Boultwood, Jacqueline

Abstract Introduction: Standardized reporting of clinical trials results for MDS is essential to improve clinical interpretation and cross-study comparison. However, reporting of patient characteristics, response criteria, and endpoints in publications is often inconsistent; there is no systemic analysis of MDS trial reporting available. We conducted a systematic review of published MDS trial manuscripts on behalf of the international consortium for MDS (icMDS) to assess variability in reporting practices. Methods We searched ClinicalTrials.gov to identify all clinical trials registered for adults (≥18 years) with MDS that reported results between 2015-2024. Clinical trials that included acute myeloid leukemia (AML) or MDS/myeloproliferative neoplasms (MPN) were included if they enrolled ≥5 MDS patients. We excluded trials without an MDS cohort; non-therapeutic trials; trials focused on transplant interventions; or those which enrolled solid malignancies or other hematologic malignancies (chronic myeloid leukemia or lymphoid diseases). Finally, trials were required to have a manuscript available on Larvol, PubMed, or Google Scholar. Trials were categorized by disease risk (lower-risk [LR] vs. higher-risk [HR]) and trial phase (early phase [EP] vs. late phase [LP]). Results We identified 502 MDS trials on ClinicalTrials.gov, of which 351 did not meet inclusion criteria and 79 lacked a manuscript. A total of 72 trials (32 EP, 40 LP) with 80 publications (34 EP, 46 LP) were analyzed. Frequently reported baseline characteristics included age (100% EP, 100% LP), disease risk (74% EP, 74% LP), Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status (85% EP, 72% LP), prior treatments (71% EP, 67% LP), and RBC transfusion dependency (32% EP, 70% LP). Less frequently reported characteristics included blood counts (hemoglobin [Hb; 38% EP, 54% LP], platelet count [38% EP, 54% LP], neutrophil count [24% EP and LP]) and bone marrow blasts (29% EP, 43% LP). Although disease risk was widely reported, definitions varied: IPSS and IPSS-R were each reported in 54% of manuscripts, while IPSS-M appeared in only 3%. Cytogenetic risk was separately reported in 39% of manuscripts (38% EP, 39% LP), and mutational data in 45% (47% EP, 43% LP). Responses per IWG 2006 criteria were reported in 84% of manuscripts. The primary endpoint involved safety/tolerability in 85% of EP manuscripts, though definitions were variable; recommended phase 2 dose was the most common (26% of EP manuscripts). In LP trials, primary endpoints were risk-specific: transfusion independence (TI) in 77% of LR, overall response rate (ORR) in 28% of HR, and complete remission (CR) or overall survival (OS) in 22% of HR. In HR manuscripts, CR was reported in 100%, ORR in 73%, hematologic improvement (HI) in 48%, RBC-TI in 23%, and OS in 80%. However, seven different definitions were used for ORR: CR + marrow CR + partial remission + HI per IWG 2006 was most common (35%). Event-free survival was reported in 25%; progression-free survival and relapse-free survival in 13%; and leukemia-free survival in 5%. Early mortality rate was reported in 35% (18% EP, 56% LP) and transplant rate in 58% (50% EP, 67% LP). Only 47% of HR and 90% of LR manuscripts identified HI-eligible patients. In LR-MDS, RBC-TI was reported in 72% of manuscripts but used six definitions. The most common were RBC-TI ≥8 weeks at any time during treatment (24%), ≥8 weeks within 28 weeks of treatment (13%), ≥8 weeks with Hb increase ≥1.0 (4%), ≥12 weeks with Hb increase ≥1.5 (4%), and ≥16 weeks within 24 weeks of treatment (12%). The remainder did not report RBC-TI, did not define it, or used a custom definition not used in another trial. HI was reported in 80% of LR papers with most of those reporting HI using IWG 2006 criteria (90%). Conclusion Reporting of baseline characteristics, response criteria, and outcomes is inconsistent in MDS clinical trials, with wide variability in response definitions, including ORR and TI. This heterogeneity limits interpretability, hampers historical comparisons and may obscure efficacy signals. Our findings highlight the need for standardized reporting guidelines to ensure clarity and consistency in MDS trial publications. As a next phase of this effort, we will conduct a formal Delphi process among icMDS experts to establish consensus recommendations for minimal and optimal MDS clinical trial reporting in manuscripts by disease risk (LR/HR) and trial phase (EP/LP).

Abstract Excessively restrictive inclusion and exclusion criteria in clinical trials are one of many barriers to clinical trial enrollment for patients with myelodysplastic syndromes/neoplasms (MDSs). Many organizations are developing efforts to increase clinical trial eligibility; yet, several recent publications focused on patients with MDS suggest that many patients with this disease may be excluded from clinical trials unnecessarily. Clinical trial eligibility should reflect the phase of the study and risks of the agent being studied. Phase 3 trials should be less restrictive than early-phase trials to represent the real-world population as closely as possible. We hypothesize that many clinical trials, particularly phase 3 trials, have unnecessarily restrictive eligibility criteria. This study aims to evaluate the most common eligibility criteria according to phase of trial and to determine whether criteria correspond with drug safety signals. We identified MDS clinical trials registered on ClinicalTrials.gov from 1 January 2000 to 1 September 2023 and analyzed the eligibility criteria of 191 therapeutic MDS trials. We found that categorical inclusion and exclusion criteria are remarkably similar in representation across trial phases. Additionally, only 13% of trials are concordant with drug safety signals, suggesting that the eligibility criteria are often arbitrary. On behalf of the icMDS (International Consortium for Myelodysplastic Syndromes), an association of international MDS experts, we provide a position statement on restrictive eligibility criteria for MDS clinical trials that should be avoided with the aim of removing barriers to clinical trial enrollment.

Abstract Abstract 1875 Recent experimental evidence suggests that acute myeloid leukemia (AML) originates from hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPC) following the acquisition of multiple genetic or epigenetic changes that initially give rise to pre-leukemic HSPC (pre-LSC) and then to fully transformed leukemia stem cells (LSC). Relapse continues to be the major cause of death in most subtypes of AML, suggesting that current therapies are largely ineffective in eliminating LSC and pre-LSC. Cellular heterogeneity and the recent observation that LSC are contained within different phenotypic cellular compartments are challenges for the identification of pathways contributing to the initiation and maintenance of AML. To address these challenges we employed a novel strategy of parallel transcriptional analysis of multiple phenotypic HSPC populations from individuals with AML with normal karyotype (N=5), -7/7q- (N=6) and complex karyotype (N=5), including long-term HSC, short-term HSC, and granulocyte-monocyte progenitors (GMP), and comparison to corresponding cell populations from age-matched healthy controls (HC) (N=6). Specifically, we sorted Lin−/CD34+/CD38−/CD90+ (LT-HSC), Lin−/CD34+/CD38−/CD90− (ST-HSC), and Lin−/CD34+/CD38+/CD123+/CD45RA+ (GMP), and hybridized RNA to Affymetrix GeneST 1.0 expression arrays. Differential gene expression was determined within each compartment by direct comparison of AML LT-HSC vs. HC LT-HSC, AML ST-HSC vs. HC ST-HSC, and AML GMP vs. HC GMP. Subsequent intersection of all differentially expressed genes revealed that only a relatively small number of 6 to 11 genes were consistently dysregulated in all examined leukemic stem and progenitor cell compartments. Interleukin 1 receptor accessory protein (IL1RAP) was one of the most significantly upregulated genes in LT-HSC, ST-HSC, and GMP in all examined subtypes of AML. IL1RAP is a transmembrane protein required for signaling through several receptors of the IL1 family, including IL-1R1 and ST2. We detected significant overexpression of IL1RAP protein on HSC and progenitor cells of AML patients. Interestingly, CD34+/Lin+ precursor cells showed only a marginal increase of IL1RAP at the protein level in AML, underscoring the importance of purifying HSPC with stringent lineage depletion. We performed fluorescence in situ hybridization in sorted IL1RAP+ and IL1RAP− cells from -7 AML. We observed that the -7 clone was restricted to IL1RAP+ cells, while IL1RAP- cells did not display monosomy 7, demonstrating that IL1RAP overexpression is a distinguishing feature of the cells of the -7 clone. Patients with normal karyotype AML showed a wider range of IL1RAP expression levels; some were as high as in -7 AML and others were as low as in HC. We asked whether IL1RAP expression levels were associated with known clinical or molecular parameters. We analyzed two published datasets of patients with normal karyotype AML (Metzeler, Blood. 2008;112:4193–4201; Tomasson, Blood. 2008;111:4797–4808). Patients with high IL1RAP levels showed inferior overall survival than patients with lower IL1RAP (p=2.2×10−7; median survival: 7.82 mo. for IL1RAP high, 20 mo. for IL1RAP low). Multivariate analysis using a Cox regression model showed that high IL1RAP status was an independent prognostic factor (p=0.002), and even stronger than FLT3 mutation status (p=0.006). In addition, we analyzed data from 183 patients with MDS and found IL1RAP expression to be specifically elevated in cases with RAEB-2, suggesting a role of IL1RAP in MDS and in the progression to AML. Downregulation of IL1RAP protein expression in 4 AML cell lines (THP1, OCI-AML3, HL60, HEL) led to a significant 45–98% decrease in clonogenic growth and increased apoptosis in vitro. To assess the effects of IL1RAP downregulation in vivo, we performed xenotransplants into immunodeficient NOD/SCID/IL2Rg-null mice. THP-1 AML cells showed a 92% reduced proliferation and infiltration of hematopoietic organs upon IL1RAP knockdown in comparison to a non-silencing control in vivo. Genetic studies to assess the role of IL1RAP in the initiation and maintenance of AML in an IL1RAP−/− mouse model are currently ongoing. In summary, our study provides a map of consistently dysregulated transcripts across multiple fractionated stem and progenitor cell types from patients with AML, and identifies IL1RAP as a putative new therapeutic and prognostic target in stem cells in AML and MDS. Disclosures: No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.

Abstract Despite the established use of poly-chemotherapy, relapse continues to be the most common cause of death in AML and MDS and cure rates remain below 20%. AML/MDS arise following the accumulation of stepwise genetic and epigenetic changes in hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPC). Utilizing a novel strategy of parallel transcriptional analysis of sorted HSPC populations in distinct subtypes of AML, we compared the gene expression in AML HSPC with identical compartments from age-matched healthy controls and identified Interleukin 1 receptor accessory protein (IL1RAP) as one of the most significantly upregulated genes in HSPC in all examined subtypes of AML. Fluorescence in situ hybridization of sorted IL1RAP+ and IL1RAP- cells from patients with monosomy 7 AML (-7) indicated that the aberrant clone was restricted to IL1RAP+ cells, demonstrating that IL1RAP overexpression is a distinguishing feature of the -7 clone. Multivariate analysis of a large cohort of patients with normal karyotype AML showed that patients with high IL1RAP levels had inferior overall survival than patients with lower IL1RAP levels, suggesting an independent prognostic value for this molecule in AML. IL1RAP expression levels in MDS were found elevated on stem cells of patients with high risk disease, proposing a role of IL1RAP in higher risk MDS and progression to AML. Downregulation of IL1RAP expression by lentivirally expressed shRNAs decreased clonogenicity in cell lines and AML/MDS primary patient samples, induced apoptosis of AML cells, and reduced proliferation of AML cells and infiltration of hematopoietic organs in vivo. IL1RAP is a transmembrane protein required for signaling through several receptors of the IL1 family. Downregulation of IL1RAP expression in AML cells led to phosphorylation changes in several kinases and their substrates suggesting participation of IL1RAP in multiple signaling pathways and highlighting its potential as therapeutic target. We investigated whether inhibition of IL1RAP with pharmacological compounds is feasible and effective. Antibody-mediated inhibition of IL1RAP led to inhibition of AML cell growth in vitro. In addition, we designed peptides to interfere with IL1RAP-receptor interactions which lead to inhibition of AML cell growth. Both types of agents are being further tested and optimized. In summary, our study reveals IL1RAP as aberrantly expressed on HSPC of AML and high-risk MDS patients. Inhibition of IL1RAP is feasible and functionally effective, and thus has the potential to lead to novel therapies specifically directed at such stem cells. Beyond IL1RAP, our study provides a map of dysregulated transcripts in HSPC from patients with AML, which may offer further opportunities for therapeutic intervention. The strategy of comparative analysis of sorted stem and progenitor cells in cancer versus healthy controls may be applicable to other type of cancers with a suspected stem cell origin, and instrumental for the identification of targets for stem cell-directed therapy. Citation Information: Mol Cancer Ther 2013;12(11 Suppl):C225. Citation Format: Laura Barreyro, Kelly Mitchell, Britta Will, Boris Bartholdy, Li Zhou, Tihomira Todorova, Robert Stanley, Susana Ben-Neriah, Cristina Montagna, Samir Parekh, Andrea Pellagatti, Jacqueline Boultwood, Elisabeth Paietta, Rhett Ketterling, Larry Cripe, Hugo Fernandez, Peter Greenberg, Jacob Rowe, Martin Tallman, Christian Steidl, Constantine Mitsiades, Amit Verma, Ulrich Steidl. IL1RAP as functionally relevant target for stem-cell directed therapy in acute myeloid leukemia (AML) and myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS). [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR-NCI-EORTC International Conference: Molecular Targets and Cancer Therapeutics; 2013 Oct 19-23; Boston, MA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Mol Cancer Ther 2013;12(11 Suppl):Abstract nr C225.

AbstractCellular and interpatient heterogeneity and the involvement of different stem and progenitor compartments in leukemogenesis are challenges for the identification of common pathways contributing to the initiation and maintenance of acute myeloid leukemia (AML). Here we used a strategy of parallel transcriptional analysis of phenotypic long-term hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs), short-term HSCs, and granulocyte-monocyte progenitors from individuals with high-risk (−7/7q−) AML and compared them with the corresponding cell populations from healthy controls. This analysis revealed dysregulated expression of 11 genes, including IL-1 receptor accessory protein (IL1RAP), in all leukemic stem and progenitor cell compartments. IL1RAP protein was found to be overexpressed on the surface of HSCs of AML patients, and marked cells with the −7/7q− anomaly. IL1RAP was also overexpressed on HSCs of patients with normal karyotype AML and high-risk myelodysplastic syndrome, suggesting a pervasive role in different disease subtypes. High IL1RAP expression was independently associated with poor overall survival in 3 independent cohorts of AML patients (P = 2.2 × 10−7). Knockdown of IL1RAP decreased clonogenicity and increased cell death of AML cells. Our study identified genes dysregulated in stem and progenitor cells in −7/7q− AML, and suggests that IL1RAP may be a promising therapeutic and prognostic target in AML and high-risk myelodysplastic syndrome.