Mut, Fernando

ABSTRACT Endoluminal flow diverters are increasingly used to treat cerebral aneurysms. Despite good aneurysm occlusion efficacy, delayed ischemic complications due to side branch or perforator occlusion remain a serious concern. However, the mechanisms leading to side branch occlusion are poorly understood. To investigate these mechanisms, a combination of animal and computational models was utilized. Flow diverters were deployed in four rabbit superior mesenteric artery (SMA) and studied with computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and a previously developed fibrin dynamics model. Subject‐specific vascular models were reconstructed from 3D rotational angiography images and flow conditions were derived from Doppler ultrasound velocity measurements. Flow diverting devices were virtually deployed within the vascular models under guidance from angiography images. Coupled flow and fibrin production, transport, and adhesion simulations were carried out and the effects of fibrin accumulation at the origin of jailed side branches after flow diverter implantation were analyzed. The results of the computational models suggest significant fibrin accumulation across the struts of all flow diverting devices jailing side branches. Larger accumulation was observed at the more distal branches. However, minor flow alterations were produced which were not detectable in angiography sequences. These results were in agreement with experimental observations. On the other hand, fibrin accumulation alone did not explain complete side branch occlusions, which are likely the result of the interaction between initial fibrin accumulation and subsequent cell migration from the peripheral parent artery.

ABSTRACT Incomplete aneurysm occlusion after flow disruption treatment strongly depends on the persistence of strong flow into the aneurysm, which in turn depends on the aneurysm and parent artery geometry as well as the device placement. However, at the time of treatment it remains challenging to predict future outcomes (complete or incomplete occlusion). This paper describes a strategy to evaluate the local hemodynamic environment created immediately after flow‐modifying device deployment to treat cerebral aneurysms and connect it to the subsequent long‐term outcomes. The approach is based on the concept of angiographic signatures that can be extracted from DSA sequences or computational models and represented as images that can be used to compare different aneurysmal environments. The methodology is demonstrated on two small series of four experimental rabbit aneurysms each, treated with either intrasaccular flow disruptors or endoluminal flow diverters. Noticeable differences in the angiographic signatures of completely and incompletely occluded aneurysms at follow‐up were observed. Specifically, larger values of mean transit times and longer time‐to‐peaks were observed deeper into the aneurysms that remained incompletely occluded in both series. The findings suggest that angiographic signatures can be used to assess the underlying hemodynamic environment immediately after device implantation and prognosticate the likelihood of future complete or incomplete occlusion.

ABSTRACT As the number of cerebral aneurysms treated with flow diverters continues to increase, it is important to understand what factors influence not only thrombus formation within the aneurysm cavity but also fibrin accumulation across the device and its associated disruption and blockage of the inflow stream. Both processes contribute to the eventual occlusion of the aneurysm or its continued patency and incomplete occlusion which may require future re‐treatment. To investigate fibrin accumulation on flow diverters placed across the neck of cerebral aneurysms, a previously developed computational model that couples flow and fibrin dynamics is used in combination with experimental in vitro models of cerebral aneurysms treated with flow diverters. Fibrin accumulation was previously investigated in four glass models of cerebral aneurysms with varying parent artery geometries placed in a flow loop at different flow rates. Corresponding computational models were constructed and compared with the experimental findings. The computational model based on fibrin production stimulated from flow shear stress and subsequent adhesion to device wires was able to reproduce and explain the fibrin accumulation patterns observed in the experimental aneurysms treated with flow diverters. Specifically, these models indicated that increasing vessel curvature, flow rate, and thrombin concentration induced faster fibrin accumulation and associated aneurysm inflow disruption and blockage. The models described and tested in this paper are valuable to understand the detailed mechanisms leading to aneurysm occlusion and healing or incomplete occlusions after treatment with flow diverting devices.

ABSTRACT The mechanisms leading to aneurysm occlusion after treatment with flow‐diverting devices are not fully understood. Flow modification induces thrombus formation within the aneurysm cavity, but fibrin can simultaneously accumulate and cover the device scaffold, leading to further flow modification. However, the interplay and relative importance of these processes are not clearly understood. A computational model of fibrin accumulation and flow modification after flow diversion treatment of cerebral aneurysms has been developed under the guidance of in vitro experiments and observations. The model is based on the loose coupling of flow and transport‐reaction equations that are solved separately by independent codes. Interaction or reactive terms account for thrombin production from prothrombin stimulated by thrombogenic metallic wires and inhibition by antithrombin as well as fibrin production from fibrinogen stimulated by thrombin and flow shear stress, and fibrin adhesion to device wires and already attached fibrin. The computational model was demonstrated and tested on idealized vessel and aneurysm geometries. The model was able to reproduce the salient features of fibrin accumulation after the deployment of flow‐diverting devices in idealized in vitro models of cerebral aneurysms. Namely, fibrin production in regions of high shear stress, initial accumulation at the inflow zone, and progressive occlusion of the device and corresponding flow attenuation. The computational model linking flow dynamics to fibrin production, transport, and adhesion can be used to investigate and better understand the effects that lead to fibrin accumulation and the resulting aneurysm inflow reduction and intra‐aneurysmal flow modulation.

Introduction: Predicting the course of aneurysms after treatment with flow diverters is important to prognosticate long term outcomes and optimize interventions. Hypothesis: Aneurysm occlusion after flow diversion can be predicted using post-treatment flow information. Methods: Flows in experimental aneurysms in rabbits (n=15) and clinical cases (n=23) were evaluated with computational fluid dynamics. Subject-specific models were created from 3D angiographies. Flow conditions were measured with ultrasound in the rabbits, and derived from measurements in normal subjects in the clinical cases. Models of the devices were virtually deployed into the anatomical models. Experimental aneurysms were assigned to either a “complete” occlusion group if completely occluded at 4 weeks follow up, or to an “incomplete” occlusion group if still open at 8 weeks. Similarly, clinical cases were classified as “complete” occlusions if completely occluded at 3 months, or as “incomplete” occlusions if still patent at 6 months. Flow variables were then statistically compared between these groups for both the experimental and clinical series, and the predictive power of different variables to discriminate between aneurysms in each group was assessed by calculating the area under the receiving operating characteristics curves. Results: In the clinical (experimental) series, the aneurysm inflow rate was 4.02 (3.29) times larger in the incomplete occlusion group than in the completely occluded group, p=0.0210 (0.0239). Similarly, the mean aneurysm velocity was 2.75 (2.29) times larger, p=0.0044 (0.0582), and the shear rate was 1.57 (1.78) times larger, p=0.0210 (0.0722). Inflow rate could discriminate complete and incomplete occlusions with a 77% (90%) accuracy in the clinical (experimental) series. Similarly, mean velocity had a predictive power of 84% (83%) and shear rate of 76% (76%) in the clinical and experimental series. Conclusions: Flow conditions created immediately after treatment, in particular aneurysm inflow rate and mean aneurysm velocity, can prognosticate the future occlusion of aneurysms treated with flow diverters.

AbstractModeling the flow dynamics in cerebral aneurysms after the implantation of intrasaccular devices is important for understanding the relationship between flow conditions created immediately posttreatment and the subsequent outcomes. This information, ideally available a priori based on computational modeling prior to implantation, is valuable to identify which aneurysms will occlude immediately and which aneurysms will likely remain patent and would benefit from a different procedure or device.In this report, a methodology for modeling the hemodynamics in intracranial aneurysms treated with intrasaccular flow diverting devices is described. This approach combines an image‐guided, virtual device deployment within patient‐specific vascular models with an immersed boundary method on adaptive unstructured grids. A partial mesh refinement strategy that reduces the number of mesh elements near the aneurysm dome where the flow conditions are largely stagnant was compared with the full refinement strategy that refines the mesh everywhere around the device wires.The results indicate that using the partial mesh refinement approach is adequate for analyzing the posttreatment hemodynamics, at a reduced computational cost. The results obtained on a series of four cerebral aneurysms treated with different intrasaccular devices were in good qualitative agreement with angiographic observations.Promising results were obtained relating posttreatment flow conditions and outcomes of treatments with intrasaccular devices, which need to be confirmed on larger series.

Background and purpose Vertebrobasilar dolichoectatic and fusiform aneurysms (VBDAs) are known to have a poor natural history, with high rates of growth, rupture, and stroke. The purpose of this study was to identify hemodynamic characteristics that differ between VBDAs associated with growth, rupture, and stroke. Materials and methods VBDAs with CT angiography or MR angiography followed longitudinally without treatment were studied. Unstable aneurysms were defined as those that grew or ruptured during follow-up. Aneurysms associated with stroke were defined as those associated with posterior circulation infarct at follow-up. Baseline data, including demographics, comorbidities, and aneurysm morphology and size were collected. Image based computational fluid dynamics models were created and run under pulsatile flow conditions. Relevant hemodynamic and geometric variables were calculated and compared between groups (stable vs unstable and no stroke vs stroke) using the Wilcoxon test. Results A total of 37 VBDAs were included (24 stable, 13 unstable; 30 no stroke, 7 stroke). Unstable aneurysms had lower shear rates (P=0.05), blood flow velocity (P=0.03), and lower vorticity (P=0.049) than stable aneurysms. In addition, unstable aneurysms had higher mean oscillatory shear indices (P=0.001). There were no differences in the hemodynamic characteristics of aneurysms in the stroke group compared with the non-stroke group. Conclusion This small study suggests there may be hemodynamic differences between unstable and stable VBDAs. Unstable VBDAs appear to be under lower flow conditions with lower velocity, vorticity, and shear rates, and have more oscillatory flow. There was no difference in the hemodynamic characteristics of aneurysms in the stroke and no stroke group.

Abstract Objective : Blood flow waveforms—essential data for hemodynamic modeling—are often in practice unavailable to researchers. The objectives of this work were to assess the variability among the waveforms for a clinically relevant older population, and develop data-based methods for addressing the missing waveform data for hemodynamic studies. Approach : We analyzed 272 flow waveforms from the internal carotid arteries of older patients (73 ± 13 yr) with moderate cardiovascular disease, and used these data to develop methods to guide new approaches for hemodynamic studies. Main results : Profound variations in waveform parameters were found within the aged population that were not seen in published data for young subjects. Common features in the aged population relative to the young included a larger systole-to-diastole flow rate ratio, increased flow during late systole, and absence of a dicrotic notch. Eight waveforms were identified that collectively represent the range of waveforms in the older population. A relationship between waveform shape and flow rate was obtained that, in conjunction with equations relating flow rate to diameter, can be used to provide individualized waveforms for patient-specific geometries. The dependence of flow rate on diameter was statistically different between male and female patients. Significance : It was shown that a single archetypal waveform cannot well-represent the diverse waveforms found within an aged population, although this approach is frequently used in studies of flow in the cerebral vasculature. Motivated by these results, we provided a set of eight waveforms that can be used to assess the hemodynamic uncertainty associated with the lack of patient-specific waveform data. We also provided a methodology for generating individualized waveforms when patient gender, age, and cardiovascular disease state are known. These data-driven approaches can be used to devise more relevant in vitro or in silico intra-cranial hemodynamic studies for older patients.

SUMMARYUnderstanding the flow alteration in side branches during flow diversion treatment of cerebral aneurysms is important to prevent ischemic complications and improve device designs. Flow diverters were placed in the aorta of four rabbits crossing the origin of side arteries. Subject‐specific computational models were constructed from 3D angiographies and Doppler ultrasounds (DUSs). Flow simulations were run before and after virtually deploying the flow diverters, assuming distal resistances remained unchanged after treatment. All jailed arteries remained patent angiographically 8 weeks after treatment. The computational models estimated decreases compared to pretreatment in the mean flow rates between 2% and 20% and in peak flow rates between 5% and 36%. The major changes were observed during systole. Flow patterns did not exhibit recirculation zones before treatment. Implantation of the flow diverters altered the flow structure only locally near the device wires. No major recirculation regions were created or destroyed. Flow diverters seem safe with respect to perforator or side branch occlusion. Relatively small changes in flow rates through jailed arteries are expected, even for moderate to large degrees of coverage of their origins. These results seem consistent with previous clinical experiences where no or very few complications related to perforator occlusion have been reported.Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

SUMMARY Quantification and characterization of the hemodynamic environment created after flow diversion treatment of cerebral aneurysms is important to understand the effects of flow diverters and their interactions with the biology of the aneurysm wall and the thrombosis process that takes place subsequently. This paper describes the construction of multi‐modality image‐based subject‐specific CFD models of experimentally created aneurysms in rabbits and subsequently treated with flow diverters. Briefly, anatomical models were constructed from 3D rotational angiography images, flow conditions were derived from Doppler ultrasound measurements, stent models were created and virtually deployed, and the results were compared with in vivo digital subtraction angiography and Doppler ultrasound images. The models were capable of reproducing in vivo observations, including velocity waveforms measured in the parent artery, peak velocity values measured in the aneurysm, and flow structures observed with digital subtraction angiography before and after deployment of flow diverters. The results indicate that regions of aneurysm occlusion after flow diversion coincide with slow and smooth flow patterns, whereas regions still permeable at the time of animal sacrifice were observed in parts of the aneurysm exposed to larger flow activity, that is, higher velocities, more swirling, and more complex flow structures. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.