Oglesbee, Devin

COASY-related disorders (CRDs) are a spectrum of autosomal recessive conditions caused by the dysfunction of CoA synthase, an enzyme responsible for the final steps of CoA synthesis. Clinical manifestations of CRDs are highly variable, ranging from perinatal lethal pontocerebellar hypoplasia to childhood-onset neurodegenerative brain iron accumulation, which is often recognized after clinical regression. Recent reports have described a few individuals with CRD who screened positive for carnitine palmitoyltransferase-I deficiency by newborn screening (NBS). However, heterogeneous clinical presentations, conflicting biochemical/molecular sequencing of CPT1A, and a lack of metabolic characterization have led to lengthy, costly diagnostic journeys. To address some of these aspects, this investigation retrospectively evaluated NBS acylcarnitine patterns in five CRD cases using Collaborative Laboratory Integrated Reports (CLIR). A total of 25 metabolites/ratios were identified to deviate significantly from reference ranges and were primarily composed of elevated free carnitine and reduced long-chain acylcarnitine levels. While low acylcarnitine concentrations are often not reported due to a lack of lower reference cutoffs, ratios involving these metabolites relative to short-chain acylcarnitines could aid in identifying CRD cases via NBS. When comparing this pattern to CPT-Ia cases, we confirmed a nearly identical acylcarnitine pattern between these, and thus support the need to consider CRD in cases with NBS results suggestive of CPT-Ia. This study is the first case series to characterize NBS patterns in patients with CRD and highlights the unique opportunity for early detection, particularly in cases that are neonatally asymptomatic and have unremarkable confirmatory biochemical results.

Abstract Background Pathogenic variants in the DMD gene are associated with Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophy (DMD/BMD). Professional medical societies currently recommend DMD carrier screening for all patients who are pregnant or considering pregnancy. Such testing may identify intragenic duplications of DMD (i.e., involving one or more exons but fully contained with the gene) in patients without a personal or family history of DMD/BMD. These incidentally detected DMD intragenic duplications, however, pose significant challenges for variant interpretation. Pathogenicity of an intragenic duplication depends on its structural configuration. Tandem duplications may cause reading frame disruption and gene loss-of-function; conversely, non-tandem duplications may not disrupt gene function. Current carrier screening assays cannot determine the structural configuration of an intragenic duplication. The current guidelines (e.g., the ClinGen PVS1 decision tree) presume intragenic duplications are in tandem unless proven otherwise. If this presumption of tandem configuration is inaccurate, it may lead to overestimation of variant pathogenicity, potentially resulting in unnecessary invasive procedures (e.g., amniocentesis for prenatal diagnosis) and/or having other negative impacts with regards to prenatal decision-making. This study aims to evaluate the validity of this presumption for incidentally detected DMD intragenic duplications. Methods We performed high-coverage whole-genome long-read sequencing on the PromethION instrument (Oxford Nanopore Technologies) for 15 cases with previously identified DMD intragenic duplications. Among these cases, four had personal or family history of DMD/BMD, while 11 had no known history (i.e., incidentally detected). The structural configurations of the duplications were determined by an in-house bioinformatics tool and manual inspection of the alignment files. Results In all 4 cases with a known personal or family history of DMD/BMD, the DMD intragenic duplications were confirmed to be in tandem, aligning with expectations of their pathogenicity. Interestingly, among the 11 cases with incidentally detected DMD intragenic duplications, seven (64%) were found to involve interspersed duplications. In five of these seven interspersed duplication cases, the involved DMD exons were co-duplicated with distinct segments of the Xp arm located 0.5–30 Mb away, forming complex structural variants. In another case, the duplicated DMD exons have inserted into the Xq arm, about 90 Mb downstream of DMD. The final case involved the duplicated DMD exons inserted into a repetitive region most consistent with 9q12 (i.e., the 9qh region). Conclusions Our study reveals that while DMD intragenic duplications in patients with a personal or family history of DMD/BMD were consistently in tandem, a substantial 64% of incidentally detected DMD intragenic duplications were not in tandem. These findings have important implications for both clinicians and laboratorians. They challenge the presumption of tandem configuration for DMD intragenic duplications in individuals where the variants were identified incidentally, e.g., through carrier screening in those without a family history of DMD/BMD. In these cases, we recommend classifying the DMD intragenic duplications as variants of uncertain significance (VUS), unless there is evidence of tandem configuration.

AbstractClinical recognition of primary mitochondrial disorders (PMD) is difficult due to the clinical and genetic heterogeneity. Whereas lactate has low sensitivity and specificity, in structured clinical studies growth differentiation factor 15 (GDF15) has shown promise with elevations in mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)‐related PMD, but its specificity has been questioned. In a tertiary care hospital‐wide study, medical records were retrospectively reviewed from 418 cases where GDF15 levels were obtained by clinicians. Patients were classified into patients with PMD due to mtDNA‐related defects (mtDNA maintenance, mtDNA deletions, and mtDNA‐encoded tRNA variants), PMD due to structural defects or other nuclear causes, and in non‐mitochondrial disease. Patients with liver disease or systemic critical illness were excluded. GDF15 was assayed in a clinical laboratory with a cutoff of 750 ng/L. There were 38 mtDNA‐related PMD (GDF15 >750 pg/mL in 76%), 35 other nuclear DNA‐encoded PMD or structural subunits (31% elevated GDF15), 309 non‐mitochondrial disorders (13% elevated GDF15). Based on the highest Youden J‐index, the optimal cut‐off value to identify these target mtDNA‐related disorders was 815 pg/mL, with sensitivity 76%, specificity 88%, positive predictive value of 41% and negative predictive value of 97%. At this optimized cutoff level, mtDNA‐encoded PMD patients had elevated GDF15 in 76%, nuclear DNA‐encoded PMD in 26%, and non‐mitochondrial disorders in 11% of patients. Thus, in a real‐life clinical setting, after excluding abnormal liver function and critical illness, GDF15 had good clinical utility increasing the odds at predicting mtDNA‐related primary mitochondrial disorders 14‐fold, but not for structural or other nuclear‐encoded primary mitochondrial disorders.

Abstract Background The number of known inherited metabolic diseases (IMDs) has been expanding, and the rate of diagnosis is improving with the development of innovative approaches including next generation sequencing (NGS). However, a substantial proportion of IMDs remain undetected by traditional diagnostic approaches. We aim to highlight the spectrum of IMDs diagnosed by the Undiagnosed Diseases Network (UDN) and to learn from the UDN diagnostic processes that were able to detect IMDs. Methods We conducted a retrospective analysis of 757 UDN participants diagnosed from 2015 until 2023 using the cohort database, which were divided into a cohort with IMDs (n = 194; 27%) and a cohort whose phenotypes were not explained by an IMD (n = 563; 73%), based on the International Classification of Inherited Metabolic Disorders (ICIMD). Then, we divided the causes of the metabolic 194 diagnoses into seven groups that included all the ICIMD categories. We inspected which clinical and laboratory approaches contributed to a final UDN diagnosis. We also present a UDN case example from each group to highlight the diagnostic yields that resulted from combining newer diagnostic approaches in the UDN and illustrate potential pitfalls of current NGS methods. Results These 194 cases of IMDs included examples from 21/25 (84%) of the ICIMD categories. Of the UDN subjects 164/194 (85%) were diagnosed with IMDs through NGS. Conclusion The spectrum of IMDs detected in the UDN cohort is large and growing and appropriate use of newer multiple diagnostic approaches should further increase diagnosis of IMDs that are presently missed by the traditional laboratory screening methods.

ABSTRACTFrataxin is an evolutionarily conserved mitochondrial protein responsible for iron homeostasis and metabolism. A deficiency of frataxin (encoded by FXN) leads to Friedreich's ataxia (FRDA), a progressive disorder that affects both the central and peripheral nervous systems, most commonly via a pathogenic GAA trinucleotide expansion. In contrast, pathogenic variants in ALG1 in humans cause a form of congenital disorder of glycosylation. Here, we present a 15‐year‐old boy with a clinical presentation that raised concern for complex hereditary spastic paraplegia (HSP), with motor features including progressive spastic paraparesis, cervical dystonia, cerebellar dysfunction, and diminished lower extremity reflexes. The proband was initially found to have a novel compound heterozygous variant in ALG1 on exome sequencing, along with N‐glycan profiling revealing evidence of defective mannosylation and Western blot analysis demonstrating an 84% reduction in ALG1 expression. Although several of his clinical features could be explained by the ALG1 variant specifically or considered as part of the presentation of CDGs in general, there were additional phenotypes that suggested an alternative, or additional, genetic diagnosis. Subsequently, he was found to have biallelic pathogenic GAA repeat expansions in FXN on genome sequencing, leading to a diagnosis of FRDA. Given that FRDA explained all his clinical features, the ALG1 variant may have been a hypomorphic form and/or a biochemical phenotype. Our findings underscore the importance of considering FRDA as a differential diagnosis in cases of complex HSP and demonstrate the utility of unbiased genome sequencing approaches that include detection of trinucleotide repeat expansions for progressive motor disorders.

Abstract Background Sphingolipids play a crucial role in cellular functions and are essential components of cell membranes, signaling molecules, and lipid metabolism. In particular, ceramide is a key intermediate in sphingolipid metabolism and defects in ceramide metabolism can lead to various inborn errors of metabolism, making ceramides important targets for clinical screening and diagnosis. Detecting altered concentration patterns of sphingolipids is desirable for distinguishing related inborn errors of metabolism for diagnosis and treatment monitoring. Methods We developed a liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry method with a pathway-oriented approach to focus on sphingolipids involved in ceramide metabolism. A total of 47 sphingolipids bearing different head groups and side chains were targeted. Precision/reproducibility, linearity, and spike recovery extraction efficiency tests were performed on plasma and serum samples from confirmed cases of sphingolipidosis. Results Linearity of the method showed the coefficient of determination (r2) for all standards to be >0.99 with a slope of 1.00 ± 0.01. Intra- and interday reproducibility of standards spiked into plasma and serum revealed a coefficient of variation <20%. Spike and recovery assessment showed recovery values of 80%–120% for all standards. Altered levels of sphingolipids from patients with hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathy caused by pathogenic variants in SPTLC2 and hypomyelinating leukodystrophy related to variants in DEGS1 were detected, in agreement with trends reported in earlier studies confirming the utility of this pathway-centric method. Conclusions This method can serve as a useful tool to simultaneously monitor sphingolipids, enabling screening and diagnosis of inborn errors of ceramide metabolism.