Convergent and criterion validity of a computer adaptive self‐administered word list memory test and the Mayo Test Drive composite: correlations with traditional measures and group difference by PET imaging biomarker status in persons without dementia.
AbstractBackgroundMayo Test Drive (MTD): Test Development through Rapid Iteration, Validation and Expansion, is a web‐based platform optimized for remote self‐administered assessment that includes a computer adaptive word list memory test (Stricker Learning Span; SLS) and a measure of processing speed (Symbols Test). Study aims were to determine 1) convergent validity of MTD through correlations with in‐person neuropsychological measures and 2) criterion validity of MTD by qualitatively comparing the ability of Mayo Test Drive and in‐person administered neuropsychological measures to differentiate biomarker‐defined groups, independent of clinical diagnosis.MethodsMayo Clinic Study of Aging participants (N = 282) completed a brief remote cognitive assessment (mean age = 74, SD = 12; 262 CU and 20 MCI per consensus conference diagnosis; see Table 1). A subset of participants had brain amyloid and/or brain tau PET scans available within 3 years; overlapping groups were formed for 1) those on the Alzheimer’s disease (AD) continuum (A+, n = 31) or not (A‐, n = 57) and for 2) those with biological AD (A+T+, n = 19) or without any AD biomarkers (A‐T‐, n = 47). Primary outcome variables were SLS sum of trials, AVLT sum of trials, SYM Correct Trials response time, Digit Symbol Coding, MTD composite and Mayo‐PACC (AVLT sum of trials, Trails B, animals). Bivariate correlations were performed across all participants. Linear model ANOVAs were used to investigate biomarker subgroup differences; Hedge’s g effect sizes are reported.ResultsConvergent validity was supported through significant correlation (p’s < .001) of SLS and AVLT (r = .63), SYM and Coding (r = ‐.64), and MTD composite with Mayo‐PACC (r = .67); see Table 2. MTD subtests showed expected relationships with age and education (p’s < .05; Table 3). All MTD performances were significantly lower for A+ and A+T+ participants relative to A‐ or A‐T‐ (p’s<.001; Table 4). All MTD outcome measures showed a similar or greater group difference effect size relative to traditional in‐person administered neuropsychological measures for separating A+ vs. A‐ and A+T+ vs. A‐T‐ groups. See Figure 1 and Table 4.ConclusionsMTD subtests show evidence of convergent validity through strong correlations with traditional in‐person cognitive measures. Preliminary analyses suggest MTD has promise for differentiating PET biomarker groups.
Characterization of CDR® plus NACC FTLD at Phenoconversion from Asymptomatic to Mild Behavioral and/or Cognitive Impairment in Familial Frontotemporal Lobar Degeneration: Data from the ALLFTD Consortium
AbstractBackgroundThe three most common genes responsible for the familial Frontotemporal Lobar Degeneration (f‐FTLD) are MAPT, GRN, and C9orf72, with the C9orf72 mutation being the most common cause of f‐FTLD. The ALLFTD Consortium targets to characterize f‐FTLD, including its preclinical stage, to prepare for clinical trials in FTLD. We sought to investigate the initial symptoms and clinical picture of f‐FTLD and compare them among the common pathogenic genes using longitudinal CDR® plus NACC FTLD.MethodWe longitudinally assessed the CDR® plus NACC FTLD among 292 asymptomatic participants of the ALLFTD Consortium who are family members of f‐FTLD caused by MAPT (n = 99), GRN (n = 67), or C9orf72 (n = 126) mutations, and described the detailed profiles of the CDR® plus NACC FTLD in the participants who developed Mild Behavioral and/or Cognitive Impairment (MBCI).ResultForty‐one participants (17 MAPT, 11 GRN, 13 C9orf72) developed MBCI during follow‐up visits . Age at the diagnosis of MBCI was 52.3±13.0 years (GRN 63.2±11.8, MAPT 43.5±8.6, C9orf72 54.7±10.7). Frequencies of abnormal rating on the eight CDR® plus NACC FTLD domains at the time of MBCI diagnosis were: “Memory” 44% (MAPT 47%, GRN 55%, C9orf72 31%); “Orientation” 7% (MAPT 6%, GRN 9%, C9orf72 8%); “Judgment and Problem Solving” 39% (MAPT 41%, GRN 55%, C9orf72 23%); “Community Affairs” 22% (MAPT 24%, GRN 18%, C9orf72 23%); “Home and Hobbies” 22% (MAPT 35%, GRN 0%, C9orf72 23%); “Personal Care” 0%; “Behavior/Comportment/Personality” 51% (MAPT 59%, GRN 55%, C9orf72 38%); “Language” 29% (MAPT 18%, GRN 55%, C9orf72 23%).ConclusionInitial symptoms and clinical picture of f‐FTLD in MBCI stage differ among responsible FTLD genes, which could be useful in detecting very early features of f‐FTLD in pathogenic mutation carriers.
Diagnostic accuracy of the Stricker Learning Span and Mayo Test Drive Composite for amnestic Mild Cognitive Impairment.
AbstractBackgroundRemote assessment tools offer significant promise for aiding early detection of cognitive impairment. Mayo Test Drive (MTD): Test Development through Rapid Iteration, Validation and Expansion, is a web‐based platform for remote self‐administered assessment that includes a computer adaptive word list memory test (Stricker Learning Span; SLS) and a measure of processing speed (Symbols Test). We examined the diagnostic accuracy of the SLS and a MTD composite (SLS max span, SLS trials 1–5 total correct, SLS delay correct, [Symbols correct item response time*‐1]) for amnestic mild cognitive impairment (aMCI). We also explored diagnostic accuracy for a broader group that included individuals with possible MCI (pMCI; see Figure 1).MethodsParticipants were recruited from the Mayo Clinic Study of Aging for this ancillary remote study. 226 were cognitively unimpaired (CU; concordant CU diagnosis by 3 independent raters). Fifty‐six participants had possible MCI (at least 1 of 3 raters indicated MCI) and 16 had a consensus diagnosis of aMCI. Primary outcome variables were SLS sum of trials, AVLT sum of trials, Symbols correct items response time, and MTD composite. Mean difference analyses used linear model ANOVAs (alpha = .05). Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were applied; we derived optimal cutoff scores based on the Youden index method.ResultsBoth aMCI and possible MCI groups showed significantly lower performance than the CU group on SLS (Hedge’s g aMCI = ‐1.72, pMCI = ‐1.04), Symbols (Hedge’s g aMCI = 1.38, pMCI = 0.64), and MTD composite (Hedge’s g aMCI = ‐1.89, pMCI = ‐1.09); see Tables 1 and 2 (all p‘s<.01 even when additionally covarying age, education, sex). Total area under the curve was high for differentiating of CU vs. aMCI (MTD Composite = 0.91, SLS = 0.91) and acceptable for CU vs. pMCI (MTD Composite = 0.77, SLS = 0.77); see Table 2. Consistent with our flexible platform, a variety of device types were used to complete remote testing (32% smartphone, 12% tablet, 56% PC).ConclusionsMTD and the SLS show high diagnostic accuracy for aMCI. MTD is a flexible, brief, and easy‐to‐use remote cognitive assessment tool with great potential for scalable use in future studies seeking to maximize inclusion of individuals with aMCI in clinical trials or for cognitive screening in clinical settings.
An examination of the usability of the Mayo Test Drive remote cognitive testing platform in older adults with and without cognitive impairment
AbstractBackgroundMayo Test Drive (MTD): Test Development through Rapid Iteration, Validation and Expansion, is a web‐based platform for self‐administered assessment for novel (Stricker Learning Span) and open access (Symbols Test) cognitive measures with previously demonstrated validity and reliability. Our study aim was to examine the usability of MTD, defined as the extent to which MTD was used to achieve the desired study goal of completing a testing session among participants willing to engage in an all‐remote study.Methods248 Mayo Clinic Study of Aging and Mayo Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center participants were invited to participate in this ancillary, uncompensated remote pilot study via email. To examine 1) willingness to participate in a remote cognitive assessment study and 2) usability of MTD, the initiation and completion rates of MTD were examined by cognitively unimpaired (CU; n = 142) and cognitively impaired (CI; n = 106) groups (see Figure 1). These rates and other factors associated with MTD feasibility were further explored across age in CU (i.e., 50–69, 70–79, and 80+ years) and specific diagnostic groups in CI (i.e., individuals with dementia, mild cognitive impairment (MCI), and possible MCI).ResultsSession completion rate (usability) was 98% across all participants who chose to participate, and, surprisingly, completion rates did not vary by age or diagnostic groups (p = .69; see Table 1). As expected, more individuals chose to participate in the CU (77%) versus CI (52%) group (p < .001). In terms of feasibility, individuals over 80 and with CI were more likely to have some contact with the study coordinator. Use of smartphones decreased with age, with most CU individuals over 70 using a personal computer (69‐73%; Table 2).ConclusionsThough the CI group was less likely to choose to participate than the CU group, out of those that did choose to participate the rate of completion was 98%. This demonstrates high usability of MTD. Study coordinator support and a flexible testing platform is critical for facilitating participation in remote testing across the aging population, and more supports and incentives may be needed for individuals with cognitive impairment to improve participation rates.
Contributions of remote, unsupervised dyadic subjective measures to identify older adults with Mild Cognitive Impairment
AbstractBackgroundDyadic (self and study partner) subjective reports of an individual’s recent cognitive and functional decline are an efficient approach to facilitate identification of older adults with, and at risk for, Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI). Such methods can be easily adapted for remote administration, but few studies have investigated the ability of remotely‐collected, unsupervised dyadic subjective reports to accurately detect MCI and cognitive decline.MethodsIn 289 older adults enrolled in the Brain health Registry (BHR), with clinically‐confirmed diagnoses of Cognitively‐unimpaired (CU) or MCI, we identified the optimal combination of remote measures to accurately distinguish CU from MCI. We then externally validated our predictive model in 217 participants enrolled in a separate cohort, Validation of Online Methods to Predict Cognitive Decline (eVAL). Predictors included Cogstate Brief Battery One Card Learning (OCL) accuracy; self‐ and study partner‐reported memory concern (SMCs); performance on online adaptations of Everyday Cognition Scale (ECog, self‐ and study partner‐report versions), Geriatric Depression Scale Short Form (GDS); family history of AD, age, gender, and education. We calculated 10‐fold cross validated area under the ROC curves (cvAUC), 95% confidence intervals (CI), and the percentage of participants correctly classified (accuracy) for all models. Likelihood ratio (LR) tests were used to compare model fits.ResultsIn the BHR cohort, models including dyad‐report ECog, family history of AD, GDS, and Cogstate OCL scores distinguished CU from MCI with the highest accuracy (cvAUC = 0.90; 95% CI = 0.83, 0.92; accuracy = 85.5%). Models excluding study partner‐report ECog distinguished diagnostic groups with moderate accuracy (cvAUC = 0.83; 95% CI = 0.78, 0.85; accuracy = 75.9%) When applied to the validation cohort, the optimal training model including dyadic report performed with moderate accuracy ( Table 2 ). In the validation cohort, inclusion of study partner (but not self) report SMC, in addition to dyadic‐report ECog, improved model fit (LR test p<0.01).ConclusionsRemotely‐collected dyadic subjective measures, along with other remote measures, accurately distinguish CU from MCI. Subjective cognitive and functional decline and concerns about memory problems independently contribute to diagnostic discrimination. Results support future utilization of remote dyadic subjective measures to efficiently identify older adults with MCI for prodromal AD clinical trials, and in clinical care settings.
Gait Correlates of Cognitive Function and Future Decline
AbstractBackgroundSlow walking speed is associated with numerous negative health outcomes including global cognitive decline.1 More detailed gait analysis can differentiate among different dementia subtypes,10 but the predictive power of baseline gait metrics for domain‐specific cognitive decline needs further characterization.MethodWe conducted a follow up study on 534 participants of the Mayo Clinic Study of Aging who underwent evaluations every 15 months (median follow‐up = 5.4 years). We analyzed quantitative gait metrics, acquired with a pressure‐sensing walkway (GAITRite® instrument), and cognitive scores using a linear mixed effects model to identify correlations between z‐scored baseline gait metrics (cadence, swing time, stance time, velocity, double support time (DST), stride length, stride length standard deviation (SD), stride time SD, swing time SD, stance time SD, DST SD) and cognitive domain z‐scores (memory, attention, language, visuospatial, global) at baseline and over time. Models controlled for age, sex, and probable REM sleep behavior disorder at baseline.ResultThe table includes both baseline associations and difference in slopes (Δ), relative to the average person, in cognitive domains. These slopes ranged from about ‐0.05 for visuospatial to ‐0.12 for attention.ConclusionIncreased gait velocity and stride length are associated with less severe domain‐specific and global cognitive decline while increased swing time SD and DST are associated with more severe rates of decline in some domains. These findings suggest that baseline gait characteristics could be a helpful predictor of future cognitive changes.References:1. Savica R, Wennberg AMV, Hagen C, et al. Comparison of Gait Parameters for Predicting Cognitive Decline: The Mayo Clinic Study of Aging. Journal of Alzheimer's disease : JAD. 2017;55(2):559. doi:10.3233/JAD‐1606972. Mc Ardle R, del Din S, Galna B, Thomas A, Rochester L. Differentiating dementia disease subtypes with gait analysis: feasibility of wearable sensors? Gait & Posture. 2020;76:372–376. doi:10.1016/j.gaitpost.2019.12.028
Brain region‐specific metabolic signatures of Alzheimer’s disease
AbstractBackgroundMetabolic dysregulation is one of the hallmarks of Alzheimer’s disease (AD). Alterations in metabolism have been associated with AD‐related comorbidities, cognitive decline, and AD brain pathology. Brain regions are differentially affected with AD neuropathology and exhibit metabolic heterogeneity. Therefore, to build a more comprehensive picture of metabolic impact of AD, region‐specific AD‐associated metabolic changes need to be determined.MethodWe profiled 344 brain samples from the Mayo Clinic brain bank using Metabolon’s untargeted metabolomics platform, covering 182 samples from the cerebellum (CER) and 162 samples from the temporal cortex (TCX). Generalized linear models were used to assess the association of metabolic profiles with AD. Models included confounder correction for age at death, sex, and number of APOE‐ε4 alleles. To extend this study to four more brain regions, we included results from previously published brain metabolomics studies based on samples from three independent cohorts, including dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) from ROS/MAP, parietal lobe (PTL) from Washington University School of Medicine (WUSM), inferior temporal gyrus (ITG) and middle frontal gyrus (MFG) from Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging (BLSA).ResultIn the Mayo cohort, a total of 190 out of the 658 metabolites were significantly associated with AD. Out of the 190, 127 metabolites associated only in the CER region, 37 metabolites associated only in the TCX region, and 26 metabolites were associated in both brain regions. There were no metabolites commonly regulated in all the 6 brain regions under investigation. DLPFC and CER had the highest overlap of 70 metabolites, followed by DLPFC and PTL with 64 metabolites, and CER and PTL with 47 metabolites. For functional interpretation of our findings, each metabolite was further categorized with a sub‐pathway annotation provided by Metabolon. 3 of the 88 pathways including methionine cycle, phospholipid metabolism, and glutathione metabolism, were commonly regulated in the six brain regions under investigation.ConclusionWe present a first global perspective on AD‐associated metabolic alterations across six brain regions. This study will pave the way to fill the gap in our understanding of region‐specific metabolic deregulations associated with AD pathophysiology.
The coarse‐grained plaque is an Aβ plaque‐type in APOE Ɛ4+ Alzheimer’s disease that is associated with astrogliosis and p‐tau burden
AbstractBackgroundThe coarse‐grained plaque (CGP) is a divergent plaque‐type recently described in Alzheimer’s disease (AD)1. In the current study, we studied the CGPs distribution over the brain, and its association with APOE, p‐tau, and neuroinflammation.MethodThe cohort (N = 60) was selected from the Mayo Clinic brain bank in Jacksonville, USA. Brain tissue from the frontal ‐, parietal ‐, temporal cortex, and the hippocampus was immunohistochemically stained for Aβ (6F/3D), p‐tau (AT8), CD68, and GFAP. The CGP and classic cored plaque (CCP) were scored as previously described1. Total plaque burden was expressed as the sum of all cortical regions.ResultThe CGP was predominantly located in the neocortex and present in ∼60% of AD cases, who were younger at onset (p<0.05) and had a lower brain weight (p<0.05) than CGP negative cases. When stratified for APOE Ɛ4+ and Ɛ4‐, CGP burden was only in Ɛ4+ positively correlated with p‐tau, Aβ, and GFAP burden in the frontal and parietal cortex (Table 1). CGP burden was not correlated with CD68. The CCP was negatively correlated with p‐tau, and not with GFAP, Aβ or CD68 (Table 1). In APOE Ɛ4+ cases, the burden of CGPs was negatively correlated with the burden of CCPs (Fig.1).ConclusionThe neocortical CGP is correlated with increased p‐tau burden and astrogliosis in APOE Ɛ4+. The CGP is inversely correlated with the common CCP, suggesting an opposite effect of Aβ‐induced tau‐toxicity for the CGP versus the CCP. 1Boon et al., Acta Neuropathologica, 2020
TAR DNA‐binding protein 43 (TDP‐43) contributes to the mismatch between medial temporal volumes and flortaucipir uptake in elderly patients with Alzheimer’s disease neuropathologic changes
AbstractBackgroundWe previously demonstrated that Alzheimer’s disease (AD) patients ≥70 y/o tend to have smaller medial temporal volumes in the presence of relatively less medial temporal 18F‐flortaucipir‐PET uptake compared to young AD patients. TAR DNA‐binding protein 43 (TDP‐43) is frequently found in the brains of AD patients and is associated with old age and medial temporal atrophy. In this study, we aimed to determine whether TDP‐43 could be contributing to the mismatch between medial temporal volumes and flortaucipir‐PET uptake in older AD patients.MethodWe identified 77 participants (median age at death 79 years [range: 51‐99]) who had been enrolled into the Mayo Clinic Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center or Neurodegenerative Research Group (NRG), had undergone flortaucipir‐PET and volumetric MRI scans close to death, and autopsy confirmed AD neuropathological changes, as well as TDP‐43 assessments. Grey matter volumes and flortaucipir standard uptake value ratios (SUVRs) were calculated for hippocampus, amygdala, entorhinal, inferior temporal, and midfrontal cortices. We used bivariate‐response linear regression modelling, adjusting for Braak neurofibrillary tangle stage, to estimate the effect of TDP‐43 and age on gray matter volume and flortaucipir uptake, and tested whether TDP‐43 effect sizes varied according to age.ResultAfter accounting for Braak stage, older individuals tended to have significantly lower flortaucipir uptake across regions and lower hippocampal and entorhinal cortex (ERC) volumes. TDP‐43 was associated with reduced hippocampus and ERC volumes but was unrelated to flortaucipir SUVRs (Figure 1). Notably, the TDP‐43 effect size for the hippocampus and ERC was largely consistent across age, i.e., at any age, TDP‐43‐positive participants had significantly smaller hippocampal (∼12% decrease) and ERC (13% decrease) volumes than TDP‐43‐negative participants. However, at older ages, the mean volumes in the whole cohort and, more evidently, in those with dementia moved closer towards the mean of those with TDP‐43 (Figure 1), likely attributable to the increasing frequency of TDP‐43 with age.ConclusionTDP‐43 is a major contributor to the mismatch between flortaucipir uptake and medial temporal lobe volumes in older AD patients where lower medial temporal regional volumes are observed in the presence of less flortaucipir uptake.
Frequency of TAR DNA‐binding protein 43 (TDP‐43) increases linearly with age in the demented and non‐demented elderly population
AbstractBackgroundTDP‐43 is a nuclear RNA‐binding protein involved in various neurodegenerative diseases, including Alzheimer’s Disease (AD), and normal aging. It strongly affects cognition and memory loss in AD. Concomitant TDP‐43 pathology increases the likelihood of being cognitively impaired at death.MethodMayo Clinic has amassed a large database with 1072 study participants with known TDP‐43 pathology status, who were prospectively recruited and followed in the Mayo Clinic Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center, Mayo Clinic Study of Aging, and Neurodegenerative Research Group. All underwent neurologic, genetic, and neuropathologic evaluations. Amygdala sections immunostained with antibodies against TDP‐43 were screened for TDP‐43‐immunoreactive inclusions and successively staged using the Josephs staging scheme. The frequency of TDP‐43 pathology by age at death was estimated using logistic regression with age modelled using a restricted cubic spline. Models were fit for all cases including the subset of 581 cases with dementia.ResultOur cohort was predominantly White (99%) with median age at death of 87 years (IQR: 80‐92) and relatively even sex distribution (52% female). About 55% had Braak stage V‐VI and 61% had Thal amyloid phase ≥3. Fifty‐two percent met criteria for intermediate‐high probability AD. TDP‐43‐immunoreactivity (TDP‐43+) was detected in 44% with median TDP‐43 stage of 3 (IQR: 1‐5), and in 54% with a median stage of 3 (IQR: 2‐5) in those with dementia. TDP‐43+ frequency increased approximately linearly with age at death. At 70 years at death, an estimated 30% (95% CI: 25–35) of the cohort was TDP‐43+ versus 33% (CI: 27–40) of those with dementia. By 90 years at death, 49% (CI: 45–52) of the overall cohort and 68% (CI:62‐73) of those with dementia were TDP‐43+.ConclusionThe results from our large cohort confirm that TDP‐43 pathology frequency increases in elderly White study participants with age of death, independent of cognitive status. Furthermore, TDP‐43 pathology frequency increases to a greater degree with age in those with dementia. Given the clear links between TDP‐43 and impaired cognition, the contribution of TDP‐43 to an individual’s cognitive impairment is likely to increase with age; a dynamic with significant public health consequences given our aging population.