Back to Authors

Lindorfer, Margaret A.

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4203-405X

Mayo Clinic

University of Virginia

Citations 5

Resistance to Complement Dependent Cytotoxicity in CLL Cells From Patients Treated with Ofatumumab
Baig, Nisar A. , Lindorfer, Margaret A. , Church, Amy K., LaPlant, Betsy, Pavey, Emily S., Call, Timothy G. , Nowakowski, Grzegorz S. , Taylor, Ronald P. , Shanafelt, Tait D. , Kay, Neil E. , Zent, Clive S.

Blood | October 14, 2019 | Volume: 118 | Issue: 21 | Pages: 2836-2836

10.1182/blood.v118.21.2836.2836 Get It

Abstract Abstract 2836 Monoclonal antibodies (mAb) are an effective but non-curative treatment of CLL. Although the mechanisms of action of mAb in vivo are not fully defined, complement dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) appears to play an important role. We have previously shown that addition of ofatumumab (OFA) significantly increases alemtuzumab (ALM) CDC in vitro and identified a subpopulation of CLL cells that are intrinsically resistant to activated complement. We propose that resistance to CDC could be an important cause of mAb treatment failure in CLL patients. To test the hypothesis that CLL cells treated in vivo with OFA would be resistant to subsequent OFA retreatment in vitro, we studied CLL cells and serum from 10 previously untreated patients with progressive CLL treated with pentostatin, cyclophosphamide, and ofatumumab (PCO). Methods. Patients received 300 mg of OFA followed by 2 mg/m2 of pentostatin and 600 mg/m2 of cyclophosphamide on day 1 of therapy. Samples were taken prior to treatment (S1), immediately after the OFA infusion and prior to chemotherapy (S2), and post-chemotherapy before the second dose of OFA on day 2 (S3). Mononuclear blood cells isolated from EDTA anticoagulated blood by Ficoll-Paque centrifugation were purified to achieve a concentration of > 90% CLL. CDC was assayed at a concentration of 2 × 106/ml CLL cells with 10 mg/ml of ALM (Genzyme), OFA (G.S.K.) or rituximab (RTX)(Genentech) in AIM V medium (Invitrogen, CA) and 10% normal human serum (10%NHS)(Sigma, MO) as a source of complement for 1 hour at 37°C. Absolute viable cell counts were measured by flow cytometry using counting beads (Trucount, BD, CA) and propidium iodide staining (Sigma, MO) with a FACSCalibur (BD, CA) and CellQuest Pro software (BD, CA). Percent CDC was calculated relative to counts for CLL cells treated with only 10%NHS. Binding of mAb and C3b to CLL cells was measured by flow cytometry with mouse anti-human Fc antibody FITC-HB43 and anti-C3b antibody FITC-7C12. C5 deficient serum (C5-serum)(Sigma, MO) was used to examine mAb and C3b binding without CDC. Results were expressed as delta mean fluorescent intensity (dMFI) relative to cells treated without mAb in 10%NHS or C5-serum as appropriate. Complement (CH50) was measured based on lysis of opsonized sheep red cells using standard methods. OFA concentrations in serum samples were determined by measuring the level of binding to Daudi cells compared to standards as previously described. Results: S1 CLL cells were significantly more susceptible to in vitro OFA CDC (median 30%) than S2 and S3 cells (both 0%, p=0.002)(Fig. 1). In contrast, high levels of CDC (median 86 – 88%) were induced in vitro by ALM in all these samples and prior in vivo exposure to OFA did not affect susceptibility to ALM CDC in vitro (p>0.1). CLL cells from S2&S3 had low levels of OFA binding both prior to and post in vitro exposure to OFA (median dMFI 2 and 3 respectively) which was significantly less than OFA binding for S1 (median dMFI 38 p=0.002) likely reflecting in vivo trogocytosis of bound OFA and CD20, as previously described for RTX. In vitro ALM binding was higher than OFA (median dMFI>150) in all specimens. C3b binding was low in S2&S3 both before and after in vitro OFA exposure (median dMFI 3 and 4 respectively) with significantly higher levels in S1 (median dMFI 94, p=0.002). C3b binding was higher in all CLL cells treated with ALM (median dMFI>358). OFA treatment resulted in marked decreases in serum complement levels in S2 (median 86%, range 65–98%) and S3 (median 78% range 61–88%) compared to S1. The median serum OFA concentration was 18.5 μg/ml (range 7.3–50.4) in S2 and 19.8 μg/ml (range 0–32.3) in S3. Conclusions: Circulating CLL cells from patients treated with OFA are resistant to in vitro OFA CDC primarily because of low levels of expression of CD20. The reduction in complement titers could limit in vivo CDC but we found no evidence that low levels of OFA were important. Cells surviving OFA in vivo do retain sensitivity to ALM CDC. Our data support the previous description of trogocytosis in CLL patients treated with RTX and suggest that lower doses of these mAb, that promote far lower levels of trogocytosis, could be more effective in sustaining CDC. In addition, our study provides pre-clinical data to support a clinical trial of combination therapy with OFA and ALM for CLL. Acknowledgment: This study was supported by funding from GlaxoSmithKline and the University of Iowa/Mayo Clinic Lymphoma SPORE (CA097274). Disclosures: Taylor: Genmab: Consultancy; Glaxo Smith Kline: Research Funding. Zent:GlaxoSmithKline: Research Funding; Genentech: Research Funding; Genzyme: Research Funding.
Complement Activation and Cytotoxicity In CLL Cells Treated with Alemtuzumab and Ofatumumab: Evidence for Multiple Mechanisms of Resistance to Complement Dependent Cytotoxicity
Baig, Nisar A. , Church, Amy K., Nowakowski, Grzegorz S. , Lindorfer, Margaret A. , Taylor, Ronald P. , Zent, Clive S.

Blood | October 12, 2019 | Volume: 116 | Issue: 21 | Pages: 3575-3575

10.1182/blood.v116.21.3575.3575 Get It

Abstract Abstract 3575 Unconjugated monoclonal antibodies (MoAb) have proven value in the therapy of CLL, and alemtuzumab (ALEM) has efficacy in patients with purine analog refractory/p53 defective disease. Although the mechanisms of action of ALEM in vivo are not fully defined, complement dependant cytotoxicity (CDC) appears to play an important role. ALEM CDC resistance in a subpopulation of CLL cells in vivo could thus contribute to treatment failure. We hypothesized that the CD20 targeted complement activating human MoAb ofatumumab (OFA) would increase complement activation (as manifested by C3b deposition) as well as CDC in CLL cells treated with ALEM in vitro. Methods: We have completed experiments on 4 of 15 specimens collected from patients with progressive untreated CLL. CLL cells were isolated from blood by density gradient centrifugation and negative selection with magnetic beads. CD52 and CD20 expression were measured with fluorescent beads (Quantum MESF, Bangs Laboratories, IN). CLL cells were treated at a concentration of 2 × 106/ml with 10 mcg/ml of ALEM (Genzyme) and/or OFA (G.S.K.) in AIM V medium (Invitrogen CA) and 10% standard normal human serum (NHS) (Sigma, MO) as a source of complement for 1 hour at 37C. Absolute viable cell counts were assayed with counting beads (TruCOUNT, BD, CA) and propidium iodide (PI) staining (Sigma) using a FACSCalibur (BD) and CellQuest Pro software (BD). CDC was determined by comparing counts to CLL cells treated with NHS alone. Membrane levels of CD59, bound MoAb, and deposited C3b on the CLL cells membranes were measured by flow cytometry using using the anti-CD59 antibody FITC-CD59 (BD), mouse anti-human Fc antibody FITC-HB43, and the anti-C3b antibody FITC-7C12. To study ALEM CDC resistant cells, CLL cells were first treated with ALEM and NHS as detailed above. Surviving viable cells were isolated using density gradient centrifugation and then retreated. C5 deficient serum (Sigma) was used in experiments to determine MoAb binding and C3b deposition in the entire CLL cell population. Results: Binding of either ALEM or OFA to the CLL cells in NHS resulted in activation of complement and deposition of large amounts of membrane C3b on the cells. However, ALEM induced higher levels of C3b deposition (delta MFI 220) and caused more CDC (73% vs. 18%) compared to OFA. This correlated well with the higher levels of expression of CD52 vs. CD20 expression in CLL cells (143 ×103, range 131 ×103 – 159 ×103 vs. mean 20 ×103 molecules/cell, range 10 ×103 – 28 ×103). Studies with the anti-Fc antibody showed that only a small subpopulation of CLL cells had weak MoAb binding. Addition of OFA to ALEM increased complement-mediated C3b deposition. In three patients with high initial ALEM CDC, addition of OFA did not appreciably increase CDC (81% to 87%). However, in one patient with cells that were less sensitive to ALEM CDC, addition of OFA did appreciably increase CDC (51% to 86%). There was no relationship between levels of CD59 expression and CDC. All four CLL specimens studied contained a subpopulation of cells that were resistant to CDC (mean 13%, range 9–18%) despite robust C3b deposition. Conclusions: These data suggests that there are multiple mechanisms of resistance to MoAb-mediated CDC including: 1. Low MoAb binding because of low target antigen expression; 2. Insufficient C3b deposition after MoAb ligation and; 3. Intrinsic resistance in some cells in cells in which high levels of C3b deposition were clearly demonstrable. OFA can increase MoAb binding, C3b deposition, and CDC in CLL cells treated with ALEM. However, addition of OFA does not overcome the intrinsic resistance of a small subpopulation of CLL cells to CDC. Future studies will be needed to examine these resistance mechanisms and to develop interventions to disrupt them. In addition, membrane C3b could be a target for complement dependent cellular cytotoxity in these CDC resistant cells. Disclosures: Taylor: G.S.K.: Research Funding; Genmab: Research Funding. Zent:Genzyme: Research Funding; Genentech: Research Funding; Novartis: Research Funding; G.S.K.: Research Funding.
CLL Cells From Subjects Treated with Rituximab and Alemtuzumab Can Lose Target Antigen and Develop Resistance to Mab-Mediated Complement Dependent Cytotoxicity
Beum, Paul V., Lindorfer, Margaret A. , Taylor, Ronald P. , Zent, Clive S. , Weiner, George J.

Blood | October 12, 2019 | Volume: 116 | Issue: 21 | Pages: 3585-3585

10.1182/blood.v116.21.3585.3585 Get It

Abstract Abstract 3585 Relapsed/refractory CLL is often resistant to antibody-based therapy. Understanding the dynamics of interaction between complement and cell-based antibody-antigen complexes that promote complement dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) of targeted cells could lead to improved therapies. We are conducting a clinical trial of chemoimmunotherapy for relapsed/refractory CLL using pentostatin, alemtuzumab (ALEM), and low-dose rituximab (RTX). Correlative studies were designed to determine if circulating CLL cells developed resistance to CDC. Peripheral blood CLL cells were obtained from 12 patients (median age 66 years, 11 male, 17p13- in 4) including 7 (58%) who responded (4 CR, 3 PR) to treatment. Blood samples were obtained before initiating therapy (day 1), 48 hr after the 1st RTX dose (20 mg/m2 IV MWF), one hour after the 2nd dose of RTX and 1st dose of ALEM (3 mg SC) (day 3), and 72 hr after the 3rd doses of RTX (cumulative dose 60 mg/m2) and ALEM (cumulative dose 43 mg) (day 8). All blood samples were taken prior to the 1st dose of pentostatin. B cells were examined for expression of several markers including complement control proteins (CCP), CD20 and CD52. By treatment day 8, ALC decreased by 70 % or more for 7 patients. The other 5 patients had ALC that were 50 – 100% of pre-treatment levels. In agreement with previous studies from our laboratories, low-dose RTX rapidly decreased CD20 levels on circulating CLL cells; on day 3 after the 2nd RTX dose (and 1st ALEM dose), CD20 was reduced by > 75% in 10 subjects. CD20 levels recovered by day 8 in 6 of these subjects. One hour after completion of mAb infusions on day 3, fragments of complement breakdown product C3dg were demonstrable on circulating CLL cells in 7 subjects, suggesting that infusion of RTX had promoted complement activation on circulating cells. After the RTX and ALEM infusions on day 3, circulating CLL cells with bound C3dg fragments had considerably reduced levels of CD20 but were not cleared from the circulation, suggesting that RTX had bound to the cells, activated complement and promoted shaving (CD20 loss) without inducing bloodstream clearance of these cells. CD52 levels on circulating CLL cells showed modest decreases by day 8 (~ 50% of pre-treatment values) in 4 subjects. To study CDC in vitro, washed blood samples were reconstituted with ABO-matched normal human serum, ALEM was added and complement activation (C3 fragment deposition) and CDC of targeted CLL cells were measured by flow cytometry. Alternatively, mononuclear cells were isolated by ficoll-hypaque centrifugation and subjected to the same analyses, with very similar results. ALEM-mediated in vitro CDC of CLL cells varied from 10 to 90 % for pre-treatment blood samples. Measures of ALEM-mediated CDC and C3b fragment deposition in vitro correlated with the density of CD52 on CLL cells (P<0.001). The initial burden of circulating cells was not predictive of a drop in ALC, and pre-therapy levels of CDC were not correlated with cell clearance after therapy. On day 8, ALEM-mediated in vitro CDC of circulating CLL cells had decreased to <50% of the values measured on pre-treatment samples in 6 subjects, suggesting that cells of these patients might be developing resistance to ALEM-mediated CDC. This decrease in CDC was not correlated with decreases in levels of CD52 expression on patients’ CLL cells or with increases in expression of CCP (CD35, CD46, CD55, CD59). Our findings demonstrate that even after treatment with both RTX and ALEM, CLL cells can persist in the bloodstream in a subset of patients, suggesting that some patients have circulating CLL cells that are resistant to mAb-mediated clearance and CDC due to mechanism(s) that may include loss of antigen and possibly intrinsic resistance. Disclosures: Zent: Genzyme: Research Funding; Genentech: Research Funding; Novartis: Research Funding; G.S.K.: Research Funding. Weiner:Genentech: Consultancy.
Chemoimmunotherapy for relapsed/refractory and progressive 17p13‐deleted chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) combining pentostatin, alemtuzumab, and low‐dose rituximab is effective and tolerable and limits loss of CD20 expression by circulating CLL cells
Lindorfer, Margaret A. , Beum, Paul V., LaPlant, Betsy, Call, Timothy G. , Bowen, Deborah A., Conte, Michael, Frederick, Lori, Link, Brian K. , Veeramani, Suresh , Baig, Nisar A. , Viswanatha, David S., Weiner, George J. , Zent, Clive S. , Taylor, Ronald P. , Wu, Wenting , Blackwell, Sue E , Witzig, Thomas E. , Link, Brian K , Weiner, George

American Journal of Hematology | April 10, 2014 | Volume: 89 | Issue: 7 | Pages: 757-765

10.1002/ajh.23737 Get It

Chronic lymphocytic leukemia/small lymphocytic lymphoma (CLL) patients with purine analog refractory disease or TP53 dysfunction still have limited treatment options and poor survival. Alemtuzumab‐containing chemoimmunotherapy regimens can be effective but frequently cause serious infections. We report a Phase II trial testing the efficacy and tolerability of a short‐duration regimen combining pentostatin, alemtuzumab, and low‐dose high‐frequency rituximab designed to decrease the risk of treatment‐associated infections and to limit the loss of CD20 expression by CLL cells. The study enrolled 39 patients with progressive CLL that was either relapsed/refractory (n = 36) or previously untreated with 17p13 deletion (17p13−) (n = 3). Thirteen (33%) patients had both 17p13− and TP53 mutations predicted to be dysfunctional, and eight patients had purine analog refractory CLL without TP53 dysfunction. Twenty‐six (67%) patients completed therapy, with only five (13%) patients having treatment‐limiting toxicity and no treatment‐related deaths. Twenty‐two (56%) patients responded to treatment, with 11 (28%) complete responses (four with incomplete bone marrow recovery). Median progression‐free survival was 7.2 months, time to next treatment was 9.1 months, and overall survival was 34.1 months. The majority of deaths (82%) were caused by progressive disease, including transformed diffuse large B‐cell lymphoma (n = 6). Correlative studies showed that low‐dose rituximab activates complement and natural killer cells without a profound and sustained decrease in expression of CD20 by circulating CLL cells. We conclude that pentostatin, alemtuzumab, and low‐dose high‐frequency rituximab is a tolerable and effective therapy for CLL and that low‐dose rituximab therapy can activate innate immune cytotoxic mechanisms without substantially decreasing CD20 expression. Am. J. Hematol. 89:757–765, 2014. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Induced Resistance to Ofatumumab-Mediated Cell Clearance Mechanisms, Including Complement-Dependent Cytotoxicity, in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia
Baig, Nisar A. , Lindorfer, Margaret A. , Church, Amy K., LaPlant, Betsy, Pettinger, Adam, Nowakowski, Grzegorz S. , Taylor, Ronald P. , Shanafelt, Tait D. , Zent, Clive S.

The Journal of Immunology | January 16, 2014 | Volume: 192 | Issue: 4 | Pages: 1620-1629

10.4049/jimmunol.1302954 Get It

Abstract Ofatumumab (OFA), a human CD20-targeting mAb, kills B lymphocytes using the innate immune system including complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC). The efficacy of OFA in patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) is limited by drug resistance, which is not well characterized. To better understand mechanisms of resistance, we prospectively studied CLL cells isolated from blood samples collected before and after in vivo exposure to the initial dose of OFA therapy in 25 patients undergoing their first treatment for progressive CLL. As previously reported, OFA therapy rapidly decreased the absolute lymphocyte count, CD20 expression by CLL cells, and serum complement levels. We now show that after administration of the first dose of OFA, there was a modest rebound in the absolute lymphocyte count and serum complement levels, but substantial ongoing loss of CD20 expression by CLL cells. These post-OFA treatment CLL cells were highly resistant to OFA-mediated CDC but retained sensitivity to alemtuzumab-mediated CDC in vitro. Posttherapy serum OFA levels correlated inversely with both the amount of pretreatment circulating cell-bound CD20 and with the decrease in this value following treatment. In vitro OFA-mediated CDC did not predict clinical responses, and the patients with first-dose reactions to OFA did not have markers of increased complement activation in vivo. We propose that optimal efficacy of CD20- targeted therapy for CLL requires determining an mAb dose size and frequency that optimizes CLL killing without exceeding the capacity of the cytotoxic mechanisms and thus minimizes loss of CD20 expression in the surviving CLL cells.