Long-Term Follow-Up of E3311, an ECOG-ACRIN Cancer Research Group Phase II Trial of Transoral Surgery and Risk-Based Adjuvant Treatment in Human Papillomavirus–Initiated Oropharynx Cancer
This phase II trial of transoral surgery (TOS) with deintensified postoperative management in human papillomavirus (HPV)–associated oropharynx cancer (OPC) enrolled patients with resectable cT1-2 stage III/IV American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) seventh edition p16+ OPC without matted neck nodes. Those with clear margins, 0-1 + nodes (LN), and no extranodal extension (ENE) were observed (arm A); those with clear margins, 2-4 + LN, or ENE ≤1 mm were randomly assigned to 50 Gy (arm B) or 60 Gy (arm C); and those with involved margins, >4 + LN, or >1 mm ENE received weekly cisplatin and 60-66 Gy (arm D). Among 359 evaluable patients, the 54-month progression-free (PFS) and overall survival (OS) were 90.6% (90% CI, 87.2% to 93.1%) and 95.3% (93.0% to 96.9%), respectively. The 54-month PFS by arm was A 93.2% (79.6% to 97.8%; all four recurrences among N1 patients), B 94.9% (89.7% to 97.5%), C 90.2% (82.7% to 94.6%), and D 85.5% (77.5% to 90.8%). The 54-month OS by arm was A 97.1% (85.7% to 99.4%), B 97.9% (93.5% to 99.3%), C 95.1% (90.1% to 97.6%), and D 92.5% (86.9% to 95.7%). PFS or OS did not differ by primary site or smoking history. TOS and neck dissection with deintensified postoperative management results in outstanding 54-month PFS and OS. Among patients with favorable pathologic characteristics, those with N1 disease are at risk of late recurrence without radiation.
Long-term follow up of E3311, a phase II trial of transoral surgery (TOS) followed by pathology-based adjuvant treatment in HPV-associated (HPV+) oropharynx cancer (OPC): A trial of the ECOG-ACRIN Cancer Research Group.
6009 Background: E3311 is a phase II trial of TOS by credentialed surgeons with pathology-driven deintensified post-operative management in HPV+ OPC. Intermediate risk patients were randomized between standard and reduced dose radiation. We present mature outcome data, at median follow up of 52.4 months (m). Methods: Patients were eligible who had resectable cT1-2 stage III/IV AJCC7 p16+ OPC without matted neck nodes. Those with clear margins, 0-1 + nodes (LN), and no extranodal extension (ENE) were observed (Arm A, N=38); those with clear margins, 2-4 + LN, or ENE ≤1mm were randomized to 50Gy (Arm B, N=100) or 60Gy (Arm C, N=108); those with involved margins, >4 + LN, or >1mm ENE received weekly cisplatin 40 mg/m2 and 60-66Gy (Arm D, N=113). Progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) were estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method and compared using a log-rank test, stratified by arm for comparisons of primary site and smoking history. Results: Among 359 evaluable patients, 54-m PFS and OS were 90.6% (90% CI: 87.2%, 93.1%) and 95.3% (90% CI: 93.0%, 96.9%). 54-m PFS by arm was: A 93.2% (90% CI: 79.6%, 97.8%); B 94.9% (90% CI: 89.7%, 97.5%); C 90.2% (90% CI: 82.7%, 94.6%) and D 85.5% (90% CI: 77.5%, 90.8%). 54-m OS by arm was: A 97.1% (90% CI: 85.7%, 99.4%); B 97.9% (90% CI: 93.5%, 99.3%), C 95.1% (90% CI: 90.1%, 97.6%) and D 92.5% (90% CI: 86.9%, 95.7%). Among patients in Arm A, 11 had N0 and 27 N1 stage. Median Arm A lymph node yield (LNY) was 29 (11 to 91 LN) and did not differ for patients with/without recurrence (p=0.83). All Arm A recurrences were in N1 patients: 1 at 18 m and 3 at > 40 m. No significant difference in PFS or OS was observed by prescribed radiation dose for intermediate risk patients (Arm B vs. C). Outcome did not differ by primary site of tonsil vs. other OPC (oOPC): 54-m PFS Tonsil 89.3% (90% CI: 84.9%, 92.5%) vs. oOPC 92.9% (90% CI: 87.0%, 96.2%), p=0.28, and 54-m OS Tonsil 94.6% (90% CI: 91.5%, 96.6%) vs oOPC 96.6% (90% CI: 92.4%, 98.5%), p=0.35. Smoking history also did not impact outcome. 54-m PFS was 89.9% (90% CI: 85.9%, 92.9%) for those with ≤10 pack-years (PY) tobacco exposure and 91.7% (90% CI: 83.9%, 95.9%) for those with >10 PY. Conclusions: TOS, neck dissection with deintensified risk-based post-operative management results in outstanding 54-m PFS and OS across all subsites of T1-2 p16+ OPC, irrespective of smoking history. Late recurrence is not increased when post-operative radiation is reduced from 60 to 50Gy for intermediate risk patients. Pathologic >1mm ENE (N=87), involved margin (N=12) or >4 involved LN (N=30) accurately identify patients at increased recurrence risk and outcomes were favorable among such patients. Among patients with favorable pathologic characteristics, a subset with N1 disease are at risk for late recurrence and further characterization of these patients is warranted. Clinical trial information: NCT01898494 .
The NAVigate-HPV Registry: A comprehensive biomarker evidence base for HPV-driven cancers.
e15045 Background: Human papillomavirus (HPV) is an oncogenic driver of several human cancers, including those of the anal canal, uterine cervix, and head and neck (predominantly oropharynx). Despite advancements in our understanding of HPV-related cancers, there remains an unmet need for a comprehensive biomarker-driven registry to establish correlations between biomarker detectability and clinicopathologic features in patients diagnosed and treated for HPV-driven cancers. To address this need, the NAVigate-HPV Registry has been established to systematically collect and analyze integrated biomarker and clinical data from many U.S. cancer centers. Methods: NavDx (Naveris, Inc.) is a clinically validated blood-based assay detecting circulating cell-free tumor tissue modified viral (TTMV)-HPV DNA. The NAVigate-HPV Registry is a web-based data platform based on a centrally IRB approved protocol. Participating investigators will include providers that order NavDx tests in the routine clinical care of their patients and agree to the terms and conditions for use of the registry. Eligible subjects will have or have had an HPV-driven cancer (with an initial focus on HPV-driven oropharynx cancer with confirmatory tissue testing) and have received one or more NavDx blood tests during routine clinical care. Clinical data and TTMV-HPV DNA scores will be collected at enrollment and defined intervals over five years or until death. Results: In the initial phase, the registry has enlisted participation and established a steering committee composed of a representative from each of 14 institutions. These institutions are geographically diverse centers ranging from community hospitals to clinics and academic medical facilities. An IRB protocol governing the registry will maintain ethical standards, ensuring compliance and ethical conduct throughout the registry process. Data extraction methods have been previously established to evaluate an initial cohort of 543 patients (Hanna GJ, Roof SA, et. al 2023). Conclusions: Naveris and collaborators have together successfully launched the NAVigate-HPV registry with the aim of creating a robust database linking tumor biomarker results from NavDx with clinical outcomes data for HPV-related cancers. The NAVigate-HPV database is expected to encompass more than 1,000 patients within 1 year and grow to > 5,000 patients within 5 years, serving as a powerful tool for precision cancer medicine in this patient cancer population. Establishing this registry will deepen insights into HPV-related cancers and advance diagnostic and therapeutic approaches to improve patient outcomes.
Outcomes by time to adjuvant therapy in E3311, a phase II trial of transoral surgery (TOS) followed by pathology-based adjuvant treatment in HPV-associated (HPV+) oropharynx cancer (OPC): A trial of the ECOG-ACRIN Cancer Research Group.
6036 Background: E3311 is a phase II randomized study of intermediate risk HPV+ OPC patients who underwent TOS by credentialed surgeons and were then treated by pathology-guided, deintensified post-operative treatment. Recent retrospective population data suggest that time to post-operative radiotherapy (PORT) > 6 weeks is associated with worse progression-free survival (PFS). Methods: We retrospectively analyzed demographics, pathologic characteristics, and oncologic outcomes in E3311 by time to initiation of PORT (short vs long, exploring both 6 and 7 weeks postop as the cutpoint). Binary and categorical variables were compared using a chi-square test (or a Fisher’s exact test for small sample sizes). Ordinal variables were compared using a Wilcoxon rank sum test. PFS and overall survival (OS) were estimated using the Kaplan-Meier method and compared using a log-rank test, which was stratified by intermediate- (Arms B/C) vs high-risk (Arm D). Results: Among 321 evaluable patients, the median time to initiation of PORT was 5.1 weeks (range 0.7-15.7); 5.0 (0.7-15.7) for Arm B, 5.1 (2.4-7.0) for Arm C, 5.6 (3.6-7.9) for Arm D. No significant difference in PFS or OS was observed whether PORT commenced by 6 or 7 weeks postoperatively, compared with longer time to initiation of PORT (p = 0.62 and 0.65, p = 0.30 and p = 0.41, respectively). 3-yr PFS rates were 93.5% (95% CI: 89.4%, 96.0%) among those treated ≤6 weeks, and 91.2% (95% CI: 81.4%, 95.9%) among those treated > 6 weeks; 3-yr OS rates were 96.1% (95% CI: 92.7%, 98.0%) among those treated ≤6 weeks, and 94.1% (95% CI: 84.9%, 97.8%) among those treated > 6 weeks. No significant differences in outcomes were observed between intermediate risk treatment arms (deintensified (50Gy) or standard dose (60Gy) RT). Additional demographic and pathologic characteristics, including primary site, margin status, histologic grade, stage, and extranodal extension were not significantly different between those with short vs long time to PORT, whether 6 or 7 weeks was used as the cutpoint. There were more T2 tumors in those treated > 7 weeks postop (84% vs. 49%, p = 0.007). PS = 1 patients were more numerous among those with shorter time to PORT (10% vs 0%, with the 7 week cutpoint). Conclusions: In contrast to retrospective NCDB data, intermediate- and high-risk HPV+ OPC patients enrolled on E3311 had favorable 3-yr PFS and OS rates that were not significantly worse when adjuvant therapy was started > 6 wks or > 7wks. These results argue against a survival advantage for initiation of PORT within 6 or 7 weeks for early-stage HPV+ OPC managed with high-quality transoral resection. The optimal time window to initiate PORT in HPV+ OPC patients remains to be determined. Clinical trial information: NCT01898494 .
Prognostic value of radiographically defined extranodal extension in human papillomavirus‐associated locally advanced oropharyngeal carcinoma
AbstractBackgroundPathologic extranodal extension (ENE) has traditionally guided the management of head and neck cancers. The prognostic value of radiographic ENE (rENE) in human papillomavirus (HPV)‐associated oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma (HPV + OPX) is uncertain.MethodsPatients with HPV + OPX with adequate pretreatment radiographic nodal evaluation from a single institution were analyzed. rENE status was determined by neuroradiologists' at time of diagnosis. Distant metastasis‐free survival (DMFS), overall survival (OS), and locoregional recurrence‐free survival (LRFS) were estimated using Kaplan‐Meier methods. Cox proportional hazards models were fit to assess the impact of rENE on survival endpoints.ResultsHundred sixty‐eight patients with OPX + squamous cell carcinomas diagnosed between April 2008 and December 2014 were included for analysis with median follow‐up of 3.3 years. Eighty‐eight percent of patients received concurrent chemoradiotherapy. rENE was not prognostic; its presence in patients with HPV + OPX did not significantly impact OS, LRFS, or DMFS.ConclusionsIn patients with HPV + OPX, rENE was not significantly associated with OS, LRFS, or DMFS.