Stepanchick, Emily

Abstract Germline variants in DDX41 are the most frequent genetic predisposition to adult hematologic malignancies. The most common variants are truncating, implicating loss of function in the pathogenesis. However, non-truncating variants account for 30-40% of cases, and their impact on essential DDX41 functions remains unknown. We utilized a genetic complementation assay to assess the functionality of 10 recurrent germline non-truncating variants of DDX41. All variants restored viability to Ddx41 -deficient hematopoietic progenitor cells at exogenous expression levels. In contrast, the hotspot mutant p.R525H, which is somatically acquired at disease onset in >50% of patients, failed to restore viability. CRISPR-based modeling in cell lines and mice revealed heterogeneity: some variants were non-functional at endogenous expression levels whereas others maintained complete functionality, supporting normal cell proliferation and even lifelong hematopoiesis in a homozygous setting. Notably, co-expression of p.R525H with some variants caused impaired hematopoietic progenitor cell viability, indicating a dominant-negative effect of p.R525H. In contrast, other variants, all classified as variants of unknown significance, were unaffected by the presence of p.R525H. A screen of 100 disease-associated variants confirmed that many non-truncating germline variants are susceptible to p.R525H-mediated dominant-negative effects, whereas wild-type DDX41 is not. These findings indicate that DDX41 variant curation is complicated by variable effects on functionality and variant-specific interactions with somatically-acquired DDX41 mutations. The dominant-negative effect of p.R525H provides a mechanistic basis for the conclusion of recent patient cohort analyses that co-occurrence with a somatic hotspot mutation is a reliable indicator of DDX41-driven disease in carriers of non-truncating variants.

Abstract Germline mutations in the RNA-helicase gene DDX41 cause predisposition to myeloid malignancies (MDS/AML) with a penetrance of 50% by age 90. DDX41 germline mutations are heterozygous and predominantly truncating variants, indicative of loss-of-function. More than half of DDX41-mutated carriers that develop MDS/AML will acquire a second-hit mutation in the other allele of DDX41, frequently causing the amino acid substitution p.R525H. Single-cell analysis from a biallelic DDX41-mutated MDS patient showed that the p.R525H mutation was highly enriched in dendritic cells (DCs) but less frequent in other cell types. We hypothesized that p.R525H causes the hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs) to differentiate preferentially into DC. To precisely model the germline of DDX41-mut patients, we generated human induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSC) with a frameshift mutation in exon 6 of one allele of DDX41, modeling the most common germline mutation. We attempted to modify the other allele of DDX41 to express the p.R525H mutation but could not derive viable cells. To circumvent potential lethality of the acquired mutation, we inserted a Doxycycline (DOX)-inducible wild-type DDX41 expression cassette in the AAVS1 safe harbor locus. Then we modified the endogenous allele to cause the p.R525H mutation in trans to the existing frameshift mutation. In this manner, we derived iPSCs that would model the most common configuration of DDX41 mutations (DDX41R525H/-) upon the withdrawal of DOX from the culture. In undifferentiated iPSC cultures, we observed profound defects in cell proliferation and survival upon DOX withdrawal. To determine the effect of the p.R525H mutation on hematopoietic cells, we differentiated the iPSCs into CD34+ HSPCs in the presence of DOX, and then withdrew DOX and studied the effect of the DDX41R525H/- genotype on HSPC function. In colony formation assays, DDX41R525H/- cells produced fewer and smaller myeloid and erythroid colonies after DOX withdrawal. In liquid culture, DDX41R525H/- cells showed cell cycle arrest by EdU incorporation assay and protein synthesis deficit by HPG assay. Thus, we conclude that DDX41 is required for proliferation and survival in iPSC and hematopoietic progenitor cells and that p.R525H lacks the essential function. Next, we tracked HSPC differentiation in liquid culture containing Flt3 ligand, stem cell factor and thrombopoietin with or without GM-CSF. Identification of DC subsets by flow cytometry was based on the literature (Sontag S, et al. Stem Cells 2017;35(4)). We observed reduced overall differentiation in DDX41R525H/- cultures, evidenced by maintenance of CD34 positivity. However, among the CD45+CD34- cells, DDX41R525H/- cells were 3-4 fold more likely to be identified as plasmacytoid DC (pDC) compared to control conditions (+DOX or DDX41+/- cells). Notably, in DDX41R525H/- CD45+CD34- cells, overall CD123 and CD304 expression were profoundly upregulated and CD11c was downregulated, indicative of increased pDC character. We used a similar DOX-inducible approach to generate Molm13 human AML cell line with DDX41R525H/- and homozygous knockout (DDX41-/-) genotype and found that these cells had profound survival defects. Both genotypes exhibited DC-like morphological change with extended multiple projections upon DOX withdrawal. In flow cytometry analysis, both genotypes exhibited upregulated Clec9a (conventional DC1 (cDC1) marker) and Clec10a and CD1c (cDC2 marker) upon DOX withdrawal. DDX41R525H/- cells specifically exhibited pDC features shown by upregulated CD123 by flow cytometry and increased IRF7 by western blotting, while DDX41-/- had decreased IRF7. Furthermore, we found that DDX41R525H/- cells specifically showed increased IRF9 and phosphorylated STAT1 and STAT2, which are downstream of interferon receptor activation, indicating that type-I interferon produced by DDX41R525H/- pDC activates interferon signaling in autocrine/paracrine manner. These results indicate that p.R525H promotes differentiation into pDC, which is not observed in DDX41-/- cells. In conclusion, DDX41 p.R525H mutation has bimodal functions in HSPC: loss-of-function for proliferation/survival and gain-of-function for skewed differentiation into pDC. Dysregulated DCs may contribute to the pathogenesis of DDX41-mutated MDS/AML, particularly in light of recent descriptions of AML with pDC differentiation and the broader role of DC dysregulation in MDS/AML.

Abstract Heterozygous germline variants of DDX41 occur in 2-4% of adult Myelodysplastic Syndrome (MDS) and Acute Myeloid Leukemia (AML) cases, making them the most prevalent cause of inherited predisposition to these diseases. Homozygous deleterious variants are never observed in the germline, and loss of both DDX41 alleles causes apoptosis of proliferative cells, consistent with essentiality. Most disease-associated germline variants cause loss of full-length protein expression (truncating). However, 30-40% are missense (non-truncating) and their role in disease risk compared to truncating variants remains in question. Previous reports have shown that both truncating and non-truncating Pathogenic/Likely Pathogenic (P/LP) variants (defined by ACMG scoring) are associated with DDX41-specific disease features, including co-mutation of the contralateral allele of DDX41. In contrast, variants of unknown significance (VUS) are less associated with these features. Acquired co-mutations of DDX41, of which p.R525H accounts for 50-70%, are restricted to DDX41-mutated patients and are always missense. Our previous studies indicated that p.R525H lacks the essential DDX41 function and cannot support hematopoietic progenitor proliferation. However, the frequency with which this mutation occurs and the absence of acquired truncating mutations suggest that p.R525H has a specific effect on DDX41 function that is distinct from complete loss and promotes pathogenesis specifically in the context of existing P/LP DDX41 mutation. To understand how germline non-truncating variants predispose to disease, we characterized the effect of six recurrent non-truncating P/LP variants (p.G173R, p.R219H, p.P258L, p.Y259C, p.K331del, and p.I396T) and three VUS (p.K9E, p.Y33H, and p.M155H) on DDX41 function. We utilized a genetic complementation approach in murine lineage-negative (Linneg) bone marrow cells with inducible deletion of DDX41. We found that all non-truncating P/LP and VUS forms of DDX41 could fully rescue the colony forming potential of Ddx41-deficient cells to a similar level as wild-type protein, whereas the p.R525H variant completely failed to rescue. To determine the effect of the non-truncating variants on DDX41 function at endogenous expression levels, we utilized CRISPR to modify the DDX41 alleles in MOLM13 human AML cells. We produced viable, proliferating cell lines with homozygous mutations for all 3 VUS and 4/6 P/LP variants. For p.P258L and p.K331del, like p.R525H, we could not produce homozygous mutant cell lines despite screening hundreds of clones and finding several with heterozygosity. To further study the P/LP variants that were functional in the cell line, we generated C57Bl/6 mouse lines harboring p.G173R, p.Y259C, and p.I396T mutations in the endogenous Ddx41 alleles. Heterozygous mutant mice were phenotypically normal in all three strains. However, we could not obtain homozygous mutant mice for p.G173R or p.Y259C, indicating these cannot support embryonic/fetal development. In contrast, p.I396T-homozygous mutant mice were born at Mendelian ratios and were phenotypically normal until at least 15 months of age. Since p.R525H mutation is common in patients with non-truncating P/LP variants, we sought to model the combined effect of these mutations. We utilized the Linneg cells with inducible knockout of Ddx41, co-expressed each non-truncating variant with p.R525H by viral transduction, and monitored the colony formation potential. Remarkably, cultures expressing P/LP variants or M155I combined with p.R525H had dramatically reduced colony formation, while wild-type DDX41 and the other 2 VUS supported normal colony formation when co-expressed with p.R525H. Thus, we conclude p.R525H has a dominant-negative effect on certain non-truncating DDX41 variants. This is consistent with the emerging idea that the presence of an acquired hotspot DDX41 co-mutation is sufficient to classify a non-truncating DDX41 variant as pathogenic.Our results demonstrate that many DDX41 missense variants retain protein function when overexpressed. However, at endogenous expression levels, some P/LP variants are unable to support cell proliferation, indicative of hypomorphic effects on protein function. In patients, acquisition of the p.R525H mutation in the contralateral allele disrupts the functionality of P/LP variants through dominant-negative effects, leading to hematopoietic progenitor defects that are hallmark of the DDX41 pathogenesis.

Germline variants in DDX41 are the most common cause of inherited predisposition to Myelodysplastic Syndromes (MDS) and Acute Myeloid Leukemia (AML). DDX41 codes for an RNA helicase with many described functions, and thus the precise role of these variants in disease is uncertain. Approximately 2/3 of disease-associated DDX41 variants cause truncation of the DDX41 protein due to frameshift, loss of a translation start, or splice alterations, while the other 1/3 of DDX41 variants are missense. The effect of these missense variants on DDX41 function is largely unknown and thus they are typically categorized as variants of unknown significance (VUSs). Importantly, 30-50% of MDS/AML patients with either truncating or missense DDX41 variants acquire a somatic mutation in the other allele of DDX41, and this mutation has strong preference for the amino acid substitution R525H. Our previous work demonstrated that the R525H mutation causes loss of DDX41 function. To better understand how germline variants affect DDX41 function, we designed a genetic complementation strategy in immortalized hematopoietic progenitor cells with inducible deletion of DDX41. We screened six of the most common missense VUSs by expressing them from a lentivirus in DDX41-proficient cells and then inducing deletion of endogenous DDX41 to determine the effect of each VUS on proliferation and survival of the cells. Empty vector-transduced DDX41-deleted cells undergo cell-cycle arrest and apoptosis within 3-4 days. In contrast, viral expression of wild-type DDX41 rescues the survival and proliferation of the cells, while expression of the R525H mutant fails to rescue the cells. We screened the Y33H, M155H, G173R, R219H, P258L, and I396T variants of DDX41 in this assay, and all six of the mutants successfully rescued the survival and proliferation of DDX41-deleted cells long-term. This indicates that the mutant proteins coded for by these variants are functional. To test the effect of commonly observed truncating variants in the same assay, we expressed M1I, Q52fs, and D140Gfs variants of DDX41. Surprisingly, we saw complete rescue of cell proliferation and survival by the M1I and Q52fs variants. In contrast, the D140Gfs variant failed to rescue the cells. These data indicate that frameshift at D140 or later causes loss of DDX41 function. It is likely that translation from alternative methionine residues located at M127 or M132 of DDX41 accounts for the rescue of the cells by truncating variants affecting sites upstream of M127. In support of this theory, we targeted DDX41 for CRISPR-mediated knockout in MOLM13 cells and found that guide RNAs targeting exons 1-4, which are upstream of M127, produced homozygous frameshift mutations in proliferating cells from single-cell clones. However, guides targeting exon 6, which is downstream of M127 and M132, did not produce any surviving cells with homozygous frameshift mutations, despite screening 96 clones. This finding indicates that short DDX41 isoforms expressed from alternative start sites are functional and can support cell proliferation when full-length protein is lost. Collectively, these data raise important questions about the precise role of DDX41 variants in hematologic malignancy. Data from recently published patient cohorts indicates that patients with missense DDX41 variants have similar patient characteristics to those with truncating variants and thus these aberrations are thought to cause disease by similar mechanisms. While these cell line models may not fully recapitulate the pathogenic mechanism by which DDX41 variants cause MDS/AML predisposition, the results of this study demonstrate that the germline variants are not complete loss-of-function alleles in all cases and more complex mechanisms may be involved.