Back to Authors

Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L.

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3621-7335

Mayo Clinic

Mayo Clinic

Citations 54

Sex Differences in Tolerability to Anti-Programmed Cell Death Protein 1 Therapy in Patients with Metastatic Melanoma and Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: Are We All Equal?
Duma, Narjust , Abdel-Ghani, Azzouqa, Yadav, Siddhartha , Hoversten, Katherine P., Reed, Clay T. , Sitek, Andrea , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Aguilera, Jesus Vera, Leventakos, Konstantinos , Lou, Yanyan , Kottschade, Lisa A. , Mansfield, Aaron S. , Adjei, Alex A. , Dronca, Roxana , Sitek, Andrea N, Manochakian, Rami , Dronca, Roxana S., Mansfield, Aaron S , Yadav, Siddhartha , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Paludo, Jonas , Dong, Haidong

The Oncologist | April 29, 2019 | Volume: 24 | Issue: 11 | Pages: e1148-e1155

10.1634/theoncologist.2019-0094 Get It

Abstract Background Immune-related adverse events (irAEs) have emerged as a serious clinical issue in the use of immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs). Risk factors for irAEs remain controversial. Therefore, we studied sex differences in irAEs in patients treated with anti-programmed cell death protein 1 (PD-1) therapy. Materials and Methods All patients with metastatic melanoma and non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) treated with anti-PD-1 therapy at Mayo Clinic Rochester and Florida from 2015 to 2018 were reviewed. Kaplan-Meier method and log-rank test was used for time-to-event analysis. Results In 245 patients with metastatic melanoma, premenopausal women were more likely to experience irAEs (all grades) compared with postmenopausal women and men (67% vs. 60% vs. 46%), primarily because of an increase in endocrinopathies (33% vs. 12% vs. 10%, respectively). In patients with NSCLC (231 patients), women (all ages) were also more likely to develop irAEs of all grades (48% vs. 31%). Women with NSCLC were more likely to develop pneumonitis (11% vs. 4%) and endocrinopathies (14% vs. 5%). No differences in grade ≥3 toxicities were seen across sexes in both cohorts, but women were more likely to receive systemic steroids for the treatment of irAEs compared with men. Better progression-free-survival was observed in women with NSCLC and irAEs (10 months vs. 3.3 months) compared with women without irAEs. Conclusion Women with metastatic melanoma and NSCLC are more likely to experience irAEs compared with men. We also observed differences between sexes in the frequency of certain irAEs. Larger studies are needed to investigate the mechanisms underlying these associations. Implications for Practice The results of this study suggest that women may be at a higher risk for immune-related adverse events (irAEs) compared with men when treated with anti-programmed cell death protein 1 therapy. In addition, women were more likely to develop certain irAEs, including endocrinopathies and pneumonitis. Close follow-up of women undergoing treatment with immune checkpoint inhibitors will allow clinicians to diagnose these treatment-related complications early, potentially reducing their associated morbidity and mortality. In addition, a possible association between irAEs and response to therapy was observed.
Abstract A38: Blood-based T cell biomarkers and soluble PD-L1 predict responses and immune-related toxicity to PD-1 blockade in melanoma and lung cancer
Dronca, Roxana , Mansfield, Aaron, Liu, Xin , Harrington, Susan M. , Kottschade, Lisa A. , McWilliams, Rob, Block, Matthew S. , Nevala, Wendy K. , Thompson, Michael A, Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Markovic, Svetomir N. , Dong, Haidong

Cancer Immunology Research | February 4, 2019 | Volume: 6 | Issue: 9_Supplement | Pages: A38-A38

10.1158/2326-6074.tumimm17-a38 Get It

Abstract Despite unprecedented successes with immune checkpoint blockade in advanced cancers, these agents provide durable clinical benefit in only a subset of patients. In addition, the clinical management of patients receiving immune checkpoint blockade remains quite challenging due to the unpredictable and kinetically heterogeneous responses which can manifest as late responses, pseudoprogression, or hyperprogression in subsets of patients. The dynamics and heterogeneity of programmed cell death protein ligand 1 (PD-L1, aka B7-H1) expression confound its use as a predictive biomarker in cancer immunotherapy, but blood-based biomarkers have the potential to predict responders and detect mechanisms of resistance to immunotherapy. We previously reported that Bim (BH3-only protein) is a downstream signaling molecule of the PD-1 pathway, and that Bim levels in circulating tumor-reactive T-cells reflected patient responses to anti-PD-1 therapy in melanoma. We also discovered the existence of soluble PD-L1 (sPD-L1) in the plasma of cancer patients and showed a correlation of sPD-L1 with cancer stages in renal cell carcinoma and with prognosis in metastatic melanoma. Here we evaluated the frequency of tumor-reactive T cells with Bim expression along with effector memory profile and sPD-L1 as biomarkers of response in a new cohort of patients with metastatic melanoma and lung cancer undergoing anti-PD-1 therapy. We recruited 100 cancer patients treated with anti-PD-1 therapy who had peripheral blood collected at baseline and at each subsequent radiographic tumor evaluation. Frequencies of Bim+ and effector memory CD8+ T cells were measured by flow cytometry in gated tumor-reactive CD11a high PD1+ CD8+ T cells. We also measured levels of sPD-L1 in plasma at baseline and serially during treatment with ELISA. Baseline T cell markers and sPD-L1 levels and their percent changes in patients who had a radiographic response were compared to those who had progressive disease (PD). We found that patients with objective response after 4 cycles of anti-PD-1 therapy had higher frequency of Bim+ CD8+ T cells at baseline compared to patients with PD (mean 43% vs. 30%, P=0.0484). The frequencies of Bim+ T cells decreased significantly after the first 3 months of treatment in responders compared with progressors (mean -16% vs. + 40% P=0.0111). The frequency of effector memory CD8+ T cells also dramatically increased in responders in 3-6 months after anti-PD-1 therapy (mean 89% vs. 9.56%, p=0.002). High baseline sPD-L1 was associated with progression on anti-PD-1 therapy (mean 2.8 ng/mL vs. 0.7 ng/mL, p=0.07) or development of immune-related toxicities and the levels increased by 12 weeks in patients progressing on therapy. Conclusion: Measurements of T cell biomarkers (Bim and effector memory) and sPD-L1 levels provide a new noninvasive way to predict and monitor patient responses to anti-PD-1 monotherapy in melanoma and lung cancers. Note: This abstract was not presented at the conference. Citation Format: Roxana S. Dronca, Aaron Mansfield, Xin Liu, Susan Harrington, Elizabeth Enninga, Svetomir Markovic, Lisa Kottschade, Rob Mcwilliams, Matthew Block, Wendy Nevala, Michael Thompson, Haidong Dong. Blood-based T cell biomarkers and soluble PD-L1 predict responses and immune-related toxicity to PD-1 blockade in melanoma and lung cancer [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference on Tumor Immunology and Immunotherapy; 2017 Oct 1-4; Boston, MA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Immunol Res 2018;6(9 Suppl):Abstract nr A38.
The mystery of assisted reproductive technologies
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Roberson, Elle C.

Molecular Reproduction and Development | December 5, 2018 | Volume: 86 | Issue: 2 | Pages: 121-121

10.1002/mrd.23094 Get It

Regenerative Prophylaxis In Utero
Ruano, Rodrigo , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Rivera, Paola E. Brana, Brana Rivera, Paola E, Ruano, Rodrigo , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Terzic, André

Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics | November 12, 2018 | Volume: 105 | Issue: 1 | Pages: 39-41

10.1002/cpt.1262 Get It

Bim and soluble PD-L1 (sPD-L1) as predictive biomarkers of response to anti-PD-1 therapy in patients with melanoma and lung carcinoma.
Dronca, Roxana , Harrington, Susan M. , Kottschade, Lisa A. , Koo, Chi Wan , Block, Matthew S. , Nevala, Wendy K. , Mansfield, Aaron S. , Liu, Xin , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , McWilliams, Robert R. , Markovic, Svetomir N. , Dong, Haidong

Journal of Clinical Oncology | September 6, 2018 | Volume: 35 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 11534-11534

10.1200/jco.2017.35.15_suppl.11534 Get It

11534 Background: To date, there are no validated blood-based biomarkers of predicting response to PD-1 blockade. We previously reported that Bim is a downstream signaling molecule of the PD-1 pathway, and that measurement of Bim levels in circulating T-cells may predict and monitor responses to anti–PD-1 therapy in melanoma. We have identified the existence of sPD-L1 in cancer patients and showed that the sPD-L1 is biologically active and capable of triggering apoptosis in activated T-cells. Here we evaluated T cell Bim and sPD-L1 in the peripheral blood (PB) as biomarkers of response in a cohort of patients with metastatic melanoma and lung cancer undergoing anti-PD1 therapy. Methods: 60 pts treated with anti-PD-1 had PB collected at baseline and at radiographic tumor evaluation. Frequencies of Bim+ T cells and Bim median fluorescence intensity (MFI) were measured by flow cytometry in gated tumor-reactive CD11ahighPD1+ CD8+ T cells. We also measured levels of sPD-L1 at baseline and serially during treatment with sPD-L1 ELISA. Baseline Bim and sPD-L1 levels and percent change in Bim levels in patients (pts) who had a radiographic response (CR/PR) were compared to those who had progressive disease (PD) at 12 wks. Results: Similarly to previously reported preliminary data, pts with objective response (CR/PR, 15/60) after 4 cycles of anti-PD1 therapy had higher frequency of Bim T cells at baseline compared to pts with PD (16/60) (mean 43% vs. 30%, P = 0.0484). The frequencies of Bim+ T cells decreased significantly after the first 3 months of treatment in responders compared with progressors (mean -16% vs. + 40% P = 0.0111). High baseline sPD-L1 were associated with progression on anti-PD1 therapy (mean 2.8 ng/mL vs. 0.7 ng/mL, p = 0.07, n = 13) and the levels increased by the first tumor assessment in patients resistant to anti-PD-1. Conclusions: Measurements of Bim and sPD-L1 levels may help to select patients who are likely to benefit from anti-PD1 monotherapy versus combinatorial strategies, and provide a new non-invasive way to monitor response to anti-PD-1 blockade. A larger validation study is underway.
Sex differences in tolerability to Anti-PD1 therapy: Are we all equal?
Duma, Narjust , Yadav, Siddhartha , Vera-Aguilera, Jesús, Kottschade, Lisa A. , Adjei, Alex A. , Dronca, Roxana , Yadav, Siddhartha , Paludo, Jonas , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Dong, Haidong

Journal of Clinical Oncology | September 5, 2018 | Volume: 36 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: 9547-9547

10.1200/jco.2018.36.15_suppl.9547 Get It

The Primordial Journey
Mihalas, Bettina P. , Houston, Brendan J. , Green, Ella S. , Rhon‐Calderón, Eric A. , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L.

Molecular Reproduction and Development | August 7, 2018 | Volume: 85 | Issue: 11 | Pages: 809-809

10.1002/mrd.23048 Get It

CD206‐positive myeloid cells bind galectin‐9 and promote a tumor‐supportive microenvironment
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Chatzopoulos, Kyriakos , Butterfield, John T. , Sutor, Shari L., Leontovich, Alexey A. , Nevala, Wendy K. , Flotte, Thomas J. , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Markovic, Svetomir N.

The Journal of Pathology | May 7, 2018 | Volume: 245 | Issue: 4 | Pages: 468-477

10.1002/path.5093 Get It

Abstract In patients with metastatic melanoma, high blood levels of galectin‐9 are correlated with worse overall survival and a bias towards a Th2 inflammatory state supportive of tumor growth. Although galectin‐9 signaling through TIM3 on T cells has been described, less is known about the interaction of galectin‐9 with macrophages. We aimed to determine whether galectin‐9 is a binding partner of CD206 on macrophages and whether the result of this interaction is tumor‐supportive. It was determined that incubation of CD68 + macrophages with galectin‐9 or anti‐CD206 blocked target binding and that both CD206 and galectin‐9 were detected by immunoprecipitation of cell lysates. CD206 and galectin‐9 had a binding affinity of 2.8 × 10 −7 m . Galectin‐9 causes CD206 + macrophages to make significantly more FGF2 and monocyte chemoattractant protein (MCP‐1), but less macrophage‐derived chemokine (MDC). Galectin‐9 had no effect on classical monocyte subsets, but caused expansion of the non‐classical populations. Lastly, there was a positive correlation between increasing numbers of CD206 macrophages and galectin‐9 expression in tumors, and high levels of CD206 macrophages correlated negatively with melanoma survival. These results indicate that galectin‐9 binds to CD206 on M2 macrophages, which appear to drive angiogenesis and the production of chemokines that support tumor growth and poor patient prognoses. Targeting this interaction systemically through circulating monocytes may therefore be a novel way to improve local anti‐tumor effects by macrophages. Copyright © 2018 Pathological Society of Great Britain and Ireland. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Immune checkpoint molecules soluble program death ligand 1 and galectin‐9 are increased in pregnancy
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Harrington, Susan M. , Creedon, Douglas J., Dong, Haidong , Dronca, Roxana , Ruano, Rodrigo , Dronca, Roxana S., Dong, Haidong , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Markovic, Svetomir N.

American Journal of Reproductive Immunology | December 5, 2017 | Volume: 79 | Issue: 2 | Pages: No page available

10.1111/aji.12795 Get It

ProblemPregnancy requires balance between tolerance to the haploidentical fetus and the mother's ability to mount immune responses. There are parallels to this phenomenon that occur in metastatic cancer. We assessed soluble program death ligand‐1 soluble PD‐L1 (sPD‐L1) and galectin‐9 in the blood of pregnant women during gestation as these molecules are highly involved in immune suppression during cancer.Method of studyMaternal blood was collected from 30 primigravida women at monthly intervals during pregnancy, delivery and 6‐week post‐partum. Blood was analyzed for sPD‐L1 and galectin‐9 concentrations by ELISA. Term placentas were collected in formalin and IHC was completed for PD‐L1 and galectin‐9 expression.ResultsMaternal blood levels of sPD‐L1 (0.438 ng/mL) and galectin‐9 (1976 pg/mL) were elevated early in normal pregnancies compared to non‐pregnant controls (0.242 ng/mL and 773 pg/mL, respectively). sPD‐L1 increased throughout gestation, whereas galectin‐9 remained elevated until parturition; both proteins returned to control levels post‐partum. Women carrying male fetuses had significantly higher galectin‐9 levels, but not sPD‐L1, than those carrying females (2263 pg/mL vs 1874 pg/mL; P = .0005). Trophoblast cells of the term placenta coexpress galectin‐9 and PD‐L1.ConclusionImmune‐regulatory molecules galectin‐9 and sPD‐L1 increased during pregnancy and may play a role in immune tolerance that is critical for the fetus.
Survival of cutaneous melanoma based on sex, age, and stage in the United States, 1992–2011
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Moser, Justin C. , Weaver, Amy L. , Brewer, Jerry D., Leontovich, Alexey A. , Shuster, Lynne T., Kottschade, Lisa A. , Olariu, Ariadna, Mansfield, Aaron S. , Dronca, Roxana , Dronca, Roxana S., Mansfield, Aaron S , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Markovic, Svetomir N. , Hieken, Tina J.

Cancer Medicine | September 7, 2017 | Volume: 6 | Issue: 10 | Pages: 2203-2212

10.1002/cam4.1152 Get It

AbstractWomen diagnosed with cutaneous melanoma have a survival advantage compared to men, which has been hypothesized to be due to difference in behavior and/or biology (sex hormones). It remains controversial whether this advantage is dependent on age or stage of disease. We sought to compare melanoma‐specific survival between females in pre, peri, and postmenopausal age groups to males in the same age group, adjusting for stage of disease. This is a retrospective population‐based cohort study using the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) database. Patients diagnosed from 1 January 1992 through 31 January 2011 with primary invasive cutaneous melanoma were included in our cohort. Melanoma‐specific survival was the main outcome studied. Of the 106,511 subjects that were included, 45% were female. Females in all age groups (18–45, 46–54, and ≥55) with localized and regional disease, were less likely to die from melanoma compared to males in the same age group. Among patients with localized and regional disease, the relative risk of death due to melanoma increased with advancing age at diagnosis; this increase was more pronounced among females than males. In contrast, we observed no female survival advantage among patients with distant disease and no effect of age on relative risk of death from melanoma. Females with localized and regional melanoma have a decreased risk of death compared to males within all age groups. Our data show no differences in survival between men and women with metastatic melanoma, indicating that the influence of sex on survival is limited to early stage disease but not confined to pre or perimenopausal age groups.