Congress of Neurological Surgeons Systematic Review and Evidence-Based Guidelines for the Role of Radiosurgery for Patients With Functioning Pituitary Adenomas
BACKGROUND: Patients with functioning pituitary adenomas (FPA) require a multidisciplinary team-based approach to select best medical, surgical, and radiation treatments, including stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS). OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to provide evidence-based recommendations on the use of SRS for adult patients with FPA. METHODS: PubMed and Embase were searched from data base inception to June 8, 2021. Full-text articles were then screened using published exclusion/inclusion criteria. Evidence tables were developing based on data extraction from the full-text reviews, and evidence-based recommendations were finalized. RESULTS: Of the total 1842 abstracts pertinent to this topic, 343 full articles met eligibility. Of these, 21 met entry criteria and were included in the evidence tables. The provided Class III evidence supported 2 Level III recommendations: 1. SRS, hypofractionated SRS, fractionated (>5 fractions) radiotherapy, and conventional radiation therapy provide excellent radiographic control with variable hormonal reduction and endocrine remission rates. For SRS and fractionated radiotherapy hormonal reduction may continue for up to 10 years after treatment. 2. Clinicians may continue to administer endocrine suppressive medical treatment before SRS as this may not affect radiographic control. CONCLUSION: This systematic review provides evidence-based recommendations to guide providers caring for adult patients with FPA when making decisions pertinent to radiosurgery. The CNS Guidelines Committee will continue to pursue timely updates to further improve the care of patients with this diagnosis.
Expert Strategies: Skull Base Reconstruction—Global Perspectives, Insights, and Algorithms through a Mixed Methods Approach
ABSTRACT Objective There is limited consensus on endoscopic skull base surgery (ESBS) reconstruction principles. This study aims to generate comprehensive themes regarding ESBS reconstruction by pooling the experiences of ESBS experts, with comparison to a literature review of current published evidence. Methods Structured qualitative interviews of ESBS experts regarding postoperative management and reconstruction of various defect locations were conducted. Results A total of 68 experts comprising 40 academic teams across 13 countries with an average of 18 years of ESBS experience were included. We propose 10 stepwise algorithms for common skull base reconstruction scenarios based on these expert interviews. When available, the nasoseptal flap is used for all high_flow cerebrospinal leak defects. Multilayered reconstruction is favored at all anatomical subsites with increasing number of layers for increasing defect size and complexity. Heterogeneity exists in terms of inlay technique and materials, free grafting versus various pedicled flap options for low‐flow defects or in the absence of a nasal septum, nasal packing, tissue sealant, lumbar drain use, and postoperative management. Commonalities and discrepancies between experts were summarized. Conclusion Skull base reconstruction and post‐ESBS management is highly complex with a wide variety of practice patterns and expert strategies. Further research of higher quality evidence is warranted to identify optimal management patterns, though the current work aims to inform surgeons on these controversial areas by drawing from numerous experiences.
A Prospective, Multicenter, Observational Study of Surgical vs Nonsurgical Management for Pituitary Apoplexy
Abstract Context Pituitary apoplexy (PA) has been traditionally considered a neurosurgical emergency, yet retrospective single-institution studies suggest similar outcomes among patients managed medically. Objective We established a multicenter, international prospective registry to compare presentation and outcomes in PA patients treated with surgery or medical management alone. Methods A centralized database captured demographics, comorbidities, clinical presentation, visual findings, hormonal status, and imaging features at admission. Treatment was determined independently by each site. Key outcomes included visual, oculomotor, and hormonal recovery, complications, and hospital length of stay. Outcomes were also compared based on time from symptom onset to surgery, and from admission or transfer to the treating center. Statistical testing compared treatment groups based on 2-sided hypotheses and P less than .05. Results A total of 100 consecutive PA patients from 12 hospitals were enrolled, and 97 (67 surgical and 30 medical) were evaluable. Demographics, clinical features, presenting symptoms, hormonal deficits, and imaging findings were similar between groups. Severe temporal visual field deficit was more common in surgical patients. At 3 and 6 months, hormonal, visual, and oculomotor outcomes were similar. Stratifying based on severity of visual fields demonstrated no difference in any outcome at 3 months. Timing of surgery did not affect outcomes. Conclusion We found that medical and surgical management of PA yield similar 3-month outcomes. Although patients undergoing surgery had more severe visual field deficits, we could not clearly demonstrate that surgery led to better outcomes. Even without surgery, apoplectic tumor volumes regress substantially within 2 to 3 months, indicating that surgery is not always needed to reduce mass effect.
Significant Variability in Postoperative Thromboprophylaxis in Cushing's Disease Patients: A Survey of the North American Skull Base Society and the AANS/CNS Joint Tumor Section
Abstract Introduction Cushing's disease (CD) is associated with hypercoagulability which is associated with an increased risk of venous thromboembolic events (VTEs) perioperatively. This risk persists even after successful transsphenoidal surgery (TSS). However, there are no current guidelines for pharmacologic thromboprophylaxis in this patient population. Objective Characterize existing thromboprophylaxis management practices in patients undergoing TSS for CD. Methods An anonymous RedCap survey comprised of questions about perioperative thromboprophylaxis in CD patients was distributed via the American Association of Neurological Surgeons (AANS)/Congress of Neurological Surgeons (CNS) Joint Tumor Section and the North American Skull Base Society (NASBS) email lists. Results The survey was distributed to 554 members of the AANS/CNS Joint Tumor Section and 1,094 members of NASBS asking that members who surgically treat CD respond. Sixty responses (3.0% response rate) were received. Fifty-two (86.7%) respondents are involved in the postoperative management of CD patients. Thirty-six (69.2%) treat all patients with postoperative VTE chemoprophylaxis, 8 (15.4%) treat some patients, while 8 (15.4%) do not use chemoprophylaxis. Preferred chemoprophylaxis varies as 26 (59.1%) administer low molecular weight heparin, 14 (31.8%) give unfractionated heparin, 1 (2.3%) give direct oral anticoagulants, and 3 (6.8%) give aspirin. Most (28, 53.8%) of the respondents perceive the VTE risk in this patient population to be 0 to 5%, 16 (30.8%) perceive the risk to be 6 to 10%, and 8 (15.4%) perceive it to be 11 to 20%. Conclusion There is great variability in VTE detection and postoperative prevention practice patterns in CD patients. This study highlights the need for prospective studies to clarify optimal pharmacologic chemoprophylaxis strategies and duration in this patient population.
Beyond the surgical margin: Patterns of recurrence in WHO grade II intracranial meningiomas
Abstract Purpose To characterize and classify the location of recurrence in surgically resected World Health Organization (WHO) grade II intracranial meningiomas that did not receive adjuvant radiation, and compare the recurrence pattern of those that underwent gross total (GTR) versus subtotal resection (STR). Methods A retrospective review of patients who underwent surgical resection of WHO grade II meningiomas at our institution between 2006 and 2019 was performed. Patients that were observed postoperatively without adjuvant radiation and subsequently developed a recurrence were included. Recurrence was defined as evidence of radiographic progression on postoperative surveillance MRI. Location of recurrence were categorized as: (1)central - growth observed inside the area of the previously resected tumor more than 1 cm inside the original tumor margin; (2)marginal - growth observed within 1 cm (inside or outside) of the original tumor margin; and (3)distant - growth observed more than 1 cm outside of the original tumor margin. Results A total of 22 patients matched the inclusion criteria. Twelve (55%) underwent GTR while ten (45%) underwent STR. Of the GTR patients, ten (83.3%) had central recurrence, 11 (91.7%) had marginal recurrence, and only 4 (33.3%) had distant recurrence. Of the STR patients, 9 (90.0%) had central recurrence, all 10 (100.0%) had marginal recurrence, and only 4 (40.0%) had distant recurrence. Conclusion The present study evaluating patterns of recurrence for WHO grade II meningiomas after surgical resection showed that recurrence occurred centrally and/or at the original tumor margin, with only a minority recurring > 1cm outside the original tumor margin.
Triphasic response after endoscopic craniopharyngioma resection and its dependency on infundibular preservation or sacrifice
OBJECTIVE Surgery is the primary treatment for craniopharyngioma with the preservation of hypothalamic function of paramount importance. Infundibular preservation is debated, as maximal resection decreases recurrence rates but causes hypopituitarism. A triphasic response of diabetes insipidus (DI), syndrome of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion (SIADH), and recurrent DI has been described after pituitary surgery, but the impact of infundibular preservation on the triphasic response following craniopharyngioma resection has not been well established. The authors’ objective was to assess postoperative fluid and sodium balance and differences in ADH imbalance management following endonasal craniopharyngioma resection based on infundibular transection status. METHODS This is a retrospective cohort study of 19 patients with craniopharyngioma treated with endoscopic endonasal resection between 2014 and 2021. Resection was dichotomized into infundibular transection or preservation. Postoperative triphasic response, time to DI, and time to ADH replacement were compared using Fisher’s exact test and Kaplan-Meier analysis. RESULTS Based on surgeon impression, 10 patients had infundibular transection and 9 had infundibular preservation. Overall, 16 patients experienced DI, 12 experienced persistent DI, and 6 experienced SIADH. A postoperative triphasic response occurred in 40% (n = 4) of transection patients without preoperative DI and 11% (n = 1) of preservation patients without preoperative DI. The median time to postoperative DI (0.5 vs 18.0 hours, p = 0.022) and median time to ADH replacement therapy (4.5 vs 24 hours, p = 0.0004) were significantly shorter in the transection group than in the preservation group. CONCLUSIONS Following endonasal craniopharyngioma resection, the triphasic response occurs in nearly half of infundibular transection cases. DI begins earlier with infundibular transection. On the basis of the study findings in which no patients met the criteria for SIADH or were endocrinologically unstable after postoperative day 6, it is reasonable to suggest that otherwise stable patients can be discharged at or before postoperative day 6 when ADH fluctuations have normalized and endocrinopathy is appropriately managed with oral desmopressin. Infundibular transection status may impact postoperative hormonal replacement strategies, but additional studies should evaluate their efficacies.
Endoscopic Transpterygoid Transcavernous Approach for Resection of a Petroclival Chondrosarcoma: 2-Dimensional Operative Video
Background Historically, lumbar drains (LD) have played a prominent role in endonasal skull base surgery. Over the past few decades, advancements in techniques have augmented our ability to successfully reconstruct complex skull base defects and often obviates the need for cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) diversion. Clarity on the appropriate use of LDs is needed. Objective To examine the literature for the need for LDs in contemporary skull base reconstruction after resection of skull base tumors. Methods A systematic literature review of English language articles by using PubMed and Ovid. Search terms included “lumbar drain,” “CSF leak,” and “endoscopic endonasal reconstruction.” Articles were included when they pertained to adults, used current methods for reconstruction (i.e., multilayered repair or vascularized tissue), and addressed CSF leak rates secondary to endoscopic resection of skull base masses. All the studies discussed CSF leaks that resulted from traumatic-, idiopathic-, or sinus surgery-related iatrogenic causes were excluded. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines were followed. Results A total of five articles met inclusion criteria. These comprised 376 endoscopic skull base tumor resection and reconstruction cases; 5.59% developed postoperative CSF leaks. A meta-analysis was conducted by incorporating three studies that met criteria based on testing for heterogeneity. The average odds ratio for postoperative CSF leak for patients who did not have an LD relative to patients who had an LD was 0.590 (95% confidence interval, 0.214–1.630). Given a p value of 0.30, the results demonstrated a lack of statistically significant improvement between patients who had an LD and patients who did not have an LD. Various details, such as the defect size and type of CSF leak, were not consistently reported among studies. Conclusions Available evidence for the use of LDs in skull base surgery is of poor quality. Analysis of the literature revealed heterogenous and varied reporting in the primary literature. Further studies that include randomized controlled trials are needed.
Successful repair of intraoperative cerebrospinal fluid leaks improves outcomes in endoscopic skull base surgery
BackgroundThe impact of failed cerebrospinal fluid leak (CSF) leak repair in endoscopic skull base surgery has not been adequately studied.MethodsIn this investigation we reviewed patients who had undergone endoscopic skull base surgery between 2002 and 2014 at 7 international centers. Demographic variables, comorbidities, tumor characteristics, and repair techniques were evaluated to determine association with successful repair of CSF leak. Postoperative complications and length of stay were compared among groups.ResultsData were collected on 2097 patients who were divided into 3 groups: (1) those with no intraoperative leak (n = 1533); (2) those with successful repair of their intraoperative leak (n = 452); and (3) those with failed repair (n = 112). Compared with successful repair, failed repair was associated with an increased risk of intracranial infection (odds ratio [OR], 5.6; 95% confidence interval [CI], 5.3‐13.15), pneumocephalus (OR, 16; 95% CI, 5.8‐44.4), 30‐day readmission (OR, 8.4; 95% CI, 5.3‐13.5), reoperation (OR, 115.4; 95% CI, 56.3‐236.8), and prolonged hospital stay (14.9 vs 7.0 days, p < 0.01). Outcomes in patients who had successful repairs of intraoperative leaks were similar to those who never had leakage. Intraoperative use of pedicled nasoseptal flaps was associated with successful repair (OR, 0.60; 95% CI, 0.34‐0.92).ConclusionIntraoperative CSF leaks are a frequent and expected occurrence during endoscopic skull base surgery. Failed CSF leak repair has a significant impact on patient outcomes, with increased rates of postoperative pneumocephalus, intracranial infections, reoperation, deep vein thrombosis, readmission, and prolonged hospital stay. Recognition and repair of intraoperative CSF leaks reduces postoperative complications. Use of pedicled nasoseptal flaps improves outcomes in reconstructing defects at higher risk for postoperative leak.