Abstract Background Massively parallel sequencing (MPS) of nucleic acids has been a transformative technology for basic and applied genomic science, increasing efficiencies and decreasing costs to enable studies of unprecedented scope and impact. In clinical settings, these technological and scientific advances have led to the development of tests that are increasingly fast, comprehensive, and more frequently employed. Practitioners of genomic medicine have applied these tools across clinical settings, including diagnosis of inherited disorders and cancers and infectious disease detection and surveillance. In recent years, the commercial marketplace for MPS sequencers and reagents has been dominated by a few companies. The growing demand for sequencing has led to the recent emergence of several new sequencing platforms with techniques that may provide alternatives or improvements to existing workflows or allow the adoption of sequencing workflows in new settings. Clinical genomics laboratories will evaluate these platforms from a unique perspective, focusing on how technological advancements can improve patient care. Content This review describes short-read sequencing platforms provided by Illumina, Element Biosciences, MGI, PacBio, Singular Genomics, Thermo Fisher Scientific, and Ultima Genomics. This review discusses their innovative approaches, principles, workflows, and applications. Summary This review aims to inform laboratory geneticists, clinicians, and researchers about emerging short-read technologies and their applications in clinical genomics. By highlighting their principles and potential contributions, we aim to assist laboratories in selecting suitable solutions for their sequencing needs considering key factors such as applications, throughput, and integration with existing laboratory workflows.
Multi‐omics profiling of Alzheimer’s disease in multi‐ethnic populations
AbstractBackgroundAlzheimer’s disease (AD) is a devastating neurodegenerative disorder with few therapies to treat, mitigate or prevent its onset. Understanding of this disease is predominantly based on research in non‐Hispanic Whites (NHW) although AD disproportionately affects African Americans (AA) and Latin Americans (LA), underrepresented in AD research. To address this knowledge gap, the Accelerating Medicine Partnership for Alzheimer’s Disease (AMP‐AD) Diversity Working Group was launched to generate multi‐omics data from post‐mortem brain tissue from donors of predominantly AA and LA descent. Here, we focus on genomic and transcriptomics measures, made available through the AD Knowledge Portal (ADKP).MethodBrain tissue from dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC), caudate nucleus (CN), superior temporal gyrus (STG) and temporal pole (TP) regions of AA (N = 299), LA (N = 344) and NHW (N = 532) donors was obtained through Mayo Clinic, Mt. Sinai School of Medicine, Emory, Columbia, Rush Alzheimer’s Disease Center, Banner Sun Health, and 1Florida. DNA extracted from DLPFC tissue samples (n = 641) was utilized for whole genome sequencing (WGS) at New York Genome Center (NYGC). RNAseq of 2,224 samples was conducted either at Mayo, Rush or NYGC. Sequencing reads were processed through GenomeGPS and MAPRseq pipelines for WGS and RNAseq data, respectively. Following quality control (QC), RNAseq data was normalized and assessed for sources of variation (SOV). Integration of WGS and RNAseq data to perform comparative eQTL analysis across multi‐ethnic populations and brain regions is ongoing.ResultWGS data for 621 donors, and RNAseq data generated at Mayo (n = 1,136 samples), Rush (n = 627), and NYGC (n = 779) sequencing centers, were deposited to the ADKP. Consensus processing of RNAseq data revealed site, sex, race/ethnicity, RIN, AD diagnosis, age at death and/or library batch as SOV across various sites and brain regions. Principal component analysis of gene expression measures revealed no major stratification by disease or brain region. Accompanying clinical metadata of donors have been distributed through ADKP.ConclusionThese multi‐omics data made available to the research community is expected to be an initial step towards bridging our data and knowledge gap to elucidate conserved and distinct AD related pathways across these underrepresented at‐risk populations.
AbstractBackgroundGenome‐wide association studies (GWAS) in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) leveraging endophenotypes beyond case/control diagnosis, such as brain amyloid β pathology, have shown promise in identifying novel variants and understanding their potential functional impact. In this study, we leverage two brain amyloid β pathology measurement modalities, PET imaging and neuropathology, to address sample size limitations and to discover novel genetic drivers of disease.MethodWe conducted a meta‐analysis on an amyloid PET imaging GWAS (N = 7,036, 35% amyloid positive, 53.67% female, age = 71) and an autopsy GWAS of brain amyloidosis (N = 6,519, 63.08% amyloid positive, 51.34% female, age at death = 83), both adjusted for covariates including age, sex and principal components of genetic ancestry. All participants in both GWAS were unrelated individuals of European descent. We defined amyloid positivity as moderate or frequent neuritic plaques using the Consortium to Establish a Registry for Alzheimer’s Disease (CERAD) staging scores within each autopsy cohort. A Gaussian mixture model (GMM) was applied to each amyloid PET imaging cohort to identify the cohort and tracer‐specific cut‐offs that differentiate amyloid positive and negative populations.ResultThe genome‐wide significant results from the meta‐analysis identified three known AD loci (APOE, CR1, and BIN1) and a novel chromosome 17 locus (rs35635959, intergenic, MAF = 0.27, OR = 1.18, p = 1.47 × 10‐8). The MAGMA gene‐level analysis excluding the APOE region suggests significant associations between rs35635959 and COASY, PLEKHH3, and TUBG2 on chromosome 17, implying the potential roles of these genes on amyloidosis. Functional annotations of rs35635959 leveraging brain eQTL databases indicate its association with differential gene expression of COASY and TUBG2 in AD brains. ROSMAP bulk and single‐nucleus RNAseq analyses link TUBG2 downregulation to the higher amyloid burden and AD diagnosis while suggesting such observations are enriched in excitatory and inhibitory neurons, reaching FDR significance.ConclusionThis study is the most extensive European GWAS of brain amyloidosis, and our findings replicate known AD loci and identify a possible novel locus (index SNP rs35635959) on chromosome 17. Functional annotations of the novel variant indicate TUBG2, implicating in microtubule organization, warrants further assessment. Ongoing efforts aim to validate these novel effects using independent datasets.
Validation Of the Tau Heterogeneity Evaluation in Alzheimer’s Disease (THETA) Score Using Longitudinal and Histopathology Data
AbstractBackgroundWe recently developed a novel tau‐PET summary measure THETA, capturing regional heterogeneity and identifying tau status, using ground truth visual assessments from a large single‐center cross‐sectional dataset and validated on independent cohorts [1, 2]. In this study, we aimed to evaluate the performance of THETA on longitudinal and histopathology data.MethodWe included longitudinal tau‐PET ([18F]flortaucipir) data from 696 Mayo Clinic Study of Aging (MCSA) and ADRC participants, with histopathology in n = 90. Fig. 1 shows the model that uses regional standard uptake value ratios (SUVR) and a target of binary class of tau positivity for prediction of THETA. This model was applied to predict tau status on each followup scan. Slopes of the meta‐ROIs’ tau SUVRs and THETA were evaluated by diagnostic group and as a function of baseline amyloid SUVR in discordant CU participants (where meta‐ROI and visual assessments did not match at baseline) and in incident‐THETA+ CU participants (whose THETA moved from below to above 1 over serial tau‐PET scans). We evaluated tau measurements as a function of Braak stages for neurofibrillary tangles.ResultLongitudinal plots of meta‐ROIs for diagnostic groups were very similar, but the expanded range of THETA based on visual positivity prediction clearly identified tau positive or tau‐negative scans. In discordant‐CU (n = 97) and incident‐THETA+ CU participants (n = 14 all amyloid positive at follow‐up but only 65% at baseline), the relationship between baseline amyloid and rate of tau increase was stronger for THETA than temporal meta‐ROI (Fig. 2). Separation between baseline and follow‐up was greater for THETA (t‐statistics = 90) compared to temporal meta‐ROI (t‐statistics = 20) (p<0.01) in the incident‐THETA+ CU participants. THETA showed a slightly stronger association with Braak stage than meta‐ROIs (rho = 0.87 vs. ≤0.83, p<0.05), with better separation of clinical diagnoses (Fig. 3).ConclusionTHETA remained clearly negative or positive in MCI and AD, providing consistent information on underlying etiology of impairment at both baseline and follow‐up. Although binary in its construction, THETA both provided separation of values based on tau status and its change correlated with baseline amyloid burden especially in discordant‐CU where tau deposition is not in typical meta‐ROIs. Further work is needed to confirm if THETA captures early tau changes.
Functional connectivity associations with markers of disease progression in GRN mutation carriers
AbstractBackgroundAutosomal dominant progranulin (GRN) mutations are a common genetic cause of frontotemporal lobar degeneration. Though clinical trials for GRN‐related therapies are underway, there is an unmet need for biomarkers that can predict symptom onset and track disease progression. We previously showed that presymptomatic GRN carriers exhibit thalamocortical hyperconnectivity that increases with age when they are presumably closer to symptom onset. However, whether hyperconnectivity arises concomitantly with markers of neurodegeneration remains unclear.MethodUtilizing T1 and task‐free functional magnetic resonance imaging (tf‐fMRI) from 49 presymptomatic and 26 symptomatic GRN mutation carriers, we determined the relationships between functional connectivity as measured by voxel‐wise whole brain degree and GRN‐relevant markers of disease progression, which included plasma neurofilament light chain (NfL) concentrations, CSF complement C1q and C3b protein levels, grey matter atrophy, and OCD symptom severity.ResultNfL concentrations were associated with frontotemporoparietal and thalamic hyperconnectivity in presymptomatic GRN carriers and extensive regions of atrophy in symptomatic carriers. Complement levels were associated with regions of hyperconnectivity, but not gray matter, in symptomatic carriers. Presymptomatic carriers with thalamic hyperconnectivity tended to have lower grey matter volume in bilateral insula and left lateral parietal cortex, which are among regions that deteriorate in GRN‐FTD. OCD symptom severity was associated with hypoconnectivity across all GRN carriers.ConclusionIn presymptomatic carriers, the co‐occurrence of hyperconnectivity, high NfL, and low gray matter suggests that tf‐fMRI hyperconnectivity may portend the onset of the neurodegenerative phase. These findings point toward hyperconnectivity as an indicator of approaching symptomatic onset.
A harmonized memory composite score for cross‐cohort Alzheimer’s disease and related dementia research: development and validation
AbstractBackgroundThe Uniform Data Set (UDS) neuropsychological battery, administered across Alzheimer’s Disease Centers (ADC), includes memory tests but lacks a list‐learning paradigm. ADCs often supplement the UDS with their own preferred list‐learning task. Given the importance of list‐learning for characterizing memory, we aimed to develop a harmonized memory score that incorporates UDS memory tests while allowing centers to contribute differing list‐learning tasks.MethodWe applied item‐banking confirmatory factor analysis to develop a composite memory score in 5,287 participants (mean age 67.1; SD = 12.2) recruited through 18 ADCs and four consortia (DiverseVCID, MarkVCID, ALLFTD, LEADS) who completed UDS memory tasks (used as linking‐items) and one of five list‐learning tasks. All analyses used linear regression. We tested whether memory scores were affected by which list‐learning task was administered. To assess construct validity, we tested associations of memory scores with demographics, disease severity (CDR Box Score), an independent memory task (TabCAT Favorites, n = 675), and hippocampal volume (n = 811). We compared performances between cognitively unimpaired (n = 279), AD‐biomarker+ MCI (n = 26), and AD‐biomarker+ dementia (n = 98). In a subsample with amyloid‐ and tau‐PET (n = 49), we compared memory scores from participants with positive vs negative scans determined using established quantitative cutoffs.ResultModel fit indices were excellent (e.g., CFI = 0.998) and factor loadings were strong (0.43‐0.93). Differences in list‐learning task had a negligible effect on scores (average Cohen’s d = 0.11). Higher memory scores were significantly (p’s<.001) correlated with younger age (β = ‐0.18), lower CDR Box Scores (β = ‐0.63), female sex (β = 0.12), higher education (β = 0.19), larger hippocampal volume (β = 0.42), and an independent memory task (β = 0.71, p<0.001). The memory composite declined in a stepwise fashion by diagnosis (cognitively unimpaired>MCI>AD dementia, p<0.001). On average, amyloid‐PET positivity was associated with lower composite scores, but was not statistically significant (β = ‐0.34; p = 0.25; d = 0.40). Tau‐PET positivity was associated with worse performance, demonstrating a large effect size (β = ‐0.75; p<0.002; d = 0.91).ConclusionThe harmonized memory score developed in a large national sample was stable regardless of contributing list‐learning task and its validity for cross‐cohort ADRD research is supported by expected associations with demographics, clinical measures, and Alzheimer’s biomarkers. A processing script will be made available to enhance cross‐cohort ADRD research.
Evaluating Congruence Between Clinical and Biological Staging Across The Alzheimer’s Disease Spectrum
AbstractBackgroundThe newly proposed criteria by the AA working group incorporates both biological and clinical stages to characterize the progression of AD. In this study, we aim to evaluate the agreement between these two complementary systems.MethodsUsing 188 participants from McGill TRIAD and 139 from the HEAD cohorts, we categorized participants into biological (0‐4) and clinical (0‐4) stages using amyloid PET, tau PET(MK‐6240), and clinical measures as described by the working group. Participants were then stratified into three categories: congruent (clinical = biological), higher in the biological stage (clinical < biological), and higher in the clinical stage (clinical > biological). In the TRIAD cohort, we further compared these groups for age, sex, years of education, vascular burden (WMH), microglial activation (PBR scan), Astrocyte reactivity (GFAP), amyloid load, tau load, and NPI‐Q scores using Welch two‐sided t‐test with FDR multiple comparison correction.ResultsIn the TRIAD cohort, 34% of participants were congruent, 24.5% had a higher clinical stage, and 41.5% had a higher biological stage. Meanwhile in the HEAD cohort 68.2% were congruent, 20.7% had a higher clinical stage, and 17% had a higher biological stage. TRIAD participants with a higher clinical stage had lower education (P = 0.02), more neuropsychiatric symptoms (P = 0.03), and a higher vascular burden (P = 0.03) (Table 1). As expected, people with higher biological stage had more amyloid(P<0.001), tau(P<0.001), and astrocyte reactivity(P<0.001) (Table 1, Figure 2).ConclusionsOur findings highlight important discordance between clinical and biological stages, which could be partially explained by cognitive reserve. This was supported by the protective effects of educational attainment in participants with a higher biological stage. Vascular burden played a major role in the cognitive impairment of individuals with higher clinical stages. Future studies should replicate these findings in larger more representative population‐based cohorts.
Distribution of cognitive domains and neuropathology of cases with mild cognitive impairment
AbstractBackgroundMild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) is a pre‐dementia state where impaired cognitive domains (memory, executive, visuospatial processing, language) may predict underlying pathology, e.g. Alzheimer’s disease(AD), Lewy body (LB), and other. Delineating neuropathological heterogeneity in MCI and their associations with neuropsychological profiles are important in identifying individuals at risk of further deterioration. We aimed to characterize the neuropathological heterogeneity in cases with a diagnosis of MCI.MethodCases with a final consensus cognitive diagnosis of MCI (n = 128) prior to death were selected from the Arizona Study of Aging and Neurodegenerative disorders (AZSAND). Groups were divided into amnestic (aMCI) and non‐amnestic MCI (naMCI), single and multi‐domain impairment, and specific domain impairment (executive, language, visuospatial) was explored. Presence and severity of neuropathology including AD, LB, cerebral white matter rarefaction (CWMR), cerebral amyloid angiopathy (CAA), cerebral infarcts and microinfarcts (cortical and subcortical), TAR DNA‐binding protein 43 (TDP‐43), and apolipoprotein E (ApoE) status were compared between MCI subtypes.ResultThe number of cases meeting neuropathological criteria for AD was not different between aMCI (36.4%) and naMCI (22.6%) while co‐existent PD was less frequent in aMCI (19.5% vs 38.7%). When compared to naMCI (n = 31), the aMCI (n = 85) group had an older age of death (p = 0.001), less educational years (p = 0.04), a higher number of subcortical infarcts (p = 0.012), a higher regional density of neurofibrillary tangles (p = 0.027) and a lower density of LB (p = 0.015) in the temporal lobe, and CWMR in tended to be more severe in the frontal lobe (p = 0.052). Those with single domain aMCI had less CWMR (p = 0.001) compared to the multidomain. Within the naMCI group, those with single domain MCI had higher proportions of CAA (p = 0.042), and lower LB density (p = 0.019) compared to multidomain. CWMR was more severe (p = 0.026) inConclusionA high heterogeneity was observed between MCI subtypes. While AD pathology was similar between groups, regional anatomical differences were observed. Vascular pathology including subcortical infarcts, CWMR and CAA appear to be commonly associated with both aMCI and naMCI respectively while CWMR was associated with executive dysfunctions. CWMR, CAA and LBs appear to be more frequent in multidomain aMCI and naMCI respectively.
1‐ versus 2‐test criteria for cognitive impairment and associations with CSF and imaging markers in former American football players
AbstractBackgroundClinically meaningful cognitive impairment has typically been defined as a single impaired test score, but this approach is prone to false‐positive errors. Examining two test scores at a lower threshold (i.e., using neuropsychological criteria) can improve diagnostic reliability and has shown stronger associations with biomarkers of Alzheimer’s disease. Cognitive impairment in episodic memory and/or executive functioning is a core feature of traumatic encephalopathy syndrome (TES). However, there remains a need to improve the specificity of TES criteria. We applied 1‐ vs. 2‐test criteria for cognitive impairment in former American football players to examine whether 2‐test criteria showed stronger associations with biomarkers of tau, axonal injury, and neurodegeneration.Method169 male former American football players from the DIAGNOSE CTE Research Project completed neuropsychological assessment, lumbar puncture, and MRI (see Table). Episodic memory measures were delayed recall from Craft Story, Brief Visuospatial Memory Test, and NAB List Learning. Executive functioning measures were FAS, Stroop Interference, NAB Mazes, and Trails B. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) was measured using Lumipulse technology (p‐tau, t‐tau) and an in‐house ELISA (neurofilament light [NfL]). Hippocampal volumes were extracted from structural MRI using Freesurfer 7.1. Cognitive impairment was identified by 1‐test criteria (≥1.5 SD below norms on one test in either domain) and 2‐test criteria (>1 SD below norms on two tests within a domain). Regressions adjusting for age, race, education, and APOE ε4 status assessed whether meeting 1‐ or 2‐test criteria, separately, predicted log‐transformed CSF p‐tau181, p‐tau231, t‐tau, and NfL, and hippocampal volumes.Result37 of the 99 football players that were impaired by 1‐test criteria did not meet 2‐test criteria, and four uniquely met 2‐test but not 1‐test criteria (see Figure). Cognitive impairment by 2‐test but not 1‐test criteria predicted higher log‐CSF NfL (2‐test: B = 0.24, p = .007; 1‐test: B = 0.06, p = .53), smaller left hippocampal volume (2‐test: B = ‐195.84, p = .01; 1‐test: B = ‐131.52, p = .08), and smaller right hippocampal volume (2‐test: B = ‐161.19, p = .045; 1‐test: B = ‐134.88, p = .08). Neither criterion predicted p‐tau181, p‐tau231, or t‐tau.Conclusion2‐test criteria demonstrated stronger associations between cognitive impairment and markers of axonal injury and neurodegeneration. Incorporating multiple test scores to identify cognitive impairment could improve diagnostic specificity in TES.
Beyond Traditional Measures: Exploring Cognitive Intraindividual Variability in Traumatic Encephalopathy Syndrome
AbstractBackgroundTraumatic encephalopathy syndrome (TES) is the proposed clinical syndrome of chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a neurodegenerative disease associated with repetitive head impacts in contact/collision sports. A core clinical feature of TES is cognitive impairment, particularly in memory and executive functions. Cognitive intraindividual variability (IIV) is the extent of variability in neuropsychological test performance (i.e., dispersion of test scores) and is believed to be an indicator of disruption in executive control, linked to altered fronto‐subcortical circuits. Here, we examined cognitive IIV as a method to detect subtle executive dysfunction in TES that may not be captured by traditional neuropsychological measures.MethodThe sample included former American football players (120 professional, 60 college); participants were males, aged 45‐74. Participants completed a baseline neuropsychological test battery (n = 8 excluded for suboptimal performance validity). A multidisciplinary diagnostic consensus conference classified participants using the 2021 NINDS Consensus Diagnostic Criteria for TES (see Table‐1): (1) No‐TES (n = 62); (2) TES‐CTE Suggestive (n = 35); (3) TES‐CTE Possible (n = 21); (4) TES‐CTE Probable (n = 54). TES‐CTE Possible and Probable were combined. The coefficient of variation (CoV) was used to measure cognitive IIV (CoV = iSD/iOTBM, iOTBM = average T‐score across neuropsychological tests; iSD = standard deviation of iOTBM). A higher CoV indicates greater score dispersion. To avoid circularity, memory and executive tests used for classifying TES groups were intentionally excluded from the CoV calculation. Analysis of covariance compared the TES groups on CoV, controlling for age, education, and race.ResultResults showed a significant difference in CoV between TES groups, F(2, 165) = 8.20 p<.001, partial η2 = .09. The TES‐CTE Possible/Probable group had the highest CoV (M = .226, SE = .007), compared with the TES‐no (M = .192, SE = .008, p<.001) and TES‐CTE Suggestive groups (M = .178, SE = .011, p<.001). CoV did not significantly differ between the TES‐no and TES‐CTE suggestive groups (Mdiff = 0.014, SE = .013, p = .293).ConclusionThe TES‐CTE possible/probable group had the highest cognitive IIV with ∼23% dispersion (vs. ∼18‐19% in TES‐no and TES‐CTE suggestive groups), suggesting greater cognitive variability in those with the greatest likelihood for having underlying CTE (based on TES criteria). This finding emphasizes the potential utility of exploring cognitive IIV as a method for detecting nuanced executive dysfunction in TES.