Tonelli, Celsa

Abstract The optimal management of diverticulitis in young and immunocompromised patients remains controversial, particularly regarding whether these groups warrant a lower threshold for surgery. Historically, young patients were often offered elective colectomy after the first episode of diverticulitis because of concerns regarding recurrence and more aggressive disease. However, contemporary evidence shows that although younger patients may experience higher recurrence rates, they are not at increased risk for complicated recurrence, emergency surgery, or mortality compared with older adults. Nonoperative management is successful in most cases, supporting an individualized rather than age-based surgical approach. Immunocompromised patients, including those with solid organ transplantation, malignancy, chemotherapy exposure, chronic steroid use, or autoimmune disease requiring immunosuppression, represent a higher-risk population. These patients more commonly present with complicated diverticulitis, perforation, sepsis, and atypical symptoms that may delay diagnosis. Although uncomplicated disease can often be managed nonoperatively, immunocompromised patients experience higher rates of emergent surgery, stoma creation, postoperative complications, and mortality, particularly when surgery is performed in a non-elective setting. Current evidence does not support lowering the surgical threshold solely on the basis of young age or immunosuppression status. Instead, management should remain individualized, incorporating disease severity, recurrence pattern, comorbidities, operative risk, and patient preferences. Further research is needed to better define optimal surgical timing and patient selection in these two populations.