Citations

Mayo Clinic

Clear

1413 citation(s) found for "Xu, Kathryn K".

Diagnostic and treatment delays in young women with breast cancer.
Poorvu, Philip D. , Sella, Tal , Rosenberg, Shoshana M. , Ruddy, Kathryn J. , Gelber, Shari , Peppercorn, Jeffrey , Schapira, Lidia , Come, Steven E. , Zheng, Yue , Tamimi, Rulla M. , Borges, Virginia F. , Warner, Ellen , Partridge, Ann H.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | May 27, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 6575-6575

10.1200/jco.2019.37.15_suppl.6575 Get It

6575 Background: Delays in diagnosis (dx) and treatment (tx) affect breast cancer (BC) outcomes. We sought to identify factors associated with delays among young women, who do not undergo routine screening and often have pregnancy or breastfeeding-related breast changes that may mask a BC. Methods: The Young Women’s Breast Cancer Study is a multicenter, prospective cohort that enrolled 1302 women with newly dx BC age ≤40 between 2006-2016. Women reported the method and timing of cancer detection on the baseline survey. 231 were ineligible or excluded due to missing information. Among those reporting self-detected cancers, using multivariable regression we evaluated factors associated with delays ≥90 days (d) from symptom to presentation (self delay) and presentation to dx (care delay); in stage 0-III BC we evaluated delays ≥60d from dx to tx (tx delay). Results: 1071 eligible women had median age at dx of 37 yrs (17-40) and 74% reported self-detected cancers. Self delay or care delay ≥90d was reported in 17% and 13%, respectively. Factors inversely associated with self delay included pregnancy at dx (vs nulliparous, OR 0.10, CI 0.01-0.78) and perceived financial comfort (vs not, OR 0.62, CI 0.41-0.93). Women dx ≤1 year post-partum who breastfed (vs nulliparous, OR 2.60, CI 1.14-5.93) and those with a family history of breast/ovarian cancer (vs none, OR 1.79, CI 1.00-3.19) were more likely to have a care delay. Age was inversely associated with care delays (OR 0.94, CI 0.89-0.99). Tx delay was reported by 10% (105/1015), and associated with being single (vs partnered, OR 1.61, CI 1.02-2.56 ), non-white (vs white, OR 1.85, CI 1.09-3.13) and having Stage 0 BC (vs stage 1, OR: 3.08, CI 1.65-5.77); women with stage 3 BC (vs stage 1, OR 0.13, CI 0.03-0.56) were less likely to have a tx delay. Conclusions: In this cohort, most young women with BC underwent timely dx and tx initiation. Women dx ≤1 year post-partum who breastfed were more likely to experience a care delay, likely because lactational changes may mask BC signs and symptoms. The associations of perceived financial status with self delay and non-white race with tx delay underscore the need for additional support to ensure timely care for underserved populations with the goal of eliminating disparities in outcomes.
Previsit breast cancer educational microlearning videos: Impact on patient satisfaction and engagement.
Hurley, Rachel M. , Wyatt, Kirk D. , Johnson, Rachel F, O’Brien, Michael W., Zenz, Wendy J, Anderson, Stacy R, Brugger, C, Ruddy, Kathryn J. , Pruthi, Sandhya , Johnson, Rachel F., Brugger, Cheryl A, Boughey, Judy C.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | May 27, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 6526-6526

10.1200/jco.2019.37.15_suppl.6526 Get It

6526 Background: Most patients diagnosed with breast cancer turn to the Internet to learn about their diagnosis; however, information online is often generic, challenging to navigate, and not expert-curated. To facilitate patient education and engagement in our breast clinic, we piloted the implementation of pre-visit education via brief microlearning videos organized within an online platform. Methods: Seventeen videos of 2-4 minute duration were developed by multidisciplinary content experts. Videos covered a variety of educational topics relevant to breast cancer, including treatment options. Patients received a link via email to create an account, which provided access to the platform. Aggregate viewing data and optional patient surveys (online after viewing 3 videos and at the clinical appointment) were used to assess opt-in rates, engagement, and satisfaction. Results: Between September 2018 and January 2019, 57.4% (240/418) of women with biopsy proven breast cancer who were sent an email invitation registered on the platform. On average, patients watched 11 of the 17 videos, with 93.7% of users (225/240) viewing at least one. Overall, 85% (168/198) of women recommend the microlearning format for patient education. The most-viewed video topics included types of breast cancer, breast abnormality and biopsy, understanding biopsy results, tumor markers, and staging. Seventy-eight percent (154/198) of women reported that they planned to share the videos with family or caregivers, and 67% (133/198) felt that the educational content increased their satisfaction with their overall experience. Barriers to video access were emails marked as junk, not having an email address, and difficulties with videos loading. Conclusions: The majority of patients participating in this pilot registered on the platform and watched pre-visit microlearning educational videos. These expert-curated videos contributed to high levels of satisfaction and engagement. Strategies to overcome barriers to access will be developed to expand the reach of this new valuable component of breast cancer care.
Long-term survival of adjuvant high-dose (HDC) vs weekly cisplatin (WC) for human papilloma-virus (HPV) and non-HPV head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC).
Price, Katharine A. , Foote, Robert L. , Garces, Yolanda I. , Neben-Wittich, M.A. , Moore, Eric J. , Kasperbauer, Jan C., Janus, Jeffrey R. , Geiger, J.L. , Chintakuntlawar, Ashish V. , Daniel, J. , Price, Daniel L. , Abel, Kathryn M. Van

Journal of Clinical Oncology | May 27, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 6071-6071

10.1200/jco.2019.37.15_suppl.6071 Get It

6071 Background: Phase III data suggests a benefit of HDC in the adjuvant setting, but the effect of HDC and WC on long term survival and for HPV+ HNSCC is unknown. Methods: Data from a published retrospective study (Geiger Oral Onc 2013) of HDC vs WC in resected HNSCC was updated. Overall survival (OS) and recurrence-free survival (RFS) was assessed by Kaplan-Meier method for all pts and by HPV status. Multivariate analyses were performed to assess impact of HPV status, smoking, age, HDC vs WC, and cumulative cisplatin dose ( < 200mg/m2 vs ≥200 mg/m2). Results: 51 patients (pts) received HDC and 53 WC. Median follow-up was 8.7 yrs (0.8-13.7). For the whole cohort, HDC had significantly improved OS over WC (p = 0.0095; 5- and 10-yr OS 84% and 80% vs 72% and 60%). No OS benefit for HDC was seen in pts with HPV+HNSCC (5- and 10-yr OS 90% and 87% for HDC and 81% and 81% for WC; p = 0.51). For HPV-negative HNSCC, OS had borderline significance with HDC vs WC (5- and 10-yr OS 73% and 68% vs 65% and 44%; p = 0.06). For the whole cohort, there was no difference in 5- and 10-yr RFS (78% and 74% for HDC vs 72% and 62% for WC; p = 0.32). When analyzed by HPV status, there was no difference in RFS with HDC or WC for either HPV+ (p = 0.43) or HPV-negative HNSCC (p = 0.97). On multivariate analyses of OS for all pts, only HPV status was significant (p = 0.0011; HR 0.27, CI 0.12-0.62). For HPV+ HNSCC, there was no significant predictor of OS. For non-HPV HNSCC, the benefit of HDC approached significance with a decreased risk of death (HR 0.38; p = 0.07). For all pts, those who received ≥200mg/m2 had significantly improved OS (5-yr 90% vs 72% and 10-yr 86% vs 61%; p = 0.004). By HPV status, cumulative dose had no significant effect on OS. Conclusions: OS is better with HDC and with cumulative dose > 200 mg/m2 in unselected patients. The benefit of cisplatin is likely higher for non-HPV HNSCC. A difference in OS with no difference in RFS suggests non cancer-related causes of death in the WC cohort. Ability to receive HDC could be a surrogate marker of comorbidity. [Table: see text]
The Circulating Cell-free Genome Atlas (CCGA) Study: Follow-up (F/U) on non-cancer participants with cancer-like cell-free DNA signals.
Cohn, Allen Lee, Seiden, Michael V., Gross, Samuel, Venn, Oliver, Fung, Eric T. , Liu, Minetta C. , Oxnard, Geoffrey R. , Hartman, Anne‐Renee , Kurtzman, Kathryn N. , Hubbell, Earl , Gross, Samuel, Klein, Eric A. , Waterhouse, David

Journal of Clinical Oncology | May 27, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 5574-5574

10.1200/jco.2019.37.15_suppl.5574 Get It

5574 Background: A noninvasive cell-free DNA (cfDNA)-based cancer detection assay offers the hope of a blood test that might reduce morbidity and mortality of cancers, particularly those without recommended screening tests (eg, some gynecologic cancers). CCGA (NCT02889978) is a prospective, multi-center, longitudinal, case-control study evaluating models for discriminating cancer versus non-cancer. Here, we report F/U of control participants (pts) who demonstrated a cancer-signal in CCGA. Methods: Clinically evaluable samples (N = 2508) from pts enrolled without a cancer diagnosis (dx; NC) and treatment-naive pts with newly diagnosed cancer (C) were divided into training (n = 1564; 580 NC, 984 C) and test (n = 944; 368 NC, 576 C) sets. Classification performance (cancer/non-cancer) was assessed via 3 prototype assays: whole-genome bisulfite (WGBS), whole-genome (WGS), and targeted (507 gene) sequencing. Notable outlier NC pts were identified with cancer-like scores in either ≥2 assay classification results or by the presence of known cancer drivers with ≥1 assay classification result suggesting cancer. All pts are currently in F/U in accordance with study protocol (to date: 80% with > 10 mo and 15% with > 22 mo F/U). Results: Among training and test sets, 8 ( < 1%) NC pts were identified with a cancer-like signal. To-date, 2 have been diagnosed with a gynecologic malignancy: 1 stage IIIc clear cell endometrial carcinoma and 1 stage IIIc ovarian cancer, 3 and 2 months (mo) post-enrollment [PE], respectively. Among C pts in the study, sensitivity (at 98% specificity; WGBS) in these cancer types was: uterine/endometrial: 11% (n = 27 train) and 22% (n = 9 test); ovarian: 82% (n = 17) and 71% (n = 7). In addition, a third NC pt was diagnosed with a stage IV lung cancer 15 mo PE. Conclusions: This cfDNA-based assay detected a cancer-like signal that anticipated a clinical presentation of cancer in undiagnosed pts as early as 15 months prior to the actual dx. High specificity ( > 99%) requires accounting for undiagnosed cancers in study design and analysis. Together, these data suggest that this prototype assay may have high performance detecting a variety of gynecological and other cancers. Clinical trial information: NCT02889978.
Genome-wide cell-free DNA (cfDNA) methylation signatures and effect on tissue of origin (TOO) performance.
Liu, Minetta C. , Jamshidi, Arash , Venn, Oliver, Fields, Alexander P. , Maher, M. Cyrus , Cann, Gordon, Amini, Hamed , Gross, Samuel, Bredno, Joerg , Miller, M. Barry, Schellenberger, Jan, Fung, Eric T. , Maddala, Tara, Oxnard, Geoffrey R. , Hartman, Anne‐Renee , Aravanis, Alex, Seiden, Michael V., Gross, Samuel, Kurtzman, Kathryn N. , Klein, Eric A. , Spigel, David R. , Aravanis, Alexander M.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | May 27, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 3049-3049

10.1200/jco.2019.37.15_suppl.3049 Get It

3049 Background: For multi-cancer detection using cfDNA, TOO determination is critical to enable safe and efficient diagnostic follow-up. Previous array-based studies captured < 2% of genomic CpGs. Here, we report genome-wide fragment-level methylation patterns across 811 cancer cell methylomes representing 21 tumor types (97% of SEER cancer incidence), and define effects of this methylation database on TOO prediction within a machine learning framework. Methods: Genomic DNA from 655 formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tumor tissues and 156 isolated cells from tumors was subjected to a prototype 30x whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (WGBS) assay, as previously reported in the Circulating Cell-free Genome Atlas (CCGA) study (NCT02889978). Two independent TOO models, one with and one without the methylation database, were fitted on training samples; each was used to predict on the test set. A WGBS classifier was used to detect cancer at 98% specificity; reported TOO results reflect percent agreement between predicted and true TOO among those detected cancers (166 cases: 81 stage I-III, 69 stage IV, 16 non-informative). Results: Genome-wide methylation data generated from this database allowed fragment-level analysis and coverage of ~30 million CpGs across the genome (~60-fold greater than array-based approaches). Incorrect TOO assignments decreased by 35% (20% to 13%) after incorporating methylation database information into TOO classification. Improvement was observed across all cancer types and was consistent in early-stage cancers (stage I-III). Respective performances in breast cancer (n = 23) were 87% vs 96%; in lung cancer (n = 32) were 85% vs 88%; in hepatobiliary (n = 10) were 70% vs 90%; and in pancreatic cancer (n = 17) were 94% vs 100%. Results using an optimized approach informed by these results in a large cohort of CCGA participants will be reported. Conclusions: Incorporating data from a large methylation database improved TOO performance in multiple cancer types. This supports feasibility of this methylation-based approach as an early cancer detection test across cancer types. Clinical trial information: NCT02889978.
Prognostic significance of blood-based cancer detection in plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA): Evaluating risk of overdiagnosis.
Oxnard, Geoffrey R. , Chen, Xiaoji , Fung, Eric T. , Ma, Ting , Lipson, Jafi A. , Patel, Shilpen, Shaknovich, Rita , Brooks, Jacqueline D., Seiden, Michael V., Aravanis, Alex, Hartman, Anne‐Renee , Liu, Minetta C. , Hubbell, Earl , Kurtzman, Kathryn N. , Zhao, Dong , Liu, Hai , Spigel, David R. , Aravanis, Alexander M. , Klein, Eric A.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | May 27, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 1545-1545

10.1200/jco.2019.37.15_suppl.1545 Get It

1545 Background: Screening tests for early cancer detection are often criticized due to risk of overdiagnosis—detection of good prognosis cancers which may not require immediate treatment. We recently reported development of cfDNA sequencing approaches for cancer detection; longitudinal follow-up (F/U) data were utilized here to evaluate prognostic significance of cancer detection using cfDNA. Methods: Plasma cfDNA samples were subjected to whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (WGBS, 30X) as part of a previously-reported Circulating Cell-free Genome Atlas (CCGA; NCT02889978) substudy. This exploratory analysis evaluated the overall survival (OS) of training and test set participants (pts) with cancer (20 cancer types, any stage I-IV). Combining train and test set pts, univariate and multivariate analyses (Cox proportional hazards) assessed OS association with WGBS result (cancer detected vs not detected, set at 98% specificity), clinical stage (IV vs I-III), diagnostic method (symptom- vs screen-detected), sex, age, and histologic grade. Results: Of 827 pts from the training set with F/U (median 12.2 mo), 334 (40.4%) had WGBS-detected cancer. Among 127 (15.4%) pts with cancer that died during F/U, cancer was detected in 104 (81.9%). Results were similar in the test set. In univariate analyses all variables were associated with prognosis, including WGBS result (HR 7.7 p<0.001). In multivariate analyses accounting for other covariates, the three variables that most significantly remained prognostic were WGBS (HR 3.0, p<0.001), clinical stage (HR 3.3, p<0.001), and diagnostic method (HR 3.0, p<0.001). Validation of these findings is ongoing in an independent cohort of ~5,000 cancer pts from CCGA using an optimized assay; updated performance results will be reported. Conclusions: Cancers detected using WGBS of cfDNA had a worse prognosis than cancers not detected. WGBS cancer detection carried comparable prognostic significance as clinical stage. By preferentially detecting higher risk cancers, cancer detection using plasma cfDNA may avoid some of the overdiagnosis that has been seen with some existing cancer screening methods. Clinical trial information: NCT02889978.
Genomics of HER2+ breast cancer in young women before and after exposure to chemotherapy (chemo) plus trastuzumab (H).
Waks, Adrienne G. , Jain, Esha , Collins, Laura C. , Rosenberg, Shoshana M. , Ruddy, Kathryn J. , Schapira, Lidia , Come, Steven E. , Peppercorn, Jeffrey , Wagle, Nikhil , Tamimi, Rulla M. , Borges, Virginia F. , Warner, Ellen , Snow, Craig , Partridge, Ann H. , Jain, Esha

Journal of Clinical Oncology | May 27, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 554-554

10.1200/jco.2019.37.15_suppl.554 Get It

554 Background: HER2+ breast cancer (BC) is particularly common in young women. Genomic features of HER2+ tumors before and after H-based therapy have not been described in a population of young women and may point to clinically targetable mechanisms of resistance. Methods: From a large prospective cohort of women diagnosed with BC age ≤40 years, we identified those with HER2+ BC and tumor tissue available for sequencing before and after chemo+H. Whole exome sequencing (WES) was performed on each tumor and on germline DNA from blood. Tumor-normal pairs were analyzed for mutations and copy number (CN) changes. Evolutionary analysis was performed for patients with both pre- and post-treatment (tx) samples. Results: 22 women had successful WES samples from at least one timepoint; 13 of these had paired sequencing results both before and after chemo+H. For the majority of women, post-tx sample was following neoadjuvant chemo + H, though post-tx timepoint for other women represented locoregional or distant metastasis (Table). TP53 was the only gene that was significantly recurrently mutated in both pre- and post-tx samples. Comparison of matched pre-tx and post-tx samples demonstrated that large changes in HER2 CN over the course of tx were uncommon, only 2/13 pts had > 2-fold change in HER2 CN. Other clonal and subclonal genomic alterations were found to be acquired in the post-tx sample compared to the pre-tx sample. One patient acquired a putative activating mutation in ERBB2. Another patient acquired a clonal hotpsot mutation in TP53. MYC gene amplification was observed in 4 post-tx tumors. NOTCH2 alterations were found in post-tx biopsies from 2 different patients, and mutations in STIL were also found in post-tx biopsies from 2 patients, though the function of these mutations is not known. Conclusions: HER2+ breast tumors in young women display genomic evolution following tx with chemo+H. HER2 CN changes are uncommon, but we identified several genes that warrant exploration as potential mechanisms of resistance to therapy in this population.[Table: see text]
Patient-reported outcomes (PROs) in NRG oncology/NSABP B-39/RTOG 0413: A randomized phase III study of conventional whole breast irradiation (WBI) versus partial breast irradiation (PBI) in stage 0, I, or II breast cancer.
Ganz, Patricia A. , White, Julia , Vicini, Frank A. , Julian, Thomas B. , Arthur, Douglas W., Rabinovitch, Rachel , Kuske, Robert R. , Parda, David S., Scheier, Michael F. , Winter, Kathryn, Kuerer, Henry M. , Vallow, Laura A., Pierce, Lori J. , Mamounas, Eleftherios P. , Costantino, Joseph P., Curran, Walter J. , Cecchini, Reena S. , Paik, Soonmyung , Mamounas, Eleftherios P. , McCormick, Beryl L. , Wolmark, Norman

Journal of Clinical Oncology | May 27, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 508-508

10.1200/jco.2019.37.15_suppl.508 Get It

508 Background: PBI is an alternative to WBI, with potentially greater therapy (tx) compliance, and better integration with chemotherapy (CTX). NSABP B-39/RTOG 0413 clinical outcome results from 2018 did not show equivalence of PBI to WBI in local tumor control; PBI was statistically inferior, but with clinically small differences. PBI may be an acceptable alternative to WBI for some women. Understanding cosmesis and quality of life (QOL) treatment outcomes is important. Methods: B-39/0413 included a prospective QOL substudy with PRO evaluation of breast cancer treatment outcomes (cosmesis, function, pain) and fatigue using BCTOS and SF-36 vitality scales. Secondary QOL parameters included treatment related symptoms, perceived convenience of care, and the BPI pain scale. The study sample was stratified by CTX or not, as CTX is given before WBI but after PBI. PRO assessments occurred before randomization, the last day of adjuvant tx [CTX or radiation], 4 wks later, and 6, 12, 24, and 36 mo later. Primary aims included comparisons of change in fatigue from baseline to end of tx and equivalency of change in cosmesis from baseline to 36 mo for PBI v WBI. Separate analyses were done for CTX and non-CTX pts, controlling for axillary dissection. Each comparison used α=0.0125. Planned sample size was 964. Results: From 3-23-05 to 5-27-09, 975 pts were enrolled in the PRO study; 950 had follow-up data. 504 did not receive CTX and 446 received CTX. In non-CTX pts, PBI had less fatigue (p=0.011) and did not meet criteria for cosmesis equivalence (97.5% CI, -0.02 to 0.22; ∆=0.20). In CTX pts, PBI had worse fatigue (p=0.011) and equivalent cosmesis to WBI (97.5% CI, -0.09 to 0.21; ∆=0.24). In both groups, PBI pts reported less pain at end of tx. In non-CTX pts, PBI had more pain at 36 mo but in CTX pts, there was no difference. Convenience of care and treatment related symptom outcomes will be presented. Conclusions: In non-CTX pts, PBI is more convenient with less fatigue and slightly poorer cosmesis at 36 mo. Cosmesis was equivalent at 36 mo in CTX pts. Support: U10CA180868, -180822, UG1CA189867. Clinical trial information: NCT00103181.
Phase 1 study of selinexor plus carfilzomib and dexamethasone for the treatment of relapsed/refractory multiple myeloma
Jakubowiak, Andrzej , Jasielec, Jagoda, Rosenbaum, Cara A. , Cole, Craig E. , Chari, Ajai , Nam, Jennifer, McIver, Amanda, Severson, Erica, Stephens, Leonor A, Tinari, Kathryn M., Rosebeck, Shaun , Zimmerman, Todd M., Hycner, Tyler, Turowski, Agata, Karrison, Theodore, Zonder, Jeffrey A. , Jakubowiak, Andrzej J , Mıkhael, Joseph , Zonder, Jeffrey A , Chari, Ajai

British Journal of Haematology | May 24, 2019 | Volume: 186 | Issue: 4 | Pages: 549-560

10.1111/bjh.15969 | PMID 31124580 Get It

SummarySelinexor, an oral Selective Inhibitor of Nuclear Export, targets Exportin 1 (XPO1, also termed CRM1). Non‐clinical studies support combining selinexor with proteasome inhibitors (PIs) and corticosteroids to overcome resistance in relapsed/refractory multiple myeloma (RRMM). We conducted a phase I dose‐escalation trial of twice‐weekly selinexor in combination with carfilzomib and dexamethasone (SKd) to determine maximum tolerated dose in patients with RRMM (N = 21), with an expansion cohort to assess activity in carfilzomib‐refractory disease and identify a recommended phase II dose (RP2D). During dose escalation, there was one dose‐limiting toxicity (cardiac failure). The RP2D of twice‐weekly SKd was selinexor 60 mg, carfilzomib 20/27 mg/m2 and dexamethasone 20 mg. The most common grade 3/4 treatment‐emergent adverse events included thrombocytopenia (71%), anaemia (33%), lymphopenia (33%), neutropenia (33%) and infections (24%). Rates of ≥minimal response, ≥partial response and very good partial response were 71%, 48% and 14%, respectively; similar response outcomes were observed for dual‐class refractory (PI and immunomodulatory drug)/quad‐exposed (carfilzomib, bortezomib, lenalidomide and pomalidomide) patients (n = 17), and patients refractory to carfilzomib in last line of therapy (n = 13). Median progression‐free survival was 3·7 months, and overall survival was 22·4 months in the overall population. SKd was tolerable and re‐established disease control in RRMM patients, including carfilzomib‐refractory patients.Registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT02199665)
Intellectual Equipoise and Challenges: Accruing Patients With Advanced Cancer to a Trial Randomizing to Surgical or Nonsurgical Management (SWOG S1316)
Deutsch, Gary B. , Deneve, Jeremiah L. , Al-Kasspooles, Mazin F, Nfonsam, Valentine , Gunderson, Camille C., Secord, Angeles Alvarez , Rodgers, Phillip , Hendren, Samantha , Silberfein, Eric J. , Grant, Marcia , Sloan, Jeff A. , Arnold, Kathryn B. , Sloan, Jeff, Sun, Virginia Chih-Yi , Anderson, Garnet L. , Krouse, Robert S.

American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Medicine® | May 24, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 1 | Pages: 12-18

10.1177/1049909119851471 | PMID 31122027 Get It

Background: Prospective, randomized trials are needed to determine optimal treatment approaches for palliative care problems such as malignant bowel obstruction (MBO). Randomization poses unique issues for such studies, especially with divergent treatment approaches and varying levels of equipoise. We report our experience accruing randomized patients to the Prospective Comparative Effectiveness Trial for Malignant Bowel Obstruction (SWOG S1316) study, comparing surgical and nonsurgical management of MBO. Methods: Patients with MBO who were surgical candidates and had treatment equipoise were accrued and offered randomization to surgical or nonsurgical management. Patients choosing nonrandomization were offered prospective observation. Trial details are listed on www.clinicaltrials.gov (NCT #02270450). An accrual algorithm was developed to enhance enrollment. Results: Accrual is ongoing with 176 patients enrolled. Most (89%) patients chose nonrandomization, opting for nonsurgical management. Of 25 sites that have accrued to this study, 6 enrolled patients on the randomization arm. Approximately 59% (20/34) of the randomization accrual goal has been achieved. Patient-related factors and clinician bias have been the most prevalent reasons for lack of randomization. An algorithm was developed from clinician experience to aid randomization. Using principles in this tool, repeated physician conversations discussing treatment options and goals of care, and a supportive team–approach has helped increase accrual. Conclusions: Experience gained from the S1316 study can aid future palliative care trials. Although difficult, it is possible to randomize patients to palliative studies by giving clinicians clear recommendations utilizing an algorithm of conversation, allotment of necessary time to discuss the trial, and encouragement to overcome internal bias.