Abstract Table 1. Samples to p53 deletions p 53 deletion FISH aCGH FISH and aCGH MGUS 142 - - SMM 108 - - Newly diagnosed MM - 182 - Relapsed/refractory MM 62 156 19 HMCLs - 48 - Total 312 386 19 Background: Inactivation of p53 by mutation or allelic loss is a rare event in multiple myeloma (MM) at the time of disease diagnosis and believed to be more common in the late stages of the disease. Here we defined the prevalence of p53 deletions in monoclonal gammopathy of undetermined significance (MGUS), smoldering multiple myeloma (SMM), newly diagnosed MM, relapsed MM and human myeloma cell lines (HMCLs). Indirect mechanisms of p53 inactivation such as amplification of MDM2, or deletion of CDKN2A (p14ARF) were also investigated. Patients and Methods: A total of 631 MM samples and 48 HMCLs were analyzed for p53 abnormalities (Table 1) and compared with a cohort of plasma cell leukemia (PCL) previously published by us. Interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and highresolution array-based comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) were used to detect p53 deletions. MDM2 amplification and p14ARF loss were evaluated by aCGH. Overall survival (OS) was estimated through Kaplan Meier method. Results: The prevalence of p53 deletions was 1.4%, 3.7%, 8.9%, 20% and 87.5% in MGUS, SMM, newly diagnosed MM, relapsed MM and HMCLs respectively (Figure 1). Of interest patients in first relapse showed a p53 deletion prevalence of 18% in comparison with 33% for patients in second relapse or more. We obtained p53 deletion status in 8 patients noted to have deletion at the time of relapse and in whom we had previous samples stored. In 7 of 8 cases deletions had been acquired (absent in the previous samples). The median OS for relapsed MM patients with or without p53 deletion were 4.2 months and 37.8 months respectively (p <0.001). MDM 2 amplification and p14ARF loss was detected in 0.4% and 2% of new diagnosed MM, 0.6% and 5.1% of relapsed MM and 2% and 29% of HMCLs respectively. Discussion: Emergence of p53 deletion/mutations denotes progression genetic events in MM. Importantly we show for the first time the overriding importance of p53 deletions as prognostic markers in relapsed MM. A molecular staging system that is based on the presence of p53 inactivation may be more powerful than classifying patients based on the loss of p53. Other abnormalities involving p53 pathway regulators like MDM2 gain and p14ARF loss are infrequent events in MM, even in advanced disease. Figure 1. Prevalence of p53 deletions Figure 1. Prevalence of p53 deletions
Validation of CLL FISH Panel Scoring by Members of the Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia Research Consortium.
Abstract Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) probes and analysis methods for B-cell Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL) vary extensively among cytogenetic laboratories. This is not unexpected, as neither national nor international standards have been established for most FISH studies. Lack of standardization is problematic when data collected at multiple institutions are used for clinical correlative studies. To circumvent such problems, the five participating laboratories in the CLL Research Consortium (CRC) designed and executed a joint CLL FISH validation study. Methods: Initially a survey was sent to assess equipment, methods and experience with FISH for CLL. In a pilot study to compare laboratory performance in scoring patient samples, slides from ten patients were prepared and sent to each participating lab to be hybridized with five probe sets (= 50 hybridizations) and analyzed according to their local protocol. In a second pilot study, slides from two patient samples and identical probe sets were sent to the participating labs where hybridization and analysis were carried out according to their local protocol. Next, technologists and directors from all participating labs attended a workshop where technologists working in pairs scored nuclei together, techniques and scoring criteria were established, and consensus reached on other concerns. In a proficiency test nine months after the workshop, slides from two patient samples (10 hybridizations) were hybridized and scored according to each lab’s protocol and results shared using a common reporting form. Results: Survey results indicated that four labs used the same commercially available CLL FISH panel, and one used a combination of probes from the same vendor plus several home-brew probes. Each lab scored between 100 and 200 nuclei per hybridization site, and each independently set normal cutoff values. The FISH panel included probes to detect 11q, 13q, and 17p deletions, trisomy 12, and IGH gene rearrangement. One lab included probes to detect 6q deletion. In the first pilot study each lab used their hybridization methods, probe sets, and scoring criteria. Differences among labs were observed due to variations in probe strategy, reporting of anomalies, and perhaps most important, scoring criteria. Probe strategy differences resulted in variable reporting of 11q- vs monosomy 11 and 12q duplication vs trisomy 12. Some participants reported 13q-x1 and 13q-x2 as subclones and some reported only 13q-. One lab reported an IGH rearrangement whereas the others scored IGH as normal. In the second pilot study each lab used the same methods and probe sets to facilitate comparison of scoring by the technologists. All labs correctly identified the abnormalities, and there were no false positive results. Minor scoring differences were attributed to variation in scoring criteria or inexperience with an unfamiliar FISH probe strategy. The proficiency test that followed the workshop demonstrated 100% concordance in identification of abnormalities. Inter-lab scoring was much improved compared to the first pilot study. The only exceptions were a 13q- range of 72–90% in one case, and a 17p- range of 38–67% in another case. Conclusion: The pilot studies identified a need to develop common scoring criteria. The subsequent workshop and proficiency test demonstrated that the collaborative effort resulted in more standardized scoring among the CRC laboratories. Our collaborative study emphasizes the need to establish rigorous standards and guidelines for FISH procedures and scoring criteria. Standardization of FISH methods among participating laboratories will enhance the confidence in FISH studies for both clinical applications and cooperative intergroup clinical research.
Cytogenetic Analysis of Normal Human B Cells Following CpG Stimulation: Implications for Interpretation of CpG Induced CLL Metaphase Analysis
Abstract BACKGROUND: Karyotype analysis of metaphase cells for discovering genome-wide cytogenetic abnormalities has played an important role in prognosis and counseling of patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL). Due to the low proliferative rate of CLL B cells, karyotype analysis has been of limited clinical utility in this disease. Thus, fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) on interphase cells has replaced karyotype analysis for the assessment of recurrent genetic changes in CLL. Recently, immunostimulatory CpG-oligodeoxynucleotides (CpG) have been shown to induce primary CLL B cell proliferation via engagement of toll-like receptor 9 (TLR9), thereby rendering karyotype analysis feasible and providing for a useful and reliable method to discover new cytogenetic abnormalities in CLL B cells. However, we and others have shown that CpG stimulation of CLL and normal B cells also induces robust expression of activation induced cytidine deaminase (AID), a mutagenic enzyme that is linked to the development of cytogenetic abnormalities. It is therefore plausible that cytogenetic abnormalities observed following CpG stimulation of CLL B cells may not reflect de novo abnormalities but rather reflect CpG induced-AID mediated cytogenetic alterations. We began to address this possibility by assessing the effects of CpG stimulation on the karyotypes of normal blood B cells. HYPOTHESIS: Since CpG stimulation induces AID expression in CLL and normal B cells, we hypothesize that: robust B cell activation by CpG could result in cytogenetic abnormalities thereby contributing to lymphomagenesis; and if CpG induces cytogenetic abnormalities that are linked to disease initiation and/or progression, such information would be of great value in the interpretation of cytogenetic data obtained from CpG-stimulated CLL B cells. METHODS: We performed interphase FISH analysis on freshly isolated blood B cells, and metaphase karyotype analysis on CpG stimulated B cells from 17 healthy blood donors. Pure (>98%) B cells obtained by negative selection, were hybridized at isolation with a probe set to identify deletion 6q, 11q, 13q, and 17p, trisomy 12, and IGH gene rearrangements, and cells were also stimulated for 5 days with 10 μg/ml CpG (CpG 2006, synthesized in-house) plus IL-2 and IL-15 for metaphase analysis. At least 20 post-CpG metaphase spreads were analyzed for each sample and abnormalities were considered clonal using the accepted convention (gains or translocations are present in two or more cells and loss present in at least 3 cells). The expression of AID in the B cells pre- and post-CpG stimulation was assessed by RT-PCR. RESULTS: FISH analysis of freshly isolated B cells showed that all 17 subjects were normal. After CpG stimulation, all samples examined exhibited strong AID expression as revealed by RT-PCR. By karyotype analysis, none of the 17 CpG stimulated samples showed evidence of clonal abnormalities. However, one or more nonclonal chromosomal abnormalities were observed in 7 out of 17 (41.2%) samples. Among those 7 samples, 4 samples had 1 abnormal metaphase out of a minimum of 20 examined while the other 3 samples exhibited two or more cells, each with distinct abnormalities. Some of those nonclonal abnormalities have also been observed in CLL (i.e., trisomy 3, trisomy 12 and 14q32 rearrangements). This is a much higher incidence of nonclonal abnormalities than has been seen with peripheral blood cells cultured by other methods. CONCLUSION: Our data have significance for the biology of CLL and for clinical practice. First, our data suggest that signaling through TLR9, and perhaps other receptors that likewise induce robust B cell AID expression, may represent a natural mechanism by which B lineage cells acquire chromosomal abnormalities during normal immune responses that may predispose toward neoplastic transformation. Second, given that none of the CpG-induced metaphases in normal B cells resulted in clonal abnormalities in the 5 day timeframe, our data also validate the clinical utility of CpG as a valuable tool for the cytogenetic analysis of CLL B cells since only clonal abnormalities are currently scored. However, it remains possible that non-clonal abnormalities seen in CpG-stimulated CLL B cells may be relevant to the disease process if future work shows that CpG stimulation uncovers recurring non-clonal defects of chromosomes/genes associated with tumorigenic events.
Clinical Outcome of Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia Patients with Sole 13q FISH Detectable Defects: One Versus Two 13q Deletions.
Abstract Figure Figure Background: An isolated 13q deletion in patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) is the single most common cytogenetic abnormality and is a favorable prognostic parameter (Dohner et al., NEJM3432:1910, 2000). Although 13q- can occur as either a heterozygous (13q-x1) or homozygous (13q-x2) deletion, it is unknown whether these two genetic types differ in their impact on clinical outcome. We previously postulated that 13q-x2 may be a more aggressive anomaly than 13q-x1 (Dewald et al., BJH121:287, 2003) and have undertaken a long-term clinical follow-up of patients with an isolated FISH detectable 13q- to test this hypothesis. Methods: We identified patients diagnosed with CLL between October 1992 to May 2008 and who had 13q deletion as their sole FISH abnormality. FISH was performed within 2 years of diagnosis and prior to treatment in all patients. Patients were sorted into three groups: 13q-x1 only, 13q-x2 only, or mosaic with both 13q-x1 and 13q-x2 cells. We assessed differences in percentage of abnormal cells, demographic characteristics, and clinical outcome among the three groups. Results: We identified 259 patients with isolated 13q deletion. Age ranged from 38 to 90 years (median=61) and included 99 women and 160 men. With respect to Rai stage, 142 patients (60%) had low risk [Rai 0], 81 (34%) intermediate risk [Rai I-II], and 13 (6%) high risk [Rai III-IV] disease. After a median follow-up of 1.9 years, 40 patients (15%) have been treated and 17 (7%) have died. Median TFS and OS for all patients were 6.9 and 9.3 years, respectively. The mean percentage of abnormal nuclei in the three groups was 44%, 53%, and 47% for 13q-x1 only, mosaic 13q-x1/13q-x2, or 13q-x2 only, respectively (p=0.22). No significant difference in age or gender was observed based on whether 13q- occurred as a heterozygous or homozygous deletion, or was mosaic. Likewise, no significant difference in survival (p=0.313, see Table) or time to treatment (p=0.53) was found among the three groups. Five year OS rates for the 13q- x1 only, 13q- x2 only, and mosaic 13q- x1/13q- x2 are 85%, 95%, and 83%, respectively Median time to treatment for 13q-x1 was not reached, and for the mosaic13q-x1/13q-x2 and 13q-x2 groups median time to treatment was 6.9 and 4.9 years, respectively. Conclusions: The presence of deletion in one versus two 13q- chromosomes in CLL patients appears to have no significant impact on treatment free or overall survival. This observation supports the grouping of CLL patients with isolated 13q- of one or both alleles into a single risk category as originally proposed in the risk categorization by Dohner et al. Taking the present findings together with those of Dohner et al and Dewald et al, we propose a hierarchical risk model of FISH abnormalities in CLL as 17p- à 11q- à 6q- à +12 à normal à 13q-, from most to least aggressive. The 13q- group would now include 13q-x1, 13q-x2, and the mosaic subgroups.
Inactivation of Tumor Necrosis Factor 3 Gene (TRAF3) Is Frequently Identified in Waldenström’s Macroglobulinemia Patients.
Abstract Constitutive activation of NF-κB signaling pathways has been identified in a variety of malignancies, however the molecular basis has remained largely unknown. Recently, we have shown mutations in 10 genes encoding positive and negative regulators of NF-κB signaling pathways in 20% of multiple myeloma (MM) patients, with TRAF3 being the most commonly affected gene. TRAF3 is a negative regulator of NF-κB signal and its inactivation results in the constitutive activation of the alternative or noncanonical NF-κB signaling pathway. With the exception of two recent studies in MM, there is no available data regarding the mechanisms that dysregulate NF-κB in other B-cell malignancies. The aim of this study was to analyze the TRAF3 status in a cohort of Waldenström’s macroglobulinemia (WM) patients. Forty-nine WM were analyzed by using a combination of array-based comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) and cIgM-FISH. Genome sequencing from 28 of these patients was performed on all coding exons of TRAF3 and the adjacent intron-exon junctions. A NF-κB index, as a measure of NF-κB transcription activity, was calculated from 21 patients with gene expression data. The index is the mean expression level of four probe sets differentially expressed between human myeloma cell lines with identified mutations compared to those without identified NF-κB pathway mutations (CD74, IL2RG and 2x TNFAIP3). By performing aCGH we identified a small monoallelic deletion (∼460 Kb), including the TRAF3 locus in one of 22 patients. Genome sequencing identified a missense mutation (D483N) in the remaining allele. This substitution affects a highly conserved amino acid throughout vertebrate evolution, suggesting its functional relevance. We used cIgM-FISH to screen 27 patients with no available aCGH data and we found one biallelic TRAF3 deletion and one chromosome 14 monosomy. In the later case, no DNA was available to sequence the remaining allele. Both samples with biallelic inactivation of TRAF3 possess the two highest NFKB index values of our WM cohort, suggesting NF-κB transcription activity. Moreover, the case with biallelic deletion showed the lowest level of TRAF3 gene expression. Additionally, the entire TRAF3 coding region was sequenced in 28 of these 49 patients and one homozygous nonsense mutation (K286X) was identified. No GEP was available in this sample to calculate the NF-κB index. TRAF3 was only recently implicated in a malignant process, when inactivating mutations and biallelic deletions were reported in approximately 13% of MM patients, making it the most frequently inactivated tumor suppressor in MM. Our study has identified biallelic TRAF3 inactivation in at least 3 of 49 WM patients, suggesting that the constitutive activation of NF-κB signaling pathways may be involved in the pathogenesis of WM. Recent findings showing an association between TRAF3 loss of function and good response to bortezomib in MM patients suggest that proteasome inhibitor-based therapy may be an attractive option in the treatment of the WM patients with constitutive activation of NF-κB signaling pathways. Additional mutational screening of TRAF3 and other regulators of these pathways are ongoing to determine the extent of constitutive activation present in WM and other B-cell malignancies.
Peripheral Blood Cytogenetic Studies in Myelofibrosis: Overall Yield and Comparison with Bone Marrow Cytogenetic Studies
Abstract Background: Peripheral blood (PB) is sometimes used in place of bone marrow (BM) for cytogenetic studies in either primary (PMF) or post-polycythemia vera/essential thrombocythemia (post-PV/ET MF) myelofibrosis. In a retrospective study, we examined overall yield from PB cytogenetic studies in MF and where possible compared the results with those obtained by BM cytogenetic analysis. Methods: Standard laboratory techniques were used to perform cytogenetic studies in both the PB and BM. A successful study constituted the acquisition of at least two analyzable metaphases and an abnormal clone required the presence of a specific cytogenetic abnormality in at least two metaphases. Clinical and laboratory correlations were made using variables collected at the time of cytogenetic studies. Results I: A total of 242 PB cytogenetic studies were reviewed to identify 59 MF cases; 39 were PMF and 20 post-PV/ET MF. Median age was 60 years (range 36–77) and 37 were male patients. The median duration of the disease at the time of PB cytogenetic studies was 3.5 years (range 0.2–35). At least two analyzable metaphases (median 20, range 2–31) were obtained in 49 (81%) of the 59 study patients; in univariate analysis, this was predicted by presence and degree of circulating myeloid progenitor cells (p < 0.0001), higher PB CD34 count (p < 0.0001), higher leukocyte count (p = 0.0008), and absence of myeloid growth factor therapy (p = 0.005). In multivariable analysis, only the presence of circulating myeloid progenitor cells sustained its significance. Results II: Twenty two cases had concomitant PB and BM cytogenetic studies performed. Of these, 9 patients had abnormal BM cytogenetic findings; the concomitant PB cytogenetic studies were also abnormal in 5 (56%) patients but normal in the other 4. Conversely, PB cytogenetic studies were abnormal in 12 patients; the concomitant BM cytogenetic studies were abnormal in 5 (41%) and normal in the remaining 7. PB cytogenetic studies were not successful in 4 of the 22 total cases; BM studies were successful in 3 of these 4 cases and the results were normal in all. Conclusion: In the presence of circulating myeloid progenitor cells, PB can be considered as an alternative to BM for cytogenetic studies in MF patients, especially in view of the difficulty getting BM aspirates in this disease. However, considering the prognostic value of specific cytogenetic abnormalities in MF, the non-trivial discordance between the BM and PB cytogenetic findings, observed in the current study, warrants a prospective evaluation for further clarification.
The Histone Acetyltransferase CBP Is Essential for Conventional T Cell Development.
Abstract Defining the epigenetic mechanisms (e.g. chromatin modifications) that underlie T cell fate decisions is a major challenge. The transcriptional coactivators CREB binding protein (CBP) and the closely related p300 comprise a two-member family of histone/protein acetyltransferases that interact with over 50 T lymphocyte-essential transcriptional regulators. Rather than having distinct regulatory roles, CBP and p300 are often thought to confer utilitarian transactivation and histone modifying functions to transcription factors that mediate T cell fate. In contrast to this view, we show here that CBP acts uniquely in conventional T cell development. Inactivation of CBP, but not p300, starting at the double negative stage of T cell development yielded thymocytes with partial activation of an effector/memory- or innate-T cell program. CD8SP thymocytes from CBP mutant mice expressed genes that define professional CD8 cells such as Il-2/Il-15 receptor β chain, granzyme A, interferon γ (Ifnγ), Fas ligand, perforin, and the chemokine receptors Ccr5, and Cxcr3. CD4SP thymocytes from CBP mutant mice also expressed effector genes such as Ifnγ, Il-4, and Ccr5. In addition, CD8SP and CD4SP thymocytes from CBP mutant mice produced Ifnγ protein when the cells were stimulated with phorbol ester and ionomycin. Mechanistically, loss of CBP acted cell non-autonomously to induce the expression of the CD8 T cell master regulatory transcription factor eomesodermin (Eomes). This suggests that CBP in thymocytes or T cells controls an extracellular factor that helps demarcate conventional naïve T cell development in the thymus from effector/memory T cell differentiation in the periphery.
Comparative High Resolution Array-Based CGH (aCGH) in B-Cell Malignancies.
Abstract The use of high-resolution aCGH allows for whole genome screening for copy number changes even in tumors that rarely produce metaphase spreads. The aim of this study was to characterize the aCGH findings in B-CLL, lung MALT lymphoma, Waldenström’s Macroglobulinemia (WM), Multiple Myeloma (MM) and human myeloma cell lines (HMCLs). This study includes 301 B-cell malignancy samples (19 B-CLL, 19 MALT, 20 WM, 48 HMCLs and 195 MM) and an additional 76 melanoma samples. We found MM to have the highest number of abnormalities per karyotype, with 15.8±7.5 (mean ± SD) and 20.6±17.0 in hyperdiploid (H) and non-hyperdiploid MM (NH), respectively. The remaining diseases have a significantly lower number of abnormalities: 5.5±4.5 in B-CLL, 3.5±1.96 in MALT and 4±3.5 in WM. Aneuploidy and biallelic deletions were rare events in these three diseases. B-CLL has two highly recurrent abnormalities involving 11q22-q23 (29%) and 13q14.3 (33%). A minimal deleted region (MDR) of ∼108Kb was identified at 11q comprising ACAT1, NPAT and ATM. In 13q, a 280Kb MDR was recognized, including TRIM13, KCNRG, mir-15a and mir-16. The subgroup of MALT patients with t(11;18) had very few abnormalities and the majority are a consequence of unbalanced translocations (MALT, BIRC2 and BIRC3 deletions). In the remaining MALT samples, trisomy 3 and 18q gain were the most common abnormalities (31% each). The 6q16.3-q26 deletion was the most common abnormality in WM (45%). In 4 of 9 patients with 6q deletion there was an associated 6p gain. The same observation was found in 2 of 3 patients with 8p loss and concomitant 8q gain. Interestingly, 6p and 8q gain were not identified in patients without 6q and 8p deletions. Deletion of 17p was the most common recurrent abnormality observed in our panel of B-cell cancers, being identified in MM, WM and B-CLL. In B-CLL and WM, small mono and biallelic deletions of the NF-kB negative regulators, TRAF3 and NFKBIA, were identified, suggesting a potential involvement of this pathway in the pathogenesis of these diseases. Hierarchical clustering of the aCGH data in MM identified 3 distinct groups, NH-MM, H-MM and MM with deletions of chromosome 13 and 14. Interestingly, MGUS and SMM were more commonly clustered with H-MM. Several sub-clusters were observed in the H-MM group, the most prominent being made up exclusively of patients from TC class D1. This cluster was characterized by the presence of trisomy 11 and 21. The 11q13 TC group clustered and was highly associated with 11q amplifications due to unbalanced t(11;14). The 6q deletion defined a cluster with WM, MM and Melanoma patient with that abnormality. In the case of B-CLL and MALT, the only identifiable clusters were observed in cases with 13q loss and trisomy 3, respectively. These results highlight both, the common and unique aCGH findings in several B-cell cancers. By hierarchical clustering, MM was significantly divergent from the rest of the B-cell diseases. Due to the limited number of abnormalities in B-CLL/MALT/WM, the clustering of these groups was exclusively based on the common abnormalities. The use of aCGH has refined the MDRs of 11q and 13q in B-CLL. Additionally, the identification of deletions affecting the NF-kB pathway in B-CLL and WM has prompted us to hypothesize on the importance of constitutive NF-κB activation in these diseases.
A Comprehensive Study of Chromosome 13 Abnormalities (Δ 13) in Multiple Myeloma Using High-Throughput, Array-Based Methods.
Abstract Chromosome 13 abnormalities (Δ13), monosomy or deletion, are seen in greater than 50% in patients with Multiple Myeloma (MM) and are associated with poor survival and reduced response to therapy. Δ13 is suggestive of a tumor suppressor model. In this study, we use a comprehensive, high-throughput approach involving array-based technologies to identify genes on chromosome 13 that are important in the pathogenesis and/or progression of MM. Array-based Comparative Genomic Hybridization (aCGH) is being conducted to identify a minimum region of 13q loss in a series of MM cell lines and patient samples. DNA is isolated, labeled and hybridized with a differentially labeled normal DNA reference to determine gene/genomic copy number changes. Arrays are analyzed to search for the minimum region of loss based upon single copy loss for a series of nearby mapping transcripts in each cell line. Data will be cross-referenced to determine the true minimum region of 13q loss in MM. Also, to discover genes harboring potential inactivating mutations, we are using inhibition of nonsense-mediated RNA decay (NMD) coupled with cDNA microarray. This modification of the Gene Identification by NMD Inhibition (GINI) method, first introduced by Noensie and Dietz (2001), is used to identify genes on chromosome 13 that may be inactivated due to premature truncating codons (PTCs). This method is based upon a cell’s natural ability to survey for and degrade RNA species that contain PTCs by activation of the nonsense mediated RNA decay (NMD) pathway. Treating cells with the drug Emetine can inhibit NMD and increase the expression of genes likely harboring truncating mutations. Preliminary data have revealed several candidate genes, with increased ratios after Emetine treatment, which map to chromosome 13. Upon defining a minimum region of loss based upon aCGH data, we will prioritize genes from our NMD study for mutational analysis. It our hope to also perform an array-based CpG island screen to simultaneously analyze all CpG islands on chromosome 13 to detect genes possibly inactivated by hypermethylation. This comprehensive, organized approach incorporating high-throughput techniques for the detection of genomic loss, mutation, and methylation is the first of its kind to our knowledge and may maximize the potential for the identification of a 13q tumor suppressor in MM.
‘Must See’ Videos? Why Educators Need Better Video Analytics to Measure Learning
The pervasiveness of flipped classrooms and blended learning has tasked educators with creating content targeting fundamental concepts for asynchronous learning. The visual nature of anatomy subject matter makes video technology particularly well‐suited to convey important relationships. Education technology companies purport that video analytics may provide educators insights into their learners and the effectiveness of their videos. This study examines this claim using analytics recorded by a learning video platform during a 7‐week human anatomy course at the Mayo Clinic Alix School of Medicine (Arizona campus). First‐year medical students (n=48) were provided with daily faculty‐guided videos (n=21) of prosected cadavers [mean length ± SD (mm:ss) = 07:32 ± 3:28]. The videos highlighted structures covered during laboratory sessions. Each video was released less than 36 hours after the associated laboratory session. Video analytic data was recorded, including the number of times a video was viewed and played, average view time and the length of time a student watched a video before closing the page or pausing the video and never restarting it (drop‐off rate). Multiple linear regression analysis was conducted using JMP software to examine the relationship between these video analytic variables and laboratory practical examination performance. None of the video analytic variables, when calculated by individual video or individual student, were significant predictors of practical exam performance [mean exam performance = 88.83%; individual videos, R 2 = 0.024, p = 0.78; individual student, R 2 = 0.113, p = 0.63]. The results of this study are consistent with previous analyses of the educational effectiveness of videos in anatomy courses, in spite of the company’s claim that “videos can improve learning results”. While videos may make education more accessible and engaging, the impact on student learning is difficult to determine using the basic metrics supplied by the video learning platform. Until more sophisticated video analytics become available, such data will remain of limited use to educational researchers.