Comstock, Chris

Abstract Background: Despite its widespread adoption, there is a lack of data as to whether breast MRI for local staging and surgical planning of newly diagnosed breast cancer patients improves oncologic outcomes. The Alliance A011104 phase III trial was designed to test the hypothesis that MRI detection of mammographically occult disease helps to tailor surgical intervention thereby reducing local recurrence and improving local regional control. Here we report on the primary outcome of 5-year local regional recurrence. Methods: Patients with newly diagnosed clinical stage I-II, ER/PR- and HER2- negative (triple- negative) or ER/PR-negative and HER2-positive breast cancer, deemed eligible for breast- conserving surgery (BCS) based on clinical exam, mammography +/- ultrasound were randomized to undergo staging breast MRI or no further local staging. Patients with multifocal tumors that could be encompassed in a single operative resection were eligible. Patients who were carriers of gBRCA 1/2, or who had bilateral breast cancer, or a prior history of breast cancer were excluded. Initial eligibility was limited to patients not scheduled to receive neoadjuvant chemotherapy; however, a subsequent amendment allowed for enrollment after completion of neoadjuvant chemotherapy. Categorical variables were compared between arms with a chi-square or Fisher’s exact test. LRR, distant recurrence and overall survival (OS) were estimated with Kaplan-Meier point estimates and 95% confidence intervals (CIs). Hazard ratios (HRs) and 95% CIs were obtained from Cox proportional hazards models. Results: Of 319 patients enrolled from 2/2014-12/2019,161 were randomized to undergo breast MRI and 158 to no breast MRI evaluation. The mean age at enrollment was 58.9 years (range 29-85). Most patients (72.1%) had T1 tumors, 93.4% were cN0 and 19.7% were HER2 positive. Systemic chemotherapy was utilized in 85% with 17.6% receiving treatment neoadjuvantly; receipt of systemic therapy was unknown for 15 patients (4.7%). Two hundred and ninety-eight patients (93.4%) underwent surgical intervention; 91.9% underwent BCS as initial surgical procedure with no significant differences noted between groups (92.7% in the no MRI group and 91.9% in the MRI group [p=0.62]). Of patients who underwent breast surgery, 293 underwent axillary evaluation with the majority (270 patients, 92%) undergoing sentinel lymph node biopsy as the only axillary intervention. Among patients who received neoadjuvant chemotherapy, the overall pathologic complete response rate was 39.3%, 29.0%in the MRI arm vs. 52.0% no MRI arm (p=0.10). Receipt of adjuvant radiation was comparable between arms, 85.4% and 85.0% receiving radiation in the no MRI and MRI arms, respectively. Among 298 patients evaluable for the primary endpoint, with median follow-up of 61.1 months (0.2, 68.1), there were no differences in rates of LRR; 5-year local regional control was 93.2% (89.0-97.6%) in the MRI group and 95.7% (92.3-99.1%) in the no MRI group (HR: 1.1, 95% CI: 0.3, 3.9). For the entire cohort, 5-year distant recurrence-free rate and OS were 94.3% (91.7, 97.1) and 92.2% (89.1, 95.4), respectively, with no differences between groups. Conclusions: With multimodality therapy, rates of 5-year LRR in patients with early stage triple- negative and HER2-positive breast cancer are very low. Breast MRI for local staging and surgical planning in this setting does not result in improved local regional control. Support: U10CA180821, U10CA180882; UG1CA189823; U10CA180868 (NRG Oncology); ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01805076; https://acknowledgments.alliancefound.org Citation Format: I. Bedrosian, K. Ballman, L. M. McCall, C. E. Comstock, G. W. Unzeitig, T. Yen, A. Weiss, B. G. Haffty, J. M. Bensenhaver, S. M. DeSnyder, J. J. Liu, A. H. Partridge, L. A. Carey, K. K. Hunt.Effect of Preoperative Breast MRI Staging on Local Regional Recurrence (LRR) in Early Stage Breast cancer: Alliance A011104/ACRIN 6694 [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium 2025; 2025 Dec 9-12; San Antonio, TX. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Clin Cancer Res 2026;32(4 Suppl):Abstract nr GS2-07.

Abstract Background Surgical planning and local-regional treatment of breast cancer relies on accurate assessment of disease extent including the primary tumor size and the presence/absence of multiple tumor foci. As a staging modality for breast cancer, MRI has shown high sensitivity for detection of additional foci of diseases within the index breast. However, the impact of preoperative breast MRI on reducing re-excision rates and improving local control is less clear. Data from the COMICE trial in the UK suggested that routine use of pre-operative breast MRI did not alter rates of re-excision; however issues have been raised about the lack of quality standards for the MR imaging that may have resulted in the negative results of this trial. Retrospective data suggest that local recurrence is not impacted by use of breast MRI. In concert with data showing no improvement in clinical outcomes of breast cancer patients, concerns have been raised that routine use of preoperative breast MRI is associated with increased rates of mastectomy and delays to surgery. Therefore, the application of MRI for preoperative surgical staging remains controversial. In order to address this ongoing controversy, a joint effort has been launched by ACOSOG and ACRIN for a prospective clinical trial focused on evaluating the impact of preoperative breast MRI on clinically relevant patient outcomes. An important part of this collaboration is implementation of standards of how MRI findings should be clinically managed and used to direct localization methods and surgical planning, thereby creating guidelines for subsequent patient intervention. Trial design/eligibility criteria: A prospective multicenter trial will include women eligible for BCT by standard criteria and randomized between current standard of care, clinical examination and mammography (+/− ultrasound) and the same plus preoperative breast MRI. The study will focus on women at the highest risk of local recurrence: ER/PR/HER-2 negative (triple negative) and HER-2 amplified breast cancers. Specific aims: To compare the rates of local recurrence following breast conserving therapy in a cohort randomized to preoperative staging with mammography or mammography plus breast MRI. Additionally, a comparison of rates of re-operation, time to local recurrence, survival outcomes, contralateral breast cancer rates, rates of multicentric disease and other secondary aims will be performed. Costs and quality of life measures will also be investigated. Statistical methods: A stratified logrank test and Cox partial likelihood score test will be used to assess whether the distribution of LR times differs with respect to diagnostic work-up approach having adjusted for tumor stage. Cox modeling with the Cox partial likelihood score test will be used to examine the strength of association between these time to event distributions and such additional potential prognostic factors as menopausal status, chemotherapy, radiation therapy, ER, PR, number of positive lymph nodes, HER-2/neu expression, Nottingham grade, and Ki-67 expression. Target Accrual: 556 patients Citation Information: Cancer Res 2011;71(24 Suppl):Abstract nr OT2-05-06.