Citations

Clear

23 citation(s) found for "Smith, Patrick".

Intratunnel Anchor Fixation and Transtibial Pull‐Through Repair Show Comparable Short‐Term Outcomes After Meniscus Root Repair: A Propensity‐Matched Comparative Study
Tagliero, Adam J. , Ahmad, Rana A. , Mikula, Jacob D. , Hevesi, Mario, Smith, Patrick A. , Krych, Aaron J. , Krych, Aaron J , Tagliero, Adam

Mayo Clinic

Arthroscopy | September 24, 2026 | Volume: No volume available | Issue: No issue available | Pages: No page available

10.1002/arj.70601 | PMID 42782213 Get It

Purpose To compare short‐term outcomes of intratunnel anchor fixation versus transtibial pull‐through repair for meniscus root tears with a minimum of 12‐month follow‐up. Methods Patients who underwent primary meniscus root repair between 2011 and 2024 at a single institution were retrospectively reviewed. Inclusion criteria consisted of primary medial or lateral meniscus root repair using either intratunnel anchor fixation or transtibial pull‐through repair, availability of preoperative radiographs, and completion of postoperative patient‐reported outcome measures with a minimum of 12‐month follow‐up. The groups were propensity‐matched by age, sex, body mass index, operative side, root laterality, and concomitant procedures. Baseline radiographic characteristics (hip‐knee‐ankle angle and posterior tibial slope) were measured. Outcomes included Lysholm score, International Knee Documentation Committee score, Tegner activity score (preoperative and postoperative), Visual Analog Scale for pain at rest and with activity, satisfaction, subjective surgical outcome, and reoperations. Results Fifty patients who underwent intratunnel anchor fixation (mean age, 44 years) were propensity‐matched to 100 patients who underwent transtibial pull‐through repair (mean age, 41 years). Mean follow‐up was 1.5 years (range, 1.0‐2.3) in the intratunnel anchor group and 6.1 years (range, 2.7‐13.7) in the transtibial pull‐through group. Reoperation rates were 8% and 14%, respectively ( P = .43), with repair failure occurring in 4% and 6% ( P > .99). Preoperative and postoperative Tegner scores were similar between groups. Tegner minimal clinical important difference was 0.8, and 26.5% of intratunnel anchor patients achieved this compared with 0% of transtibial pull‐through patients. Patients in the intratunnel anchor cohort reported slightly lower Visual Analog Scale pain with activity (1.8 vs 2.5, P = .02). Postoperative Lysholm (87 vs 83, P = .05) and International Knee Documentation Committee scores (79 vs 76, P = .09) were comparable between groups. A greater proportion of intratunnel anchor patients achieved Patient Acceptable Symptomatic State compared with transtibial pull‐through patients for Visual Analog Scale with activity (74% vs 56%, P = .03) and Lysholm (66% vs 47%, P = .01). Most patients in both cohorts rated their outcome as “much better” or “slightly better” ( P = .49), and satisfaction scores were high. Conclusions At short‐term follow‐up, both the intratunnel anchor and transtibial pull‐through techniques showed high patient satisfaction and comparable overall clinical outcomes. There were no differences in reoperation rates between techniques. Level of Evidence Level III, retrospective comparative case series.
Biomechanical Comparison of 4 Radial Meniscal Repair Techniques Including a Novel Dual Tie-Grip Configuration
Bachmaier, Samuel , Krych, Aaron J. , Bedi, Asheesh , Müller, P, Smith, Patrick A. , Krych, Aaron J

Mayo Clinic

The American Journal of Sports Medicine | May 12, 2026 | Volume: 54 | Issue: 8 | Pages: 1859-1866

10.1177/03635465261439079 | PMID 42116567 Get It

Background: Complex repairs of radial meniscal tears have shown increased fixation strength compared to conventional sutures. A simplified 2-suture hybrid and a novel dual tie-grip repair with interconnected vertical mattress sutures spanning the tear were tested and compared to all-inside double-horizontal and tie-grip repairs. Hypothesis: The dual tie-grip repair would increase the initial compression load across the tear and show the least cyclic displacement and highest failure strength. Study Design: Controlled laboratory study. Methods: A total of 40 porcine medial menisci were assigned to 4 repair groups: double-horizontal, hybrid, tie-grip, and dual tie-grip (10 per group). Results from tie-grip repairs were used to assess the effect of vertical mattress suture interconnection. After suture placement according to the described technique and fixation, the initial compressive load, stiffness, and relief displacement were measured. The repaired specimens underwent cyclic loading between 5 and 30 N over 1000 cycles (0.75 Hz), while cyclic stiffness and displacement were measured. Ultimate stiffness and load-to-failure were analyzed at 3.15 mm/s. Results: Analysis of variance revealed that dual tie-grip and hybrid repairs showed higher initial compressive load and relief displacement than the other techniques, with dual tie-grip repair reaching the highest values for both metrics (load: 19.3 ± 2.3 N [ P < .001]; displacement: 0.75 ± 0.19 mm [ P < .001]). The double-horizontal repair had the lowest initial stiffness ( P < .001). Cyclic displacement was lowest for the dual tie-grip repair and highest for the double-horizontal repair (both P < .001). All repaired specimens stiffened during cycling without intergroup differences. Analysis of covariance for stiffness over displacement revealed higher stabilization ( P < .040) with dual tie-grip repair and reduced stabilization ( P < .001) with double-horizontal repair. Despite comparable ultimate stiffness across groups, the dual tie-grip repair failed predominantly by suture rupture at the highest ultimate load (275.5 ± 26.2 N; P < .001), whereas the double-horizontal repair failed by tissue rupture the earliest (127.2 ± 15.9 N; P < .001). Conclusion: The dual tie-grip repair provided the highest initial compression across the radial meniscal tear, the lowest cyclic displacement, and the greatest load-to-failure among all techniques in a porcine cadaveric model. The simplified 2-suture hybrid repair showed higher initial compression than other repairs and comparable cyclic stability to the tie-grip repair. Clinical Relevance: The dual tie-grip repair provided high compression across the radial tear and strong resistance to cyclic displacement. Future clinical series assessing differences in healing rates among different repair groups are warranted.
Primary Fixation of Single Stitch All-Inside and Inside-Out Meniscal Devices for Repairing Vertical Longitudinal Meniscal Tears: A Human Microscopic Imaging and Biomechanical Study
Bachmaier, Samuel , Krych, Aaron J. , Seil, Romain , Smith, Patrick A. , Bedi, Asheesh , Wijdicks, Coen A. , Wijdicks, Coen A , Krych, Aaron J , Seil, Romain , Woiczinski, Matthias

Mayo Clinic

Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine | October 8, 2025 | Volume: 13 | Issue: 10 | Pages: No page available

10.1177/23259671251371295 | PMID 41079761 Get It

Background: Optimized surgical fixation and meniscal stabilization during rehabilitation increase healing success. However, the latest generation of all-inside devices has not yet been biomechanically compared with inside-out suture tape (IO-ST) repair. Hypothesis: (1) The contact area of a suture anchor (SA) would compensate for a meniscal defect better than polyether ether ketone anchors (PA); (2) adjustable tensioning for all-inside meniscal repair fixation would result in higher initial load than IO-ST repair; and (3) stiffer constructs would decrease secondary displacement. Study Design: Controlled laboratory study. Methods: This study investigates human menisci (N = 39) via microscopic imaging and a biomechanical testing protocol. For the imaging protocol, needles of an all-inside SA or PA device and an IO-ST device were inserted after staining to measure the iatrogenic defect created by the needle insertion (n = 20) and the length, width, and meniscus contact area of deployed all-inside anchors (n = 6). For biomechanical testing, menisci with longitudinal bucket handle tears were prepared, and single stitches were repaired (each n = 9). After suture tensioning (50 N) and fixation, initial load, initial stiffness, and relief displacement were measured. Constructs underwent cyclic loading between 2 and 20 N, with 10,000 cycles (0.75 Hz), and stiffness and displacement were measured. Ultimate stiffness and load-to-failure were analyzed at 3.15 mm/sec. Results: All-inside needles created greater iatrogenic meniscal defects ( P < .001) than IO-ST repair. While PAs were longer ( P < .001), SAs were wider with a greater meniscal contact area (both P < .001). IO-ST repair resulted in the lowest initial load ( P < .001) and relief displacement ( P < .001), whereas SA repair resulted in a higher initial load ( P < .007) and stiffness ( P < .023) than PA repair. The overall stiffer SA fixation ( P < 001) significantly reduced cyclic displacement compared with other repairs ( P < .044). The PA group failed due to an anchor fracture at a significantly lower load (84.3 ± 10.7 N; P < .001) than the IO-ST (136.4 ± 10.5 N) and the SA repair (122.1 ± 17.5 N), with a suture-based failure mode. The ultimate stiffness of SA constructs was higher ( P < .045) than that of other repairs. Conclusion: While all-inside devices showed improved primary stability, the IO-ST construct demonstrated the highest load-to-failure. In a human cadaveric model, meniscal repair with a more compact and conforming SA was stiffer and reduced cyclic displacement compared with PA and IO-ST repair. Clinical Relevance: All-inside SA repair improved primary stability. Future clinical series will define the overall significance of healing rates.
Arthroscopic Medial Meniscus Allograft Transplant With Re‐tensionable Suture Anchor Fixation and Centralization Stabilization Suture
Smith, Patrick A. , Ina, Jason , Cuny, Julia F., Krych, Aaron J. , Ina, Jason G, Krych, Aaron J , Ina, Jason G , Cuny, Julia F.

Mayo Clinic

Arthroscopy Techniques | September 11, 2025 | Volume: 14 | Issue: 11 | Pages: No page available

10.1016/j.eats.2025.103855 | PMID 41425355 Get It

Abstract Meniscus allograft transplant (MAT) can provide meaningful improvement in patient outcomes in those who are otherwise meniscus deficient. A common finding in the setting of a failed MAT is meniscus extrusion. Meniscus centralization is a technique performed to reduce the meniscus to its intra‐articular location and has been shown to improve postoperative pain and function in patients with an extruded meniscus. Prior techniques have been described for meniscus centralization in the setting of a meniscus root tear or with the use of single tension devices that are tensioned after meniscocapsular fixation. We present a minimally invasive technique for meniscus centralization that can be performed in conjunction with MAT using a centralization stabilization suture and re‐tensionable root‐fixation subchondral anchors that can be secured prior to meniscocapsular fixation. Technique Video video See video under supplementary data.
Surgical Treatment and Complications of Lateral Extra‐articular Procedures in the Anterior Cruciate Ligament–Reconstructed Knee: Part II of an International Consensus Statement
Sonnery‐Cottet, Bertrand , Carrozzo, Alessandro , Saithna, Adnan , Vieira, Thaïs Dutra , Musahl, Volker , Helito, Camilo Partezani , Panel, The International Experts, Bedi, Asheesh, Bryant, Dianne, Cavaignac, Etienne, Chahla, Jorge, Claes, Steven, Cordasco, Frank, Daggett, Matt, Devitt, Brian, Feller, Julian, Fink, Christian, Frank, Rachel, Geeslin, Andrew, Grassi, Alberto, Green, Daniel, Guenther, Daniel, Heard, Mark, Herbst, Elmar, Hopper, Graeme, Inderhaug, Eivind, Irrgang, James, Kaeding, Christopher, Kittl, Christopher, Kocher, Mininder, Koga, Hideyuki, Krych, Aaron J., LaPrade, Robert, Levy, Bruce, Litchfield, Robert Bruce, Lording, Tim, Lowe, Walter, MacDonald, Peter, Marx, Robert, Moatshe, Gilbert, Neri, Thomas, Ouanezar, Herve, Padua, Vitor Barion de Castro, Parker, David, Pioger, Charles, Servien, Elvire, Sherman, Seth, Smith, Patrick, Spalding, Tim, Tapasvi, Sachin, Verdonk, Peter, Williams, Andy, Xerogeanes, John, Young, Simon W., Monaco, Edoardo , Getgood, Alan , Panel, The International Experts, Bedi, Asheesh, Bryant, Dianne, Cavaignac, Etienne, Chahla, Jorge, Claes, Steven, Cordasco, Frank, Daggett, Matt, Devitt, Brian, Feller, Julian, Fink, Christian, Frank, Rachel, Geeslin, Andrew, Grassi, Alberto, Green, Daniel, Guenther, Daniel, Heard, Mark, Herbst, Elmar, Hopper, Graeme, Inderhaug, Eivind, Irrgang, James, Kaeding, Christopher, Kittl, Christopher, Kocher, Mininder, Koga, Hideyuki, Krych, Aaron J., LaPrade, Robert, Levy, Bruce, Litchfield, Robert Bruce, Lording, Tim, Lowe, Walter, MacDonald, Peter, Marx, Robert, Moatshe, Gilbert, Neri, Thomas, Ouanezar, Herve, Padua, Vitor Barion de Castro, Parker, David, Pioger, Charles , Servien, Elvire, Sherman, Seth, Smith, Patrick, Spalding, Tim, Tapasvi, Sachin, Verdonk, Peter, Williams, Andy, Xerogeanes, John, Young, Simon W.

Mayo Clinic

Arthroscopy | June 20, 2025 | Volume: 41 | Issue: 9 | Pages: 3313-3321

10.1016/j.arthro.2025.06.013 | PMID 40544924 Get It

Purpose To establish international expert consensus on surgical techniques, complications, and rehabilitation protocols for lateral extra‐articular procedures (LEAPs) performed adjunctively with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Methods Fifty‐five knee surgeons from 17 countries on 5 continents completed a 3‐round modified Delphi process. In the final round, 16 statements on LEAP techniques and complications were scored on a 5‐point Likert scale; ≥75% “agree/strongly agree” constituted consensus. When appropriate, strength of recommendation was graded. Statements lacking support were revised until consensus or abandonment. Results Six statements achieved unanimous consensus (100%), 2 had strong consensus (90%‐99.9%), and 3 reached consensus (75%‐89.9%); 4 were removed. Key technical recommendations were as follows: (1) in iliotibial band procedures, the graft strip should pass beneath the lateral collateral ligament; (2) an anatomic technique is mandatory for anterolateral ligament reconstruction; and (3) no single LEAP is clinically superior to another. Unanimous agreement indicated that modern LEAPs do not increase lateral compartment osteoarthritis risk, carry a low complication rate, and do not necessitate changes to rehabilitation or return‐to‐play timelines. Conclusions Consensus defined core surgical principles and confirmed the safety of adding LEAPs to anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. When an iliotibial band graft is used, it should be routed deep to the lateral collateral ligament and fixed between 0° and 60° of knee flexion under low tension. For anterolateral ligament reconstruction, femoral fixation should be in full extension at a posterior‐proximal point relative to the lateral epicondyle. Although no single LEAP proved superiority, adherence to these principles permits safe, effective surgery without altering standard rehabilitation or return‐to‐sport protocols and without increasing osteoarthritis risk. Level of Evidence Level V, expert opinion.
Indications for Lateral Extra‐articular Procedures in the Anterior Cruciate Ligament–Reconstructed Knee: Part I of an International Consensus Statement
Sonnery‐Cottet, Bertrand , Carrozzo, Alessandro , Saithna, Adnan , Vieira, Thaïs Dutra , Musahl, Volker , Helito, Camilo Partezani , Panel, The International Experts, Bedi, Asheesh, Bryant, Dianne, Cavaignac, Etienne, Chahla, Jorge, Claes, Steven, Cordasco, Frank, Daggett, Matt, Devitt, Brian, Feller, Julian, Fink, Christian, Frank, Rachel, Geeslin, Andrew, Grassi, Alberto, Green, Daniel, Guenther, Daniel, Heard, Mark, Herbst, Elmar, Hopper, Graeme, Inderhaug, Eivind, Irrgang, James, Kaeding, Christopher, Kittl, Christopher, Kocher, Mininder, Koga, Hideyuki, Krych, Aaron J., LaPrade, Robert, Levy, Bruce, Litchfield, Robert Bruce, Lording, Tim, Lowe, Walter, MacDonald, Peter, Marx, Robert, Moatshe, Gilbert, Neri, Thomas, Ouanezar, Herve, Padua, Vitor Barion de Castro, Parker, David, Pioger, Charles, Servien, Elvire, Sherman, Seth, Smith, Patrick, Spalding, Tim, Tapasvi, Sachin, Verdonk, Peter, Williams, Andy, Xerogeanes, John, Young, Simon W., Sherman, Seth L. , Monaco, Edoardo , Getgood, Alan , Panel, The International Experts, Bedi, Asheesh, Bryant, Dianne, Cavaignac, Etienne, Chahla, Jorge, Claes, Steven, Cordasco, Frank, Daggett, Matt, Devitt, Brian, Feller, Julian, Fink, Christian, Frank, Rachel, Geeslin, Andrew, Grassi, Alberto, Green, Daniel, Guenther, Daniel, Heard, Mark, Herbst, Elmar, Hopper, Graeme, Inderhaug, Eivind, Irrgang, James, Kaeding, Christopher, Kittl, Christopher, Kocher, Mininder, Koga, Hideyuki, Krych, Aaron J., LaPrade, Robert, Levy, Bruce, Litchfield, Robert Bruce, Lording, Tim, Lowe, Walter, MacDonald, Peter, Marx, Robert, Moatshe, Gilbert, Neri, Thomas, Ouanezar, Herve, Padua, Vitor Barion de Castro, Parker, David, Pioger, Charles , Servien, Elvire, Sherman, Seth, Smith, Patrick, Spalding, Tim, Tapasvi, Sachin, Verdonk, Peter, Williams, Andy, Xerogeanes, John, Young, Simon W.

Mayo Clinic

Arthroscopy | June 20, 2025 | Volume: 41 | Issue: 9 | Pages: 3303-3312

10.1016/j.arthro.2025.06.012 | PMID 40544926 Get It

Purpose To define expert consensus on whether and how lateral extra‐articular procedures (LEAPs) should accompany anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction to optimize outcomes in ACL‐deficient knees. Methods Fifty‐five knee surgeons from 17 countries on 5 continents completed a 3‐round modified Delphi process. Twenty‐one statements on patient selection for combined ACL reconstruction (ACLR) + LEAPs were graded on 5‐point Likert scales; ≥75% “agree/strongly agree” signified consensus. Strength of recommendation was ranked, and statements failing the threshold were revised or discarded after discussion. Results One statement achieved unanimous agreement (100%): it is strongly recommended to add a LEAP for active patients ≤25 years receiving hamstring‐autograft ACLR to reduce graft failure. Strong consensus (≥90%) supported LEAPs in primary ACLR when grade 3 pivot shift (97.9%), knee hyperextension (97.9%), skeletally immature status (79.5%), revision ACLR (91.5%), return to pivoting sports (93.2%), active patients ≤25 years using nonhamstring grafts (90.7%), grade 3 Lachman test (90%), and when multiple relative risk factors coexist (statement 36, 97.1%). Consensus (75%‐89.9%) favored LEAPs for chronic symptomatic ACL deficiency (86.1%), posterior tibial slope >12° (85.7%), and a history of contralateral ACL injury (88.9%). Eight statements did not reach consensus regarding small‐diameter autografts, female athletes, imaging signs of anterolateral injury (e.g., Segond fracture, lateral femoral‐notch sign), and concomitant meniscal procedures. One statement on LEAPs with primary ACL repair was withdrawn because the project focused on reconstruction. Conclusions International experts strongly recommend adding a LEAP in young active patients undergoing hamstring‐autograft ACLR and in cases of high‐grade rotational or anterior laxity, knee hyperextension, revision surgery, or returning to pivoting sports. Unresolved issues include small graft size, female athletes, imaging findings of rotational instability, and concurrent meniscal procedures, highlighting priorities for future research. Level of Evidence Level V, expert opinion.
Primary Fixation and Cyclic Performance of Posterior Horn Medial Meniscus Root Repair With Knotless Adjustable Suture Anchor–Based Fixation: A Human Biomechanical Evaluation Over 100,000 Loading Cycles
Bachmaier, Samuel , Krych, Aaron J. , Smith, Patrick A. , Nuelle, Clayton W. , Müller, Peter E., Bedi, Asheesh , Krych, Aaron J , Wijdicks, Coen A.

Mayo Clinic

The American Journal of Sports Medicine | February 19, 2025 | Volume: 53 | Issue: 5 | Pages: 1093-1100

10.1177/03635465251317210 | PMID 39972533 Get It

Background: Recent biomechanical evidence for adjustable suture anchor (ASA)–based posterior medial meniscus root (PMMR) fixation has shown promising results compared with conventional transtibial pull-out repair (TPOR). However, ASA fixation has not been evaluated in human tissue to 100,000 cycles. Hypothesis: ASA repair would lead to increased primary fixation strength and less cyclic displacement than conventional TPORs. Study Design: Controlled laboratory study. Methods: A total of 32 human medial menisci were used, 8 of which were intact specimens and served as native controls. For the others, PMMR tears were created and repaired using 3 different techniques (n = 8 group). Two conventional PMMR repairs were prepared consisting of two No. 2 simple sutures (TSS) and two No. 2 sutures in a Mason-Allen (MA) configuration, all tied over a cortical button. The knotless ASA repair was fixed in MA with repair sutures tensioned at 120 N (MA-120). The repairs’ initial force, stiffness, and relief displacement from the tensioned state toward repair unloading (2 N) were measured after fixation. All repair constructs were loaded for 100,000 cycles, with displacement and stiffness measured, and finally were pulled to failure. Results: The TPORs demonstrated similar primary fixation and cyclic loading behavior except for initial cyclic displacement (cycle 10). The ASA repair provided a higher initial repair load ( P < .001) and stiffness ( P < .001) with relief displacement similar to conventional TPORs. Lower initial cyclic displacement ( P < .011; cycle 10) with overall higher repair stiffness ( P < .011) resulted in significantly lower displacement ( P < .001) throughout testing for ASA repair. Although both TPORs were completely loose after 100,000 cycles, the ASA repair achieved near-native dynamic meniscal stabilization. The TSS repair had lower overall ultimate load ( P < .001) and ultimate stiffness ( P < .023) compared with the ASA repair. All repairs had lower ultimate stiffness and loads than the native meniscus ( P < .001). Conclusion: The ASA repair resulted in improved primary PMMR fixation that was stiffer with less cyclic displacement than conventional TPORs and approached that of the human meniscal function after 100,000 load cycles in a cadaveric model. However, all repair techniques had lower ultimate strength than the native human PMMR. Clinical Relevance: Knotless ASA meniscus root fixation resulted in higher tissue compression and less displacement in a cadaveric model; however, future clinical series with surveillance imaging will define the overall significance of healing rates.
Arthroscopic Centralization of the Extruded Meniscus With Posterior Root Tear: A Technique Using Meniscotibial Ligament Fixation
Krych, Aaron J. , Meta, Fabien , Kang, Louis , Hevesi, Mario, Smith, Patrick A. , Krych, Aaron J , Kang, Louis S , Hevesi, Mario

Mayo Clinic

Arthroscopy Techniques | October 16, 2024 | Volume: 14 | Issue: 3 | Pages: No page available

10.1016/j.eats.2024.103274 | PMID 40207329 Get It

Abstract Meniscal root tears have been shown to significantly impact tibiofemoral mechanics and contribute to accelerated development of osteoarthritis. A common finding in conjunction with a meniscal root tear is extrusion of the meniscus. Meniscal extrusion is an independent risk factor for tibiofemoral cartilage loss and the progression of osteoarthritis. Meniscus centralization was first introduced to directly address extrusion alongside root repair techniques. To date, reported techniques for meniscus centralization generally involve anchoring the meniscus directly to the tibia in some fashion, which can limit the normal anatomic motion of the meniscus. We present a technique for meniscus centralization that aims to maintain natural meniscal motion by utilizing the meniscotibial ligaments. Technique Video video See video under supplementary data.
Arthroscopic Repair of a Lateral Meniscus Oblique Radial Tear
Langhans, Mark T. , Smith, Patrick A. , Hevesi, Mario , Pan, Xuankang , Krych, Aaron J.

Mayo Clinic

Video Journal of Sports Medicine | April 16, 2024 | Volume: 4 | Issue: 2 | Pages: No page available

10.1177/26350254231212931 | PMID 40308979 Get It

Background: Lateral meniscal oblique radial tears (LMORTs) are the most common type of lateral meniscal tears and occur concomitantly with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tears in up to 12% of cases. Four types of LMORTs have been classified in the literature based on proximity to the meniscal root and extent of the tear. Type 1 and 2 LMORTs represent partial and complete posterior root tears less than 10 mm from the root insertion. Type 3 and 4 LMORTs are partial and complete posterior radial meniscus tears greater than 10 mm from the root insertion. Indications: Type 3 and 4 LMORTs can and should be addressed with an all-inside side-to-side repair at the time of ACL reconstruction. LMORTs that are not repaired at the time of ACL reconstruction can contribute to persistent instability and meniscal extrusion. Technique Description: Diagnostic arthroscopy is performed to evaluate the posterior aspects of both the medial and lateral meniscus. The medial leaflet is commonly flipped into the notch and scarred to ACL remnant. After identifying and isolating the medial leaflet, an arthroscopic suture passer is used to pass a suture from inferior to superior through the medial leaflet. A second suture is passed from inferior to superior through the lateral leaflet. This is used to shuttle the suture pass through the medial leaflet to the bottom of the meniscus, where it can be tied in a horizontal mattress fashion. The sutures are tied down with aide of an arthroscopic knot pusher. A second set of sutures is passed and used to shuttle a second suture that would be tied posterior to the first suture, again in a horizontal mattress fashion. This allows reduction of the fragments in apposition across the tear. Postoperatively, patients are allowed range of motion from 0° to 90° and to toe touch weightbearing for the first 4 weeks. Patients are advanced to weightbearing as tolerated at 5 weeks. Typical return to sport ranges from 6 to 9 months postoperatively. Results: Results have been published for 2-year outcomes of type 3 and 4 LMORT repairs and have demonstrated persistent improved patient-reported outcomes as well as healing rates that are greater than 80% and in some series approach nearly 100%. Discussion/Conclusion: Arthroscopic all-inside side-to-side surgical repair is a durable and reliable treatment option for patients presenting for ACL reconstruction with concomitant type 3 or 4 LMORT. Patient Consent Disclosure Statement: The author(s) attests that consent has been obtained from any patient(s) appearing in this publication. If the individual may be identifiable, the author(s) has included a statement of release or other written form of approval from the patient(s) with this submission for publication.
Biomechanical Performance of Transtibial Pull-Out Posterior Horn Medial Meniscus Root Repair Is Improved With Knotless Adjustable Suture Anchor–Based Fixation
Bachmaier, Samuel , Smith, Patrick A. , Feucht, Matthias J. , LaPrade, Robert F. , LaPrade, Robert F , Krych, Aaron J. , Wijdicks, Coen A.

Mayo Clinic

Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine | April 5, 2024 | Volume: 12 | Issue: 4 | Pages: No page available

10.1177/23259671241239575 | PMID 38584990 Get It

Background: While posterior medial meniscus root (PMMR) techniques have evolved, there remains a need to both optimize repair strength and improve resistance to cyclic loading. Hypothesis: Adjustable tensioning would lead to higher initial repair strength and reduce displacement with cyclic loading compared with previously described transtibial pull-out repair (TPOR) fixation techniques. Study Design: Controlled laboratory study. Methods: A total of 56 porcine medial menisci were used. Eight intact specimens served as a control for the native meniscus. For the others, PMMR tears were created and repaired with 6 different TPOR techniques (8 in each group). Fixed PMMR repairs were executed using 4 different suture techniques (two No. 2 cinch sutures, two cinch tapes, two No. 2 simple sutures, and two No. 2 sutures in a Mason-Allen configuration) all tied over a cortical button. Adjustable PMMR repairs using Mason-Allen sutures were fixed with an adjustable soft tissue anchor fixation tensioned at either 80 N or 120 N. The initial force, stiffness, and relief displacement of the repairs were measured after fixation. Repair constructs were then cyclically loaded, with cyclic displacement and stiffness measured after 1000 cycles. Finally, the specimens were pulled to failure. Results: The PMMR repaired with the 2 cinch sutures fixed technique afforded the lowest ( P < .001) initial repair load, stiffness, and relief displacement. The adjustable PMMR repairs achieved a higher initial repair load ( P < .001) and relief displacement ( P < .001) than all fixed repairs. The 2 cinch sutures fixed technique showed an overall higher cyclic displacement ( P < .028) and was completely loose compared with the native meniscus functional zone. Repairs with adjustable intratunnel fixation showed displacement with cyclic loading similar to the native meniscus. With cyclic loading, the Mason-Allen adjustable repair with 120 N of tension showed less displacement ( P < .016) than all fixed repairs and a stiffness comparable to the fixed Mason-Allen repair. The fixed Mason-Allen technique demonstrated a higher ultimate load ( P < .007) than the adjustable Mason-Allen techniques. All repairs were less stiff, with lower ultimate failure loads, than the native meniscus root attachment ( P < .0001). Conclusion: Adjustable TPOR led to considerably higher initial repair load and relief displacement than other conventional fixed repairs and restricted cyclic displacement to match the native meniscus function. However, the ultimate failure load of the adjustable devices was lower than that of a Mason-Allen construct tied over a cortical button. All repair techniques had a significantly lower load to failure than the native meniscus root. Clinical Relevance: Knotless adjustable PMMR repair based on soft anchor fixation results in higher tissue compression and less displacement, but the overall clinical significance on healing rates remains unclear.