Enriquez‐Sarano, Maurice

BackgroundMitral valve repair has been suggested as providing a better postoperative outcome than valve replacement for mitral regurgitation, but this impression has been obscured by differences in baseline characteristics and has not been confirmed in multivariate analyses.Methods and ResultsThe outcomes in 195 patients with valve repair and 214 with replacement for organic mitral regurgitation were compared using multivariate analysis. All patients had preoperative echocardiographic assessment of left ventricular function. Before surgery, patients with valve repair were less symptomatic than those with replacement (42% in New York Heart Association functional class I or II versus 24%, respectively;P=.001), had less atrial fibrillation (41% versus 53%;P=.017), and had a better ejection fraction (63±9% versus 60±12%,P=.016). After valve repair, compared with valve replacement, overall survival at 10 years was 68±6% versus 52±4% (P=.0004), overall operative mortality was 2.6% versus 10.3% (P=.002), operative mortality in patients under age 75 was 1.3% versus 5.7% (P=.036), and late survival (in operative survivors) at 10 years was 69±6% versus 58±5% (P=.018). Late survival after valve repair was not different from expected survival. After surgery, ejection fraction decreased significantly in both groups but was higher after valve repair (P=.001). Multivariate analysis indicated an independent beneficial effect of valve repair on overall survival (hazard ratio, 0.39;P=.00001), operative mortality (odds ratio, 0.27;P=.026), late survival (hazard ratio, 0.44;P=.001), and postoperative ejection fraction (P=.001).ConclusionsValve repair significantly improves postoperative outcome in patients with mitral regurgitation and should be the preferred mode of surgical correction. The low operative mortality is an incentive for early surgery before ventricular dysfunction occurs.

BACKGROUND Left ventricular dysfunction is a frequent cause of death after successful surgical repair of mitral regurgitation. The role of preoperative echocardiographic left ventricular variables in the prediction of postoperative survival and thus their clinical implications remain uncertain. METHODS AND RESULTS The survival of 409 patients operated on between 1980 and 1989 for pure, isolated, organic mitral regurgitation and with a preoperative echocardiogram (within 6 months of operation) was analyzed. The overall survival was 75% at 5 years (90% of expected), 58% at 10 years (88% of expected), and 44% at 12 years (73% of expected). Operative mortality was 6.6% and markedly improved from 1980 to 1984 (10.7%) to 1985 to 1989 (3.7%). Multivariate analysis showed that age (P = .0003), date of operation (P = .003), and functional class (P = .016) but not left ventricular function were predictors of operative mortality. In the most recent period (1985 to 1989), operative mortality was 12.3% in patients age 75 years or older and 1.1% in patients younger than 75 years. Late survival was analyzed in the operative survivors. Multivariate analysis showed that the most powerful predictor was echocardiographic ejection fraction (EF) (P = .0004), followed by age (P = .0031), creatinine level (P = .0062), systolic blood pressure (P = .0164), and presence of coronary artery disease (P = .0237). The late survival at 10 years was 32 +/- 12% for patients with EF < 50%, 53 +/- 9% for EF 50% to 60%, and 72 +/- 4% for EF > or = 60%. The hazard ratio compared with EF > or = 60% was 2.79 (95% confidence interval, 1.65 to 4.72) for EF < 50% and 1.81 (95% confidence interval, 1.11 to 2.95) for EF 50% to 60%. Echocardiographic EF remained the best predictor of late survival, even when combined with left ventricular angiographic variables. The survival of patients with EF > or = 60% was 100% of expected at 10 years but was better in patients in class I or II than in those in class III or IV (82 +/- 6% versus 59 +/- 6%, respectively, at 10 years; P = .0021). The preoperative predictors of operative and late mortality remained significant independent of the type of surgical correction performed in combined multivariate analyses. CONCLUSIONS In organic mitral regurgitation, (1) operative mortality has markedly decreased recently, being at a low 1.1% in patients younger than 75 years, and is predicted by age and symptoms and not by left ventricular function, and (2) left ventricular EF measured by echocardiography is the most powerful predictor of late survival. These results suggest that surgical treatment should be considered early, even in the absence of severe symptoms, in patients with severe mitral regurgitation, before left ventricular dysfunction occurs.

Background —Myocardial infarction (MI) can directly cause ischemic mitral regurgitation (IMR), which has been touted as an indicator of poor prognosis in acute and early phases after MI. However, in the chronic post-MI phase, prognostic implications of IMR presence and degree are poorly defined. Methods and Results —We analyzed 303 patients with previous (>16 days) Q-wave MI by ECG who underwent transthoracic echocardiography: 194 with IMR quantitatively assessed in routine practice and 109 without IMR matched for baseline age (71±11 versus 70±9 years, P =0.20), sex, and ejection fraction (EF, 33±14% versus 34±11%, P =0.14). In IMR patients, regurgitant volume (RVol) and effective regurgitant orifice (ERO) area were 36±24 mL/beat and 21±12 mm 2 , respectively. After 5 years, total mortality and cardiac mortality for patients with IMR (62±5% and 50±6%, respectively) were higher than for those without IMR (39±6% and 30±5%, respectively) (both P <0.001). In multivariate analysis, independently of all baseline characteristics, particularly age and EF, the adjusted relative risks of total and cardiac mortality associated with the presence of IMR (1.88, P =0.003 and 1.83, P =0.014, respectively) and quantified degree of IMR defined by RVol ≥30 mL (2.05, P =0.002 and 2.01, P =0.009) and by ERO ≥20 mm 2 (2.23, P =0.003 and 2.38, P =0.004) were high. Conclusions —In the chronic phase after MI, IMR presence is associated with excess mortality independently of baseline characteristics and degree of ventricular dysfunction. The mortality risk is related directly to the degree of IMR as defined by ERO and RVol. Therefore, IMR detection and quantification provide major information for risk stratification and clinical decision making in the chronic post-MI phase.

Background —Surgical correction of mitral regurgitation in patients with no or mild symptoms remains controversial, particularly because the impact of preoperative symptoms on postoperative outcome is unknown. Methods and Results —The long-term outcome of 478 patients with organic mitral regurgitation (199 in NYHA functional class I/II and 279 in class III/IV before surgery) operated on between 1984 and 1991 was analyzed. In patients in NYHA class I/II before surgery compared with those in class III/IV, postoperative long-term survival was higher (at 10 years, 76±5% versus 48±4%, P <0.0001), with lower operative mortality (0.5% versus 5.4%, P =0.003) and better late survival ( P <0.0001). Comparison of observed and expected survival showed identical curves in patients in class I/II before surgery ( P =0.18), whereas excess mortality was observed in patients in class III/IV before surgery ( P <0.0001). Excess mortality associated with severe symptoms was also confirmed in all subgroups (all P <0.003) and in multivariate analysis ( P =0.0036; adjusted hazard ratio [95% CI], 1.81 [1.21 to 2.70]). Conclusions —In patients with organic mitral regurgitation, preoperative functional class III/IV symptoms are associated with excess short- and long-term postoperative mortality independently of all baseline characteristics. These data should lead to consideration of surgical correction of severe organic mitral regurgitation when no or minimal symptoms are present in patients at low operative risk, especially if repair is feasible.

Background —The outcome of aortic regurgitation conservatively followed in clinical practice is poorly defined. Methods and Results —Long-term outcome of 246 patients with severe or moderately severe aortic regurgitation diagnosed by color Doppler echocardiography was analyzed. With conservative management, mortality rate was higher than expected (at 10 years, 34±5%, P <0.001) and morbidity was high (10-year rates of 47±6% for heart failure and 62±4% for aortic valve surgery). At 10 years, 75±3% of patients had died or had surgery and 83±3% had had cardiovascular events. In multivariate analysis, predictors of survival were age ( P <0.001), functional class ( P <0.001), comorbidity index ( P =0.033), atrial fibrillation ( P =0.002), and left ventricular end-systolic diameter corrected for body surface area ( P =0.025). Ejection fraction was also an independent predictor of overall survival, including postoperative follow-up of surgically treated patients ( P <0.001). High risk during conservative treatment, with mortality rate in excess of that expected, was noted among patients with severe, even transient, symptoms (24.6% yearly, P <0.001) but also in those with mild (class II) symptoms (6.3% yearly, P =0.02) and in asymptomatic patients with left ventricular ejection fraction <55% (5.8% yearly, P =0.03) or with end-systolic diameter normalized to body surface area ≥25 mm/m 2 (7.8% yearly, P =0.004). Surgery performed during follow-up was independently associated with reduced cardiovascular mortality (adjusted hazard ratio, 0.54; P =0.048). Conclusions —Patients diagnosed with severe aortic regurgitation in clinical practice incur excess mortality and high morbidity, underscoring the serious prognosis of the disease. Surgery, which reduces cardiac mortality rates, should be considered promptly in high-risk patients.

BACKGROUND Quantitation of valvular regurgitation remains a challenge. The accuracy of quantitative Doppler is controversial, and its ability to measure regurgitant volume is unknown; therefore, it is not widely used. METHODS AND RESULTS In 120 patients (20 without regurgitation, 19 with aortic regurgitation, and 81 with mitral regurgitation), the stroke volume through the mitral annulus and left ventricular outflow tract were measured using pulsed-wave Doppler concurrently with left ventricular stroke volume calculated using left ventricular volumes measured by two-dimensional echocardiography Simpson's biapical method. Regurgitant volume and fraction were thus computed using Doppler or ventricular methods. In normal patients there were good correlations between Doppler and left ventricular measurements of stroke volume. Doppler regurgitant volume and fraction were 4.4 +/- 4.4 mL and 5.3 +/- 4.5%, respectively. In patients with aortic regurgitation, there were good correlations between Doppler and left ventricular measurements of stroke volume, regurgitant volume, and regurgitant fraction (r = 0.97, r = 0.95, and r = 0.93, respectively; p < 0.0001). In patients with mitral regurgitation, despite good correlations between Doppler and ventricular methods for stroke volume, regurgitant volume, and regurgitant fraction (r = 0.94, r = 0.93, and r = 0.94, respectively; p < 0.001), these variables were overestimated by Doppler. However, in the last 54 patients compared with the first 27, overestimation decreased significantly for regurgitant volume (5 +/- 10 mL versus 18 +/- 27 mL, p < 0.05) and regurgitant fraction (3.3 +/- 6.7% versus 6.2 +/- 6.8%, p = 0.05). CONCLUSIONS Quantitative Doppler can be performed in large numbers of patients in a clinical laboratory. Its potential limitation was identified as overestimation of mitral regurgitation, which is overcome with increased experience. Its achieved accuracy in mitral and aortic regurgitation allows measurement not only of regurgitant fraction but most importantly of regurgitant volume.

Background— Mitral regurgitation (MR) of mitral valve prolapse predominates in late systole but may be holosystolic or purely mid-late systolic, but the impact of MR timing on MR left ventricular and left atrial consequences and outcome is unknown. Whether effective regurgitant orifice (ERO) by the flow convergence method is similarly linked to outcome in mid-late systolic MR and holosystolic MR is uncertain. Methods and Results— We comprehensively and prospectively quantified MR in 111 patients with mitral valve prolapse and mid-late systolic MR and matched them to 90 patients with mitral valve prolapse and holosystolic MR for age, gender, atrial fibrillation, ejection fraction, and ERO (flow convergence). Mid-late systolic MR versus holosystolic MR groups were well matched, including for comorbidity, blood pressure, and heart rate (all P >0.10). Mid-late systolic MR versus holosystolic MR caused similar color jet area, midsystolic regurgitant flow, and peak velocity ( P >0.40). Despite identical ERO (0.25±0.15 versus 0.25±0.15 cm 2 ; P =0.53), the shorter duration of mid-late systolic MR (233±56 versus 426±50 ms; P <0.0001) yielded lower regurgitant volume (24.8±13.4 versus 48.6±25.6 mL; P <0.0001). MR consequences, systolic pulmonary pressure, and left ventricular and left atrial volume index (all P <0.001) were more benign in mid-late systolic MR versus holosystolic MR. Under medical management, fewer cardiac events (5 years: 15.8±4.6% versus 40.4±6.1%; P <0.0001) occurred in mid-late systolic MR versus holosystolic MR, requiring less mitral surgery. Multivariable analysis confirmed the independent association of mid-late systolic MR with benign consequences and outcomes (all P <0.01). Absolute ERO was not linked to outcome, in contrast to regurgitant volume. Conclusions— MR of mitral valve prolapse that is purely mid-late systolic causes more benign consequences and outcomes than holosystolic MR. Assessment may be misleading because jet area and ERO by flow convergence appear similar to those of holosystolic MR. However, shorter MR yields lower regurgitant volume, consequences, and benign outcomes. Instantaneous ERO by flow convergence should be interpreted in context, and in mid-late systolic MR, regurgitant volume provides information more reflective of MR severity. Therefore, for clinical management and surgical referral, clinicians should carefully take into account the timing and consequences of MR.

Background— Left atrium (LA) enlargement is common in organic mitral regurgitation (MR) and is an emerging prognostic indicator. However, outcome implications of LA enlargement have not been analyzed in the context of routine clinical practice and in a multicenter study. Methods and Results— The Mitral Regurgitation International DAtabase (MIDA) registry enrolls patients with organic MR due to flail leaflets, diagnosed in routine clinical practice, in 5 US and European centers. We investigated the relation between LA diameter and mortality under medical treatment and after mitral surgery in 788 patients in sinus rhythm (64±12 years; median LA, 48 [43 to 52] mm). LA diameter was independently associated with survival after diagnosis (hazard ratio, 1.08 [1.04 to 1.12] per 1 mm increment). Compared with patients with LA <55 mm, those with LA ≥55 mm had lower 8-year overall survival ( P <0.001). LA ≥55 mm independently predicted overall mortality (hazard ratio, 3.67 [1.95 to 6.88]) and cardiac mortality (hazard ratio, 3.74 [1.72 to 8.13]) under medical treatment. The association of LA ≥55 mm and mortality was consistent in subgroups. Similar excess mortality associated with LA ≥55 mm was observed in asymptomatic and symptomatic patients ( P for interaction, 0.77). In patients who underwent mitral surgery, LA ≥55 mm had no impact on postoperative outcome ( P >0.20). Mitral surgery was associated with greater survival benefit in patients with LA ≥55 mm compared with LA <55 mm ( P for interaction, 0.008). Conclusions— In MR caused by flail leaflets, LA diameter ≥55 mm is associated with increased mortality under medical treatment, independent of the presence of symptoms or left ventricular dysfunction.

Background— Preoperative factors associated with increased mortality and worse outcome after tricuspid valve replacement in patients with severe tricuspid regurgitation are poorly understood. Methods and Results— We retrospectively analyzed 189 patients (37% men; age, 67.5±11.3 years) who underwent tricuspid valve replacement for severe tricuspid regurgitation. Operative mortality rate was 10%, and was associated with intra-aortic balloon pump (odds ratio, 3.2; 95% confidence interval, 1.9 to 5.6; P <0.0001) or the presence of severe symptoms (New York Heart Association class IV relative to classes II and/or III) at the time of surgery (1.7; 95% confidence interval, 1.05 to 2.8; P =0.02). At the end of follow-up (29.3±27.1 months), 70 patients (37%) died, 6 (3%) needed tricuspid reoperation, and 41 (21.7%) were readmitted for heart failure. Seventy-eight patients (41.3%) were free from cardiovascular events (death, tricuspid reoperation, or heart failure admissions). The only echocardiographic parameter independently associated with adverse outcomes was a decrease in the right index of myocardial performance ratio. All-cause mortality was independently associated with a higher Charlson index (hazard ratio, 1.18; 95% confidence interval, 1.01 to 1.36; P =0.03), shorter right index of myocardial performance ratio (0.91; 95% confidence interval, 0.87 to 0.96; P =0.005), and preoperative New York Heart Association IV class (1.71; 95% confidence interval, 1.3 to 2.2; P <0.0001). In 68 patients with isolated tricuspid valve replacement, the associations between short right index of myocardial performance ratio, high Charlson index, New York Heart Association class IV, and increased mortality remained significant. Conclusions— Tricuspid valve replacement for severe tricuspid regurgitation can be performed with an acceptable operative mortality if patients undergo surgery before the onset of advanced heart failure symptoms. Late mortality is associated with a high preoperative Charlson index, short right index of myocardial performance ratio, and advanced New York Heart Association class.