Back to Authors

Mahoney, Douglas W.

https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5144-0645

Mayo Clinic

Mayo Clinic

Citations 91

Plasma methylated DNA markers of cutaneous melanoma: Association with PET/CT-positive disease.
Meves, Alexander , Taylor, William R. , Burger, Kelli N. , Quattrocchi, Enrica , Doering, Karen A. , Gonser, Anna M. , Heilberger, Justin, Gysbers, Brianna, Katerov, Viatcheslav E. , Allawi, Hatim T. , Doering, Karen A , Berger, Calise K. , Mahoney, Douglas W. , Cao, Xiaoming , Foote, Patrick H. , Kisiel, John B.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | June 6, 2022 | Volume: 40 | Issue: 16_suppl | Pages: 9567-9567

10.1200/jco.2022.40.16_suppl.9567 Get It

9567 Background: Cutaneous melanoma surveillance is important to identify low-volume systemic disease, but imaging is costly and poorly accessible to patients; frequent skin checks lack sensitivity and specificity. We aimed to establish clinical feasibility of a liquid biopsy blood test, which quantifies validated, melanoma-specific, methylated DNA markers (MDMs), previously discovered, and reported by our team, using tissue extracted DNA. Methods: We prospectively collected blood from adult patients with histologically confirmed melanoma metastases and no other internal malignancies (within 5-years) who underwent surveillance by FDG-PET/CT (N = 88). Blood from age- and sex balanced cancer-free controls (N = 100) were compared. From PET/CT, we extracted the number of organs involved, SUV-max, and largest tumor diameter. Unequivocal metastasis was defined as SUV ≥ 4 and largest diameter > 5 mm. Because PET/CT is inadequate for the screening of brain metastases, we excluded the brain from the analysis. MDMs ( chr11.149, HOXA9, chr20.210, FLJ22536, CLIC5, SIX4, chr7.155, chr17.730, chr1.110) were assayed using target enrichment long-probe quantitative-amplified signal assays, normalized to B3GALT6, in blinded fashion. Using a logistic regression approach and nine candidate MDMs, we calculated the sensitivity for detecting patients with metastasis on PET/CT at 100% specificity. Results: 52/88 (59%) of melanoma patients showed evidence of metastasis on PET/CT at the time of blood draw. At 100% specificity, a panel of 4 MDMs ( HOXA9, chr20.210, chr17.730, chr1.110) yielded a sensitivity of 86.5% (45/52 cases) vs. 100 cancer-free controls. When applying this model to the 36 PET/CT-negative patients, specificity was as high as 97.2% (35/36 cases) while maintaining a sensitivity of 86.5% (one patient with a positive test result had a complete metabolic response to binimetinib / encorafenib prior to negative PET/CT). For patients with ≥ 2 organs involved by metastasis, sensitivity was 100% (29/29 cases). False-negative cases had metastasis in single organs and were characterized by minimal tumor burden and oral corticosteroid use. One false-negative patient had localized stage III disease without known primary melanoma. Conclusions: Plasma MDM levels appear highly concordant with FDG-PET/CT in patients with metastatic cutaneous melanoma. A liquid biopsy approach has potential to lower cost and improve patient access to surveillance. Additional prospective studies in larger intended use cohorts are needed to validate our results.
Methylated DNA markers in early detection of lymphoma: Discovery, validation, and clinical pilot.
Burger, Kelli N. , Devens, Mary E., Arndt, Jacquelyn R., Novak, Anne J. , Hennek, Jacquelyn, Katerov, Viatcheslav E. , Allawi, Hatim T. , Dao, Linda N. , Witzig, Thomas E. , Taylor, William R. , Mahoney, Douglas W. , Bamlet, William R. , Foote, Patrick H. , Doering, Karen A. , O'Connell, Maria, Berger, Calise K. , Cerhan, James R. , Jevremović, Dragan , Graham, Rondell P. , Kisiel, John B.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | June 6, 2022 | Volume: 40 | Issue: 16_suppl | Pages: 7562-7562

10.1200/jco.2022.40.16_suppl.7562 Get It

7562 Background: Lymphoma is the 6th most common cancer and a top 10 cause of cancer deaths. To date, there are no blood test approaches to population screening, and accurate surveillance markers are limited. Methylated DNA markers (MDMs) are broadly informative for early detection of cancer but have not been extensively studied for lymphomas. We sought to discover and validate MDMs in DNA extracted from lymphoma tissue, then test these MDMs in archival blood plasma specimens. Methods: Reduced representation bisulfite sequencing (RRBS) was performed on DNA extracted from a discovery set of frozen tissues of classic Hodgkin lymphoma (CHL, n=24), non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL, n=78: T-cell-TCL (8); diffuse large B-cell-DLBCL (18); follicular-FL (12); mantle cell-MCL (20); marginal zone-MZL (15)), and lymphoma cell line samples (27); controls included benign lymph node (n=11) and healthy donor buffy coat (n=30). 30 MDMs were ranked by fold-change and AUC and used to design methylation-specific PCR assays for biological validation on independent DNA samples extracted from FFPE tissue from 13 normal lymph node and 63 lymphoma samples and 36 buffy coats from healthy patients. Target enrichment long-probe quantitative-amplified signal assays were developed for 16 MDMs and then assayed in plasma-extracted, bisulfite-converted DNA samples from 390 independent treatment-naïve lymphoma patients (100 CHL and 290 NHL:100 DLBCL, 73 FL, 41 MCL, 41 MZL, 35 TCL), and 210 controls without cancer. Lymphoma plasma samples and 159 controls were provided by the Lymphoma SPORE (CA97274); 51 controls came from a 7-county population archive. Classification of lymphoma cases vs controls was modeled with random forest method and cross-validated across 500 bootstrap samples of each dataset. Results: For MDMs tested in DNA from independent biological validation samples, cross-validated random forest models identified 60/63 cases (95% sensitivity) and 12/13 normal controls (92% specificity). In plasmas, a panel of 16 MDMs ( ZNF503, VWA5B1, HOXA9_5195, GABRG3, ITGA5, MAX_chr17_793, BNC1_2407, CDK20, MAX_chr4_184, TPBG, DNAH14, SYT2, CACNG8, FAM110B, and NRN1) detected 78% (95% CI, 74-82%) of lymphoma cases at 90% specificity. Excluding MZL and TCL, sensitivity increased to 84% (80-88%) including 26/49 (53% (38-67%)) of stage I and 59/71 (83% (71-90%)) of stage II cases. Conclusions: MDMs show promise to detect lymphoma. These markers could be evaluated as part of multicancer early detection testing and could also be evaluated as response markers to treatment and subsequent surveillance.[Table: see text]
Methylated DNA markers discriminate ovarian cancer from benign tissue in BRCA carriers.
Cao, Xiaoming , Burger, Kelli N. , Arndt, Jacquelyn R., Taylor, William R. , Samadder, Jewel, Weng, Jessica , Bakkum‐Gamez, Jamie N. , Slettedahl, Seth W. , Mahoney, Douglas W. , Foote, Patrick H. , Berger, Calise K. , O'Connell, Maria, Doering, Karen A. , Sherman, Mark E. , Chen, Longwen , Couch, Fergus J. , Kisiel, John B.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | June 6, 2022 | Volume: 40 | Issue: 16_suppl | Pages: e17610-e17610

10.1200/jco.2022.40.16_suppl.e17610 Get It

e17610 Background: Methylated DNA markers (MDMs) associated with sporadic ovarian cancer (OC) are detected in plasma from patients with treatment naïve tumors, but not cancer-free controls. To assess potential benefits to patients at risk for hereditary OC, the aim of this study was to measure the performance of validated sporadic OC MDMs in OC and benign ovarian tissue (BOT), surgically obtained from germline BRCA1 or BRCA2 ( BRCA1/2) mutation carriers. Methods: BRCA1/2 carriers with OC and BRCA1/2 carriers who had undergone risk-reducing salpingo-oophorectomy (SO) were identified at a comprehensive cancer center. BRCA1/2 carriers in both OC and BOT groups were balanced on age and year of surgery with non- BRCA carriers with sporadic OC or benign indications for SO. OC and BOT formalin fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) tissues were macrodissected following pathologist selection of representative sites; DNA was extracted, and bisulfite converted. 15 OC MDMs ( GDF6, IFFO1, MAX.chr1.147790358, MAX.chr6.10382190, MAX.chr11.14926602, C2CD4D, PDRM14, NCOR2, SKI, DSCR6, SIM2, PALLD, CDO1, GPRIN1, BCAT1) previously identified in sporadic OC were assayed by quantitative methylation specific PCR, normalized by β-actin, by blinded personnel. Areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) were generated for each MDM to assess discrimination of OC from benign tissue and compared between BRCA1/2 and sporadic (non- BRCA) patients, using a z-test. Results: Among BRCA1/2 carriers, there were 48 OC ( BRCA-OC) and 48 BOT ( BRCA-BOT); among non- BRCA, we matched 48 OC (Sporadic-OC) and 48 BOT (non- BRCA-BOT). The median AUC for OC MDM discriminated between OC and BOT with AUCs in BRCA1/2 carriers was 0.87, (IQR, 0.83-0.93). Sporadic-OC vs non- BRCA-BOT median AUC was 0.88 (IQR, 0.83-0.92). AUCs were not significantly different for each MDM when stratified by BRCA or sporadic status. MDMs with an AUC of ≥0.9 in either group are shown (Table). Conclusions: OC MDMs identified and validated in sporadic OC are highly discriminant for OC from BOT in DNA extracted from tissues of people who carry a BRCA1/2 mutation. Testing the performance of these OC MDMs in plasma from BRCA1/2 carriers with and without OC may be of clinical value for high-risk patients and inform multi-cancer early detection testing strategies.[Table: see text]
Methylated DNA markers in urine aid in the selective identification of patients with prostate cancer as well as clinically significant pathology.
Shah, Paras , Taylor, William R. , Gysbers, Brianna, Then, Sara S., Devens, Mary E., Burger, Kelli N. , Nikolai, Brandon, Kaiser, Michael W., Allawi, Hatim T. , Gettman, Matthew T., Mahoney, Douglas W. , Foote, Patrick H. , Doering, Karen A. , Kisiel, John B.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | June 6, 2022 | Volume: 40 | Issue: 16_suppl | Pages: 5091-5091

10.1200/jco.2022.40.16_suppl.5091 Get It

5091 Background: Controversy surrounding prostate-specific antigen (PSA) based screening for prostate cancer (PCa) highlights the need for non-invasive assays that better discriminate patients with and without clinically significant prostate cancer (csPCa). Such distinction avoids overtreatment in patients with absent or indolent disease while capturing pathology that would derive benefit from intervention. We analyzed the presence of specific methylated DNA markers (MDMs) within urine samples of patients with biopsy proven PCa and assessed the ability to discriminate these patients from healthy controls with no clinical suspicion for PCa. Methods: 24 healthy volunteers with no clinical suspicion for PCa were age-matched to 24 patients with biopsy-confirmed disease across all Gleason scores. Urine collected from subjects was centrifuged with the cell-free supernatant analyzed in a blinded fashion for methylation signal within specific DNA sequences across 14 genes ( HES5, ZNF655, ITPRIPL1, MAX.chr3.193, SLCO3A1, CHST11, SERPINB9, WNT3A, KCNB2, GAS6, AKR1B1, MAX.chr3.727, GRASP, ST6GALNAC2) by target enrichment long-probe quantitative-amplified signal assays. A patient was considered to have a positive MDM panel if any individual marker exceeded the corresponding100% specificity cut-off value (overall MDM panel specificity of 100%). MDM panel positivity was used to evaluate the sensitivity for distinguishing patients with PCa (any Gleason score) from controls as well as discriminate csPCa cancers from PCa Gleason 6. Results: Median age of healthy controls and PCa patients was 70 years (IQR 67-72) and 65 years (IQR 61-71), respectively. Median PSA was 6.4 (IQR 4.9-9.0) among PCa patients, including median PSA of 5 (IQR 4.0-6.1) for Gleason 6, and 7.8 (IQR 5.1-9.2) for Gleason ≥7 disease. Gleason 6, Gleason 7, and Gleason 8+ cancer was noted in 8, 10, and 6 patients, respectively. Utilizing an overall specificity cut-off of 100% for discriminating normal controls from PCa cases across the MDM panel revealed an overall sensitivity of 83% (95% CI: 63-95%) for detection of PCa (6 of 8 Gleason 6, 9 of 10 Gleason 7, 5 of 6 Gleason 8+) and 88% (95% CI: 62-98%) for csPCa (Gleason ≥ 7). When considering a 100% specificity threshold for controls and Gleason 6 patients, the sensitivity the MDM panel was 69% (95% CI: 41-89%) for csPCa (6 of 10 Gleason 7, 5 of 6 Gleason 8+). Conclusions: We describe a panel of 14 MDMs within urine that offer high specificity and sensitivity for detection of prostate cancers as well as selective identification of clinically significant disease states. Prospective comparison between urine MDMs and PSA blood testing is necessary to discern the differential clinical impact of each screening methodology.
Plasma methylated DNA markers detect recurrence and response to therapy in colorectal cancer.
Zhu, Mojun , Then, Sara S., Burger, Kelli N. , Gonser, Anna M. , Kaiser, Michael W., Allawi, Hatim T. , Taylor, William R. , Mahoney, Douglas W. , Berger, Calise K. , Doering, Karen A. , Foote, Patrick H. , Hubbard, Joleen M. , Kisiel, John B.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | June 6, 2022 | Volume: 40 | Issue: 16_suppl | Pages: e15567-e15567

10.1200/jco.2022.40.16_suppl.e15567 Get It

e15567 Background: Radiographic surveillance of colorectal cancer (CRC) after therapy is costly and insensitive. We have reported high cross-sectional performance of methylated DNA markers (MDMs) for detection of primary CRC and metastatic recurrence. This study evaluated MDMs to detect recurrence and measure response to anti-cancer therapy in a longitudinal cohort. Methods: This was a nested case-control study drawn from a prospective cohort of adult patients with CRC who completed definitive treatment and followed forward from the start of surveillance by cross-sectional imaging (CT or MRI) and carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), collected every 3-6 months under routine care. Blood was collected in LBgard® tubes (Biomatrica, San Diego CA). Cases had recurrent CRC (defined by RECIST v1.1 or radiographic findings that justify re-initiation of anti-cancer therapy as determined by treating clinicians). Controls remained NED (no radiographic recurrence and off therapy for ≥4 surveillance visits). From 6mL of plasma, MDMs ( CNNM1, ANKRD13B, FER1L4, ZNF568, CHST2, ZNF671, VAV3, QKI, GRIN2D, DTX1, PDGFD, SFMBT2, JAM3) were measured by target enrichment long-probe quantitative-amplified signal assays, normalized to B3GALT6, in blinded fashion. Previously published random forest models of MDMs +/- CEA, developed on independent patients with intact primary tumors, were used to develop a summary score. Results: With a median follow-up of 276 days (IQR 187-343) and 3 visits per patient (54 visits total), 18 patients had recurrence after start of surveillance. Another 18 patients remained NED after median 555 days (IRQ 469-662) and 4 surveillance visits per patient (76 visits total). Using a 90th %-ile cut-off summary score from 60 NED patients in a prior cross-sectional measurement, the MDM panel was positive in 15 of 18 patients who recurred and only 2 of the 18 NED patients (Table). Of the 76 patient visits for NED patients, 67 (88%) were below the threshold. The MDM panel score crossed the positivity threshold by a median of 127 days (IRQ 0-233) preceding clinical or radiographic documentation of recurrence. A random forest model with CEA was more sensitive but less specific (Table). In patients who resumed therapy, the MDM panel scores correlated closely with subsequent RECIST scores (not shown). Conclusions: Plasma MDMs rise in anticipation of recurrent CRC prior to radiographic detection and remain low in patients without radiographic disease over serial measurements, warranting further development of this tumor-agnostic liquid biopsy approach as a cost-effective tool to assist cancer surveillance.[Table: see text]
Integrating Genome and Methylome Data to Identify Candidate DNA Methylation Biomarkers for Pancreatic Cancer Risk
Zhu, Jingjing , Yang, Yaohua , Kisiel, John B. , Michaud, Dominique S. , Shu, Xiao-Ou , Liu, Duo , Li, Bingshan , Tao, Ran , Wu, Lang , Mahoney, Douglas W. , Shu, Xiao-Ou , Cai, Qiuyin , Zheng, Wei , Kisiel, John B , Michaud, Dominique S , Guo, Xingyi , Taylor, William R. , Shu, Xiao‐Ou , Cai, Qiuyin , Zheng, Wei , Long, Jirong , Yang, Yaohua

Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention | September 9, 2021 | Volume: 30 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 2079-2087

10.1158/1055-9965.epi-21-0400 Get It

AbstractBackground:The role of methylation in pancreatic cancer risk remains unclear. We integrated genome and methylome data to identify CpG sites (CpG) with the genetically predicted methylation to be associated with pancreatic cancer risk. We also studied gene expression to understand the identified associations.Methods:Using genetic data and white blood cell methylation data from 1,595 subjects of European descent, we built genetic models to predict DNA methylation levels. After internal and external validation, we applied prediction models with satisfactory performance to the genetic data of 8,280 pancreatic cancer cases and 6,728 controls of European ancestry to investigate the associations of predicted methylation with pancreatic cancer risk. For associated CpGs, we compared their measured levels in pancreatic tumor versus benign tissue.Results:We identified 45 CpGs at nine loci showing an association with pancreatic cancer risk, including 15 CpGs showing an association independent from identified risk variants. We observed significant correlations between predicted methylation of 16 of the 45 CpGs and predicted expression of eight adjacent genes, of which six genes showed associations with pancreatic cancer risk. Of the 45 CpGs, we were able to compare measured methylation of 16 in pancreatic tumor versus benign pancreatic tissue. Of them, six showed differentiated methylation.Conclusions:We identified methylation biomarker candidates associated with pancreatic cancer using genetic instruments and added additional insights into the role of methylation in regulating gene expression in pancreatic cancer development.Impact:A comprehensive study using genetic instruments identifies 45 CpG sites at nine genomic loci for pancreatic cancer risk.
Abstract 6278: Burden of Chronic Renal Insufficiency in the General Population and Added Predictive Power of GFR to BNP and NT-proBNP in Detection of Altered Ventricular Structure and Function
Rodeheffer, Richard J. , Redfield, Margaret M. , Martín, Fernando L., Burnett, John C. , Cataliotti, Alessandro , Mahoney, Douglas W. , Lam, Carolyn S.P.

Circulation | July 3, 2021 | Volume: 118 | Issue: suppl_18 | Pages: No page available

10.1161/circ.118.suppl_18.s_1173 Get It

Background: Chronic renal insufficiency (CRI) is a strong predictor of increased mortality in the presence of heart failure (HF) and its prevalence has been increasing in the US. In addition, CRI is a major contributing factor to the progression of HF as it is associated with chronic volume overload, accelerated atherosclerosis and hypertension (HTN). The first aim of the current study was to evaluate the prevalence of CRI in an adult general population. The second aim was to address whether calculated glomerular filtration rate (cGFR) adds value to the cardiac biomarkers BNP and NT-proBNP in detecting early cardiac structural and functional impairments in the general population. Methods: From 1997 to 1999 medical history, physical examination, echocardiography, BNP (Biosite) and NT-proBNP (Roche) and serum creatinine (SCr) were obtained in 1,982 randomly selected residents of Olmsted County, MN >= 45 years (range 45 – 96 years). GFR was calculated using the Cockroft Gault equation. CRI was defined as a GFR < 60 ml/min. Cardiac structure and function were evaluated by in-depth echocardiographic examination. Results: The prevalence of cardiovascular co-morbidities was coronary atherosclerosis 12%, HTN 29.5% and diabetes mellitus 7.5%. The prevalence of CRI was 22.8% when cGFR was used for its detection. Importantly, by Chi-Square model, cGFR significantly increased the ability of BNP in detecting left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) (p=0.004), increased relative wall thickness (p=0.0036), diastolic dysfunction (DDF) (p=0.0001) and HTN (p=0.0002). Similarly, when combined with NT-proBNP, cGFR increased the predictive power of detecting DDF (p=0.0001) and HTN (p=0.0366). Conclusion: This study reports a higher than predicted prevalence of CRI in this general US population equal to 23% and closely associated with the prevalence of HTN (29.5%). Importantly, this study also demonstrates that cGFR has additive predictive power when used in combination with two cardiac biomarkers of cardiac dysfunction and remodeling, BNP and NT-proBNP. These studies underscore the increasing burden of CRI in the general population and the utility of assessing cardiorenal function by combining renal and cardiac biomarkers in assessment of cardiac structure and function.
Abstract 111: Accurate multi-cancer detection using methylated DNA markers and proteins in plasma
Katerov, Slava, Vaccaro, Abram, Hennek, Jacquelyn, Carlson, Jennifer , Allawi, Hatim T. , Carlson, Jennifer, Taylor, William R. , Mahoney, Douglas W. , Kisiel, John B.

Cancer Research | July 1, 2021 | Volume: 81 | Issue: 13_Supplement | Pages: 111-111

10.1158/1538-7445.am2021-111 Get It

Abstract Purpose: Screening for high prevalence cancers (breast, colorectum and uterine cervix) reduces mortality; however, most cancer deaths arise in unscreened organs. An ideal solution would accurately detect multiple currently unscreened cancers in a single round of testing. We aimed to assess the feasibility of a targeted assay panel of methylated DNA markers (MDMs) and proteins for detection of highly lethal cancers in a multi-cancer case-control study. Experimental Procedures: Prospectively collected plasmas from 180 cases of 6 cancer types (stage A-D liver (n=36), and TNM stage II-IV esophageal (n=18), lung (n=36), ovarian (n=30), pancreatic (n=30), and stomach (n=30)) and 257 smoking status, age-, and gender-matched asymptomatic controls were tested in blinded fashion. To quantify 26 MDMs previously found to be common among many cancers, multiplex PCR followed by LQAS (Long probe Quantitative Amplified Signal) assay was performed on bisulfite converted DNA extracted from 3 mL of plasma. Additionally, 5 proteins were tested from paired serum aliquots and combined with MDMs for a multi-analyte analysis. Two-thirds of the cases and controls were used to develop prediction algorithms, both logistic regression and random forest models, and the remaining 1/3 were used to validate the models. Results: Using stepwise logistic regression, a combination of 3 proteins (CEA, CA-125, CA19-9) and 5 MDMs (ZNF671, GRIN2D, NDGR4, SHOX2, B3GALT6) resulted in an AUC of 0.95 and an overall sensitivity of 87% for all cancers at 95% specificity. The logistic model on the validation set of the samples resulted in an AUC of 0.96 and a sensitivity of 83% with an observed specificity of 94%. The cancer-specific sensitivities ranged from 78% for lung cancer to 90% for ovarian and pancreatic cancer (Table). Random forest and logistic analyses were in agreement. Conclusion: Targeted assay of select MDMs and proteins show high discrimination for multiple cancers in a case control study, which included early stage patients. Performance with 95% confidence intervals of multi-target assay for multi-cancer detectionSensitivitySpecificityModelOverallBy cancer typeLungEsophagealGastricPancreaticLiverOvarianLogisticTraining set87%(79-92%)79%83%90%95%88%85%95%(90-97%)Test set83%(72-91%)75%100%80%80%75%100%94%(87%-98%)Training + Test186%(80-90%)78%89%87%90%83%90%95%(91-97%)Training + Test275%(68-81%)50%89%83%76%81%80%98%(96-99%)Random forest377%(70-83%)58%78%83%77%81%87%95%(92-97%)195% specificity goal, 5 MDMs and 3 proteins.298% specificity goal, 5 MDMs and 3 proteins.3With 500-fold in silico cross-validation on all samples and all markers (26 MDMs + 5 proteins) Citation Format: Slava Katerov, Abram Vaccaro, Jacquelyn Hennek, Jennifer Carlson, William R. Taylor, Douglas Mahoney, John B. Kisiel, Hatim T. Allawi. Accurate multi-cancer detection using methylated DNA markers and proteins in plasma [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2021; 2021 Apr 10-15 and May 17-21. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2021;81(13_Suppl):Abstract nr 111.
Detection of Postcolonoscopy Colorectal Neoplasia by Multi-target Stool DNA
Eckmann, Jason D. , Burger, Kelli N. , Bering, Jamie , Rodríguez, Eduardo A. , Prichard, David O. , Wallace, Michael B. , Kane, Sunanda V. , Gurudu, Suryakanth, Mahoney, Douglas W. , Kahn, Allon , Gurudu, Suryakanth R, Kisiel, John B , Wallace, Michael B , Ebner, Derek W. , Rutten, Lila J. Finney , Kisiel, John B.

Clinical and Translational Gastroenterology | June 18, 2021 | Volume: 12 | Issue: 6 | Pages: e00375

10.14309/ctg.0000000000000375 Get It

INTRODUCTION: Significant variability between colonoscopy operators contributes to postcolonoscopy colorectal cancers (CRCs). We aimed to estimate postcolonoscopy colorectal neoplasia (CRN) detection by multi-target stool DNA (mt-sDNA), which has not previously been studied for this purpose. METHODS: In a retrospective cohort of patients with +mt-sDNA and completed follow-up colonoscopy, positive predictive value (PPV) for endpoints of any CRN, advanced adenoma, right-sided neoplasia, sessile serrated polyps (SSP), and CRC were stratified by the time since previous colonoscopy (0–9, 10, and ≥11 years). mt-sDNA PPV at ≤9 years from previous average-risk screening colonoscopy was used to estimate CRN missed at previous screening colonoscopy. RESULTS: Among the 850 studied patients with +mt-sDNA after a previous negative screening colonoscopy, any CRN was found in 535 (PPV 63%). Among 107 average-risk patients having +mt-sDNA ≤9 years after last negative colonoscopy, any CRN was found in 67 (PPV 63%), advanced neoplasia in 16 (PPV 15%), right-sided CRN in 48 (PPV 46%), and SSP in 20 (PPV 19%). These rates were similar to those in 47 additional average risk persons with previous incomplete colonoscopy and in an additional 68 persons at increased CRC risk. One CRC (stage I) was found in an average risk patient who was mt-sDNA positive 6 years after negative screening colonoscopy. DISCUSSION: The high PPV of mt-sDNA 0–9 years after a negative screening colonoscopy suggests that lesions were likely missed on previous examination or may have arisen de novo . mt-sDNA as an interval test after negative screening colonoscopy warrants further study.
Discovery and validation of novel methylated DNA markers of cervical cancer.
Broderick, Brendan T., Lemens, Maureen A. , Cao, Xiaoming , Burger, Kelli N. , Schoolmeester, J. Kenneth , Kerr, Sarah E. , Bakkum‐Gamez, Jamie N. , Graham, Rondell P. , Slettedahl, Seth W. , Mahoney, Douglas W. , Foote, Patrick H. , Berger, Calise K. , O'Connell, Maria, Doering, Karen A. , Taylor, William R. , Sherman, Mark E. , Kisiel, John B.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | June 2, 2021 | Volume: 39 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 5526-5526

10.1200/jco.2021.39.15_suppl.5526 Get It

5526 Background: HR-HPV DNA testing, with or without cervical cytology, provides excellent sensitivity for detection of cervical cancer (CC) and its precursors; negative test results indicate that risk of disease is extremely low and enable women to undergo reduced screening with safety. However, management of women who screen positive remains challenging as many will prove to have self-limited HR-HPV infections. DNA methylation is an early event in carcinogenesis that could enhance CC screening specificity. Methods: For discovery, DNA from 70 FFPE CC (36 squamous, 34 adenocarcinoma) tissues that were reviewed microscopically, 18 fresh frozen benign cervicovaginal (BCV) tissues collected at the time of benign hysterectomy, and 18 buffy coats from cancer-free women underwent reduced representation bisulfite sequencing (RRBS) to identify MDMs associated with CC. Candidate MDM selection was based on area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) discrimination, methylation fold change, and low background methylation among benign controls. Candidate MDMs were re-tested using methylation-specific PCR (MSP) to confirm performance. Blinded biological validation was performed using MSP on DNA extracted from independent FFPE CC (38 squamous, 43 adenocarcinoma) and BCV (40) tissues. The performance of CC MDMs was also tested in DNA extracted from cervical dysplasia (36 adenocarcinoma in situ (AIS), 32 cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) 2/3, 11 CIN 1) FFPE tissues. Results: From RRBS discovery and technical validation via MSP, 30 candidate MDMs showed marked methylation fold changes (10 to >1000) across both CC histologies compared to BCV tissue from cancer-free women. Each of the 30 MDMs highly discriminated CC from BCV tissue with 9 MDMs having an AUC >0.90 (Table). CC MDMs also highly discriminated AIS from BCV but did not perform well in CIN 2/3 and CIN 1 (Table). Conclusions: Whole methylome sequencing, stringent filtering criteria, and biological validation have yielded outstanding candidate MDMs for CC that highly discriminate CC from BCV, notably with high specificity. Performance in cervical dysplasias varied with higher positivity rates in AIS than in CIN 2/3 and CIN 1. Translation to testing these novel MDMs in lower genital tract biospecimens and the addition of HR-HPV to the CC panel are warranted.[Table: see text]