Background Cancers persist despite expression of immunogenic neoantigens and ongoing antitumor immune responses. While some occult tumors likely are cleared by effective antitumor immune responses, the targeted antigens are not easily identifiable as those tumors spontaneously disappear. Methods We used mouse models with a defined antigenic protein mimicking tumor-specific neoantigens to address the nature of these spontaneous anti-tumor immune responses. Results BALB/c (H-2d ) mice challenged with BALB/c breast tumors expressing the rat-erbB2 oncoprotein succumb to their tumors despite ongoing immune responses targeting tumor-specific model antigens. Meanwhile, congenic BALB.B (H-2b ) and H-2d/H-2b F1 hybrid mice spontaneously eliminate genetically matched tumors in a major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-II dependent manner. Adoptive transfer and immune cell depletion strategies revealed CD4+ T cells and CD20+ B cells are crucial mediators of the protective response in H-2b mice. Furthermore, passive transfer of immune serum from mice rejecting their tumors confers resistance in tumor antigen-tolerant animals with an inversely proportional relationship between tumor outgrowth and the amount of rat-erbB2 specific antibody present in tumor-bearing mice. Introduction of the rat-erb2 ectodomain into other H-2b tumor models also promotes their spontaneous tumor rejection. Notably, the tumor microenvironments differ in rat-erbB2+ tumor-bearing BALB.B and BALB/c mice at the time of fate decision in the models reflecting the differences between effective and ineffective tumor immune responses. Conclusions We find that the effective antitumor immunity targeting neoantigens in these breast cancer models is determined by MHC-II-restricted presentation of optimal cancer-associated antigens. These responses are dependent on CD4+ T cells, B cells, and antigen-specific antibodies.