Barresi, Valeria

Abstract INTRODUCTION Glioblastoma is the most common malignant adult brain tumor with poor prognosis, largely due to its heterogeneous landscape. The AI-RANO and RANO-RGP groups organized the BraTS-Pathology 2024 challenge, providing a publicly-available dataset and a benchmarking environment for AI models to automatically identify six clinically-relevant histopathologic sub-regions in H&E-stained whole slide images (WSIs). METHODS We reclassified the TCGA-GBM and TCGA-LGG data according to the WHO 2021 criteria and identified diagnostic WSIs of 188 glioblastoma (IDH-wt, CNS WHO Gr.4) patients. A well-defined annotation protocol was communicated to eight neuropathologists, across eight institutions, who created “ground truth” annotations for Cellular Tumor (CT), Geographic Necrosis, Cortical Infiltration, Pseudopalisading Necrosis (PN), Microvascular Proliferation, and Penetration into White Matter (PWM). Comprehensive WSI curation for elimination of artifactual content and follow up partitioning resulted in approximately 300,000 data samples/patches. FINDINGS Inter-observer variability assessment highlighted difficulties in establishing a “gold standard”. The least annotated sub-regions (PWM and PN) were the most challenging to the participating methods, whereas all methods achieved their highest accuracy in the most annotated sub-region (CT). The highest average performance across sub-regions was obtained by a foundation model-based method. However, this top-ranked solution achieved an F1 score of 0.51 (Accuracy=0.65, Sensitivity=0.56, Specificity=0.93). CONCLUSIONS Our findings suggest that achieving state-of-the-art performance, in automatically identifying clinically-relevant glioblastoma sub-regions, remains an unsolved research problem. Analysis of the ground-truth annotations underscores the critical need for more precisely defined and neuropathologically standardized annotation protocol. Current AI algorithms are facing difficulties in addressing glioblastoma’s heterogeneous histologic landscape in the absence of large, comprehensively, and consistently annotated data. Building upon these findings, and towards developing more accurate AI algorithms, the 2025 iteration of the BraTS-Path challenge is currently on-going by leveraging two million data samples, aiming to enhance our disease understanding and improve diagnostic accuracy, ultimately contributing to improved patient outcomes.

Abstract Glioblastoma, the most common malignant primary adult brain tumor, poses significant diagnostic and treatment challenges due to its heterogeneous molecular and micro-environmental profiles. To this end, we organize the BraTS-Path challenge to provide a public benchmarking environment and a comprehensive dataset to develop and validate AI models for identifying distinct histopathologic glioblastoma sub-regions in H&E-stained digitized tissue sections. We identified 188 multi-institutional diagnostic slides of glioblastoma (IDH-wt, Gr.4) cases, from the TCGA-GBM and TCGA-LGG data collections, following their reclassification according to the 2021 WHO classification criteria. Sub-regions were selected according to distinctive morphology of histopathologic features and included aggressive tumor biology and areas consistent with potential treatment effect. Selected sub-region annotations included cellular tumor, geographic necrosis, cortical infiltration, pseudopalisading necrosis, microvascular proliferation, white matter penetration, regions dense with macrophages, leptomeningeal infiltration, and presence of lymphocytes. We obtained 107,340 patches of size 512x512 from the 9 sub-regions. A global network of board-certified expert neuropathologists defined and followed a systematic annotation protocol based on clinical definitions and only delineated sub-regions with high confidence, thus ensuring high-quality standardized data. Each tissue section was assigned to an annotator-approver pair, with the annotator delineating sub-regions and the approver ensuring the consistency of the annotations. By crowdsourcing annotations, the BraTS-Path challenge harnesses the collective expertise of clinical neuropathologists and fosters a collaborative environment to advance the neuro-oncology field. The anticipated developed algorithms are expected to integrate state-of-the-art computational methods, achieving high accuracy in identifying diverse histopathologic features and advancing clinical decision-making processes. The BraTS-Path challenge aims to bridge the gap between research and clinical practice by promoting the development of AI-driven tools for precise tumor characterization. This collaborative effort can significantly enhance our understanding of glioblastoma, improve diagnostic accuracy, and inform treatment strategies, thereby contributing to better patient outcomes.