Objective To evaluate the efficacy of cytokine‐directed therapies in VEXAS (vacuoles, E1 enzyme, X‐linked, autoinflammatory somatic) syndrome using previously proposed treatment response criteria. Methods All patients with genetically confirmed VEXAS syndrome who received targeted therapies with JAK inhibitors (JAKi), tumor necrosis factor α inhibitors (TNFαi), or interleukin‐1 (IL‐1) or IL‐6 inhibitors were identified. Clinical and biochemical data were recorded for patients at time of targeted therapy initiation, and at 3‐, 6‐, and 12‐month follow‐up time points. Treatment response was labeled as complete response (CR; normalization of C‐reactive protein [CRP], prednisone <10 mg/day, and resolution of disease activity), partial response (PR; >50% improvement in CRP, >50% prednisone dose reduction, improvement or resolution of disease features), treatment failure (TF; worsening CRP, increasing prednisone, worsening of disease features), or no response (not meeting criteria for CR, PR, or TF). Results Overall, 52 patients received an IL‐1i, IL‐6i, or JAKi therapy. At six‐month follow‐up, 3 of 19 IL‐6i patients experienced CR, 4 of 19 experienced PR, and 7 of 19 experienced TF. 2 of 17 patients receiving JAKi experienced CR, 3 of 17 experienced PR, and 6 of 17 experienced TF. No patients receiving IL‐1i or TNFαi experienced CR, and only 1 of 5 IL‐1i patients experienced PR. Among those still receiving biologic therapy at 12 months, only 1 of 11 receiving IL‐6i and 0 of 7 receiving JAKi experienced CR. Conclusion IL‐6i and JAKi therapies demonstrated limited, unsustained efficacy for management of VEXAS syndrome. IL‐1i and TNFαi therapies were not efficacious. Useful application of previously reported treatment response criteria was demonstrated, but future incorporation of hematologic parameters may be beneficial.
Interplay between mutant DNMT3A and UBA1 worsens survival through altered inflammatory and metabolic pathways
Abstract Introduction: VEXAS (vacuoles, E1 enzyme, X-linked, autoinflammatory, somatic) is an adult-onset autoinflammatory disorder defined by somatic UBA1 mutations in hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs). Given the higher median age at onset and prevalent inflammation, approximately 60% of patients have concurrent clonal hematopoiesis (CH) involving epigenetic regulators, DNMT3A and TET2. We have previously demonstrated (Gutierrez-Rodrigues, Blood 2023) that DNMT3A and TET2 mutations in VEXAS are independently associated with increased mortality, without an increased risk of myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) or acute myeloid leukemia (AML). To define the role of CH in VEXAS, we investigated the impact of CH on mortality and related epigenetic dysregulation in primary VEXAS patient samples and validated these findings using an adenine base-editing (ABE) strategy to model cooccurring UBA1 and DNMT3A mutations in CD34+ HSCs. Methods: After IRB approval, 114 VEXAS patients from the Mayo Clinic and the NIH were retrospectively assessed, including 104 screened for CH by error-corrected DNA sequencing (ECS). DNA methylation changes were identified using the Illumina Infinium MethylationEPIC BeadChip and genome-wide using Biomodal 6-base sequencing on peripheral blood samples (PB). Cellular indexing of transcriptomes and epitopes (CITE)-seq was performed using the 10x Chromium 3' GEX platform; 21,114 pooled cells were subjected to UMAP dimensionality reduction, followed by Azimuth based cell identification. HSCs from different donors were base edited for UBA1 M41T mutation with and without cooccurring DNMT3A splice-site mutations. Levels of cytokines in cell culture supernatants were measured using Olink technology, transcriptomic changes were assessed using bulk RNA-seq. Statistical analyses were carried out using R. Results: Patients' median age was 68 (62-74) years; 95% were white and 99% were males. 39% had a pathogenic CH variant, with DNMT3A (18%; median VAF: 42%; range 6-46%) and TET2 (11.5%; median VAF: 11%; range: 2-37%) being most common (2% had both). While the presence of any CH mutation did not impact survival (7.7 vs 11.5yrs, p =0.69), DNMT3Amt CH had an age-independent negative impact on mortality (9.2 vs 5.6yrs, p=0.02), without an increased risk of MDS/AML (p=0.31). Changes in DNA methylation were profiled using the methylation array in 19 VEXAS patients without CH (Median Age: 68 years) and in 9 with DNMT3Amt CH (Median Age: 74 years), respectively. VEXAS samples with DNMT3Amt CH displayed a hypomethylation phenotype compared to VEXAS samples with no CH, with 4,096 unique hypomethylated CpGs, occurring mainly at gene enhancers (Enh) and transcriptional states (Tx, TxWk). This loss of DNA methylation was enriched in inflammatory pathways with extensive hypomethylation observed in the promoters and gene bodies of IL-1 family genes. CITE-seq performed on 7 VEXAS samples (4 DNMT3Amt CH vs 3 no CH) demonstrated an upregulation of gene expression predominantly in T-cell subsets. This increased expression was enriched in inflammatory genes, largely centered around IL-1 and IL-18 family signaling. Pathway analysis revealed an enrichment in respiratory electron transport and oxidative phosphorylation (oxphos), with the VEXAS samples with DNMT3Amt CH demonstrating significantly increased oxphos gene signatures. Base editing of CD34+ cells was done using an adenine base-editing (ABE) strategy to model dual UBA1 and DNMT3A splice-site mutations. We observed that the HSCs base edited for the UBA1 M41T recapitulated the cellular hallmarks of VEXAS demonstrating reduced ubiquitination, unfolded protein response (UPR) activation, and increased inflammation. The addition of cooccurring DNMT3A mutations resulted in decreased DNMT3A expression, further increasing inflammatory markers, confirming altered inflammatory and metabolic pathways. Conclusion Our study validates the age-independent, negative prognostic impact of DNMT3Amt CH on survival in VEXAS syndrome. DNMT3A mutations mediate epigenetic and transcriptional priming associated with upregulation of inflammatory and mitochondrial function pathways. These findings have been validated in a base edited cell model with UBA1 and DNMT3A co-mutations.
DNMT3A
Mutant Clonal Hematopoiesis in Vexas Syndrome Epigenetically Potentiates IL-13 and IL-15 Inflammatory Pathways and Is Associated with Increased Mortality
Introduction: VEXAS (vacuoles, E1 enzyme, X-linked, autoinflammatory, somatic) is an adult-onset autoinflammatory disorder defined by somatic UBA1 mutations in hematopoietic cells. VEXAS is associated with a high frequency of clonal hematopoiesis (CH- 60%); with the clonal landscape being dominated by DNMT3A mutations. In our prior study (Gutierrez-Rodrigues Blood 2023), we showed that DNMT3A mutations in VEXAS associated with increased mortality, but without a higher risk of MDS/AML. As DNMT3A is a critical epigenetic regulator, we conducted this study to define the epigenetic deregulation and impact on mortality of DNMT3Amt (mutant) CH in VEXAS. Methods: After IRB approval, 88 VEXAS patients from the Mayo Clinic and the NIH were retrospectively assessed, including 81 screened for CH by error-corrected DNA sequencing (ECS). DNA methylation changes were identified using the Illumina Infinium MethylationEPIC BeadChip on peripheral blood samples (PB). Cellular indexing of transcriptomes and epitopes (CITE)-seq was performed using the 10x Chromium 3' GEX platform; 16,600 pooled cells were subjected to UMAP dimensionality reduction, followed by Azimuth based cell identification. Genotyping of targeted loci with chromatin accessibility (GoTChA) was conducted on two PB DNMT3Amt samples from CCUS individuals (Izzo et al Nature 2024). Results: Patients' median age was 70 years (range: 56 - 89); 95% were white. Twelve out of 81 patients screened by ECS were found with a DNMT3Amt (15%), with a median variant allele fraction (VAF) of 42% (range: 6-46%). In this cohort, while the presence of any CH mutation did not impact survival, DNMT3Amt CH had an age-independent negative impact on mortality (5.5 years vs 8.7 years, p =0.005), without an increase in risk for MDS/AML. Changes in DNA methylation were profiled in 19 and 9 VEXAS patients without CH (Median Age: 68) or with DNMT3Amt CH (Median Age: 74), respectively. VEXAS samples with DNMT3Amt CH had >4,000 differentially methylated CpGs with 95% of the CpGs being hypomethylated compared to those without CH. Using the Roadmap Epigenomics project, we found that this hypomethylation was enriched at enhancer (Enh) sites and actively transcribed states (TxWk). Pathway analysis revealed that the hypomethylated sites were in or near genes involved in the development and differentiation of leukocytes, with IL-13 and IL-15 being identified as upstream regulators of the methylation changes. Bulk RNA-seq performed on PB of 2 and 3 VEXAS patients with and without DNMT3Amt, respectively, identified >1,500 differentially expressed genes in DNMT3Amt samples, 78% of these being overexpressed. Pathway analysis was enriched in gene pathways involved in the development of leukocytes, with IL-13 and IL-15 once again being identified as upstream regulators. Integration of methylation and transcriptomic data identified upregulation of several genes within the IL-13 and IL-15 pathways, with these regions correlating with a decrease in methylation. To assess if the epigenetic dysregulation is linked to DNMT3A mutations, we performed GoTChA-seq on two DNMT3Amt clonal cytopenia samples (CCUS). The comparison of the number of cutsites in DNMT3A wild type vs mt cells from the same individual demonstrated increased open chromatin within the IL-13 and IL-15 pathways in mt cells, both globally and in a genomic locus specific manner. CITE-seq performed on 3 VEXAS samples (2 DNMT3Amt CH vs 1 no CH) further showed that expression of genes involved in IL-13 and IL-15 pathway is significantly increased in CD4+ and CD8+ T cells from DNMT3Amt samples, suggesting a paracrine regulatory effect of T lymphocytes (mostly UBA1 and DNMT3A wild-type) in VEXAS. Pathway analysis of DEGs in these cells also revealed an enrichment of genes involved in inflammation and lymphocyte proliferation. Conclusions: Our study validates the age-independent, negative prognostic impact of DNMT3Amt CH on survival in VEXAS syndrome. DNMT3Amt mediates epigenetic and transcriptional priming associated with upregulation of IL-13/15 pathway in CD4/CD8 T cells, which are mostly DNMT3A and UBA1 wild-type, suggesting that the contribution of T lymphocytes to inflammation may be secondary to CH in the myeloid compartment.
Age and Comorbidities May Affect the Relationship Between Pulse Pressure and Adverse Outcomes
Abstract Objectives To define the prevalence, distribution and characteristics of patients with VEXAS (vacuoles, E1-enzyme, X-linked, autoinflammation, somatic) syndrome who have confirmed vasculitis. Methods Patients with VEXAS syndrome, verified by positive UBA1 mutation, were included. Chart review was performed to identify patient characteristics and outcomes. Vasculitis diagnosis was based on either histopathology showing vascular inflammation or non-invasive angiography findings. Summary statistics were calculated. Results Eighty-nine patients met inclusion criteria. All were male with a median age of onset of 66.9 years (interquartile range 60.1, 72.7). Median (interquartile range) follow-up was 3.8 (2.2–5.5) years, during which 21 patients (23.6%) had evidence of vasculitis. Vasculitis subtypes included small vessel vasculitis (19.1%), cutaneous medium vessel vasculitis (2.2%) and large vessel vasculitis (2.2%). No patient had more than one vessel size involved. Histopathology in small vessel vasculitis patients was consistent with cutaneous leukocytoclastic vasculitis in the majority, though one patient had leukocytoclastic peritubular capillaritis on renal biopsy. Cranial symptoms (headache, vision changes or jaw pain) were noted in 18.0%. Two additional patients not experiencing cranial symptoms exhibited large vessel involvement with confirmed carotid thickening on non-invasive angiography; one of these had a positive temporal artery biopsy. Conclusion VEXAS syndrome manifests as a variable vessel vasculitis in a quarter of patients, with cutaneous small and medium vessel involvement being particularly common. Some patients may have positive ANCA serologies or even renal vasculitis leading to misdiagnosis. Cranial symptoms are common and may mimic GCA, though documented large vessel inflammation is rare.
Acute kidney injury, an underrecognized feature of VEXAS syndrome
Abstract Objectives Vacuoles, E1 enzyme, X-linked, Autoinflammatory, Somatic (VEXAS) syndrome is an autoinflammatory disease caused by somatic mutation of UBA1 and affects multiple organ systems. Involvement of the kidneys is not well characterized. We aimed to investigate the incidence, risk factors and histopathologic features of acute kidney injury (AKI) in VEXAS syndrome. Methods Patients with genetically confirmed UBA1 mutation consistent with VEXAS were included. Charts were manually reviewed. Cox regression analysis was used to identify variables associated with time-to-first AKI event. For patients with a kidney biopsy, histopathologic findings were reviewed. Results Eighty-one patients were included, all white men, with a mean age of 66.3 ± 8.6 years. Median (IQR) follow up was 3.5 (2.1–5.2) years during which 20 (25%) developed AKI and 22% died. AKI relapsed in 90% of cases for a median of 6 times during the follow up period. Cumulative incidence estimates (95% CI) for AKI at 1, 3 and 5 years were 6.2% (0.80–11.3%), 16.7% (7.5–25.0%) and 27.9% (14.9–38.9%), respectively. Age and baseline C-reactive protein (CRP) were significantly associated with time-to-first AKI event. Six patients underwent a kidney biopsy. Findings included, plasma cell-rich interstitial nephritis (n = 3), neutrophilic-rich interstitial inflammation (n = 1), leukocytoclastic peritubular capillaritis (n = 1) and acute tubular injury (n = 1). AKI responded well to treatment with glucocorticoids but had relapse upon tapering. Conclusion AKI is an underrecognized feature of VEXAS occurring in 25% of patients in this cohort. Age at diagnosis and CRP were associated with time to first AKI event during follow up. Plasma cell-rich interstitial nephritis was the most common histopathologic finding.
Assessing Tubular Function, an Ignored Component of CKD, Might Be a Difference Maker!