ElBardissi, Andrew W.

Surgical flow disruptions can significantly increase the probability of surgical errors. However, little is known about the frequency and nature of surgical flow disruptions, making the development of evidence-based interventions extremely difficult. The goal of this project was to prospectively study surgical errors and their relationship to surgical flow disruptions within the context of cardiac surgery. A trained observer recorded surgical errors and flow disruptions during 31 cardiac operations over a three-week period. Flow disruptions were then reviewed and analyzed by an interdisciplinary team of surgical and human factors experts. Results revealed that flow disruptions consisted of teamwork/communication failures, equipment and technology problems, extraneous interruptions, training-related distractions, and resource accessibility issues. Errors increased significantly with increases in flow disruptions. Teamwork/communication failures were the strongest predictor of surgical errors. These findings provide preliminary data for developing evidenced-based error management and patient safety programs within cardiac surgery.

Errors with serious consequences continue to occur at a high rate in many surgical specialties. In this study, the Human Factors Analysis and Classification System (Wiegmann & Shappell, 2003) was used to develop a structured interviewing tool for prospectively assessing the systemic factors that may predispose operating room (OR) personnel to making errors. Approximately 50% (n = 68) of all staff involved in patient care within the cardiac surgery OR at our institution participated, with an equal proportion represented across staff specialties (Surgeons, Anesthesiologists, Nurses, Perfusionists and Technicians). Results identified a variety of potential error-producing factors present in the OR setting. While such factors were viewed by OR staff as occurring infrequently, significant relationships between the estimated frequency of systemic problems and specific error forms were identified. These findings can inform both the development of theoretical models of surgical error, as well as the practice of developing targeted intervention programs.

Background and Purpose— Embolic events have long been thought to occur in patients with cardiac tumors secondary to embolization of tumor fragments; however, there are no large studies examining the epidemiology and occurrence of embolism in this group of patients. Methods— From 1957 to 2006, 323 consecutive patients with primary cardiac tumors were treated surgically at our institution. Of these, patients who experienced an embolic event included 80 (cerebrovascular accident 31 [9.7%], transient ischemic attack 30 [9.3%], and other 19 [6%]). Those with no history of an embolic event (n=243 [75%]) were defined as control subjects. Results— Age was similar between the case and control groups (mean 54.5 versus 53.9 years, P =0.8). A multivariate logistic regression model including tumor location, tumor burden, tumor histology, and cerebrovascular risk factors, indicated that left atrial tumors (OR, 1.95; P =0.04), aortic valve tumors (OR, 4.17; P =0.002), and smaller tumor burden (OR, 2.20; P =0.01) were the most significant factors in the occurrence of embolism ( P <0.001). The presence of mitral regurgitation (OR, 0.12; P =0.006) and decreased functional status (New York Heart Association III/IV; OR, 0.31; P <0.001) were protective against the occurrence of embolism. Follow-up was obtained in 82% at a mean follow-up time of 6.17±6.9 years. There were no recurrent embolic events at follow-up. A Kaplan-Meier survival curve demonstrated no difference in survival between both groups ( P =0.78). Conclusion— Aortic valve and left atrial tumors have the greatest anatomic risk for embolism. Furthermore, patients with smaller tumors, minimal symptomatology, and no evidence of mitral regurgitation have a high risk of embolism. Cardiac tumors can be resected with low early mortality, and late survival after operation in the context of an embolic event is similar to patients with cardiac tumors who undergo resection for other indications.

Background— Primary cardiac tumors are rare but have the potential to cause significant morbidity if not treated in an appropriate and timely manner. To date, however, there have been no studies examining survival characteristics of patients who undergo surgical resection. Methods and Results— From 1957 to 2006, 323 consecutive patients underwent surgical resection of primary cardiac tumors; 163 (50%) with myxomas, 83 (26%) with papillary fibroelastomas, 18 (6%) with fibromas, 12 (4%) with lipomas, 28 (9%) with other benign primary cardiac tumors, and 19 (6%) with primary malignant tumors. Operative (30 day) mortality was 2% (n=6). Univariate analysis indicated that patients who underwent resection of fibromas and myxomas had superior survival characteristics in comparison to the remainder of tumor variants; these results were consistent after adjusting for age at surgery, year of surgery, and cardiovascular risk factors. Based on actuarial characteristics of the 2002 U.S. population, patients who underwent myxoma resection had survival characteristics that were not significantly different from that of an age and gender matched population (SMR 1.11, P =0.57) whereas those who underwent resection of fibromas (SMR 11.17, P =0.002), papillary fibroelastomas (SMR 3.17, P =0.0003), lipomas (SMR 5.0, P =0.0003), other benign tumors (SMR 4.63, P =0.003), and malignant tumors (SMR 101, P <0.0001) had significantly poorer survival characteristics. Furthermore, malignant tumors in younger patients were highly fatal (HR 0.899, P <0.0001). Although the most significant predictor of mortality was tumor histology, survival was also influenced the by the duration of CPB and NYHA III/IV; the impact of these risk factors varied with time. The cumulative incidence of myxoma recurrence was 13% and occurred in a younger population (42 versus 57 years, P =0.003) with the risk of recurrence decreased after 4 years. Conclusions— Surgical resection of primary cardiac tumors is associated with excellent long-term survival; patients with cardiac myxomas have survival characteristics that are not significantly different from that of a general population. Predictors of mortality are primarily related to tumor histology but also include clinical characteristics such as symptomatology and duration of CPB.