieve ≥20% curvature improvement with 6-8 prior CCH injections. Men were randomized 3:1 to receive either CCH + traction (RestoreX) + sildenafil (treatment) up front or initial observation followed by treatment (controls). Outcomes were compared between treatment and control groups. Key measures included objective curve improvements and standardized/non-standardized questionnaires, with assessments obtained at baseline, 6-weeks after completion of CCH (treatment arm), after the no treatment period (controls), and at 1 year. Results A total of 22/40 men have been randomized to date, with 11 having fully completed treatment. Mean age was 64 years, with a median PD duration of 24 months. Mean composite baseline curvature was 80 degrees, with 55% having hourglass or indentation deformities, 10% calcification, median baseline IIEF-EFD 15, and 60% able to have penetrative intercourse. Median estimated improvement with the prior CCH series was 0% (IQR 0, 19.4), and the median number of prior injections was 8. The majority of men were dissatisfied with their prior series of CCH (60% vs 30% satisfied, 10% neutral). Of the 11 men who had completed the study protocol, 64% required 1 series, 9% 2 series, 18% 3 series, and 9% 4 series. Compared to the no treatment arm, treated men experienced significantly greater improvements (mean 78 degree vs 15, p=0.01). IIEF-EFD was also improved more in treated men (+4.3 vs -5.7, p&lt;0.05). 100% of men reported a subjective major improvement in curvature, with the average subjectively estimated improvement 91%. 67% reported improved sensitivity (33% no change), while 60% reported improved or no change in erectile function, with 20% unsure, and 20% somewhat worse. Post-treatment, 83% of men were very satisfied with CCH as a treatment and 17% somewhat satisfied. Conclusions Repeating CCH using a novel protocol after an initially unsuccessful course of CCH achieves significant improvements in curvature and patient satisfaction. Additional data, including external validation, are warranted. Disclosure Yes, this is sponsored by industry/sponsor: Endo Pharmaceuticals. Clarification: Industry funding only - investigator initiated and executed study. Any of the authors act as a consultant, employee or shareholder of an industry for: Matthew Ziegelmann - Endo Pharmaceuticals.
(074) Safety and Efficacy Varying Doses of Prednisone Post Vasectomy Reversal: Results from a Randomized, Controlled Trials
Tyler, A, Brearton, K, Warner, R, Trost, Landon , Savage, Joshua S. , Brearton, K, Helo, Sevann

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | February 6, 2024 | Volume: 21 | Issue: Supplement_1 | Pages: No page available

10.1093/jsxmed/qdae001.070 Get It

Abstract Introduction There has been significant ongoing debate on the role and utility of prednisone post-vasectomy reversal to improve sperm counts and long-term patency. However, there are relatively limited data available on the efficacy, with essentially no data available on pregnancy outcomes. Objective To report outcomes of randomized, clinical trial evaluating varying protocols for prednisone administration post vasectomy reversal. Methods A randomized, controlled trial was performed (NCT04788823) with an anticipated 100 men randomized to one of four prednisone protocols post vasectomy reversal: no treatment (Control), prednisone 20 mg taper over 1 month beginning the first month post-op and then every other month x 6 months (High Dose), prednisone 20 mg taper over 1 month if declining sperm counts or a 0 count were identified (PRN), and prednisone 5 mg daily x 1 week, followed by no treatment x 1 week, continued for 6 months (Low Dose). Randomization tables were created a priori to ensure an equal representation of differing durations of time since the original vasectomy as well as an equal distribution of VV/VV vs VV/EV vs EV/EV procedures. All men had semen analyses obtained monthly for a first 12 months. Surveys were sent periodically to follow-up on subsequent pregnancies. Inclusion criteria included having a female partner &lt;36 years of age with no known fertility factors. Results A total of 75 men were ultimately enrolled due to interim findings suggesting inferiority of the High Dose and PRN treatment arms and decision to close those arms before completing full enrollment. Final enrollment included: Control (n=25), High Dose (n=14), PRN (n=11), and Low Dose (n=25). The mean patient age was 38.5 years, mean partner age 29.6, and mean time since vasectomy 6.3 years (SD 5.0). 82% of men underwent VV/VV, while 15% VV/EV, and 3% EV/EV. All men underwent successful anastomosis bilaterally with no cases of one-sided or no anastomosis performed. At a mean follow-up of 16.5 months (range 7.6 to 25.1), an overall patency (sperm observed on sample) rate of 93% was noted (Control 96%, High Dose 93%, PRN 100%, Low Dose 88%, p=0.41). The mean sperm concentration post-op was 34.4 million/ml (Control 24.0, High Dose 38.4, PRN 21.0, Low Dose 49.8, p=0.33). Patency rates at 6- and 12-months were: 6-months (Control 88%, High Dose 80%, PRN 83%, Low Dose 94%, p=0.75); 12-months (Control 75%, High Dose 71%, PRN 75%, Low Dose 91%). Mean sperm concentrations at 6- and 12-months were: 6-months (Control 15.7, High Dose 21.5, PRN 6.9, Low Dose 25.7, p=0.50); 12-months (Control 12.6 million/ml, High Dose 17.1, PRN 36.1, Low Dose 50.4, p=0.64) At the 6-month post-op time point, the overall rate of pregnancy was 47%, with notable differences between cohorts: Control 57%, High Dose 10%, PRN 38%, and Low Dose 67%, p=0.02. No patients discontinued prednisone due to side effects. Conclusions Prednisone taper protocols appear to reduce the likelihood for pregnancy following vasectomy reversal. Use of low-dose prednisone results in non-statistically higher rates of patency at 6- and 12-months, mean sperm concentration at 6- and 12-months, and pregnancy at 6-months. Overall results suggest superiority of either no prednisone post-vasectomy reversal or a low dose protocol but argue against the use of higher dosages at any time due to its negative impacts on pregnancy rates despite maintained sperm counts. Disclosure No.
Scalp Irradiation with 3D-Milled Bolus: Initial Dosimetric and Clinical Experience
Dibs, Khaled , Gogineni, Emile , Jhawar, Sachin R. , Baliga, Sujith , Grecula, J.C., Mitchell, Darrion , Palmer, Joshua D. , Haglund, Karl, Andraos, T.Y. , Zoller, Wesley , Ewing, Ashlee, Bonomi, Marcelo , Bhateja, Priyanka, Tinoco, Gabriel , Rocco, James W. , Old, Matthew , Gamez, Mauricio E. , Chakravarti, Arnab , Konieczkowski, David J. , Blakaj, Dukagjin , Jhawar, Sachin R , Mitchell, Darrion L , Palmer, Joshua D , Bhateja, Priyanka , Bonomi, Marcelo , Tinoco, Gabriel , Chakravarti, Arnab , Liebner, David A.

Cancers | February 6, 2024 | Volume: 16 | Issue: 4 | Pages: 688

10.3390/cancers16040688 | PMID 38398079 Get It

Background and purpose: A bolus is required when treating scalp lesions with photon radiation therapy. Traditional bolus materials face several issues, including air gaps and setup difficulty due to irregular, convex scalp geometry. A 3D-milled bolus is custom-formed to match individual patient anatomy, allowing improved dose coverage and homogeneity. Here, we describe the creation process of a 3D-milled bolus and report the outcomes for patients with scalp malignancies treated with Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy (VMAT) utilizing a 3D-milled bolus. Materials and methods: Twenty-two patients treated from 2016 to 2022 using a 3D-milled bolus and VMAT were included. Histologies included squamous cell carcinoma (n = 14, 64%) and angiosarcoma (n = 8, 36%). A total of 7 (32%) patients were treated in the intact and 15 (68%) in the postoperative setting. The median prescription dose was 66.0 Gy (range: 60.0–69.96). Results: The target included the entire scalp for 8 (36%) patients; in the remaining 14 (64%), the median ratio of planning target volume to scalp volume was 35% (range: 25–90%). The median dose homogeneity index was 1.07 (range: 1.03–1.15). Six (27%) patients experienced acute grade 3 dermatitis and one (5%) patient experienced late grade 3 skin ulceration. With a median follow-up of 21.4 months (range: 4.0–75.4), the 18-month rates of locoregional control and overall survival were 75% and 79%, respectively. Conclusions: To our knowledge, this is the first study to report the clinical outcomes for patients with scalp malignancies treated with the combination of VMAT and a 3D-milled bolus. This technique resulted in favorable clinical outcomes and an acceptable toxicity profile in comparison with historic controls and warrants further investigation in a larger prospective study.
Biomechanical Characteristics of Ulnar Collateral Ligament Injuries Treated With and Without Augmentation: A Network Meta-analysis of Controlled Laboratory Studies
Kunze, Kyle N. , Fury, Matthew S. , Pareek, Ayoosh , Camp, Christopher L. , Altchek, David W. , Camp, Christopher L. , Dines, Joshua S.

The American Journal of Sports Medicine | February 2, 2024 | Volume: 52 | Issue: 6 | Pages: 1624-1634

10.1177/03635465231188691 | PMID 38304942 Get It

Background: Treatment of ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) tears with suture tape augmentation has gained interest given preliminary reports of favorable biomechanical characteristics. No study to date has quantitatively assessed the biomechanical effects of multiple augmentation techniques relative to the native UCL. Purpose: To perform a systematic review and meta-analysis of controlled laboratory studies to assess and comparatively rank biomechanical effects of UCL repair or reconstruction with or without augmentation. Study Design: Systematic review and meta-analysis; Level of evidence, 4. Methods: PubMed, OVID/Medline, and Cochrane databases were queried in January 2023. A frequentist network meta-analytic approach was used to perform mixed-treatment comparisons of UCL repair and reconstruction techniques with and without augmentation, with the native UCL as the reference condition. Pooled treatment estimates were quantified under the random-effects assumption. Competing treatments were ranked in the network meta-analysis by using point estimates and standard errors to calculate P scores (greater P score indicates superiority of treatment for given outcome). Results: Ten studies involving 206 elbow specimens in which a distal UCL tear was simulated were included. UCL reconstruction with suture tape augmentation (AugRecon) restored load to failure to a statistically noninferior magnitude (mean difference [MD], –1.99 N·m; 95% CI, –10.2 to 6.2 N·m; P = .63) compared with the native UCL. UCL reconstruction (Recon) (MD, –12.7 N·m; P < .001) and UCL repair with suture tape augmentation (AugRepair) (MD, –14.8 N·m; P < .001) were both statistically inferior to the native UCL. The AugRecon condition conferred greater load to failure compared with Recon ( P < .001) and AugRepair ( P = .002) conditions. AugRecon conferred greater torsional stiffness relative to all other conditions and was not statistically different from the native UCL (MD, 0.32 N·m/deg; 95% CI, –0.30 to 0.95 N·m/deg; P = .31). Medial ulnohumeral gapping was not statistically different for the AugRepair (MD, 0.30 mm; 95% CI, –1.22 to 1.82 mm; P = .70), AugRecon (MD, 0.57 mm; 95% CI, –0.70 to 1.84 mm; P = .38), or Recon (MD, 1.02 mm; 95% CI, –0.02 to 2.05 mm; P = .055) conditions compared with the native UCL. P-score analysis indicated that AugRecon was the most effective treatment for increasing ultimate load to failure and torsional stiffness, whereas AugRepair was the most effective for minimizing medial gapping. Conclusion: AugRecon restored load to failure and torsional stiffness most similar to the parameters of the native UCL, whereas Recon and AugRepair did not restore the same advantageous properties at time zero. Medial ulnohumeral gapping during a valgus load was minimized by all 3 treatments. Based on network interactions, AugRecon was the superior treatment approach for restoring important biomechanical features of the UCL at time zero that are jeopardized during a complete distal tear.