The authors developed a new disease-specific patient-reported outcome measure to capture the multifaceted impacts of vestibular schwannoma on daily life, the Vestibular Schwannoma Quality of Life (VSQOL) Index, which contains 40 items grouped into eight categories: hearing problems; dizziness and imbalance; pain, discomfort, and tinnitus; problems with face or eyes; impact on physical, emotional, and social well-being; difficulty with thinking and memory; satisfaction or regret; and impact on employment. 1 The VSQOL Index was developed in English, although the availability of this instrument in other languages can improve access to quality of life (QOL) research worldwide with enhanced racial, ethnic, and geographic representation. The authors partnered with FACITtrans, a component of the Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy (FACIT) group with more than 25 years of experience in translation, cultural adaptation, and linguistic validation of patient-reported outcome measures, to translate the VSQOL Index to French using a rigorous translation methodology. 2–5 The translation of the VSQOL Index presented at the end of this article may be used for noncommercial research, clinical, or educational purposes without seeking written permission from the authors. By providing a suite of translations in this digital supplement of the Journal of Neurosurgery , the authors hope to increase the reach and breadth of QOL research and facilitate international collaborations.
Simplified Chinese translation of the Mayo Clinic Vestibular Schwannoma Quality of Life Index
The authors developed a new disease-specific patient-reported outcome measure to capture the multifaceted impacts of vestibular schwannoma on daily life, the Vestibular Schwannoma Quality of Life (VSQOL) Index, which contains 40 items grouped into eight categories: hearing problems; dizziness and imbalance; pain, discomfort, and tinnitus; problems with face or eyes; impact on physical, emotional, and social well-being; difficulty with thinking and memory; satisfaction or regret; and impact on employment. 1 The VSQOL Index was developed in English, although the availability of this instrument in other languages can improve access to quality of life (QOL) research worldwide with enhanced racial, ethnic, and geographic representation. The authors partnered with FACITtrans, a component of the Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy (FACIT) group with more than 25 years of experience in translation, cultural adaptation, and linguistic validation of patient-reported outcome measures, to translate the VSQOL Index to Simplified Chinese using a rigorous translation methodology. 2–5 The translation of the VSQOL Index presented at the end of this article may be used for noncommercial research, clinical, or educational purposes without seeking written permission from the authors. By providing a suite of translations in this digital supplement of the Journal of Neurosurgery , the authors hope to increase the reach and breadth of QOL research and facilitate international collaborations.
Arabic translation of the Mayo Clinic Vestibular Schwannoma Quality of Life Index
The authors developed a new disease-specific patient-reported outcome measure to capture the multifaceted impacts of vestibular schwannoma on daily life, the Vestibular Schwannoma Quality of Life (VSQOL) Index, which contains 40 items grouped into eight categories: hearing problems; dizziness and imbalance; pain, discomfort, and tinnitus; problems with face or eyes; impact on physical, emotional, and social well-being; difficulty with thinking and memory; satisfaction or regret; and impact on employment. 1 The VSQOL Index was developed in English, although the availability of this instrument in other languages can improve access to quality of life (QOL) research worldwide with enhanced racial, ethnic, and geographic representation. The authors partnered with FACITtrans, a component of the Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy (FACIT) group with more than 25 years of experience in translation, cultural adaptation, and linguistic validation of patient-reported outcome measures, to translate the VSQOL Index to Arabic using a rigorous translation methodology. 2–5 The translation of the VSQOL Index presented at the end of this article may be used for noncommercial research, clinical, or educational purposes without seeking written permission from the authors. By providing a suite of translations in this digital supplement of the Journal of Neurosurgery , the authors hope to increase the reach and breadth of QOL research and facilitate international collaborations.
Spanish translation of the Mayo Clinic Vestibular Schwannoma Quality of Life Index
The authors developed a new disease-specific patient-reported outcome measure to capture the multifaceted impacts of vestibular schwannoma on daily life, the Vestibular Schwannoma Quality of Life (VSQOL) Index, which contains 40 items grouped into eight categories: hearing problems; dizziness and imbalance; pain, discomfort, and tinnitus; problems with face or eyes; impact on physical, emotional, and social well-being; difficulty with thinking and memory; satisfaction or regret; and impact on employment. 1 The VSQOL Index was developed in English, although the availability of this instrument in other languages can improve access to quality of life (QOL) research worldwide with enhanced racial, ethnic, and geographic representation. The authors partnered with FACITtrans, a component of the Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy (FACIT) group with more than 25 years of experience in translation, cultural adaptation, and linguistic validation of patient-reported outcome measures, to translate the VSQOL Index to Spanish using a rigorous translation methodology. 2–5 The translation of the VSQOL Index presented at the end of this article may be used for noncommercial research, clinical, or educational purposes without seeking written permission from the authors. By providing a suite of translations in this digital supplement of the Journal of Neurosurgery , the authors hope to increase the reach and breadth of QOL research and facilitate international collaborations.
Japanese translation of the Mayo Clinic Vestibular Schwannoma Quality of Life Index
The authors developed a new disease-specific patient-reported outcome measure to capture the multifaceted impacts of vestibular schwannoma on daily life, the Vestibular Schwannoma Quality of Life (VSQOL) Index, which contains 40 items grouped into eight categories: hearing problems; dizziness and imbalance; pain, discomfort, and tinnitus; problems with face or eyes; impact on physical, emotional, and social well-being; difficulty with thinking and memory; satisfaction or regret; and impact on employment. 1 The VSQOL Index was developed in English, although the availability of this instrument in other languages can improve access to quality of life (QOL) research worldwide with enhanced racial, ethnic, and geographic representation. The authors partnered with FACITtrans, a component of the Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy (FACIT) group with more than 25 years of experience in translation, cultural adaptation, and linguistic validation of patient-reported outcome measures, to translate the VSQOL Index to Japanese using a rigorous translation methodology. 2–5 The translation of the VSQOL Index presented at the end of this article may be used for noncommercial research, clinical, or educational purposes without seeking written permission from the authors. By providing a suite of translations in this digital supplement of the Journal of Neurosurgery , the authors hope to increase the reach and breadth of QOL research and facilitate international collaborations.
A Multi-Institutional Analysis of Device Failures in a Recent Cochlear Implant Series
Objective To assess Advanced Bionics (AB) HiRes Ultra and Ultra 3D initial version (V1) cochlear implant electrode failures over time at four large cochlear implant programs. Study Design Retrospective cohort. Setting Four tertiary referral centers. Patients Patients receiving AB HiRes Ultra and Ultra 3D initial version (V1) devices as of December 31, 2022. Main Outcome Measures Failure rate, revision surgery, speech recognition scores. Results Over a span of 7 years, 205 (42.6%) of 483 implanted V1 devices have failed. Device failure rate varied across institutions from 32 to 67%. Of the 205 detected failures, 163 (79%) have undergone revision surgery, with 94% of revisions being performed with Advanced Bionics devices. Average time from implantation to diagnosis of device failure was 2.7 ± 1.2 years. Most patients (89.8%) with available testing were matched or exceeded their best prefailure speech performance after implant revision. After revision, patients had an average CNC score improvement of 24.7 percentage points over their most recent pre-revision scores and demonstrated average datalogging of 12.7 ± 4.1 h/d at most recent evaluation. Conclusions Comparison of patients across multiple high-volume implant centers confirms the presence of ongoing device failures. There is variability across institutions in the rate of revision surgery once a patient is diagnosed with a V1 device failure, as well as in the rate of device failure detection. Inter-institutional variability in failure rates may be explained by the variation in the routine use of electrical field imaging. Reimplantation with a new device typically results in a return to prefailure peak performance. Professional Practice Gap & Educational Need To our knowledge, a comparison of AB HiRes (V1) device failures across multiple institutions has not been conducted. Learning Objective To identify device failure rate across multiple institutions with different testing protocols. Desired Result Providers will have an improved understanding of the trajectory of device failures for HiRes (V1) devices over time. Level of Evidence Level IV—Historical cohort or case-controlled studies. Indicate IRB or IACUC IRB #230017; IRB #22-000183; IRB #STU-032018-085; IRB #H-49479.
Longitudinal Trends in Cochlear Implant Programming from a Single-Institution Review of Over 400 Adult Implant Recipients: Evidence to Support Selective De-Escalation of Device Programming
Objective To examine comfort (C) and threshold (T) levels in adult cochlear implant (CI) recipients over the first 18 months postactivation. Study Design Retrospective review of longitudinal CI programming data. Setting Tertiary academic center. Patients A total of 480 CIs among 428 adult CI recipients. Interventions Cochlear implantation with Cochlear Ltd. devices with subsequent programming to behavioral standards using Custom Sound® fitting software. Main Outcome Measures Charge levels needed to achieve C and T levels were measured longitudinally using Custom Sound®, from time of activation to a minimum of 6 and a maximum of 18 months postactivation. Charge (nC) levels were calculated as the product of pulse width (μs) and current amplitude (μA) to standardize among implant models. Changes in C and T charge levels over time were evaluated using repeated-measures analysis of variance. Results When considering the entire electrode, the largest increases were seen at 1 month postactivation, and C and T charge levels did not increase significantly after 6 and 12 months, respectively. These findings were consistent across patient age at implantation and sex. When considering proximal electrodes only, C and T levels did not increase significantly after 6 months. In distal electrodes only, C levels did not increase significantly after 6 months, but T levels continued to demonstrate small, but statistically significant increases up to 18 months postactivation. Conclusions Across the entire electrode, we observed the largest changes in C and T charge levels at 1 month postactivation. Small increases in C and T levels continued out to 6 and 12 months, respectively, but may be of limited clinical significance. The stability of programming levels over time may support selective de-escalation of CI follow-up after the initial postactivation period, but, given small yet persistent increases with time, most notably in the distal electrodes, alternatives for follow-up or remote programming may still be encouraged.
Quality of Information Provided by Artificial Intelligence Chatbots Surrounding the Management of Vestibular Schwannomas: A Comparative Analysis Between ChatGPT-4 and Claude 2
Objective To examine the quality of information provided by artificial intelligence platforms ChatGPT-4 and Claude 2 surrounding the management of vestibular schwannomas. Study design Cross-sectional. Setting Skull base surgeons were involved from different centers and countries. Intervention Thirty-six questions regarding vestibular schwannoma management were tested. Artificial intelligence responses were subsequently evaluated by 19 lateral skull base surgeons using the Quality Assessment of Medical Artificial Intelligence (QAMAI) questionnaire, assessing “Accuracy,” “Clarity,” “Relevance,” “Completeness,” “Sources,” and “Usefulness.” Main Outcome Measure The scores of the answers from both chatbots were collected and analyzed using the Student t test. Analysis of responses grouped by stakeholders was performed with McNemar test. Stuart-Maxwell test was used to compare reading level among chatbots. Intraclass correlation coefficient was calculated. Results ChatGPT-4 demonstrated significantly improved quality over Claude 2 in 14 of 36 (38.9%) questions, whereas higher-quality scores for Claude 2 were only observed in 2 (5.6%) answers. Chatbots exhibited variation across the dimensions of “Accuracy,” “Clarity,” “Completeness,” “Relevance,” and “Usefulness,” with ChatGPT-4 demonstrating a statistically significant superior performance. However, no statistically significant difference was found in the assessment of “Sources.” Additionally, ChatGPT-4 provided information at a significant lower reading grade level. Conclusions Artificial intelligence platforms failed to consistently provide accurate information surrounding the management of vestibular schwannoma, although ChatGPT-4 achieved significantly higher scores in most analyzed parameters. These findings demonstrate the potential for significant misinformation for patients seeking information through these platforms.
Cochlear Implantation With Sporadic Inner Ear Schwannomas: Outcomes in 106 Patients From an International Multi-Institutional Study
Objective To evaluate cochlear implant speech perception among patients with sporadic inner ear schwannoma who underwent ipsilateral implantation. Study Design Retrospective multi-institutional cohort study. Setting Eleven tertiary academic medical centers across Germany, Denmark, and the United States. Patients One hundred six patients with sporadic inner ear schwannoma who received an ipsilateral cochlear implant from 2011 to 2022. Interventions Ipsilateral cochlear implantation with observation, stereotactic radiosurgery, or microsurgery for tumor management. Main Outcome Measures Monosyllabic speech perception testing scores and rates of open-set speech perception. Results Among 106 patients studied, 101 (95%) achieved open-set speech perception with a median of 24 months (interquartile range [IQR] 12–42 mo) of audiometric follow-up. Median ipsilateral monosyllabic speech perception testing achieved was 72% (IQR 54–85%), and median ipsilateral AzBio in quiet was 75% (IQR 46–90%). Most (91 of 106 [86%]) underwent microsurgery for tumor control, with cochlear implantation performed simultaneously in 98% (89 of 91) of these patients. The ability to achieve gross total resection significantly differed by tumor complexity, with 97% of low-complexity tumors, 100% of intermediate complexity, and 0% of high-complexity tumors undergoing gross total resection (p < 0.001). However, among patients managed with microsurgery, there was not a statistically significant difference in post-cochlear implantation monosyllabic speech perception scores across complexity groupings, with median scores of 75 and 70% for patients with tumors of low or intermediate complexity and those with tumors of high complexity, respectively (p = 0.5). Eight of 102 patients (8%) assessed experienced deterioration in cochlear implant performance over time. Among the subset of 39 patients with available MRI to review, the region of surveillance interest could be visualized postoperatively on MRI in all cases. Conclusions Open-set speech perception is achieved in most patients with inner ear schwannoma undergoing ipsilateral cochlear implantation. Although cochlear implantation in high-complexity inner ear schwannomas is only possible with incomplete tumor resection, long-term open-set speech perception outcomes are similar to lower-complexity tumors.
Medially Migrating Vestibular Schwannomas: A Review of 10 Cases
Objective To analyze cases of medial migration of vestibular schwannomas to propose an underlying mechanism. Study Design Retrospective chart review. Patients Ten patients from one institution with sporadic vestibular schwannomas that demonstrated medial migration toward the cerebellopontine angle on serial imaging were reviewed. Interventions Among the 10 patients studied, 8 patients underwent stereotactic radiosurgery and 2 were managed with wait-and-scan. All serial imaging was analyzed throughout follow-up. Main Outcome Measures Volumetric and linear measurements were used to assess vestibular schwannoma growth. The fundal fluid cap length was measured from the most lateral end of the neoplasm within the internal auditory canal to the medial end of the cochlea. Pure tone averages of 0.5, 1, 2, and 3 kHz, word recognition scores, and AAO-HNS hearing class were used to assess levels of hearing loss per patient. Results Tumor growth exhibited a positive correlation with medial migration. Of the 10 patients studied, 9 exhibited tumor volume growth from initial to most recent imaging. Median changes in tumor volumes and fundal fluid cap lengths from initial diagnosis to the most recent imaging regardless of intervention were 130 mm3 (range 1,400–2,970) and 2.8 mm (range 1.8–6.0), respectively. Migration was noted in 4 patients prior to any intervention, in 4 patients postradiosurgery, and in 2 patients before and after radiosurgery. Therefore, half of the tumors studied migrated before an intervention and half migrated postradiosurgery. No correlation of migration and hearing decline was observed. Conclusion Medial migration of vestibular schwannoma is associated with an increase in tumor volume, supporting a “tumor squeeze” mechanism within a conical internal auditory canal toward the wider porus acusticus and cerebellopontine angle.