Back to Authors

Brachman, David

Mayo Clinic

Mayo Clinic

Citations 20

Cognition and quality of life after chemotherapy plus radiotherapy (RT) vs. RT for pure and mixed anaplastic oligodendrogliomas: Radiation therapy oncology group trial 9402
Wang, M., Cairncross, Gregory, Shaw, Edward , Jenkins, Robert B. , Scheithauer, B. W., Brachman, David, Buckner, Jan C. , Souhami, Luís, Curran, Walter J. , Laperrière, Normand , Mehta, Minesh P.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | August 25, 2020 | Volume: 27 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: e20519-e20519

10.1200/jco.2009.27.15_suppl.e20519 Get It

e20519 Background: Radiation Therapy Oncology Group 9402 compared PCV chemotherapy plus radiation therapy (PCV+RT) versus RT alone for anaplastic oligodendroglioma. Here we report 1) longitudinal changes in cognition and quality of life, 2) effects of patient factors and treatments on cognition, quality of life and survival, and 3) prognostic implications of cognition and quality of life. Methods: Cognition was assessed by Mini Mental Status Examination (MMSE) and quality of life by Brain-Quality of Life (B-QOL) by repeat assessments. Scores were analyzed for survivors and within five years of death. Shared parameter models evaluated MMSE/B-QOL with survival. Results: For survivors, MMSE and B-QOL scores were similar longitudinally and between treatments. For those dying within 5 years, MMSE scores were stable initially, while B-QOL scores decreased; both declined rapidly in the last year of life and similarly between arms. In the aggregate, scores decreased over time (P=0.0413 for MMSE; P=0.0016 for B-QOL) and were superior with age < 50 years (P<0.001 for MMSE; P=0.0554 for B-QOL) and KPS 80–100 (P<0.001). Younger age and higher KPS were associated with longer survival. After adjusting for patient factors and drop-out, survival was longer after PCV+RT (HR=0.66, 95% CI=0.49–0.9, P=0.0084; HR=0.74, 95% CI=0.54–1.01, P=0.0592) in models with MMSE and B-QOL. There were no differences in MMSE and B-QOL scores between arms (P=0.4752 and P=0.2767, respectively); higher scores predicted longer survival. Conclusions: MMSE and B-QOL scores held steady in both arms for survivors. For those who died, B-QOL scores declined slowly until the last year of life, then rapidly. Younger, fitter patients had better MMSE and B-QOL scores and longer survival. No significant financial relationships to disclose.
Comprehensive Genomic Analysis in NRG Oncology/RTOG 9802: A Phase III Trial of Radiation Versus Radiation Plus Procarbazine, Lomustine (CCNU), and Vincristine in High-Risk Low-Grade Glioma
Bell, Erica H. , Shaw, Edward G. , Buckner, Jan C. , Barger, Geoffrey, Bullard, Dennis E., Brown, Paul D. , Stelzer, K. , McElroy, Joseph P., Fleming, Jessica L. , Timmers, Cynthia , Salavaggione, Andrea L., Aldape, Kenneth , Brachman, David, Gertler, Stanley Z., Murtha, Albert , Schultz, Christopher J. , Hunter, G.K., Crocker, Ian , Won, Minhee , Chakravarti, Arnab , Chakravarti, Arnab , Chakravarti, Arnab , Zhang, Jianwen , Mehta, Minesh P. , Gilbert, Mark R. , Becker, Aline Paixão , Liu, Ziyan , Johnson, David, Laack, Nadia N.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | July 24, 2020 | Volume: 38 | Issue: 29 | Pages: 3407-3417

10.1200/jco.19.02983 Get It

PURPOSENRG Oncology/RTOG 9802 (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT00003375 ) is a practice-changing study for patients with WHO low-grade glioma (LGG, grade II), as it was the first to demonstrate a survival benefit of adjuvant chemoradiotherapy over radiotherapy. This post hoc study sought to determine the prognostic and predictive impact of the WHO-defined molecular subgroups and corresponding molecular alterations within NRG Oncology/RTOG 9802.METHODSIDH1/2 mutations were determined by immunohistochemistry and/or deep sequencing. A custom Ion AmpliSeq panel was used for mutation analysis. 1p/19q codeletion and MGMT promoter methylation were determined by copy-number arrays and/or Illumina 450K array, respectively. Progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) were estimated using the Kaplan-Meier method. Hazard ratios (HRs) were calculated using the Cox proportional hazard model and tested using the log-rank test. Multivariable analyses (MVAs) were performed incorporating treatment and common prognostic factors as covariates.RESULTSOf the eligible patients successfully profiled for the WHO-defined molecular groups (n = 106/251), 26 (24%) were IDH-wild type, 43 (41%) were IDH-mutant/non-codeleted, and 37(35%) were IDH-mutant/codeleted. MVAs demonstrated that WHO subgroup was a significant predictor of PFS after adjustment for clinical variables and treatment. Notably, treatment with postradiation chemotherapy (PCV; procarbazine, lomustine (CCNU), and vincristine) was associated with longer PFS (HR, 0.32; P = .003; HR, 0.13; P < .001) and OS (HR, 0.38; P = .013; HR, 0.21; P = .029) in the IDH-mutant/non-codeleted and IDH-mutant/codeleted subgroups, respectively. In contrast, no significant difference in either PFS or OS was observed with the addition of PCV in the IDH-wild-type subgroup.CONCLUSIONThis study is the first to report the predictive value of the WHO-defined diagnostic classification in a set of uniformly treated patients with LGG in a clinical trial. Importantly, this post hoc analysis supports the notion that patients with IDH-mutant high-risk LGG regardless of codeletion status receive benefit from the addition of PCV.
Molecular predictors of outcome and response to bevacizumab (BEV) based on analysis of RTOG 0825, a phase III trial comparing chemoradiation (CRT) with and without BEV in patients with newly diagnosed glioblastoma (GBM).
Won, Minhee , Blumenthal, Deborah T. , Vogelbaum, Michael A. , Colman, Howard , Jenkins, Robert B. , Brown, Paul D. , Jaeckle, Kurt A. , Schiff, David , Dignam, James J., Atkins, James N., Brachman, David, Werner‐Wasik, Maria, Komaki, Ritsuko , Aldape, Kenneth , Sulman, Erik P. , Colman, Howard , Chakravarti, Arnab , Jeraj, Robert , Gilbert, Mark R. , Mehta, Minesh P.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | March 11, 2020 | Volume: 31 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: LBA2010-LBA2010

10.1200/jco.2013.31.15_suppl.lba2010 Get It

LBA2010 The full, final text of this abstract will be available at abstract.asco.org at 7:30 AM (EDT) on Sunday, June, 2, 2013, and in the Annual Meeting Proceedings online supplement to the June 20, 2013, issue of Journal of Clinical Oncology. Onsite at the Meeting, this abstract will be printed in the Sunday edition of ASCO Daily News.
RTOG 0825: Phase III double-blind placebo-controlled trial evaluating bevacizumab (Bev) in patients (Pts) with newly diagnosed glioblastoma (GBM).
Dignam, James J., Won, Minhee , Blumenthal, Deborah T. , Vogelbaum, Michael A. , Aldape, Kenneth , Colman, Howard , Brown, Paul D. , Jaeckle, Kurt A. , Schiff, David , Atkins, James N., Brachman, David, Werner‐Wasik, Maria, Komaki, Ritsuko , Gilbert, Mark R. , Colman, Howard , Chakravarti, Arnab , Jeraj, Robert , Armstrong, Terri S. , Wefel, Jeffrey S. , Sulman, Erik P. , Mehta, Minesh P.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | March 11, 2020 | Volume: 31 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 1-1

10.1200/jco.2013.31.15_suppl.1 Get It

1 The full, final text of this abstract will be available at abstract.asco.org at 7:30 AM (EDT) on Sunday, June, 2, 2013, and in the Annual Meeting Proceedings online supplement to the June 20, 2013, issue of Journal of Clinical Oncology. Onsite at the Meeting, this abstract will be printed in the Sunday edition of ASCO Daily News.
Chemotherapy plus radiotherapy (CT-RT) versus RT alone for patients with anaplastic oligodendroglioma: Long-term results of the RTOG 9402 phase III study.
Cairncross, J. Gregory , Wang, Meihua , Shaw, Edward G. , Jenkins, Robert B. , Scheithauer, Bernd W., Brachman, David, Buckner, Jan C. , Fink, Karen, Souhami, Luís, Curran, Walter J. , Laperrière, Normand , Mehta, Minesh P.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | March 11, 2020 | Volume: 30 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 2008b-2008b

10.1200/jco.2012.30.15_suppl.2008b Get It

2008b Background: Anaplastic oligodendrogliomas, pure (AO) and mixed (AOA), are chemosensitive tumors, especially if co-deleted for chromosomes 1p and 19q, but whether addition of CT to RT prolongs overall survival (OS), is unknown. Methods: In the RTOG 9402 Phase III trial, patients (pts) with AO/AOA were randomly assigned to PCV [procarbazine, CCNU (lomustine) and vincristine] followed by immediate RT vs. immediate RT alone. Early analysis showed no OS benefit for the PCV+RT group but combined therapy was associated with a longer progression-free survival (PFS). It also showed that the finding of 1p/19q co-deletion was associated with a longer OS independent of treatment. The current analysis has a median follow up of 11.3 years (yrs). Results: Two hundred ninety-one patients were randomized, 148 to PCV+RT and 143 to RT. PCV+RT was associated with longer PFS [2.5 vs. 1.7 yrs, hazard ratio (HR) 0.68, 95% confidence interval (CI) (0.53, 0.88), P = 0.003] and the 1p/19q co-deletion with a longer Median Survival Time (MST) [8.7 vs. 2.7 yrs, HR 0.41, 95% CI (0.30, 0.55), P < 0.001]. For the entire cohort, there was no difference in MST by treatment [4.6 yrs for PCV+RT vs. 4.7 yrs for RT, HR 0.79, 95% CI (0.60, 1.04), P = 0.1]. However, patients with 1p/19q co-deleted tumors lived much longer after PCV+RT (n = 59) than after RT (n = 67) [14.7 vs. 7.3 yrs, HR 0.59, 95% CI (0.37, 0.95), P = 0.03]. There was no difference in MST by treatment in pts without the 1p/19q co-deletion [n=137; 2.6 vs. 2.7 yrs, HR 0.85, 95% CI (0.58, 1.23), P = 0.39]. Re-operation rates upon progression were similar between treatment arms in co-deleted pts (43%, PCV+RT vs. 54%, RT) but salvage CT rates were higher in the RT arm [57% vs. 81% (P = 0.04)]. Conclusions: PCV followed by immediate RT was a highly effective therapy for patients with 1p/19q co-deleted AO/AOA. In this setting, 1p/19q co-deletion was both prognostic and predictive, and the early PFS benefit in co-deleted cases was a harbinger of their longer OS. [This work was supported by RTOG grants U10 CA21661 and U10 CA32115, NCCTG grant U10 CA25224, ECOG grants CA17145 and CA21115, SWOG grant CA32102, and CCOP grant U10 CA37422 from the National Cancer Institute (NCI)]
Initial report of Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) 9802: Prospective studies in adult low-grade glioma (LGG)
Shaw, Edward G. , Coons, Stephen W., Brachman, David, Buckner, Jan C. , Stelzer, K. , Barger, Geoffrey, Brown, Paul D. , Gilbert, M. R., Berkey, Brian A. , Mehta, Minesh P.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | March 9, 2020 | Volume: 24 | Issue: 18_suppl | Pages: 1500-1500

10.1200/jco.2006.24.18_suppl.1500 Get It

1500 Background: Treatment of adult LGG is controversial. Favorable patients (pts) (age <40 years [yrs] who undergo gross total resection [GTR]) are typically observed. Unfavorable pts (age ≥40 who have subtotal resection [STR] or biopsy [B]) are usually given initial radiation therapy (RT), reserving chemotherapy (historically procarbazine, CCNU and vincristine [PCV]) for recurrence. In 1998, the RTOG, in conjunction with SWOG, NCCTG, and ECOG initiated prospective studies of adult LGG, the results of which are reported herein. Methods: Favorable pts were observed postoperatively in a single arm Phase II study (Arm 1). Unfavorable pts were stratified by age, histology, KPS, and presence/absence of contrast enhancement on preoperative magnetic resonance imaging and randomized to either RT alone (54Gy in 30 fractions to a local treatment field) (Arm 2) or RT followed by 6 cycles of standard dose PCV (Arm 3). Reported results include overall survival (OS) rate, median overall survival time (MOST), progression-free survival (PFS) rate, and median progression-free survival time (MPFST). Survival data are compared using Wilcoxon p-values. Results: A total of 362 eligible/analyzable pts were accrued between 1998 and 2002. Median follow-up time is 4 years. For the 111 favorable pts observed on Arm 1, OS at 2- and 5-yrs is 99% and 94%. PFS at 2- and 5-yrs is 82% and 50%. For the 251 unfavorable pts on Arms 2 (RT alone) and 3 (RT+PCV), there was no difference in OS or PFS. OS at 2- and 5-yrs was 87% and 61% with RT alone versus (vs) 86% and 70% with RT+PCV (p=0.72). MOST was not reached in RT alone pts and was 6.0 yrs in RT+PCV pts. PFS at 2- and 5-yrs was 73% and 39% with RT alone vs 72% and 61% with RT+PCV (p=0.38). MPFST was 4.0 yrs with RT alone vs 6.0 yrs with RT+PCV. Acute grade 3–4 toxicity occurred in 9% of pts who received RT alone, 67% who received RT+PCV (mostly hematologic). There were no treatment deaths on either arm. Conclusions: 5-yr PFS was poor in all three arms ranging from 39% to 61%. Only half of favorable pts were disease-free at 5 yrs. In unfavorable pts, there was no OS advantage with the addition of PCV to RT. Both PFS and MPFST were better with the addition of PCV, but not significantly. Analysis of outcome by 1p19q status is pending. No significant financial relationships to disclose.
Updated predictive analysis of the WHO-defined molecular subgroups of low-grade gliomas within the high-risk treatment arms of NRG Oncology/RTOG 9802.
Won, Minhee , McElroy, Joseph P., Shaw, Edward G. , Brachman, David, Gertler, Stanley Z., Murtha, Albert , Schultz, Christopher J. , Johnson, David , Hunter, G.K., Crocker, Ian , Chakravarti, Arnab , Bell, Erica H. , Fleming, Jessica L. , Becker, Aline Paixão , Mehta, Minesh P. , Laack, Nadia N.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | May 27, 2019 | Volume: 37 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 2002-2002

10.1200/jco.2019.37.15_suppl.2002 Get It

2002 Background: This study sought to update the predictive significance of the three WHO-defined molecular glioma subgroups ( IDHwt, IDHmt/noncodel, and IDHmt/codel) in the subset of specimens available for analysis in NRG Oncology/RTOG 9802, a phase III trial of high-risk low-grade gliomas (LGGs) treated with radiation (RT) with and without PCV after biopsy/surgical resection. Notably, this is the first phase III study to evaluate the predictive value of the WHO subgroups in LGGs using prospectively-collected, well-annotated long-term overall survival data, in a post-hoc analysis. Methods: IDH1/2 mutation status was determined by immunohistochemistry and/or next-generation sequencing. 1p/19q status was determined by Oncoscan and/or 450K methylation data. Treatment effects on overall survival (OS) and progression-free survival (PFS) by marker status were determined by the Cox proportional hazard model and tested using the log-rank test in a secondary and exploratory analysis. Results: Of all the randomized eligible high-risk G2 patients (N = 251) in NRG Oncology/RTOG 9802, 106(42%) patients had tissue available with sufficient quality DNA for profiling. Of these, 80(75%) were IDHmut; 43(41%) were IDHmut/non-co-deleted, 37(35%) were IDHmut/co-deleted, and 26(24%) were IDHwt. Upon univariate analyses, no significant difference in either PFS or OS was observed with the addition of PCV in the IDHwt subgroup. Both the IDHmut/non-co-deleted and IDHmut/co-deleted subgroups were significantly correlated with longer PFS (HR = 0.32; p = 0.003; HR = 0.13; p < 0.001) and OS (HR = 0.38; p = 0.013; HR = 0.21; p = 0.029) in the RT plus PCV arm, respectively. Conclusions: Our analyses suggest that both IDHmut/non-co-deleted and IDHmut/co-deleted subgroups received benefit from treatment with PCV although sample size is limited and analyses are post-hoc. Our results also support the notion that IDHwt high-risk LGG patients do not benefit from the addition of PCV to RT. Funding: U10CA180868, U10CA180822, and U24CA196067. Also, R01CA108633, R01CA169368, RC2CA148190, U10CA180850-01, BTFC, OSU-CCC (all to AC). Clinical trial information: NCT00003375.
Results of NRG oncology/RTOG 9813: A phase III randomized study of radiation therapy (RT) and temozolomide (TMZ) versus RT and nitrosourea (NU) therapy for anaplastic astrocytoma (AA).
Chang, Susan M. , Cairncross, J. Gregory , Bahary, Jean-Paul , Dolinskas, Carol A., Aldape, Kenneth , Schiff, David , Jaeckle, Kurt A. , Brown, Paul D. , Barger, Geoffrey, Werner‐Wasik, Maria, Brachman, David, Peñas-Prado, Marta , Robins, H. Ian, Bélanger, Karl, Schultz, Christopher J. , Zhang, Peixin, Gilbert, Mark R. , Chakravarti, Arnab , Shih, Helen A. , Mehta, Minesh P.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | March 7, 2019 | Volume: 33 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 2002-2002

10.1200/jco.2015.33.15_suppl.2002 Get It

Phase III study of radiation therapy (RT) with or without procarbazine, CCNU, and vincristine (PCV) in low-grade glioma: RTOG 9802 with Alliance, ECOG, and SWOG.
Buckner, Jan C. , Pugh, Stephanie L. , Shaw, Edward G. , Barger, Geoffrey, Coons, Stephen W., Ricci, Peter E. , Bullard, Dennis E., Brown, Paul D. , Stelzer, K. , Brachman, David, Schultz, Christopher J. , Bahary, Jean-Paul , Fisher, Barbara J., Kim, Harold , Murtha, Albert , Curran, Walter J. , Gilbert, Mark R. , Suh, John H. , Mehta, Minesh P.

Journal of Clinical Oncology | January 3, 2019 | Volume: 32 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 2000-2000

10.1200/jco.2014.32.15_suppl.2000 Get It

Influence of Residual Disease Following Surgical Resection in Newly Diagnosed Glioblastoma on Clinical, Neurocognitive, and Patient Reported Outcomes
Hall, William A. , Pugh, Stephanie L. , Armstrong, Terri S. , Brachman, David, Werner‐Wasik, Maria, Wendland, Merideth M, Brown, Paul D. , Chao, Samuel T. , Roof, Kevin S. , Robins, H. Ian, Curran, Walter J. , Movsas, Benjamin , Armstrong, Terri S , Wefel, Jeffrey S. , Gilbert, Mark R. , Mehta, Minesh P.

Neurosurgery | February 15, 2018 | Volume: 84 | Issue: 1 | Pages: 66-76

10.1093/neuros/nyy003 Get It

Abstract BACKGROUND The influence of subtotal resection (STR) on neurocognitive function (NCF), quality of life, and symptom burden in glioblastoma is unknown. If bevacizumab preferentially benefits patients with STR is unknown. OBJECTIVE To examine these uncertainties. METHODS NCF and patient reported outcomes (PRO) were prospectively collected in NRG Oncology RTOG 0525 and 0825. Changes in NCF and PRO measures from baseline to prespecified times were examined by Wilcoxon test, and mixed effects longitudinal modeling, to assess differences between patients who received STR vs gross-total resection. Changes were also compared among STR patients on 0825 receiving placebo vs bevacizumab to assess for a preferential therapeutic effect. Overall survival between STR and gross-total resection patients was compared using the Kaplan–Meier method. RESULTS A total of 427 patients were eligible with STR present in 37%. At baseline, patients with STR had worse NCF, worse MD Anderson Symptom Inventory Brain Tumor Neurological Factor ratings ( P = .004), and European Organization for the Research and Treatment of Cancer Quality of Life Questionnaire ( P = .002). Longitudinal multivariate analysis associated STR with worse NCF (Hopkins Verbal Learning Test–Revised Delayed Recognition [ P = .048], Trail Making Test Part A [ P = .035], and Controlled Oral Word Association [ P = .049]). One hundred eighty-three STR patients from 0825 were analyzed (89 bevacizumab, 94 placebo); bevacizumab failed to demonstrate improvement in select NCF or PRO measures. CONCLUSION STR patients had worse NCF and PROs before therapy. During adjuvant therapy, STR patients had worse objective NCF, despite accounting for tumor location. STR did not result in a detriment to OS. The addition of bevacizumab did not preferentially improve PRO or NCF outcomes in STR patients.