Froemming, Mitchell N.

Cellular senescence is a heterogeneous phenotype characterized primarily in mesenchymal cells, but the extent to which immune cells differ in their senescence phenotype, or “senotype,” is unclear. Here, we applied single-cell approaches alongside both global and cell-specific genetic senolytic mouse models to evaluate the senotype of immune cells in the bone marrow of aging mice. We found that myeloid-lineage cells exhibited the highest expression of p16 and senescence-associated secretory phenotype markers among all immune cell types. In contrast with clearance of p16 + senescent mesenchymal cells, targeted clearance of p16 + myeloid cells in aged mice had only minor effects on age-related bone loss in male mice, with no effects in females. In more detailed analyses, p16 + myeloid cells were only acutely cleared, being repopulated back to basal levels within a short time. This led to a lack of long-lasting reduction in senescent cell burden, unlike when targeting bone mesenchymal cells. In vitro, myeloid-lineage cells differed markedly from mesenchymal cells in the development of a senescent phenotype. Collectively, our findings indicate that aged bone marrow myeloid cells do not achieve the fully developed senescent phenotype originally described in mesenchymal cells, justifying further characterization of senotypes of immune cells across tissues.

ABSTRACT There is an increasing need for biomarkers of senescent cell burden to facilitate the selection of participants for clinical trials. p16 Ink4a is encoded by the CDKN2A locus, which produces five variant transcripts in humans, two of which encode homologous p16 proteins: p16 Inka4a , encoded by p16_variant 1 , and p16ɣ, encoded by p16_variant 5. While distinct quantitative polymerase chain reaction primers can be designed for p16_variant 5, primers for p16_variant 1 also measure p16_variant 5 ( p16_variant 1 + 5 ). In a recent clinical trial evaluating the effects of the senolytic combination, dasatinib + quercetin (D + Q), on bone metabolism in postmenopausal women, we found that women in the highest tertile for T‐cell expression of p16_variant 5 had the most robust skeletal responses to D + Q. Importantly, the assessment of p16_variant 5 was more predictive of these responses than p16_variant 1 + 5 . Here, we demonstrate that in vitro, p16_variant 1 + 5 increased rapidly (Week 1) following the induction of DNA damage, whereas p16_variant 5 increased later (Week 4), suggesting that p16_variant 5 becomes detectable only when the abundance of senescent cells reaches some threshold. Further analysis identified a SASP panel in plasma that performed as well in identifying postmenopausal women with a positive skeletal response to D + Q. Collectively, our findings provide further support for the T‐cell p16_variant 5 assay as a biomarker for selecting participants in clinical trials of senolytic interventions. In addition, our data indicate that correlated plasma SASP markers could be used in lieu of the more technically challenging T‐cell p16 assay. Trial Registration: ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT04313634.

Cells expressing features of senescence, including upregulation of p21 and p16, appear transiently following tissue injury, yet the properties of these cells or how they contrast with age-induced senescent cells remains unclear. Here, we used skeletal injury as a model and identified the rapid appearance following fracture of p21 + cells expressing senescence markers, mainly as osteochondroprogenitors (OCHs) and neutrophils. Targeted genetic clearance of p21 + cells suppressed senescence-associated signatures within the fracture callus and accelerated fracture healing. By contrast, p21 + cell clearance did not alter bone loss due to aging; conversely, p16 + cell clearance, known to alleviate skeletal aging, did not affect fracture healing. Following fracture, p21 + neutrophils were enriched in signaling pathways known to induce paracrine stromal senescence, while p21 + OCHs were highly enriched in senescence-associated secretory phenotype factors known to impair bone formation. Further analysis revealed an injury-specific stem cell–like OCH subset that was p21 + and highly inflammatory, with a similar inflammatory mesenchymal population (fibro-adipogenic progenitors) evident following muscle injury. Thus, intercommunicating senescent-like neutrophils and mesenchymal progenitor cells were key regulators of tissue repair in bone and potentially across tissues. Moreover, our findings established contextual roles of p21 + versus p16 + senescent/senescent-like cells that may be leveraged for therapeutic opportunities.