Siegel, Donald L

CD19-directed CAR T-cells (CTL019) can produce durable remissions in chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL), but therapeutic success depends on whether autologous T-cells expand, persist, and retain cytotoxic function after manufacturing. Failure of CLL T-cells is often attributed to exhaustion, although many dysfunctional CLL T-cells retain inflammatory cytokine production. We tested whether this paradox reflects immunosenescence, an aging-like program defined by costimulatory loss, DNA damage, inflammatory secretion, repertoire restriction, and proliferative arrest. In response-linked preinfusion CTL019 products, nonresponders and short partial responders had higher senescence and senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) programs than the functional-responder group, comprising complete responders and partial responders with transformed disease. These programs were detectable before infusion and became more prominent during manufacture in susceptible products. They tracked with weak in vivo CAR T-cell expansion and were associated with inferior survival. Serum proteomics revealed a circulating, CLL-associated SASP-like inflammatory milieu in nonresponders. Flow cytometry and T-cell receptor (TCR) profiling showed that poor responders carried CD27⁻CD28⁻ and KLRG1⁺ CD8 T-cells at apheresis, lower product CD27, and reduced product TCR diversity. Research-manufactured CAR T-cells from treatment-naïve CLL samples displayed the same state, most prominently in CD4 CAR T-cells, with SA-β-gal, p16, p53, DNA damage, depletion of less-differentiated states, and senescence-enriched transcriptomes. Under repeated CD19 stimulation, CLL-derived products reached a proliferative ceiling, and p53-high products lost cytotoxic reserve. Ibrutinib improved proliferative fitness, attenuated senescence-associated features and SASP output in paired patient and direct-exposure assays, and enhanced CAR T-cell expansion in an ibrutinib-resistant CLL model. Together, these data identify immunosenescence as a measurable and functionally consequential barrier to CAR T-cell efficacy in CLL and a candidate for therapeutic modulation.

Background: Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cells have repeatedly demonstrated capacity to induce high rates of response and durable remissions for B cell cancers. In contrast, CAR T cells for the treatment of acute myeloid leukemia (AML) have not yet achieved this impact. We previously demonstrated that CD123 is expressed on AML blasts at high frequency, thus making it an attractive target antigen for AML-directed CAR T cells. Methods and Results: We conducted a pilot study of CD123-directed CAR T cells (CART-123) in adults with relapsed or refractory AML. The primary objective was safety with a secondary objective of anti-leukemia efficacy. Twenty-two subjects were screened, and 20 were eligible for the trial. Fludarabine and cyclophosphamide were used for lymphodepletion (LD). Twelve subjects were infused with CART-123. There were two treatment-related deaths due to cytokine release syndrome (CRS) and infection. Four subjects (33%) achieved complete response with incomplete count recovery (CRi), three subjects had progressive disease, and five had stable disease. Of the four who achieved CRi, one subject remains alive in remission after a relapse and subsequent consolidative hematopoietic stem cell transplant (HSCT). One other subject is alive after HSCT following CART-123 failure. There was evidence of CAR T cell expansion and ten subjects (83%) experienced clinical CRS ranging from Grade I to Grade V. There was no neurotoxicity. To address the apparent paradox of high rates of CART-123 bioactivity (clinical CRS and in vivo expansion) co-occurring with low rates of response, we hypothesized that cytokines produced during CRS may undermine the anti-AML effect of CART cells. We obtained serum drawn from trial subjects at baseline (prior to LD chemotherapy) or during CRS. Serum drawn during CRS promotes primary AML survival in cell culture, while matched baseline serum from the same subjects does not. Individual cytokines secreted during CRS that signal through receptors expressed on myeloid progenitors (such as GM-CSF and Flt3 ligand) reproduced this survival advantage in primary AML blasts when tested at physiologically relevant levels. In contrast, these cytokines did not produce a pro-survival effect in primary patient B-ALL blasts. Crucially, candidate myeloid-acting cytokines, as well as serum drawn during the peak of clinical CRS, promoted resistance of AML to killing by CART-123 in vitro. Using scRNAseq of bone marrow aspirates from subjects on this clinical trial, we found that GM-CSF and FLT3L were most frequently expressed by CD4+ T cells. Exposure of primary AML samples to CRS cytokines led to upregulation of signaling (e.g. JAK/STAT5) and pro-survival pathways. In previous work in B-ALL, we showed that relative resistance to killing can translate to a functional deficit in CART-19 due to development of exhaustion in the CART cells. We similarly find that that exposure to GM-CSF reduces AML blast sensitivity to CART-123, and that the persistence of antigen leads to exhaustion in CART cells (Figure 1). Specifically, co-incubation of CART-123 cells and cytokine-exposed primary AML blasts leads to increased populations of PD-1+/CD39+/CTLA4+/LAG3+ CAR T cells, consistent with an exhaustion phenotype. Finally, we found that anti-apoptotic effects of cytokines can be prevented, and CART-123 killing of AML can be restored, via ruxolitinib blockade of JAK/STAT signaling in both in vitro and in vivo settings. Significance: Our work reveals CRS as active in undermining CART-123 lethality first by promoting survival of AML, and subsequently by exhausting CAR T cells. This is in stark contrast to its role in lymphoid malignancies and underscores biological differences in myeloid versus lymphoid neoplasms. These results highlight a need to tailor therapy to limit cytokine effects on AML blasts to improve outcomes with AML-directed CAR T cell therapy.