Citations

Clear

8 citation(s) found for "Schwartz, Lisa".

Factors That Influence Genetic Counselors' Professional Identity—A Qualitative Study
Schwartz, Lisa , Stenberg, Kaye , Casey, Andrea , Fitzpatrick, Jennifer , Mackall, Mia S. , Arjunan, Aishwarya , Witherington, Sarah , Kalia, Isha , Mills, Rachel , Goodenberger, McKinsey , Arjunan, Aishwarya , Witherington, Sarah , Kalia, Isha , Mills, Rachel , Casey, Andrea , Fitzpatrick, Jennifer , Goodenberger, McKinsey L.

Mayo Clinic

Journal of Genetic Counseling | July 30, 2026 | Volume: 35 | Issue: 4 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/jgc4.70260 | PMID 42528291 Get It

ABSTRACT Genetic counselors describe their professional identity as who they are (personal characteristics and attributes), what they do (actions and skills), and what they possess (training and knowledge). A shared multidimensional perspective highlights the transferability of their skills across diverse roles and settings. This qualitative study aimed to identify factors that influence genetic counselors' perceptions and formation of their professional identities. Using Social Identity Theory as a theoretical framework, semi‐structured recorded interviews were conducted with 50 genetic counselors who were purposefully sampled to ensure diversity of personal demographics (gender, race/ethnicity, sexual orientation, disability, and caregiver status), as well as years, settings, and roles in genetic counseling practice. Transcripts were coded and subjected to codebook thematic analysis using NVivo. Professional identity was influenced by internal validation (sense of purpose in work, pride, and confidence), external validation (from other colleagues, work system, degree of autonomy, and patients), one's personal identities (demographics, life experiences, and persona), and connections with others (professional network, peer support, role models, and giving back). Alignment and misalignment of these factors and the perceived collective identity of the profession impacted genetic counselors' sense of belonging to the profession both positively and negatively, respectively. Continued efforts to diversify the profession, as well as expanded opportunities for genetic counselors to work in new settings and roles, require critical reflection and discussion about the collective identity of the genetic counseling profession. The findings of this study can inform the recruitment, training, credentialing, continuing education, and retention of genetic counselors to ensure that genetic counselors, regardless of their personal identities or their work roles or settings, develop and maintain a sense of belonging and commitment to the profession and its values. In turn, the support of professional identity formation can positively impact genetic counselors' job satisfaction, competency, and delivery of healthcare to their patients and the populations they serve.
How genetic counselors in North America describe their professional identity
Schwartz, Lisa , Stenberg, Kaye , Casey, Andrea , Fitzpatrick, Jennifer , Mackall, Mia S. , Arjunan, Aishwarya , Witherington, Sarah , Kalia, Isha , Mills, Rachel, Mills, Rachel , Casey, Andrea , Fitzpatrick, Jennifer , Goodenberger, McKinsey , Arjunan, Aishwarya , Witherington, Sarah , Kalia, Isha , Mills, Rachel , Goodenberger, McKinsey L.

Mayo Clinic

Journal of Genetic Counseling | April 1, 2026 | Volume: 35 | Issue: 2 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/jgc4.70198 | PMID 41919756 Get It

Abstract Professional identity is defined as the attitudes, behaviors, values, and experiences by which individuals define themselves in a professional role and is influenced by socialization during training and in the workplace. As professional identity develops and is integrated with one's personal identities, it allows an individual to think, act, and feel like a member of their chosen profession and to develop a sense of meaning, confidence, and satisfaction in their work. Conflicts may arise due to perceived differences between one's professional identity and the collective identity of the profession, resulting in stress, burnout, and attrition, all of which can negatively impact patient care and the collective identity of the genetic counseling profession. Using Social Identity Theory (SIT) as a theoretical framework to develop the semi‐structured interview protocol, recorded interviews were conducted with 50 genetic counselors who were purposefully sampled to ensure diversity of personal demographics (gender, race/ethnicity, sexual orientation, disability, and caregiver status), as well as years, settings, and roles in genetic counseling practice. Transcripts were coded and subjected to codebook thematic analysis using NVivo. Genetic counselors described their professional identity in terms of who they are (characteristics and attributes), what they do (actions and skills), and what they have (training and knowledge). The majority of participants had a multidimensional perspective of what it means to be a genetic counselor, noting the transferability of their skills to a broad set of roles and settings, which supported their sense of professional identity, particularly for those who were no longer seeing patients. Yet many expressed tension with the collective identity of the profession. Expanded opportunities for genetic counselors to work in new settings and roles require review and revision of key professional documents to ensure they are reflective of the collective identity of the genetic counseling profession.
Recognition of the Large Ambulatory C2D Stage of Advanced Heart Failure—A Call to Action
Lala, Anuradha , Stewart, Garrick C. , Wong, Renee , Morris, Alanna A. , Breathett, Khadijah , Cogswell, Rebecca , Colvin, Monica , Drakos, Stavros , Gelfman, Laura P. , Kanwar, Manreet , Kittleson, M. , Lewis, Eldrin F. , Ogunniyi, Modele O. , Pandey, Ambarish , Rogers, Joseph G. , Teuteberg, Jeffrey J. , Valantine, Hannah A. , Dixon, Debra , Hanff, Thomas C. , Hsiao, Stephanie, McCormick, Amanda D. , Fenton, Kathleen N. , Longacre, Lisa Schwartz, Shanbhag, Sujata M., Taddei‐Peters, Wendy C. , Stevenson, L W, Dunlay, Shannon M. , Kanwar, Manreet K , Breathett, Khadijah , McCormick, A , Colvin, Monica M , Pinney, Sean P , McIlvennan, Colleen Kelley , Pagani, Francis D. , Allen, Larry A. , Cowger, Jennifer , Kiernan, Michael S. , Moazami, Nader , Pandey, Ambarish , Schumacher, Kurt R. , Slaughter, Mark S. , Tedford, Ryan J. , DeFilippis, Ersilia M. , Golbus, Jessica R , Gulati, Gaurav , Lewsey, Sabra C , Nayak, Aditi , Stevenson, Lynne W.

Mayo Clinic

JAMA Cardiology | February 5, 2025 | Volume: 10 | Issue: 4 | Pages: 391

10.1001/jamacardio.2024.5328 | PMID 39908057 Get It

ImportanceThe advanced ambulatory heart failure (HF) population comprises patients who have progressed beyond the pillars of recommended stage C HF therapies but can still find meaningful life-years ahead. Although these patients are commonly encountered in practice, national databases selectively capture the small groups accepted for heart transplant listing or left ventricular assist devices. The epidemiology, trajectories, and therapies for other ambulatory patients with advanced HF are poorly understood.ObservationsIn December 2022, the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute convened a team of experts to identify knowledge gaps and research priorities for the ambulatory population with limiting daily symptoms and transition toward refractory end-stage D HF, designated as stage C2D. This article summarizes the findings from that 3-day workshop. Workshop participants surveyed the initial challenges and knowledge gaps for (1) recognition of ambulatory C2D HF, (2) estimation of the magnitude of the affected population and identifiable subpopulations, and (3) physiologic phenotypes, such as low cardiac output, right HF, cardiorenal syndromes, congestive hepatopathy and frailty, which offer distinct targets for existing and emerging therapies. Social drivers of HF and patient preferences for quality/length of survival were highlighted as essential modifiers for personalization of therapies.Conclusions and RelevanceTen key points summarized workshop findings, with target cohorts for study proposed as a crucial next step. This workshop summary is intended as a call for action to address knowledge gaps and develop new strategies to improve outcomes in the large ambulatory population with C2D HF.
Graduate training, credentialing, and continuing education to prepare genetic counselors for laboratory roles—Results of a national survey
Schwartz, Lisa , Mackall, Mia S. , Arjunan, Aishwarya , Goodenberger, McKinsey L. , Mills, Rachel , Ham, C. , Witherington, Sarah , Goodenberger, McKinsey , Ham, Chloe , Arjunan, Aishwarya , Witherington, Sarah , Mills, Rachel

Mayo Clinic

Journal of Genetic Counseling | February 10, 2024 | Volume: 34 | Issue: 1 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/jgc4.1883 | PMID 38339832 Get It

Abstract Opportunities for genetic counselors to work in a variety of practice settings have greatly expanded, particularly in the laboratory. This study aimed to assess attitudes of genetic counselors working both within and outside of the laboratory setting regarding (1) the re‐wording and/or expansion of key measures of genetic counselors' competency, including practice‐based competencies (PBCs) and board examination, to include laboratory roles, (2) preparation and transferability of competencies developed in master's in genetic counseling (MGC) programs to different roles, (3) need of additional training for genetic counselors to practice in laboratory settings, and (4) preferred methods to obtain that training. An e‐blast was sent to ABGC diplomats ( N = 5458) with a link to a 29‐item survey with 12 demographic questions to compare respondents to 2021 NSGC Professional Status Survey (PSS) respondents. Statistical comparisons were made between respondents working in the laboratory versus other settings. Among 399 responses received, there was an oversampling of respondents working in the laboratory (52% vs. 20% in PSS) and in non‐direct patient care positions (47% vs. 25% in PSS). Most respondents agreed the PBCs were transferable to their work yet favored making the PBCs less direct patient care‐focused, expanding PBCs to align with laboratory roles, adding laboratory‐focused questions to the ABGC exam, and adding laboratory‐focused training in MGC programs. Most agreed requiring post‐MGC training would limit genetic counselors' ability to change jobs. Genetic counselors working in the laboratory reported being significantly less prepared by their MGC program for some roles ( p < 0.001) or how the PBCs applied to non‐direct patient care positions ( p < 0.001). Only 53% of all respondents agreed that NSGC supports their professional needs and others in their practice area, and genetic counselors working in the laboratory were significantly less likely to agree ( p = 0.002). These sentiments should be further explored.
Need for additional training to be a laboratory genetic counselor—A qualitative exploration
Schwartz, Lisa , Mackall, Mia S. , Arjunan, Aishwarya , Goodenberger, McKinsey L. , Mills, Rachel , Witherington, Sarah , Goodenberger, McKinsey , Arjunan, Aishwarya , Witherington, Sarah , Mills, Rachel

Mayo Clinic

Journal of Genetic Counseling | July 26, 2023 | Volume: 32 | Issue: 6 | Pages: 1249-1265

10.1002/jgc4.1746 | PMID 37493003 Get It

AbstractOpportunities for genetic counselors to work in the laboratory have grown exponentially, yet the professional development needed to serve in these roles had not been previously explored. This study aimed to identify competencies required for entry‐level genetic counselors working in the laboratory, explore the perceived level of preparation of these competencies as noted by experts in the laboratories, and assess the perceived value of additional credentialing for genetic counselors practicing in these settings. Twenty genetic counselors working in the laboratory setting and five MD or PhD laboratory managers, identified through purposeful and snowball sampling and with at least 5 years of experience working in a laboratory, were interviewed using a semi‐structured protocol. Transcripts were analyzed thematically using deductive and inductive coding. Key findings included the distinction of laboratory and industry roles as involving nondirect patient care and differing from genetic counseling roles in the clinical setting. Genetic counselors working in the laboratory feel well prepared to transition into this setting and provide a unique patient‐focused perspective to laboratory roles, including variant interpretation, marketing, and product development. Practice‐based competencies (PBCs) were translatable to those used in the laboratory, yet variant interpretation, limitations of genomics‐based tests, and the business of health care were noted as important to these roles but not fully addressed in the PBCs. Additional skills were often developed through on‐the‐job training and interdisciplinary collaboration, but more exposure to diverse roles in genetic counseling programs' didactic and field training was recommended. The majority felt that requiring an additional post‐master's credential to work in the laboratory setting may restrict movement into these roles. Several questioned their identity as genetic counselors as they were no longer providing direct patient care and/or had been dissuaded by others from pursuing a laboratory position. Research focused on professional identity among genetic counselors working in nondirect patient care roles is warranted.
Meeting the Challenges of Myocarditis: New Opportunities for Prevention, Detection, and Intervention—A Report from the 2021 National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Workshop
Čiháková, Daniela , Adhikari, Bishow B., Bandettini, W. Patricia , Cunningham, Madeleine W. , Danthi, Narasimhan , Longacre, Lisa Schwartz, Mann, Douglas L. , Tang, W.H. Wilson , Zhou, Guofei , Cooper, Leslie T. , Mann, Douglas L , Tang, W H Wilson , Cooper, Leslie T , Shi, Yang , Friedrich, Matthias G. , Liu, Peter Xiaoping , Świrski, Filip K.

Mayo Clinic

Journal of Clinical Medicine | September 28, 2022 | Volume: 11 | Issue: 19 | Pages: 5721

10.3390/jcm11195721 | PMID 36233593 Get It

The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) convened a workshop of international experts to discuss new research opportunities for the prevention, detection, and intervention of myocarditis in May 2021. These experts reviewed the current state of science and identified key gaps and opportunities in basic, diagnostic, translational, and therapeutic frontiers to guide future research in myocarditis. In addition to addressing community-acquired myocarditis, the workshop also focused on emerging causes of myocarditis including immune checkpoint inhibitors and SARS-CoV-2 related myocardial injuries and considered the use of systems biology and artificial intelligence methodologies to define workflows to identify novel mechanisms of disease and new therapeutic targets. A new priority is the investigation of the relationship between social determinants of health (SDoH), including race and economic status, and inflammatory response and outcomes in myocarditis. The result is a proposal for the reclassification of myocarditis that integrates the latest knowledge of immunological pathogenesis to refine estimates of prognosis and target pathway-specific treatments.
Assessing Values for Health: Numeracy Matters
Woloshin, Steven , Schwartz, Lisa M., Moncur, Megan, Gabriel, Sherine E., Tosteson, Anna N.A.

Mayo Clinic

Medical Decision Making | April 1, 2009 | Volume: 21 | Issue: 5 | Pages: 382-390

10.1177/0272989x0102100505 | PMID 11575488 Get It

Background. Patients’ values are fundamental to decision models, cost-effectiveness analyses, and pharmacoeconomic analyses. The standard methods used to assess how patients value different health states are inherently quantitative. People without strong quantitative skills (i.e., low numeracy) may not be able to complete these tasks in a meaningful way. Methods. To determine whether the validity of utility assessments depends on the respondent’s level of numeracy, the authors conducted in-person interviews and written surveys and assessed utility for the current health for 96 women volunteers. Numeracy was measured using a previously validated 3-item scale. The authors examined the correlation between self-reported health and utility for current health (assessed using the standard gamble, time trade-off, and visual analog techniques) across levels of numeracy. For half of the women, the authors also assessed standard gamble utility for 3 imagined health states (breast cancer, heart disease, and osteoporosis) and asked how much the women feared each disease. Results. Respondent ages ranged from 50 to 79 years (mean = 63), all were high school graduates, and 52% had a college or postgraduate degree. Twenty-six percent answered 0 or only 1 of the numeracy questions correctly, 37% answered 2 correctly, and 37% answered all 3 correctly. Among women with the lowest level of numeracy, the correlation between utility for current health and self-reported health was in the wrong direction (i.e., worse health valued higher than better health): for standard gamble, Spearman r = -0.16, P =0.44; for time trade-off, Spearman r = -0.13, P = 0.54. Among the most numerate women, the authors observed a fair to moderate positive correlation with both standard gamble (Spearman r = 0.22, P = 0.19) and time trade-off (Spearman r = 0.50, P = 0.002). In contrast, using the visual analog scale, the authors observed a substantial correlation in the expected direction at all levels of numeracy (Spearman r =0.82, 0.50, and 0.60 for women answering 0-1, 2, and 3 numeracy questions, respectively; all P s ≤ 0.003). With regard to the imagined health states, the most feared disease had the lowest utility for 35% of the women with the lowest numeracy compared to 76% of the women with the highest numeracy (P = 0.03). Conclusions. The validity of standard utility assessments is related to the subject’s facility with numbers. Limited numeracy may be an important barrier to meaningfully assessing patients’ values using the standard gamble and time trade-off techniques.