Background: Facial appearance influences social perception, with laypersons focusing on the central facial triangle; nasal differences may alter gaze patterns, but few studies have quantified this using eye-tracking. Objective: To evaluate how layperson gaze patterns shift in response to different nasal variations as measured by eye-tracking. Methods: In this prospective cohort study, facial images with 30 nasal differences were created using Photoshop to represent a range of phenotypes, such as dorsal hump, crooked nose, and pinched tip, alongside controls. Gaze data were captured via eye-tracking, and linear mixed-effects modeling assessed differences in time spent viewing defined areas of interest, adjusting for participant and image variables. Results: A total of 119 participants (53.8% female) were enrolled. The median age was 40 years, and 82% identified as Caucasian. Among the 30 nasal alterations, only the saddle nose resulted in significantly increased gaze time compared to controls (mean increase: 0.89 s; p < 0.001). Participant age, sex, and gender of the face in the image did not significantly influence gaze behavior. Conclusion: In this study, only the saddle nose attracted greater visual attention from lay observers compared with other nasal variants.