Trautman, James

Sixty-five patients with mild to moderate nonproliferative diabetic retinopathy who enrolled in a prospective controlled clinical trial had stereofundus photographs assessed for change over an 8-mo period. The entire study group showed a worsening of retinopathy with time (P < 0.001). The worsening was greater in the pump-treated group (15/32) than in the conventionally treated group (9/33). The significance of this difference ranged from P = 0.67, if changes in mean retinopathy level for each patient were compared, to P = 0.177 if a grading system keyed to the worse eye was compared. The difference in rates of change between treatment groups was found to be related to the baseline mean retinopathy level (P = 0.031), but less significantly so if baseline retinopathy keyed to the worse eye was used as a covariate (P = 0.08). Worsening occurred more frequently in those patients starting with the lower retinopathy levels. Progression was associated with the appearance of retinal infarcts (cotton-wool spots, soft exudates) and/or intraretinal microvascular abnormalities, with the pump patients showing a significant increase in these individual retinal lesions compared with the conventionally treated patients over 8 mo (P < 0.025).

A major goal of the study was to assess the methodologies available for the quantification of retinal lesions suitable for application in trials of metabolic management. We describe the methods used for grading stereoscopic color fundus photographs. Overall retinopathy severity level for each eye ranging from normal (level 10) to high-risk category (level 70) was assigned on the basis of gradings of individual lesions. Change in retinopathy severity level over the 8-mo period was detected in 3–62% of patients, depending on the method used and the definition of change. Lesions responsible for change in level were mainly retinal infarcts (soft exudates) and intraretinal microvascular abnormalities.