Back to Authors

Shukla, Navika

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1129-545X

Mayo Clinic

Rutgers Cancer Institute

Citations 5

Treatment and outcomes of progression of disease post–CAR T-cell therapy in mantle cell lymphoma: a multicenter analysis
Epstein‐Peterson, Zachary D. , Lionel, Anath C. , Joseph, Ashlee , Drill, Esther , Atallah‐Yunes, Suheil Albert , Brooks, Taylor , Chong, Elise A. , Chong, Emeline R. , Cruz, Jamie Dela , Frank, Matthew J. , Jacobson, Caron A. , Beyar‐Katz, Ofrat , Maddocks, Kami J. , McLoughlin, Daniel E. , Navalekar, Rohin, Ryan, Christine E. , Sauter, Craig S. , Sharma, Samanvaya , Shukla, Navika , Therwhanger, Dylan , Besien, Herman J. van, Varon, Ben , Yamshon, Samuel , Palomba, M. Lia , Kumar, Anita , Brooks, Taylor R , Kamdar, Manali , Karmali, Reem , Matasar, Matthew , McLoughlin, Daniel , Rhodes, Joanna , Riedell, Peter A , Ryan, Christine E , Salles, Gilles A , Sawalha, Yazeed , Sharma, Samanvaya , Shouval, Roni , Therwhanger, Dylan , van Besien, Herman , Varon, Ben , Wang, Yucai , Yamshon, Samuel , Zelenetz, Andrew D , Jain, Preetesh , Kumar, Anita , Chong, Elise A , Joseph, Ashlee , Atallah-Yunes, Albert , Ip, Andrew , Iqbal, Madiha , Kamdar, Manali , Karmali, Reem , Matasar, Matthew J. , Merryman, Reid W. , Muñoz, Javier , Navalekar, Rohini, Rhodes, Joanna , Riedell, Peter A. , Salles, Gilles , Sawalha, Yazeed , Wang, Yucai , Zelenetz, Andrew D. , Jain, Preetesh

Blood Advances | August 5, 2025 | Volume: 9 | Issue: 21 | Pages: 5654-5662

10.1182/bloodadvances.2025016315 Get It

Abstract The treatment patterns and clinical outcomes for patients experiencing progression of disease (POD) following CD19-directed chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T-cell therapy for relapsed or refractory (R/R) mantle cell lymphoma (MCL) are undefined. We identified all patients who received CD19-directed CAR T-cell therapy for R/R MCL therapy across 15 international centers, and studied those experiencing POD post–CAR T-cell therapy in detail. We extracted clinical/treatment/pathologic variables, and associated these features with survival outcomes. In total, 384 patients received CAR T-cell therapy, and 135 (35%) experienced POD. POD occurred at a median of 6 months following CAR T-cell therapy infusion, and most (64%) patients with POD had complete response as best response to CAR T-cell therapy. Tumor features at POD included blastoid/pleomorphic morphology in 29 of 78 (37%) patients, and TP53 mutation in 21 of 41 (51%) patients. Following POD, 17 patients received no further therapy, 13 underwent local therapy, and 105 received systemic therapy. The most common first-line systemic therapies were chemo(immuno)therapy (22 patients; overall response rate [ORR], 40%), pirtobrutinib (17 patients; ORR, 36%), and bispecific antibodies (13 patients; ORR, 67%). Among patients experiencing POD, the median progression-free survival and overall survival (OS) were 2.5 months and 5.4 months, respectively, from POD. Lack of response to CAR T-cell therapy and short time from CAR T-cell therapy infusion to POD (<3 vs 3-6 vs >6 months), among other factors, were associated with inferior OS after POD. In conclusion, we confirm the challenging prognosis for patients experiencing POD following CD19 CAR T-cell therapy for R/R MCL, and establish a benchmark for future investigations in this patient population.
Real World First-Line Treatment Strategies and Outcomes in TP53 Mutated and Unmutated Mantle Cell Lymphoma
Annunzio, Kaitlin , Karimi, Yasmin , Luu, Binh, Spurgeon, Stephen E. , Chang, Cheryl , Wan, Zihan, Gathers, Diamone, King, Emily R., Gerhard, Genevieve M. , Armand, Philippe , LaCasce, Ann S. , Vaddaraju, Vedha, Kenkre, Vaishalee P. , Junge, Chase, Stanisic, Alexander V., Zhang, Chen , Ying, Grace W, Gribbin, Caitlin , Ruan, Jia , Shukla, Navika , Smith, Sonali M. , Zelikson, Viktoriya, Williams, Michael, Elghawy, Omar , Schade, Jake , Navalekar, Rohini, Evens, Andrew M. , Danilov, Alexey V. , Fenske, Timothy S. , Stanisic, Alexander , Karimi, Yasmin H , Evens, Andrew M , Stanisic, Alexander V , Wang, Jie , Zhou, Jihao , Wang, Yucai , Muñoz, Javier , Shim, Kevin G. , Moustafa, Muhamad Alhaj , Baidoun, Firas , Epperla, Narendranath , McLane, Michael, Luu, Binh, King, Emily R., Watkins, Marcus P. , Bartlett, Nancy L. , Ryan, Christine E. , Vaddaraju, Vedha , Wallace, Danielle , Junge, Chase, Grover, Natalie S. , Florindez, Jorge A. , Karmali, Reem , Venugopal, Parameswaran , Barta, Stefan K , Matasar, Matthew J.

Blood | December 6, 2024 | Volume: 144 | Issue: Supplement 1 | Pages: 4406-4406

10.1182/blood-2024-194601 Get It

Introduction: Mantle cell lymphoma (MCL) is an uncommon B-cell non-Hodgkin lymphoma (NHL) Prognosis is highly variable due to underlying biological and molecular heterogeneity. The first-line (1L) treatment paradigm for MCL continues to evolve with increasing use of bruton tyrosine kinase inhibitors (BTKi) and decreasing use of autologous stem cell transplant (ASCT). TP53 alterations are associated with inferior outcomes in MCL. The aim of this retrospective study is to determine treatment strategies and clinical outcomes in MCL patients based on TP53 gene mutation status. Methods: Retrospective data were collected from 19 institutions in the United States from 1/1993 to 1/2024. We examined treatment patterns and outcomes among MCL patients >18 years of age with known TP53 mutation status by sequencing. Patients who did not receive treatment were excluded. The analysis was stratified based on presence of TP53 mutations. Systemic therapies were categorized as chemo-immunotherapy (CIT), non-chemotherapy (including monoclonal antibodies, lenalidomide, venetoclax, and novel agents on clinical trial), and regimens containing BTKi. The primary outcome was overall survival (OS) and secondary outcomes were progression free survival (PFS) and time to next treatment (TTNT). OS and PFS were estimated with the Kaplan-Meier method and log-rank tests were used to compare groups. Results: 645 patients were included in the study, with 468 men (72.6%) and median age was 64 years (range 30-89). 230/645 patients (35.7%) had a TP53 mutation, of which 182 (79%) were identified prior to 1L. While the male/female distribution was the same between the mutated and unmutated groups, median age at diagnosis and MIPI risk score was higher in the TP53 mutated group (age 65.9 vs 63.1 yrs, p= 0.015; MIPI 6.4 vs 6.1, p<0.001). TP53 unmutated patients had a median of 1 line of therapy vs. 2 for the mutated group (p<0.001, range 1-8). Blastoid histology and higher ki67 were also associated with the TP53 mutated group (p=0.045, 0.01 respectively) The median OS was 14.2 years for TP53 unmutated and 8.3 years for TP53 mutated patients (p<0.0001). PFS in 1L was 0.95 years in TP53 mutated compared to 2.02 years in TP53 unmutated group (p<0.0001). Selection of 1L therapeutic strategy was not associated with presence of TP53 mutation (Χ2 p= 0.21) although more patients in the TP53 unmutated group underwent ASCT (119/415 vs 38/230; Χ2 p=0.0006) TP53 mutation was associated with inferior survival compared to TP53 unmutated patients for CIT in 1L but the difference did not reach statistical significance when non-chemotherapy regimens and regimens containing BTKi were used. For CIT in 1L, 5 year OS was 78% [71-84%] for unmutated compared to 58% [48-67%] for the mutated group (p=0.0001 ). For non-chemotherapy regimens, 5 year OS for unmutated patients was 73% [52- 86%] compared to 52% [25-73%] for the mutated group (p=0.09). For regimens containing BTKi, 5 year OS for unmutated was 93% [81-97%] compared to 57% [28-78%] for mutated (p=0.07). Within the TP53 mutated group, there were no differences in any clinical outcomes between those receiving CIT, non-chemotherapy, or BTKi in 1L. While median OS appeared numerically longer in the BTKi group (14.4 yrs vs 8.8 yrs for CIT and 6.8 yrs for non-chemotherapy), the difference did not reach statistical significance (p=0.58). In contrast,TP53 unmutated patients who received CIT in 1L had better TTNT (p=0.0039) compared to those in non-chemotherapy and BTKi groups. There was no improvement in PFS (p=0.79) or OS (p=0.47). Conclusions To our knowledge this is the largest retrospective real world dataset of MCL treatment outcomes stratified by TP53 mutation. As in prior studies, TP53 mutation portends a worse prognosis in MCL compared to TP53 unmutated patients, but outcomes are better than historically reported. CIT in 1L was not associated with improved OS in either group. Irrespective of TP53 mutation status, incorporation of BTKi in first line was not associated with improved clinical outcomes. The gap in OS between TP53 mutated and unmutated MCL may be narrowing as treatment paradigms shift away from intensive induction chemotherapy and ASCT, and due to an increasing number of effective therapies for relapsed patients. Clinical trials of novel agents are needed to further improve the OS of TP53 mutated MCL patients.
Treatment Patterns and Outcomes Following Progression of Disease Post-CAR-T Therapy in Relapsed or Refractory Mantle Cell Lymphoma: A Multicenter Analysis
Epstein‐Peterson, Zachary D. , Joseph, Ashlee , Drill, Esther , Brooks, Taylor , Chong, Emeline R. , Cruz, Jamie Dela , Frank, Matthew J. , Jacobson, Caron A. , Maddocks, Kami J. , Sauter, Craig S. , Shukla, Navika , Stanisic, Alexander V., Therwhanger, Dylan , Besien, Herman van, Yamshon, Samuel , Palomba, Maria Lia, Kumar, Anita J. , Stanisic, Alexander , Brooks, Taylor R , Stanisic, Alexander V , Lionel, Anath C. , Atallah‐Yunes, Suheil Albert , Chong, Elise A. , Ip, Andrew , Iqbal, Madiha , Kamdar, Manali , Karmali, Reem , Matasar, Matthew J. , Merryman, Reid W. , Muñoz, Javier , Riedell, Peter A. , Ryan, Christine E. , Salles, Gilles , Sawalha, Yazeed , Shouval, Roni , Wang, Yucai , Zelenetz, Andrew D. , Palomba, M. Lia , Jain, Preetesh

Blood | December 5, 2024 | Volume: 144 | Issue: Supplement 1 | Pages: 238-238

10.1182/blood-2024-192995 Get It

Background: CD19-directed chimeric antigen receptor T-cell (CAR-T) therapy is an established treatment with high efficacy in treating relapsed or refractory (R/R) mantle cell lymphoma (MCL). However, with CAR-T therapy, refractory disease occurs and a continuous pattern of relapse over time has been observed. Limited data exist about post-CAR-T progression of disease (POD) management and outcomes in MCL. Such data would meaningfully inform practice and set a critical benchmark for future studies in the post-CAR-T setting. We characterized treatment patterns and outcomes for pts with POD after CD19 CAR-T therapy for R/R MCL. Methods: We queried institutional databases to identify pts with R/R MCL who received CD19-directed CAR-T therapy. Treatment may have occurred as standard-of-care or in a clinical trial. We performed chart review to extract variables and categorized therapies by mechanism(s) of action. We used descriptive statistics to characterize patient/disease characteristics and treatment patterns, the reverse Kaplan-Meier method to calculate follow-up, the Kaplan-Meier method to calculate survival, and Cox proportional hazards to associate clinical and disease features with survival outcomes. Results: Across 9 sites, we identified 306 pts who received CD19 CAR-T for R/R MCL, of which 104 (34%) experienced POD and were investigated in detail: pts with POD were mostly men (73%), had a median age of 67 yrs (range 36-86) at infusion, and had received a median of 3 lines of therapy pre-leukapheresis, including a BTK inhibitor (BTKi) in 97% of patients; 36% of BTKi-exposed patients had BTKi-unresponsive disease. High-risk tumor features were common pre-CAR-T: 47/68 (69%) with a TP53 mutation, 66/93 (71%) with Ki67 ≥50%, and 47/102 (46%) with blastoid/pleomorphic MCL. Most pts (75%) received bridging therapy. Pts received brexucabtagene autoleucel (88%) or lisocabtagene maraleucel (12%). Regarding best CAR-T response for pts with POD, 71% had a complete response (CR), 13% partial response (PR), and 15% had no response. The median time from CAR-T infusion to POD was 6 months (IQR 3-12). At time of POD, high-risk MCL features were again common: 55% blastoid/pleomorphic, 42/56 (75%) Ki67 ≥50%, 51/83 (61%) MIPIb high-risk, and 21/35 (60%) TP53-mutated MCL. Among 69 pts with CD19 assessed on a post-POD biopsy, 8 (12%) had CD19-negative disease. 30% of pts had an ECOG performance status of ≥2 at time of POD. After POD occurred, 15 pts received no anti-lymphoma therapy (Tx), 11 pts underwent excision or radiation, and 78 pts received systemic therapy. The most commonly used first-line systemic Tx post-CAR-T progression included: pirtobrutinib in 13 pts [overall response rate (ORR) 31%], chemoimmunotherapy in 12 pts (ORR 25%), venetoclax in 10 patients (ORR 20%), bispecific antibodies (BsAb) in 10 pts (ORR 60%), and small molecule combinations (at least 2 of BTK inhibitor, BCL2 inhibitor, and lenalidomide) in 8 patients with ORR 50%. The ORR to all first systemic Tx post-POD was 42%. The median follow-up from POD is 15.2 months among survivors. The median progression-free and overall survival (OS) from time of POD were 2.3 (95% CI 1.9-3.4) and 5.4 months (95% CI 4.5-9.4), respectively, and 1-year OS rate was 33%. TP53 mutations predicted inferior OS (HR 2.83, 95% CI 1.08-7.43, P = 0.026) as did age ≥65 years at time of POD (HR 1.83, 95% CI 1.07-3.15, P = 0.023), MIPIb high-risk (HR 3.56, 95% CI 1.08-11.7, P = 0.042), and non-response to CAR-T (HR 3.55, 95% CI 1.93-6.53, P < 0.001). Discussion: Our data, the largest reported cohort of pts with POD post-CAR-T with R/R MCL, confirm the poor prognosis in this patient population, with a median OS of 5.4 months. BsAbs showed promise with an overall response rate of 60%. The presence of a TP53 mutation significantly predicted inferior OS, corroborating the prognostic importance of this finding in the post-CAR-T context. Data from pts treated at additional sites and updated analyses will be presented at the meeting.
Efficacy of checkpoint inhibition after CAR-T failure in aggressive B-cell lymphomas: outcomes from 15 US institutions
Major, Ajay , Yu, Jovian , Shukla, Navika , Karrison, Theodore , Treitman, Rachel, Haverkos, Bradley M. , Godfrey, James , Babcook, Melissa A., Voorhees, Timothy , Carlson, Sophie G. , Gaut, Daria , Oliai, Caspian , Winter, Allison , Hill, Brian T. , Bansal, Radhika , Nizamuddin, Imran , Fitzgerald, Lindsey , Stephens, Deborah M. , Hu, Marie , Bachanová, Veronika , Slade, Michael , Singh, Nathan , Bishop, Michael R. , Riedell, Peter A. , Haverkos, Bradley M , Voorhees, Timothy J , Romancik, Jason T , Bansal, Radhika , Villasboas, Jose Caetano , Karmali, Reem , Stephens, Deborah M , Pophali, Priyanka , Trabolsi, Asaad , Schatz, Jonathan H , Hu, Marie , Slade, Michael J , Singh, Nathan , Ahmed, Nausheen , McGuirk, Joseph , Riedell, Peter A , Bachanova, Veronika , Major, Ajay , Che, Yan, Kamdar, Manali , Oliai, Caspian H , Romancik, Jason T. , Villasboas, José C. , Karmali, Reem , Pophali, Priyanka A. , Ahmed, Nausheen , McGuirk, Joseph P. , Bishop, Michael Russell , Kline, Justin Paul

Blood Advances | April 7, 2023 | Volume: 7 | Issue: 16 | Pages: 4528-4538

10.1182/bloodadvances.2023010016 Get It

AbstractCheckpoint inhibitor (CPI) therapy with anti–PD-1 antibodies has been associated with mixed outcomes in small cohorts of patients with relapsed aggressive B-cell lymphomas after CAR-T failure. To define CPI therapy efficacy more definitively in this population, we retrospectively evaluated clinical outcomes in a large cohort of 96 patients with aggressive B-cell lymphomas receiving CPI therapy after CAR-T failure across 15 US academic centers. Most patients (53%) had diffuse large B-cell lymphoma, were treated with axicabtagene ciloleucel (53%), relapsed early (≤180 days) after CAR-T (83%), and received pembrolizumab (49%) or nivolumab (43%). CPI therapy was associated with an overall response rate of 19% and a complete response rate of 10%. Median duration of response was 221 days. Median progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) were 54 and 159 days, respectively. Outcomes to CPI therapy were significantly improved in patients with primary mediastinal B-cell lymphoma. PFS (128 vs 51 days) and OS (387 vs 131 days) were significantly longer in patients with late (>180 days) vs early (≤180 days) relapse after CAR-T. Grade ≥3 adverse events occurred in 19% of patients treated with CPI. Most patients (83%) died, commonly because of progressive disease. Only 5% had durable responses to CPI therapy. In the largest cohort of patients with aggressive B-cell lymphoma treated with CPI therapy after CAR-T relapse, our results reveal poor outcomes, particularly among those relapsing early after CAR-T. In conclusion, CPI therapy is not an effective salvage strategy for most patients after CAR-T, where alternative approaches are needed to improve post–CAR-T outcomes.