Cai, Zhengxiang

Abstract Objective High-frequency oscillations (HFOs) are highly specific biomarkers of epileptogenic tissue, yet their noninvasive localization remains challenging due to their brief duration, low amplitude, and poor signal-to-noise ratio. Here, we introduce TH-DeepSIF, a transformer-based deep learning framework trained on biologically realistic neural mass model simulations, to robustly perform HFO source imaging from scalp EEG. Methods TH-DeepSIF was evaluated in simulated single- and dual-source HFO scenarios, where it was tasked with recovering both the spatial location and temporal dynamics of HFO generators under increasing spatiotemporal complexity. We further validated TH-DeepSIF in 25 patients with drug-resistant epilepsy by comparing EEG source imaged HFO sources against surgical resection regions. Results TH-DeepSIF accurately recovered both the spatial location and temporal dynamics of simulated HFO generators, achieving low localization error and strong waveform correspondence with ground truth. TH-DeepSIF localization for pathological HFOs (pHFOs, or spike ripples) demonstrated strong agreement with surgical resection regions, achieving a median localization error of 11.9 mm and specificity of 0.896. Compared with all HFOs (aHFOs), pHFO-based source imaging showed significantly stronger spatial correspondence with resection regions, significantly smaller localization error, and higher precision, sensitivity, geometric mean, and F1 score. Significance These findings demonstrate that TH-DeepSIF provides a robust, data-driven framework for noninvasive HFO source imaging with improved anatomical specificity and enhanced clinical utility for presurgical evaluation using scalp EEG. Moreover, they show that pathological HFOs (spike ripples )—rather than general HFOs—serve as robust EEG biomarkers for accurate localization of the epileptogenic zone. Key Points A fully data-driven, parameter-free framework for noninvasive HFO source imaging using scalp EEG. Pathological HFO source maps exhibit strong spatial concordance with both the surgical resection region and the seizure onset zone. Source imaging based on pathological HFOs consistently outperforms imaging based on all detected HFOs.

Noninvasive electrophysiological source imaging (ESI) is a valuable tool for localizing and imaging brain activity, with significant potential to aid presurgical planning in focal drug-resistant epilepsy (fDRE) patients. Scalp electroencephalography (EEG) biomarkers, including interictal spikes, high-frequency oscillations (HFOs), and seizures, each offer unique capabilities in estimating the epileptogenic zone (EZ). However, there is a limited quantitative understanding of how these biomarkers differ in source-imaging precision, requiring distinct processing pipelines. Here, we developed a spatial–temporal–spectral imaging (STSI) framework for precision source imaging, and quantitatively evaluated various epilepsy biomarkers for source imaging in 2,081 individual events (spikes, HFOs, and seizures) from a cohort of 42 fDRE patients, comparing results to clinical ground truth such as surgical resection outcomes and intracranial EEG-defined seizure onset zones. The STSI enabled quantitative comparisons across key EEG epilepsy-related biomarkers, with averaged localization errors of 6.67 mm for seizures, 8.73 mm for HFOs overlapping with spikes (pHFO), 10.28 mm for HFO-riding spikes (pSpike), 19.59 mm for general spikes (aSpike), and 36.53 mm for general HFOs (aHFO), respectively, for seizure-free patients. These findings indicate that HFOs overlapping with spikes is the most spatially accurate interictal biomarker for mapping the EZ. The proposed STSI framework not only establishes a unified analysis approach for epileptic biomarkers to enhance presurgical planning in focal drug-resistant epilepsy, but could also generalize as a versatile tool for mapping event-related potentials, neural oscillations, and dynamic brain states, within a single framework to advance cognitive neuroscience research and clinical management of neurological and psychiatric disorders.

AbstractObjectiveEpilepsy raises critical challenges to accurately localize the epileptogenic zone (EZ) to guide presurgical planning. Previous research has suggested that interictal spikes overlapping with high‐frequency oscillations, referred to here as pSpikes, serve as a reliable biomarker for EZ estimation, but there remains a question as to whether and to how pSpikes perform as compared to other types of epileptic spikes. This study aims to address this question by investigating the source imaging capabilities of pSpikes alongside other spike types.MethodsA total of 2819 interictal spikes from 76‐channel scalp electroencephalography (EEG) were analyzed in a cohort of 24 drug‐resistant focal epilepsy patients. All patients received surgical resection, and 16 were declared seizure‐free based on at least 1 year of postoperative follow‐up. A recently developed electrophysiological source imaging algorithm—fast spatiotemporal iteratively reweighted edge sparsity (FAST‐IRES)—was used for source imaging of the detected interictal spikes. The performance of 217 pSpikes was compared with 772 nSpikes (spikes with irregular high‐frequency activations), 1830 rSpikes (spikes with no high‐frequency activity), and all 2819 aSpikes (all interictal spikes).ResultsThe localization and extent estimation using pSpikes are concordant with the clinical ground truth; using pSpikes yields the best performance compared with nSpikes, rSpikes, and conventional spike imaging (aSpikes). For multiple spike type seizure‐free patients, the mean localization error for pSpike imaging was 6.8 mm, compared with 15.0 mm for aSpikes. The sensitivity, precision, and specificity were .41, .67, and .93 for pSpikes compared with .32, .48, and .93 for aSpikes.SignificanceThese results demonstrate the merits of noninvasive EEG source localization, and that (1) pSpike is a superior biomarker, outperforming conventional spike imaging for the localization of epileptic sources, and especially those with multiple irritative zones; and (2) FAST‐IRES provides accurate source estimation that is highly concordant with clinical ground truth, even in situations of single spike analysis with low signal‐to‐noise ratio.

Significance Millions of people affected by epilepsy may undergo surgical resection of the epileptic tissues to stop seizures if such epileptic foci can be accurately delineated. High-frequency oscillations (HFOs), existing in electroencephalography, are highly correlated with epileptic brain, which is promising for guiding successful neurosurgery. However, it is unclear whether and how pathological HFOs can be differentiated to localize the epileptogenic tissues given the presence of various nonepileptic high-frequency activities. Here, we show morphological and source imaging evidence that pathological HFOs can be identified by the concurrence of epileptiform spikes. We describe a framework to delineate the underlying epileptogenicity using this biomarker. Our work may offer translational tools to improve treatments by noninvasively demarking pathological activities and hence epileptic foci.

ObjectiveDrug‐resistant focal epilepsy is widely recognized as a network disease in which epileptic seizure propagation is likely coordinated by different neuronal oscillations such as low‐frequency activity (LFA), high‐frequency activity (HFA), or low‐to‐high cross‐frequency coupling. However, the mechanism by which different oscillatory networks constrain the propagation of focal seizures remains unclear.MethodsWe studied focal epilepsy patients with invasive electrocorticography (ECoG) recordings and compared multilayer directional network interactions between focal seizures either with or without secondary generalization. Within‐frequency and cross‐frequency directional connectivity were estimated by an adaptive directed transfer function and cross‐frequency directionality, respectively.ResultsIn the within‐frequency epileptic network, we found that the seizure onset zone (SOZ) always sent stronger information flow to the surrounding regions, and secondary generalization was accompanied by weaker information flow in the LFA from the surrounding regions to SOZ. In the cross‐frequency epileptic network, secondary generalization was associated with either decreased information flow from surrounding regions’ HFA to SOZ's LFA or increased information flow from SOZ's LFA to surrounding regions’ HFA.InterpretationOur results suggest that the secondary generalization of focal seizures is regulated by numerous within‐ and cross‐frequency push–pull dynamics, potentially reflecting impaired excitation–inhibition interactions of the epileptic network. ANN NEUROL 2019;86:683–694