Importance Molecular analyses of biospecimens collected from study participants are essential for identifying biomarkers that can tailor treatments to specific subsets of patients who are most likely to benefit. Sharing of data and biospecimens from clinical trials enables personalized, patient-centric use of cancer therapies and accelerates the development of new treatments. Objective To describe obstacles to sharing data and biospecimens and to propose strategies to enhance access and collaboration. Evidence Review This is a Special Communication authored by 53 academic investigators and patient representatives from the breast cancer community with extensive experience in conducting clinical and translational research. The article also evaluates the impact of biomarker research on specifying responsive subpopulations in the 29 registrational clinical trials that have led to approval of a new drug for treatment of breast cancer between 2017 and 2024. Findings Clinical trial participants are increasingly asked to provide tissue and/or body fluid biospecimens for biomarker research that is typically controlled by the sponsoring pharmaceutical company, but published biomarker studies are rare. Among 29 breast cancer registrational studies reported in the past 8 years, none resulted in biomarker research that restricted a drug’s approved indication. Herein, strategies to maximize the value of clinical data and biospecimens contributed by participants are proposed, thereby supporting the shared goals of the pharmaceutical industry and academia to improve patient care. These strategies include (1) establishing coleadership structures involving academia and patients in clinical trial design and conduct, (2) ensuring that informed consent forms state that data and biospecimens will be shared with academia for future research, (3) requiring the sharing of clinical data as a condition for regulatory approval, and (4) enabling access to biospecimens and translational research data for independent studies on biomarkers that may indicate drug efficacy and toxicity. Conclusions and Relevance Data and biospecimen sharing from registrational trials has been suboptimal. Improving clinical data, biospecimens, and biospecimens’ related data sharing requires concrete actions and a multidimensional stakeholder approach to accelerate the impact of clinical cancer research on the quality of patient care.
Longitudinal Profiling of Tumor and Immune Compartments Uncovers Patterns of Dysregulation and Associations with Response in Multiple Myeloma
Abstract Multiple myeloma is a malignancy of clonally expanded plasma cells shaped by complex interactions with the immune microenvironment (IME). To investigate immune correlates of treatment response and disease progression, we conducted multi-omics profiling including CD138neg single-cell RNA sequencing of 243 bone marrow samples from 102 patients (631,226 cells) and CD138pos bulk RNA and whole-genome sequencing from 209 samples. In longitudinal analyses, interferon-γ signaling associated with markers of impaired T-cell memory after autologous stem cell transplant, whereas naïve B-cell abundance and immunoglobulin diversity correlated with improved progression-free survival (HR = 0.48; P = 2.3e−4). At disease progression, multiple myeloma cells upregulated cancer–testis antigens (CTAg) and immune effector genes, with concurrent B-cell depletion, enrichment of myeloid-derived suppressor cell expression, and phenotypic T-cell exhaustion. These findings highlight dynamic immune–tumor interactions, identifying naïve B-cell reconstitution as a biomarker of durable response and CTAgs as potential targets for high-risk disease at progression. Significance: Longitudinal profiling of multiple myeloma and the IME revealed dynamic immune–tumor interactions across the disease course. Altered expression in CD8+ T cells limited memory phenotype after transplant, whereas naïve B-cell recovery associated with sustained treatment response. At progression, CTAg expression associated with immunosuppression, revealing novel mechanisms of immune dysregulation.
Combinations of high risk cytogenetic events in multiple myeloma drive distinct immune remodeling patterns and worse outcomes
Abstract Introduction: Multiple Myeloma (MM) is a complex hematologic malignancy, where patients often display one or more potentially high risk cytogenetic alterations associated with poor outcomes. Traditional high risk cytogenetics events in myeloma, such as NSD2 t(4;14) translocations, gain of 1q21, or deletion of 17p13, have often been studied in isolation, but emerging evidence suggests the combination of these high risk alterations has a greater negative prognostic impact than any on their own. This has been recently reflected in risk stratification guidelines from IMS and IMWG, which consider certain events, such as t(4;14), as high risk only in combination with gain of 1q21 or deletion of 1p32. Still, the mechanisms through which multi-hit high risk events disrupt the microenvironment and promote poor outcomes remains unclear. We hypothesize that myelomas with multiple high risk alterations remodel the immune environment to promote tumor progression and immune escape. Methods: To study the role of multi-hit high risk cytogenetics on the immune microenvironment, we analyzed CD138-bone marrow aspirate single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNAseq) data from 337 newly diagnosed MM patients from the MMRF CoMMpass study, generated as part of the Immune Atlas initiative. Cytogenetic alterations for these patients were derived from whole-genome and whole-exome sequencing of CD138+ bone marrow aspirates from the MMRF CoMMpass cohort. Patients were classified as multi-hit high-risk MM if they exhibited either (i) two high-risk cytogenetic events, including NSD2 t(4;14), MAF t(14;16), del(17p13), or (ii) one high-risk event with gain of 1q21. Results: Based on cytogenetic information, 33 patients in the Immune Atlas cohort were classified as 'multi-hit’ high-risk, while 34 patients had only a single high-risk alteration. These multi-hit high risk patents displayed significantly worse progression free survival compared to standard risk patients, adjusting for age, therapy, and ASCT (HR=2.34, p<7.2e-5), while single-hit patients showed a non-significant trend towards worse outcomes (HR=1.51, p=0.071). The most frequent multi-hit risk event in the cohort was NSD2 t(4;14) in combination with 1q21, observed in 23 patients. Compositional analysis of the immune populations in the scRNAseq data revealed that relative to both standard and single-hit high risk patients, multi-hit high risk patients displayed significant reductions in IFN-I stimulated CD4+ and CD8+ T cell populations, marked by decreased expression for antiviral response markers such as ISG15, XAF1, and IFI44L. Enrichment of inflammatory CD16+ non-classical monocytes was also observed. Further analysis of the most frequent multi-hit risk event, NSD2 with 1q21, revealed distinct enrichment of late-activated cytotoxic HLA+ CD8+T cells and cytotoxic CD4+.T cells. Neither alteration was observed in patients with single-hit NSD2 or 1q21. Further analysis on the interactions between high risk events revealed distinct transcriptomic profiles dependent on the high risk events involved, particularly in multi-hit events involving mutations or deletions of TP53 or gain of 1q21. Reduction in IFN-I signaling across various immune populations was primarily restricted to multi-hit risk events involving gain of 1q21. Conversely, patients with biallelic loss of TP53 displayed significant enrichment of these same IFN-I populations. Given this contrast in IFN-I signaling spanning multiple immune subtypes, we hypothesized that the malignant myeloma cells might similarly display altered IFN-I activity. Utilizing CD138+ myeloma bulk RNA sequencing data from CoMMpass, we found that IFN-I response scores strongly correlated between paired scRNA immune and bulk RNAseq tumor datasets (R2: 0.75, p=1.63e-32). Across 660 patients with bulk RNAseq and cytogenetic data, we confirmed significant reductions in IFN-I response scores in tumor cells in multi-hit high risk involving 1q21, and significant enrichment in those with complete loss of TP53 relative to standard-risk MM. Conclusions: Overall, we do observe that MM patients with multiple high risk cytogenetic alterations display distinct immunologic traits relative to standard risk or single-hit high risk patients in addition to significantly worse outcomes. Furthermore, we find variability in the immune alterations observed based on the cytogenetic events involved, further illustrating the heterogeneity in how MM shapes the immune microenvironment.
Earlier use of ciltacabtagene autoleucel (cilta-cel) is associated with better immune fitness and stronger immune effects as shown by correlative analysis of peripheral blood and the bone marrow tumor microenvironment (TME) from the CARTITUDE-4 study
Abstract Introduction: Cilta-cel is approved in the US and the EU for the treatment of patients (pts) with lenalidomide-refractory multiple myeloma (MM) after ≥1 prior line of therapy (pLOT), including a proteasome inhibitor and an immunomodulatory agent based on the CARTITUDE-1 (CART-1, NCT03548207) and CARTITUDE-4 (CART-4, NCT04181827) studies. Cilta-cel led to deep and durable responses and significant survival benefit in pts with relapsed/refractory MM (RRMM) after ≥3 pLOT in CART-1. In CART-4, cilta-cel led to a significant overall survival benefit with a higher proportion of pts achieving deep, sustained minimal residual disease negativity vs standard of care in pts with lenalidomide-refractory MM after 1–3 pLOT. We investigated the mechanism of action of cilta-cel by correlating biomarkers from peripheral blood and the bone marrow TME with progression-free survival (PFS) and number of pLOT in pts with RRMM from CART-1 and CART-4. Methods: Biomarker analyses were performed using peripheral blood and bone marrow aspirates (BMAs) collected in both CART-1 and CART-4 studies. Immunophenotyping by flow cytometry was performed using peripheral blood at baseline/time of apheresis in samples from both studies. Immune fitness at baseline was assessed in pts by pLOT and in association with PFS. Gene set enrichment scores were derived from RNA sequencing data of the TME using BMAs. Mixed-effects models were used to identify signatures/pathways modulated over time (day [D] 28 and at 6 months [mo] post infusion vs screening) and in association with PFS and pLOT. Results: In total, 176 CART-4 and 97 CART-1 pts received cilta-cel as study treatment. Immunophenotyping data were available from 248 peripheral blood samples (1 pLOT, n=56; 2 pLOT, n=61; ≥3 pLOT, n=131). At apheresis, CD4+ naïve T cells (%) were higher in pts with 1 or 2 pLOT, compared with those with ≥3 pLOT, while no difference was found in pts with ≥3 pLOT with further breakdown (i.e., 3–4 vs 5–6 vs ≥7 pLOT). Further, higher baseline levels of CD4+ naïve T cells were associated with longer PFS. These data suggest that the negative impact on peripheral immune fitness with the addition of LOT may plateau when pts have received ≥3 pLOT. TME gene expression data were available from 148 BMA samples (screening, n=50; D28, n=50; 6 mo, n=48) from CART-4. Analyses of gene expression signatures suggest depletion of B cells and antibodies at D28 post cilta-cel infusion, with partial recovery at 6 mo. This was corroborated in parallel by flow cytometry and immunoglobulin quantification. Further, elevated expression of genes associated with myeloid cells, including tumor-associated macrophages (TAM, likely M1), and of genes associated with cytotoxic T cells were also observed at D28. Elevated expression of genes associated with B-cell receptors, T-cell differentiation and activation, and cytokine signaling pathways were found at both D28 and 6 mo. Pts with longer PFS (>18 mo) had higher levels of M1 TAM at D28, while those with shorter PFS had higher levels of regulatory T cells and more suppressed interferon pathway genes at 6 mo, suggesting that relapse may be associated with a more suppressive immune response. In pts with fewer pLOT, more profound B-cell depletion on D28, better recovery at 6 mo, and elevated B-cell receptor signaling were inferred from gene expression data. Pts with 1 pLOT also demonstrated higher elevation of M1 TAM expression on D28 from screening as compared with pts with 3 pLOT, similar to what was observed in pts with longer PFS. Conclusions: Correlative biomarker data suggest that longer PFS is associated with better immune fitness at baseline and stronger immune responses post cilta-cel infusion, as observed in peripheral blood and within the TME of pts with RRMM in CART-1 and CART-4. The peripheral immune fitness was more pronounced in pts with 1 and 2 pLOT vs 3 pLOT and beyond, where deterioration plateaued. This suggests the impact of T-cell immune fitness on PFS may be limited beyond the third LOT. Importantly, other covariates, including factors within the immune TME and tumor burden, may play a significant role in balancing this compromised intrinsic T-cell immune fitness at apheresis, thereby contributing to PFS durability after 3 pLOT. Overall, these results support increased benefits in treating pts with MM with cilta-cel in earlier LOTs.
Clinical utility of ECAP dosing in a real-world population delivered via EVOKE therapy: the ECAP study
Background The efficacy of EVOKE therapy, a closed-loop spinal cord stimulation (SCS) system, has been demonstrated in a double-blinded randomized controlled trial (RCT). RCT evidence, however, may not be generalizable to clinical practice, while limitations of real-world evidence may affect its validity. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of EVOKE therapy in routine clinical practice employing a rigorous data collection approach. Methods The ECAP study was a prospective, multicenter, single-arm, pragmatic study that enrolled SCS candidates with chronic, intractable trunk and/or limb pain in 22 US investigational sites. PROMIS-29 questionnaire and objective neurophysiological metrics were collected, and minimal clinically important differences (MCIDs) were used to characterize baseline dysfunction and response to EVOKE therapy both at trial end and maximal analgesic effect post-implant visit. Pre-specified subgroup analyses were conducted based on diagnosis. Results EVOKE therapy observed included a dose ratio of 1.3 and neural dose accuracy of 2.8 μV. Improvements of >1 MCID were observed for all domains and improvements of ≥2 MCIDs were observed for six of the seven domains. Improvements observed at trial end were maintained or improved at post-implant visit, with statistically significant improvement in holistic MCID (MD 0.2, 95% CI 0.1 to 0.4, p=0.004), and a significantly greater proportion of patients considered holistic MCID responders (p=0.047). Subgroup analysis by diagnosis showed similar outcomes. Conclusions EVOKE therapy was associated with clinically meaningful improvements in a real-world chronic pain population across different subgroups and disease pathologies, with effects observed at trial end reproduced at post-implant visit.
Laboratory mice exposed naturally to multiple pathogens show profound sex- and organ-dependent immunological phenotypes 3149
Abstract Description Rationale Mice are used for models of human diseases. The immune cell composition of specific-pathogen-free (SPF) mice closely resembles that of newborn humans. Adult humans have been exposed to a multitude of pathogens throughout their lives. In this project, we sought to create a mouse model resembling humans by co-housing SPF mice to pet store mice. Methods Male and Female SPF B6 mice were co-housed with pet store mice. Multiplexed PCR was used to assess pathogen transmission. After 2 months, lungs, small intestines, and colons were analyzed by high-dimensional mass cytometry and multiplexed cytokine assay. Results Co-housed male mice frequently succumbed to infection. After two months, co-housed males still exhibited signs of active infection across all organs examined including profound myeloid and T effector cell infiltration. In female mice, infection was less fatal and active sickness resolved by two months. Across tissues, T cells exhibited both memory and effector phenotypes. Increases in monocytes and granulocytes were observed in lungs and colons while CD8+ T cells increased in the small intestine. Importantly, innate lymphoid cells were not displaced but underwent phenotypic changes. Conclusion Asynchronous systemic exposure to multiple pathogens in mice results in dramatic alterations to the immune landscape in a sex- and tissue-dependent manner. When used in disease models, these mice may provide new insight beyond those obtained previously with SPF mice. Funding Sources •NIAID R37 AL71106 Topic Categories Mucosal and Regional Immunology (MUC)
Sex-dependent responses in mice to a natural microbial environment 4174
Abstract Description Rationale Lab mice, although not germ-free, lack normal exposures to diverse commensal and environmental microorganisms. Dirty mice, as those found in the wild or in pet stores are referred to, have diverse microbiomes and history of infection with multiple pathogens; their immune systems mirror those of adult humans. It is possible to turn lab mice dirty by co-housing C57BL/6, or other genetically inbred mouse strains, with pet store mice or their dirty bedding. Due to concerns regarding aggression, dirty mouse studies typically only include female mice; if they do include male mice, they are co-housed with dirty bedding only. Methods We used divided rat cages to co-house C57BL/6J mice of both sexes for 8 weeks with either pet store mice or their dirty bedding before assessing pathogen transfer and immune profiles of brain and spleen. Results Live co-housing resulted in increased pathogen transfer and sex-dependent immune changes in brain and spleen compared to clean mice or dirty bedding alone. Co-housed males became ill later and more severely than females, showing active infection after 8 weeks while the illnesses of females had resolved. Conclusions These findings suggest that co-housing method is important in determining the changes that occur as lab mice get dirty. The sex-dependent nature of these changes suggests female-only dirty mouse studies are insufficient in representing the altered immunology of these immune-appropriate mouse models. Funding Sources Supported by Mayo Clinic Graduate School of Biomedical Sciences Topic Categories Mucosal and Regional Immunology (MUC)
Conditional ablation of MHC class I antigen presentation on microglia reduces CD8 T cell accumulation in the CNS in a novel tauopathy animal model 9099
Abstract Description Tauopathies are a subset of neurological diseases associated with pathologic tau protein accumulation and the formation of neurofibrillary tangles in the brain. There is growing evidence of immune cell infiltration including T cells and an increase of inflammatory microglia in human brains from patients that have Tauopathies. However, the effect of T cells and how they interact with CNS-resident immune cells in these pathologies is not well understood. To answer this question, we developed a neurotropic AAV1 encoding human mutant P301L-Tau. AAV-Tau transduction of neurons in neonatal mice recapitulates features of Tauopathies found in human patients. As microglia are the predominant resident antigen presenting cells within the CNS, we hypothesized that CD8 T cells may be dependent on MHC class I presentation by microglia in mice with Tauopathy to achieve full infiltration and expansion in the brain. To address this hypothesis, we introduced AAV-Tau into our novel transgenic mice for which MHC class I antigen presentation by H-2Kb on microglia can be conditional ablated. We observed lower frequencies of CD8 T cell populations and less CD8 T cell CD69+CD103+ expression in mice with Tauopathy when MHC class I was ablated in microglia. We conclude that microglia class I restricted antigen presentation contributes to the expansion of resident memory CD8 T cells in experimental Tauopathy and therefore are an important driver of the immune response observed in this dementia model. Funding Sources NIH/NINDS: R01NS122174 Mayo Graduate School of Biomedical Sciences Topic Categories Neuroimmunology (NEUR)
TMIC-113. An Alzheimer’s neuroinflammatory microenvironment resists glioblastoma immune hijacking
Abstract Glioblastoma (GBM) and Alzheimer’s disease (AD) are devastating, age associated disorders with no cure. Epidemiologic data has established an inverse comorbidity between AD and cancer, including GBM, with up to a 50% reduction of cancer incidence in AD patients. While the underlying biology remains unclear, myeloid cells, which are central players in both neurodegeneration and tumor immunity, may serve as a mechanistic link. We hypothesize that myeloid cells activated by pre-existing AD pathology suppress tumor growth more effectively than homeostatic microglia. In this study, age-matched APPNL-G-F/MAPT double knock-in (henceforth “AD”) and wildtype (WT) mice received orthotopic xenografts of syngeneic GBM cell lines (GL261, SB28) (n=15/sex/genotype). We observed a significant survival difference, with AD mice living an average of 20% longer than WT mice (p<0.0001). In vivo luciferase imaging revealed impaired engraftment of tumor cells in AD mice compared to WT a week post-engraftment (p<0.05). At the microscopic level, tumors in AD mice were found to have nearly 2-fold the amount of tumor-infiltrating myeloid cells (p<0.01), with the proportion of anti-tumoral “activated” myeloid cells also being greater (p<0.05). Tumors in AD mice were found to have markedly higher immune infiltrate at the tumor rim and margin (p<0.001). We also observed striking astrogliosis (GFAP+) and microgliosis (P2RY12+) in both the tumor rim (p<0.05) and margin (p<0.01) in AD animals. This robust glial response was significantly higher in AD mice bearing tumor compared to both WT mice bearing tumor and sham AD mice. Lastly, we utilized a luciferase stain to visualize tumor cells that invaded beyond the bulk tumor. We found that both the quantity (p<0.01) and invasion distance of tumor cells (p<0.05) was lower in AD mice. We demonstrate that an AD-induced inflammatory microenvironment antagonizes glioma growth, providing a foundation for novel GBM treatment strategies that potentially exploit these immune signals.
A Multi‐Center Retrospective Cohort Study of Neurosarcoidosis Myelitis: Current Observations and Future Directions
ABSTRACT Objective The optimal treatment for neurosarcoidosis myelitis is uncertain. We characterize incident neurosarcoidosis myelitis and assess treatment response by MRI and clinical scales. Methods Incident probable or definite neurosarcoidosis myelitis in adults was retrospectively identified from 13 academic medical centers. Cases were analyzed by initial treatment. The primary outcome was T1 post‐contrast gadolinium enhancement resolution at 6 months post‐treatment. Secondary outcomes were changes in modified Rankin scale (mRS) and Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS) from nadir to final follow‐up. Results Two hundred two patients were identified (median diagnosis age: 47 years (IQR 39–55); male: female 1.3:1). Median nadir mRS and EDSS were 2 (IQR 2–3) and 4 (IQR 2.5–6). At initial treatment, 129 (63.9%) received prolonged corticosteroids ≥ 4 weeks (group A 1 ), 36 (17.8%) received corticosteroids < 4 weeks (B 1 ), 21 (10.4%) received corticosteroids plus sarcoidosis‐directed immunosuppressant (E), and 16 (7.9%) received corticosteroids plus non‐sarcoidosis‐directed agents (F). In 167 cases with sufficient imaging, there were no significant differences in contrast enhancement resolution at 6 months (A 1 27/106 (25.5%), B 1 9/28 (32.1%), E 5/19 (26.3%), F 5/14 (35.7%); Fisher's exact p = 0.76). There were no significant differences in changes in mRS or EDSS among treatment groups (Kruskal–Wallis p = 0.69 and 0.63, respectively) after median follow‐up of 46.5 months (IQR 18–91.3). Interpretation Different initial immunosuppression strategies did not correlate with MRI contrast enhancement resolution at 6 months or clinical scales (mRS, EDSS). However, conclusions are limited by retrospective design, imbalanced cohorts, and insensitivity of binary MRI outcomes and available clinical scales for treatment response in neurosarcoidosis.