Lizarraga, Ingrid M.

BACKGROUND: Significant disparities persist in timely, guideline-concordant breast cancer treatment across the US, impacting cancer outcomes. The influence of both patient-level and facility-level socioeconomic status (SES) on adherence to Commission on Cancer quality measures remains incompletely understood. STUDY DESIGN: We conducted a retrospective cohort study using the National Cancer Database to assess associations between patient and facility SES and concordance with timeliness of 3 Commission on Cancer breast cancer quality measures: surgery, multiagent chemotherapy, and radiotherapy, among patients diagnosed from 2018 to 2022. Multivariable logistic regression models were used to evaluate predictors of concordant care, including a composite measure of facility-level social risk. RESULTS: The analytic cohorts included 471,425 patients for surgery, 82,734 for chemotherapy, and 311,523 for radiotherapy. Black race, uninsured status, and lower educational attainment were each independently associated with lower odds of receiving guideline-concordant care across all measures. Patients treated at low-SES facilities had higher odds of receiving timely surgery (adjusted odds ratio [OR] 1.27, 95% CI 1.24 to 1.31) but lower odds of receiving timely chemotherapy (OR 0.85, 95% CI 0.79 to 0.91) and radiotherapy (OR 0.95, 95% CI 0.92 to 0.97) compared with those at other institutions. Facility type, fragmented care, and comorbidities also contributed to variation in concordance. CONCLUSIONS: Significant disparities in guideline-concordant breast cancer care persist by race, insurance, education, and facility-level social risk, highlighting intervention opportunities to improve outcomes for these already vulnerable populations. These findings highlight the importance of policy and institutional strategies that address both patient- and facility-level barriers to ensure equitable access to high-quality multidisciplinary treatment.

Abstract Background: There is debate regarding the benefit of breast surgery in women with stage IV breast cancer, especially among those with oligometastatic disease and good response to systemic therapy. Although some retrospective studies have suggested that locoregional therapy may improve survival, this finding has not been universally replicated in randomized controlled trials (RCT) in India, Turkey, and recently the US. To assess need for dissemination of trial results by members of the Alliance/American College of Surgeons Clinical Research Program Dissemination and Implementation (ACS CRP D&I) committee, we sought to determine trends in surgical resection and other therapies for stage IV breast cancer in response to these findings. Methods: The National Cancer Database (NCDB) was queried to identify women diagnosed with clinical stage IV breast cancer of ductal, lobular, or metaplastic histology between 2004-2017. Trends in the rate of women who underwent surgery with breast-conserving surgery (BCS) or mastectomy, radiation, and/or systemic treatments were compared. Possible predictors of breast surgery were examined in univariable and multivariable analysis. Results: We identified 87,331 cases meeting inclusion criteria and assessed demographics for surgery versus no surgery. Of the 87,331 cases, 7,718 (9%) underwent BCS and 17,625 (20%) underwent mastectomy. Rates of breast surgical resection for women with clinically diagnosed stage IV breast cancer rose until 2009, reaching a peak at 37%, followed by a decline to a rate of 18% in 2017 (Table). The largest decline was seen in the hormone receptor positive (HR+) and HER2- subgroup with 71% of patients undergoing surgery in 2007 down to 15% in 2017. Concurrently, the mean number of days between chemotherapy initiation and definitive surgery has been on the rise, ranging from 52 days in 2004 up to 94 days in 2017. In 2004, the rate of systemic therapy alone was slightly more common than locoregional therapy (surgery and/or radiation) with or without systemic therapy (48% vs 37%). By 2017, systemic therapy alone was by far more frequently utilized (69% vs 20%, p<0.001). On multivariable analysis, factors associated with reduced odds of receiving surgery were older age, black race, higher comorbidity index, being uninsured, smaller tumors, lower histologic grade, multiple sites of metastasis, and treatment with chemo-endocrine therapy (all group p values ≤0.001). Factors associated with increased odds of receiving surgery were metaplastic histology, TN subtype, and radiation therapy (all group p values ≤0.001). Conclusions: Rates of surgical resection of the breast primary for stage IV breast cancer have been on the decline in recent years, especially for HR+/HER2- disease, suggesting that providers are responding to the lack of benefit demonstrated in RCTs. Higher rates of surgery in patients with HR-/HER2+ disease and the concurrent rise in the time interval between initiation of systemic therapy and definitive surgical intervention suggest that providers may still be selecting surgery for patients with certain subtypes or those with a durable response to systemic therapy. These areas of continued clinical equipoise could be a target for future studies or de-implementation strategies. OverallHR+/HER2-HER2+TNUnknownSurgery/Total%Surgery/Total%Surgery/Total%Surgery/Total%Surgery/Total%20041189/351334-55-30-50-3420051202/353834-65-35-23-3420061268/375834-54-36-31-3420071571/433636-71-41-32-3620081992/54203754/925926/544820/41491892/52333620092194/592437172/3604883/1525556/106531883/53063520102318/6419361162/331835554/134841352/80144250/9522620112322/6921341220/378932532/144137384/91542186/7762420122238/7110311177/393830587/163536339/85340135/6842020132147/7579281173/423128534/172831334/92536106/6951520142013/8033251086/442825496/185227306/99831125/7551720151805/794323914/434321517/198126288/9962986/6231420161609/819420829/464018459/196823247/10122474/5741320171477/813618722/467815421/190522256/10372578/51615Percent of women with stage IV breast cancer undergoing surgery by year and receptor subtype. Rows containing any number <10 are not reported by subtype to maintain confidentiality, per NCDB guidelines. Citation Format: Sasha R Douglas, Ingrid Lizarraga, Judy C Boughey, Anna Weiss, Kelly Hunt, Diana Dickson-Witmer, Preeti D Subhedar, Ko Un Park, Beiqun Zhao, Sarah Blair. Trends in surgical resection for stage IV breast cancer: Less surgery more systemic treatment [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 2021 San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium; 2021 Dec 7-10; San Antonio, TX. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2022;82(4 Suppl):Abstract nr PD7-06.