Brady, Justin

BACKGROUND: Within the US, there has been an overall increase in cost of malpractice insurance for surgeons and decrease in federal reimbursement for surgical work. This study aimed to analyze state-to-state variability to understand differences in costs relative to reimbursement for surgeons and temporal trends. STUDY DESIGN: This study uses publicly available data to conduct a cross-sectional evaluation of surgeon medical malpractice premium rates and surgical reimbursement between 2013 and 2023. Surgeon reimbursement was represented in terms of the unit reimbursement rate for laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC). The ratio of surgeon reimbursement to malpractice cost was calculated and considered as the number of LCs required in each state to cover the cost of malpractice insurance. RESULTS: Inflation-adjusted reimbursement for LC decreased in all states with a mean decrease of 24%. Although there was an overall decrease in inflation-adjusted medical malpractice premium cost, some states experienced an increase of up to 22% (Rhode Island), whereas other states experienced a decrease in cost of 62% (Oregon). For the year 2023, there was significant variability in the number of LCs needed to afford malpractice insurance premiums across states, ranging from 21 (Minnesota) to 163 (Illinois). Rhode Island experienced the greatest increase in change from 2013 to 2023 (63%), whereas Oregon experienced the greatest decrease (50%). CONCLUSIONS: This study finds significant variation in Medicare-based surgeon compensation relative to malpractice insurance costs across the US. This discrepancy highlights the challenges faced by surgical practices due to inconsistent insurance cost and decreases in reimbursement rates.

BACKGROUND: Medicare reimbursement rates have decreased across various specialties but have not yet been studied in colorectal surgery. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to analyze Medicare reimbursement trends in colorectal surgery. DESIGN: Observational study. SETTING: The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ Physician Fee Schedule was evaluated for reimbursement data for the 20 most common colorectal surgery procedures from 2006 to 2020. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Inflation-adjusted annual percentage change, compound annual growth rate, and total percentage change were the outcome measures. A subanalysis was performed comparing the changes in reimbursement between 2006 to 2016 and 2016 to 2020 because of legislative changes that went into effect in 2016. RESULTS: During the study period, the inflation-unadjusted mean Medicare reimbursement rate for the 20 most common colorectal surgery procedures increased by +15.6%. This rise was surpassed by the inflation rate of +31.3%. Consequently, the inflation-adjusted reimbursement rate decreased by –11%. The adjusted reimbursement rates decreased the most at –33.8% for a flexible colonoscopy with biopsy and increased the most at +45.3% for a diagnostic rigid proctosigmoidoscopy. Annual percentage change was –0.79%, and the compound annual growth rate was –0.98%. There was an accelerated decrease in annual reimbursement rates from 2016 to 2020 at –2.23% compared to 2006 to 2016 at –0.22% (p = 0.03). The only procedure that had an increase in adjusted reimbursement rate from 2016 to 2020 was the injection of sclerosing solution for hemorrhoids. LIMITATIONS: Only Medicare reimbursement data were analyzed. CONCLUSIONS: Medicare reimbursements for colorectal surgery procedures are decreasing at an accelerating rate. Although this study is limited to Medicare data, it still presents a representation of overall reimbursement changes because Medicare policies have a ripple effect in the commercial insurance market. It is vital to understand the financial trends to be able to structure future patient care teams and to advocate for the sustainability of colorectal surgery practices in the United States. See Video Abstract at http://links.lww.com/DCR/C136. REEMBOLSO DE MEDICARE EN CIRUGÍA COLORRECTAL: UN PROBLEMA CRECIENTE ANTECEDENTES: Las tasas de reembolso de Medicare han disminuido en varias especialidades, pero aún no han sido estudiado en cirugía colorrectal. OBJETIVO: Analizar las tendencias de reembolso de Medicare en cirugía colorrectal. DISEÑO: Estudio observacional. CONTEXTO: Se evaluó el programa de tarifas médicas de los Centros de Servicios de Medicare y Medicaid para obtener datos de reembolso de los 20 procedimientos más comunes en cirugía colorrectal entre los años 2006 y 2020. PRINCIPALES MEDIDAS DE RESULTADO: Variación porcentual anual ajustada por inflación, tasa de crecimiento anual compuesta y variación porcentual total. Se realizó un subanálisis comparando los cambios en el reembolso entre los años 2006 a 2016 y 2016 a 2020 debido a los cambios legislativos que entraron en vigencia en 2016. RESULTADOS: Durante el período de estudio, la tasa media de reembolso de Medicare sin ajuste por inflación para los 20 procedimientos más comunes en cirugía colorrectal aumentó en +15,6 %. Esta suba fue superada por la tasa de inflación del +31,3%. En consecuencia, la tasa de reembolso ajustada por inflación disminuyó un -11%. Lo máximo que disminuyeron las tasas ajustadas de reembolso fue a -33,8% para una colonoscopia flexible con biopsia y aumentaron más a +45,3% para una proctosigmoidoscopia rígida de diagnóstico. El cambio porcentual anual fue -0,79% y la tasa de crecimiento anual compuesto fue -0,98%. Hubo una disminución acelerada en las tasas de reembolso anual de 2016 a 2020 a -2,23 % en comparación con 2006 a 2016 a -0,22% (p = 0,03). El único procedimiento que tuvo un aumento en la tasa de reembolso ajustada de 2016 a 2020 fue la inyección de solución esclerosante para las hemorroides. LIMITACIONES: Solo se analizaron los datos de reembolso de Medicare. CONCLUSIONES: Los reembolsos de Medicare por procedimientos en cirugía colorrectal están disminuyendo a un ritmo acelerado. Aunque este estudio se limita a los datos de Medicare, aún presenta una representación de los cambios generales en los reembolsos, ya que las pólizas de Medicare tienen un efecto dominó en el mercado de seguros comerciales. Es fundamental comprender las tendencias financieras para poder estructurar futuros equipos de atención de pacientes y abogar por la sostenibilidad de las prácticas de cirugía colorrectal en los Estados Unidos. Consulte Video Resumen video en https://links.lww.com/DCR/C136. (Traducción—Dr. Osvaldo Gauto)