Back to Authors

Savage, J

Mayo Clinic

MFPC

Citations 6

(137) COMPARISON OF COLLAGENASE CLOSTRIDIUM HISTOLYTICUM TO SURGERY FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF PEYRONIE’S DISEASE: A RANDOMIZED TRIAL – 2 YEAR OUTCOMES
Larson, Henry, Savage, J, Trost, K, Warner, R, Ziegelmann, M, Helo, S, Kohler, T, Trost, L., Savage, J, Kohler, T

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | December 10, 2024 | Volume: 21 | Issue: Supplement_7 | Pages: No page available

10.1093/jsxmed/qdae167.134 Get It

Abstract Introduction Since FDA approval of Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum (CCH) for the treatment of Peyronie’s Disease (PD), there has been significant debate as to its role and comparable efficacy in relation to surgical therapies. We therefore sought to compare key outcomes between the two therapies. Objective To compare the satisfaction and adverse event profiles between surgery and CCH injections for the treatment of PD. Methods A randomized, controlled trial is ongoing. Participants were randomized 1:1 to receive either CCH + traction (RestoreX) + sildenafil (CCH) or penile surgery (plication and/or incision and grafting) + traction + sildenafil for PD (Surgery). Objective, standardized, and non-standardized assessments were obtained at baseline and 3, 6, 12, 24, 36, 48, and 60 months post-treatment. Key outcomes included differences in standardized questionnaires, penile curvature, penile length, subsequent interventions, and non-standardized questionnaire responses. Results A total of 40 men were randomized with 24-month data available in 29. Mean age was 54.7 years, PD duration 37.4 months (mo), composite curvature 73.1 degrees (deg), and penile length 12.7 cm. All baseline variables were similar between cohorts. Regarding primary outcomes, at 24-months post-treatment, CCH men were more likely to report being very satisfied with treatment (62% vs 25%, p < 0.05). For secondary outcomes, only questionnaire data were captured at two years without objective measurements obtained. No differences were noted between groups regarding subscales of the IIEF, PDQ, Beck’s Depression Inventory, or SEP-2, however CCH men had better SEP-3 positive responses (62% vs 19%, p = 0.02), indicating improved ability to maintain erections sufficient for intercourse. Surgery men reported higher subjective rates of length loss compared to CCH (81% vs 15%, p < 0.001) and curvature recurrence (56% vs 8%, p < 0.01), but similar rates with changes in sensation, indentation/hourglass, and erectile function. Both groups indicated similar willingness to undergo the therapy again. Interestingly, at 2-years, the majority of men in the Surgery arm said that their initial preference for treatment was surgery (56%), which decreased from a peak 86% at 1-year. However, in reviewing baseline information, 72% of Surgery men actually preferred CCH at study onset, highlighting a significant recall bias towards whatever treatment one actually ended up receiving. Conclusions Preliminary data suggests that when compared to surgery at 24-months, CCH men were more likely to be very satisfied with therapy, have greater subjective length improvements and lower curvature recurrence rates. Disclosure Yes, this is sponsored by industry/sponsor: Endo Pharmaceuticals. Clarification: Industry funding only - investigator initiated and executed study. Any of the authors act as a consultant, employee or shareholder of an industry for: PathRight Medical.
(138) EFFICACY OF A NOVEL COLLAGENASE CLOSTRIDIUM HISTOLYTICUM PROTOCOL FOR PEYRONIE’S DISEASE AMONG PRIOR NON-RESPONDERS: A RANDOMIZED, CONTROLLED, SINGLE-BLINDED STUDY
Labbé, Jean-Philippe, Savage, J, Brearton, K, Warner, R, Ziegelmann, M., Köhler, Tobias , Trost, L, Brearton, K, Helo, Sevann

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | December 10, 2024 | Volume: 21 | Issue: Supplement_7 | Pages: No page available

10.1093/jsxmed/qdae167.135 Get It

Abstract Introduction Limited data currently exist on the role and efficacy of additional series of collagenase clostridium histolyticum (CCH) injections among Peyronie’s disease (PD) men who have previously failed a first series of injections. We sought to evaluate outcomes of a novel protocol for CCH injections among men who had previously failed 6-8 CCH injections using a traditional approach. Objective To evaluate whether additional rounds of CCH using a novel protocol in men previously unresponsive results in greater curve improvements. Methods A randomized, controlled trial (NCT05108558) is ongoing. All participants previously failed to achieve ≥20% curvature improvement with 6-8 prior CCH injections. Men were randomized 3:1 to receive either CCH + traction (RestoreX) + sildenafil (treatment) up front or initial observation followed by treatment (controls). Outcomes were compared between treatment and control groups. Key measures included objective curve improvements and standardized/non-standardized questionnaires, with assessments obtained at baseline, 6-weeks after completion of CCH (treatment arm), after the no treatment period (controls), and at 1 year. Results A total of 38/40 men have been randomized to date, with 22 having fully completed treatment. Mean age was 57 years, with a median PD duration of 22 months. Median composite baseline curvature was 65 degrees, with 40% having hourglass or indentation deformities, 8% calcification, median baseline IIEF-EFD 20, and 58% able to have penetrative intercourse. Median estimated improvement with the prior CCH series was 0% (IQR 0, 18.8), and the median number of prior injections was 8. The majority of men were dissatisfied with their prior series of CCH (58% vs 35% satisfied, 8% neutral). Of the 22 men who had completed the study protocol, 50% required 1 series, 14% 2 series, 29% 3 series, and 7% 4 series. Compared to the no treatment arm, treated men experienced significantly greater improvements (median 60 degrees vs 0, p = 0.01). IIEF-EFD was non-statistically higher in treated men (0 vs -5, p = 0.17). 92% of men reported a subjective major improvement in curvature, with the median subjectively estimated improvement 90%. 42% reported improved sensitivity (58% no change), while 63% reported improved or no change in erectile function, with 9% unsure, and 27% worse. Post-treatment, 92% of men were very satisfied with CCH as a treatment and 8% neutral. Conclusions Repeating CCH using a novel protocol after an initially unsuccessful course of CCH achieves significant improvements in curvature and patient satisfaction. Additional data, including external validation, are warranted. Disclosure Yes, this is sponsored by industry/sponsor: Endo Pharmaceuticals. Clarification: Industry funding only - investigator initiated and executed study. Any of the authors act as a consultant, employee or shareholder of an industry for: PathRight Medical.
239 Improved Peyronie's Disease Curvature Outcomes Using a More Aggressive Collagenase Technique
Tyler, A, Green, B, Savage, J, Brearton, K, Burgon, H, Trost, Landon , Green, B, Savage, J, Brearton, K, Burgon, H

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | May 9, 2022 | Volume: 19 | Issue: Supplement_2 | Pages: S216-S216

10.1016/j.jsxm.2022.03.492 Get It

ABSTRACT Introduction Since the FDA approval of Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum (CCH) for the treatment of Peyronie's Disease (PD), several investigators have reported outcomes of CCH, with improvements ranging from approximately 15-30%. More recently, we reported improved results (49% mean improvement) when CCH was combined with RestoreX penile traction therapy (RxPTT). Since then, we have made additional modifications to create a more aggressive injection / traction protocol to further optimize outcomes. Objective To report outcomes of a more aggressive CCH injection / traction protocol in men with PD. Methods A prospective database has been maintained of all individuals undergoing CCH injections since 2014. Our CCH injection protocol has evolved from the one described in the IMPRESS trials to a more aggressive use of injections and manual and mechanical traction. Currently, the protocol consists of injecting 0.9 mg of CCH in 0.7 ml of saline into approximately 15-20 sites around the point of maximal curvature (pharmacologically-induced erection performed with the first injection of each series). Injections are only performed on subsequent days (not 2-3 days apart), and very aggressive (i.e. 10-15 lbs of force) modeling is performed with the 2nd injection. Patients are counseled to begin RestoreX traction at 24-48 hours after the 2nd injection for 30-60 minutes daily, and to continue aggressive manual modeling for at least the first week post injection. Penile wraps are applied for 5 days post injection. A descriptive analysis was subsequently performed to review outcomes. Results A total of 320 men underwent at least 1 series of CCH and had baseline and follow-up curve assessment data available. Mean age was 55.8 (SD 10.4), with a mean PD duration of 27.8 months (SD 53) and a median baseline composite curvature of 64 degrees (IQR 45-80). Curvature improvements (most recent minus baseline) improved over time, correlating with increased injection experience and implementation of more aggressive traction protocols: 2014-2020 (20 degrees, 29% improvement) vs 2020-mid 2021 (27.8 degrees, 50%, p<0.001). When men were stratified by those who either completed 8 injections or indicated that they were satisfied with outcomes (n=147), median results were more pronounced: 2014-2017 (29% improvement), 2018 (38%), 2019 (47%), 2020-mid 2021 (59%), p<0.01. Conclusions Progressive implementation of a more aggressive CCH injection protocol has resulted in improved curvature outcomes. Given the specialized nature of technique modifications described, these results would argue for a center-of-excellence model for CCH administration to achieve optimal outcomes. Disclosure Work supported by industry: no.
113 Comparison of Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum to Surgery for the Management of Peyronie's Disease: A Randomized Trial
Green, B, Francis, Mr. D. M., Savage, J, Brearton, K, Burgon, H, Tyler, A, Trost, Landon , Green, B, Savage, J, Brearton, K, Burgon, H

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | May 9, 2022 | Volume: 19 | Issue: Supplement_2 | Pages: S170-S170

10.1016/j.jsxm.2022.03.387 Get It

ABSTRACT Introduction Since the FDA approval of Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum (CCH) for the treatment of Peyronie's Disease (PD), there has been significant debate as to its role and comparable efficacy in relation to surgical therapies. Specifically, investigators have compared relative utilization, costs, and outcomes with varying conclusions. Objective To compare various objective and subjective outcome measures between men undergoing CCH or surgery for PD. Methods A randomized, controlled trial (NCT04786106) is ongoing at ***. Participants are randomized 1:1 to receive either CCH + traction (RestoreX) + sildenafil or penile surgery (plication and/or incision and grafting) + traction + sildenafil for PD. Objective, standardized (International Index of Erectile Function [IIEF] and Peyronie's Disease Questionnaire [PDQ]), and non-standardized assessments are obtained at baseline, and post-treatment at 3, 6, 12, 24, 36, 48, and 60 months. Key outcomes include differences in standardized questionnaires, penile curvature, penile length, subsequent interventions, and non-standardized questionnaire responses. Curvature is measured in two planes and summed to provide a composite curvature. Penile length is measured from pubic symphysis to corona. All therapies were stopped prior to the 3-month time point (i.e. traction and sildenafil). Results A total of 32 men have been randomized to date (CCH=17, surgery=15), with 3-month data available on 8 men (CCH=4, surgery=4). Mean age at enrollment was 55.8 years (SD 14.4), PD duration 38 months (SD 49.5), curvature 74.1 degrees (SD 20.9), and penile length 12.5 cm (SD 1.5). All baseline variables were statistically similar between cohorts. Regarding the primary outcome, at 3 months post-treatment, CCH men reported higher overall satisfaction (not statistically significant; 50% very satisfied, 50% somewhat satisfied; surgery 100% somewhat satisfied, p=0.06). For secondary outcomes at 3 months, the median differences between CCH and surgery respectively were: IIEF-EFD (+4 vs +4, p=1.0), PDQ-physical (-10 vs -6.5, p=0.14, note: lower is better for PDQ scales), PDQ-pain (-12 vs 0.5, p=0.77), PDQ-bother (-9 vs -8, p=0.77), length change (+0.8 vs 0 cm, p=0.29), curvature absolute change (-22.5 vs -80 degrees, p=0.11), and curvature percentage improvement (41% vs 85%, p=0.11). An equal number of CCH and surgery men felt that treatment improved sexual function (75%) and their ability to have sex (100%) and were subjectively happy with their curvature (50%). Men in the surgery arm were more likely to report (note that some are not statistically significant) subjectively worsened erectile function (50% vs 0%, p=0.15), shorter penile length (75% vs 0%, p=0.02), lower satisfaction with penile length (50% satisfied vs 75%, p=0.46), improved hourglass (33% vs 0%, p=0.42), and were less likely to report that they would repeat treatment without reservation (50% vs 75%, p=0.11). When asked which treatment they would pick if they could start again, 100% of CCH men reported CCH and/or traction, while 50% of surgery men indicated surgery, 25% CCH, and 25% other (p<0.05). Conclusions The current data are too preliminary to draw any viable conclusions on differences between CCH and surgery for PD. Disclosure Work supported by industry: yes, by Endo Pharmaceutical.
79 Outcomes of Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum in Men with Congenital Penile Curvature
Burgon, H, Tyler, A, Green, B, Savage, J, Brearton, K, Granberg, C, Ziegelmann, M, Kohler, T, Helo, S, Trost, L, Ziegelmann, M, Kohler, T, Helo, S, Trost, L

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | April 26, 2022 | Volume: 19 | Issue: Supplement_1 | Pages: S42-S42

10.1016/j.jsxm.2022.01.091 Get It

ABSTRACT Introduction Congenital penile curvature is a relatively uncommon condition characterized by penile angulation. Similar to Peyronie's Disease (PD), this condition has historically been managed with various surgical techniques. Given the efficacy of Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum (CCH) in men with PD, our team has elected to treat men with CPD with CCH injections. Objective To describe outcomes of CPD men treated with CCH injections and to compare against a traditional PD cohort. Methods A prospective database has been maintained of all men undergoing CCH injections by our team since Jan 2014. The specific CCH administration protocol has been modified over time and currently includes combined use of RestoreX traction therapy, sildenafil, 0.9 mg of CCH diluted into 0.7 ml, injections performed at the point of maximal curvature, and aggressive manual modeling. Curvatures were measured in two planes (dorsal and lateral), with the combined measure reported as a composite. Outcomes were reported based on the most recent curvature assessment obtained minus baseline. Men were included if they received at least one series of CCH injections and had at least one baseline and follow-up curvature assessment available. Results A total of 272 men comprised the current cohort, with 23 exhibiting CPD and 249 PD. Mean age was higher in PD men (57.4 vs 38.4, p<0.0001), and mean PD duration was 18 months in PD men. Median baseline curvature was non-statistically higher in PD (65 vs 55 degrees, p=0.06). Baseline curvature directions for PD and CPD, respectively were: dorsal (82% vs 35%, p<0.0001), lateral (58% vs 78%, p<0.05), ventral (11% vs 35%, p<0.01). Following treatment with CCH, median curvature improvement was similar between cohorts, with 20 degrees (IQR 5, 35) for PD and 20 degrees (IQR 5, 30) for CPD, p=0.62. Percentage improvement from baseline was non-statistically higher in PD men (33% vs 29%, p=0.99). Conclusions Treatment of CPD men with CCH is a viable therapeutic option and provides similar benefits to those observed in men with PD. Disclosure No
62 Changes in Point of Maximal Curvature During Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum Injections for Peyronie's Disease
Price, Trevor, Burgon, H, Green, B, Brearton, K, Savage, J, Ziegelmann, M., Köhler, Tobias , Trost, L, Helo, Sevann

The Journal of Sexual Medicine | April 26, 2022 | Volume: 19 | Issue: Supplement_1 | Pages: S32-S33

10.1016/j.jsxm.2022.01.074 Get It

ABSTRACT Introduction Collagenase Clostridium Histolyticum (CCH) is commonly injected at the point of maximal curvature (POMC) for Peyronie's Disease (PD). However, many providers only evaluate the POMC at baseline and do not reassess during CCH injections. As PD plaques often extend over an extended region, it is currently unknown how much the POMC may change throughout a course of CCH treatment. Objective We sought to evaluate for changes in POMC between series among men undergoing CCH injections. Methods A prospective database has been maintained of PD men undergoing CCH injections at two institutions. POMC assessments were obtained prior to each series of injections after pharmacologic erection and were measured from the coronal margin to POMC. An analysis was performed comparing changes in POMC throughout the CCH course, including associated baseline demographic and disease characteristics. Results A total of 445 men (mean age 55.9, mean PD duration 30.6 months) underwent CCH injections from Jan 2014 through Feb 2021. The mean baseline composite curvature was 63.7° (SD 23.7), and the mean distance to curvature was 3.1 cm. Among men who completed 4 series of CCH injections, the mean improvement was 21° (SD 20.6) or 31.7% (SD 33%). In reviewing changes in POMC, the largest change observed at any point within the CCH series was a median 1 cm (IQR 0.5, 2 cm; range 0, 9.5 cm). Compared to baseline, 58% of men experienced a POMC change of 1 cm or greater, 25% 2 cm or greater, and 12% 3 cm or greater during the course of CCH treatment. Age, duration of PD, and baseline curvature were not associated with changes in POMC, although the POMC itself was associated with extent of changes, with proximal curves more likely to experience more notable changes compared to distal ones (p<0.0001). The total improvement in curve was also variably associated with change in POMC, with those experiencing greater improvements noted to have larger change in POMC (p<0.05 for changes in composite curvature and p=0.07 for percent change from baseline). These findings would suggest significant evolution of the POMC during a course of CCH, particularly among men with mid shaft or proximal curves and among those with greater curve improvements. Findings would support a role for repeat curvature assessments prior to each series of CCH injections. Conclusions Based on data from a prospective, two-institution series of PD men undergoing CCH injections, the POMC changes by ≥1 cm in the majority of men. Given the small volume injected with each CCH series, the clinical relevance of these findings and their impact on injector protocols merit further investigation. Disclosure No