Whitwell, Jennifer L.

Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine the interrater reliability and validity of the Apraxia of Speech Rating Scale (ASRS-3.5) as an index of the presence and severity of apraxia of speech (AOS) and the prominence of several of its important features. Method: Interrater reliability was assessed for 27 participants. Validity was examined in a cohort of 308 participants (120 with and 188 without progressive AOS) through item analysis; item-Total score correlations; correlations among ASRS Total score and component subscores and independent clinical ratings of AOS, dysarthria and aphasia severity, intelligibility, and articulatory errors, as well as years postonset and age; and regression models assessing item and Total score prediction of AOS presence. Results: Interrater reliability was good or excellent for most items and excellent for the Total score. Item and Total score analyses revealed good separation of participants with versus without AOS. Inter-item and item-Total score correlations were generally moderately high as were correlations between the ASRS Total score and independent ratings of AOS severity, intelligibility, and articulatory errors. The Total score was not meaningfully correlated with ratings of aphasia and dysarthria severity, years postonset, or age. Total scores below 7 and above 10 revealed excellent diagnostic sensitivity and specificity for AOS. The presence of eight or more abnormal features was also highly predictive of AOS presence. Conclusions: The ASRS-3.5 is a reliable and valid scale for identifying the presence and severity of AOS and its predominant features. It has excellent sensitivity to AOS presence and excellent specificity relative to aphasia and dysarthria in patients with neurodegenerative disease. Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.21817584

AbstractBackgroundPosterior cortical atrophy (PCA) is associated with hypometabolism on FDG‐PET and atrophy on MRI in the parietal and occipital lobes, and patients often show the cingulate island sign (CIS) whereby posterior cingulate metabolism is relatively spared compared to the precuneus and cuneus. It has been hypothesized that medial temporal sparing may be related to CIS in PCA. We aimed to assess the severity of medial temporal atrophy in PCA and determine whether the presence of a CIS is related to medial temporal sparing.MethodFifty‐five PCA patients underwent a 3T volumetric MRI and FDG‐PET. The degree and symmetry of medial temporal atrophy on MRI was visually assessed in both hemispheres using the five‐point Scheltens scale (0=normal; 1=mild; 2=moderate; 3=marked; 4=severe). Visual assessments of FDG‐PET coded the presence/absence of a CIS and whether the CIS was symmetric or asymmetric. Hippocampal volumes and a quantitative CIS were also measured. Associations between medial temporal atrophy scores and clinical measures were assessed using linear regression correcting for age.ResultMedial temporal atrophy was most commonly mild (38% on the right, 40% on the left), followed by moderate (35% on the right, 29% on the left), and then no atrophy (18% on right, 25% on left). Marked or severe atrophy was only observed in 9% of patients on the right and 5% of patients on the left. Atrophy was asymmetric in 55%, and when asymmetric was most commonly worse on the right (76%). Greater medial temporal atrophy was associated with older age (p<0.001) and worse verbal episodic memory (p=0.008). The CIS was observed in 44% of the PCA patients and was asymmetric in 50% of these. The patients with a CIS showed greater medial temporal asymmetry (p=0.016), but did not show lower medial temporal atrophy scores, compared to those without a CIS. Hippocampal volumes were not associated with quantitative CIS.ConclusionMild to moderate medial temporal atrophy is a common finding in PCA and is associated with worse memory impairment and older age. However, medial temporal sparing was not related to the presence of a CIS in PCA.

AbstractBackgroundMulti‐compartment modelling of white matter (WM) microstructure using Neurite Orientation Dispersion and Density Imaging (NODDI) can provide information on WM health through the neurite (axons and dendrites) density index and free water measures. We hypothesized that cerebrovascular disease (CVD), Alzheimer’s disease (AD), and an FDG pattern suggestive of TDP‐43 proteinopathy would be associated with distinct NODDI readouts of WM damage which would be informative for identifying the substrate for cognitive impairment.MethodWe identified two independent cohorts with multi‐shell diffusion MRI, amyloid and tau PET, and cognitive assessments. One, were participants from the Mayo Clinic Study of Aging, a population‐based cohort of 347 elderly randomly sampled from the Olmsted county, Minnesota. The second were 61 amyloid positive AD participants from the Mayo AD Research Center.ResultWe observed an increase in free water and decrease in neurite density in the genu of the corpus callosum associated with vascular risk factors, which we refer to as vascular WM component (Figure 1). Tau PET signal reflective of 3R/4R tau deposition was associated with worsening neurite density index in the temporal WM where we measured parahippocampal cingulum and inferior temporal WM bundles. Worsening temporal neurite density was associated with (antemortem confirmed) FDG TDP‐43 signature. Post‐mortem neuropathologic data on a small subset (n=9) of this sample lend support to our findings. In the population‐based cohort where vascular disease was more prevalent, the vascular WM component explained variability in global cognition (partial R2 of free water and neurite density = 8.3%) and MMSE performance (8.2%) which was comparable to amyloid PET (7.4% for global cognition and 6.6% for memory) (Table 1). In the AD dementia clinic‐based cohort, tau deposition was the greatest contributor to cognitive performance (9.6%), but there was also a non‐trivial contribution of the temporal WM component (8.5%) to cognitive performance. The differences observed between the two cohorts were reflective of their distinct clinical composition.ConclusionWhite matter microstructural damage assessed using advanced diffusion models may add significant value for distinguishing the underlying substrate (whether CVD versus neurodegenerative disease caused by tau deposition or TDP‐43 pathology) for cognitive impairment in older individuals.

AbstractBackgroundWe previously demonstrated that Alzheimer’s disease (AD) patients ≥70 y/o tend to have smaller medial temporal volumes in the presence of relatively less medial temporal 18F‐flortaucipir‐PET uptake compared to young AD patients. TAR DNA‐binding protein 43 (TDP‐43) is frequently found in the brains of AD patients and is associated with old age and medial temporal atrophy. In this study, we aimed to determine whether TDP‐43 could be contributing to the mismatch between medial temporal volumes and flortaucipir‐PET uptake in older AD patients.MethodWe identified 77 participants (median age at death 79 years [range: 51‐99]) who had been enrolled into the Mayo Clinic Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center or Neurodegenerative Research Group (NRG), had undergone flortaucipir‐PET and volumetric MRI scans close to death, and autopsy confirmed AD neuropathological changes, as well as TDP‐43 assessments. Grey matter volumes and flortaucipir standard uptake value ratios (SUVRs) were calculated for hippocampus, amygdala, entorhinal, inferior temporal, and midfrontal cortices. We used bivariate‐response linear regression modelling, adjusting for Braak neurofibrillary tangle stage, to estimate the effect of TDP‐43 and age on gray matter volume and flortaucipir uptake, and tested whether TDP‐43 effect sizes varied according to age.ResultAfter accounting for Braak stage, older individuals tended to have significantly lower flortaucipir uptake across regions and lower hippocampal and entorhinal cortex (ERC) volumes. TDP‐43 was associated with reduced hippocampus and ERC volumes but was unrelated to flortaucipir SUVRs (Figure 1). Notably, the TDP‐43 effect size for the hippocampus and ERC was largely consistent across age, i.e., at any age, TDP‐43‐positive participants had significantly smaller hippocampal (∼12% decrease) and ERC (13% decrease) volumes than TDP‐43‐negative participants. However, at older ages, the mean volumes in the whole cohort and, more evidently, in those with dementia moved closer towards the mean of those with TDP‐43 (Figure 1), likely attributable to the increasing frequency of TDP‐43 with age.ConclusionTDP‐43 is a major contributor to the mismatch between flortaucipir uptake and medial temporal lobe volumes in older AD patients where lower medial temporal regional volumes are observed in the presence of less flortaucipir uptake.

AbstractBackgroundOptimizing software to measure Flortaucipir (AV‐1451) tau PET SUVR change‐over‐time is crucial for longitudinal observational studies and potential trials of anti‐tau agents. Ideal measurements should have good repeatability (low noise), and should clearly separate clinical cognitive groups.MethodWe compared 456 software methods varying in their use of: two major packages, each with cross‐sectional and longitudinal variants (FreeSurfer and an in‐house pipeline using SPM12, MCALT, and ANTs); three temporal‐lobe target regions (each with/without adjacent WM); seven reference regions; five PVC methods; and two statistics (mean vs. median). We used linear mixed‐effects models to compare methods using scans from 88 Mayo Clinic participants (46 cognitively impaired, 42 impaired, excluding those with symptoms inconsistent with the AD pathology imaged by Flortaucipir), each with three visits with PET and MRI. From these models, we calculated two criteria for each pipeline: relative measurement error (residual from the linear mixed model), and the t‐statistic for testing differences in group‐wise rates of change (which has a Cohen’s d interpretation of effect size for longitudinal data). We plotted both criteria orthogonally, then ranked methods overall according to the average of their ranks on both individual criteria.ResultMethods using the entorhinal cortex target region performed poorly in both criteria (Figure 1). The top 10 methods by the combined criteria (top‐left in Figure 2) all used the Mayo SPM12‐based pipeline with an eroded supratentorial WM (eSWM) or composite (eSWM + pons + cerebellum) reference region. Among them, 9/10 used the longitudinal variant, 8/10 used 2‐compartment PVC, and 7/10 used median. Altogether, our results favored SUVR methods with a longitudinal design (simultaneously calculating all time‐points), a temporal‐lobe meta‐ROI including adjacent WM, a composite reference region, 2‐class voxel‐based (Meltzer) PVC, and median statistics. Methods using GTM‐Tau PVC (Baker et al., Data in Brief, 2017) had the highest group separation but relatively large measurement error, giving them ranks 197 and 199 out of 456 with the joint (average rank) criteria.ConclusionCompared with popular FreeSurfer‐based methods (ranks 176, 258; Figure 2), our top‐ranked approaches approximately halved error in SUVR measurements while maintaining or improving group separation.

Abstract Aims To assess the burden of transactive response DNA‐binding protein of 43 kDa (TDP‐43) inclusions in a unique cohort of old‐age patients with genetic frontotemporal lobar degeneration (gFTLD‐TDP) and compare these patients with sporadic old‐age individuals with TDP‐43, either in the presence of Alzheimer's disease (AD‐TDP) or in isolation (pure‐TDP). Methods The brain bank at Mayo Clinic‐Jacksonville was searched for cases ≥75 years old at death with TDP‐43 extending into middle frontal cortex. Cases were split into the following groups: (1) gFTLD‐TDP ( n = 15) with progranulin ( GRN )/ C9ORF72 mutations; (2) AD‐TDP ( n = 10)—cases with median Braak neurofibrillary tangle (NFT) stage VI, Thal phase V; (3) pure‐TDP ( n = 10)—cases with median Braak NFT stage I, Thal phase I. Clinical data were abstracted; TDP‐43 burden was calculated using digital pathology. Results Amnestic Alzheimer's dementia was the clinical diagnosis in ≥50% patients in each group. The distribution of TDP‐43 burden in gFTLD‐TDP and AD‐TDP, but not pure‐TDP, was limbic‐predominant targeting CA1 and subiculum. Patients with gFTLD‐TDP had higher burden in entorhinal cortex compared to AD‐TDP. TDP‐43 burden in middle frontal cortex did not differ between the three groups. Conclusions In old age it is challenging to clinically and pathologically differentiate gFTLD‐TDP from AD‐TDP and pure‐TDP‐43 based on burden. Like AD‐TDP, old age gFTLD‐TDP have a limbic predominant TDP‐43 distribution. The finding that amnestic Alzheimer's dementia was the most common clinical diagnosis regardless of group suggests that TDP‐43 directly and indirectly targets limbic regions.

Purpose This study describes motor speech disorders and associated communication limitations in six variants of progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP). Method The presence, nature, and severity of dysarthria and apraxia of speech (AOS) were documented, along with scores on the Apraxia of Speech Rating Scale–Version 3 (ASRS-3) for 77 (40 male and 37 female) patients with PSP. Clinician-estimated and patient-estimated communication limitations were rated using the Motor Speech Disorders Severity Rating (MSDSR) Scale and the Communicative Effectiveness Survey (CES), respectively. Descriptive statistics were calculated for each of these dependent variables. One-tailed t tests were conducted to test mean differences in ASRS-3 and CES between participants with and without AOS and between participants with and without dysarthria. Spearman rank correlations were calculated between ASRS-3 scores and clinical judgments of AOS and dysarthria severity and between MSDSR and CES ratings. Results Nine participants (12%) had normal speech. Eighty-seven percent exhibited dysarthria; hypokinetic and mixed hypokinetic–spastic dysarthria were observed most frequently. AOS was observed in 19.5% of participants across all variants, but in only 10% exclusive of the PSP speech and language variant. Nearly half presented with AOS in which neither phonetic nor prosodic features clearly predominated. The mean ASRS-3 score for participants with AOS was significantly higher than for those without and correlated strongly with clinician judgment of AOS severity. Mean ASRS-3 was higher for participants with dysarthria than for those without but correlated weakly with dysarthria severity. Mean MSDSR and CES ratings were lower in participants with AOS compared to those without and moderately correlated with each other. Conclusions Motor speech disorders that negatively impact communicative effectiveness are common in PSP and occur in many variants. This is the first description of motor speech disorders across PSP variants, setting the stage for future research characterizing neuroanatomical correlates, progression of motor speech disorders, and benefits of targeted interventions. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.14111837

Purpose Individuals with primary progressive apraxia of speech (PPAOS) have apraxia of speech (AOS) in which disruptions in articulation or prosody predominate the speech pattern, referred to, respectively, as phonetic or prosodic subtypes. Many develop aphasia and/or dysarthria. Past research has demonstrated that simple temporal acoustic measures are sensitive to the presence of AOS. The aim of this study was to describe the change in temporal acoustic measures over time and assess if specific patterns of AOS or co-occurring aphasia or dysarthria impact the rate of change over time. Method Durations for multiple productions of the words cat , catnip , catapult , and catastrophe , in an imitative speech task, were recorded for 73 patients, with two to six visits each. A linear mixed-effects model was used to assess the cross-sectional differences and longitudinal influence of AOS subtype and presence of aphasia/dysarthria on speech rate. Pearson correlations were calculated between rate measures and performance on other clinical measures. Results Cross-sectionally, patients with prosodic-predominant PPAOS produced words more slowly than those with phonetic-predominant PPAOS. Patients with either aphasia or dysarthria produced words more slowly than those without. Longitudinally, the speech rate of patients with phonetic-predominant PPAOS had a reduction of 0.5 syllables per second per year. Patients with prosodic-predominant AOS changed less quickly, as did those who developed aphasia. Dysarthria did not impact rate of change. There were strong associations between speech rate measures and other clinical indices of speech and language functioning. Conclusion Simple temporal acoustic measures may reflect the subtype of AOS (phonetic or prosodic predominant), serve as an index of progression of AOS, and inform prognostication relative to the presenting combination of speech and language features. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.13564724