Abstract Background Archived formalin fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) samples are valuable clinical resources to examine clinically relevant morphology features and also to study genetic changes. However, DNA quality and quantity of FFPE samples are often sub-optimal, and resulting NGS-based genetics variant detections are prone to false positives. Evaluations of wet-lab and bioinformatics approaches are needed to optimize variant detection from FFPE samples. Results As a pilot study, we designed within-subject triplicate samples of DNA derived from paired FFPE and fresh frozen breast tissues to highlight FFPE-specific artifacts. For FFPE samples, we tested two FFPE DNA extraction methods to determine impact of wet-lab procedures on variant calling: QIAGEN QIAamp DNA Mini Kit ("QA"), and QIAGEN GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit ("QGR"). We also used negative-control (NA12891) and positive control samples (Horizon Discovery Reference Standard FFPE). All DNA sample libraries were prepared for NGS according to the QIAseq Human Breast Cancer Targeted DNA Panel protocol and sequenced on the HiSeq 4000. Variant calling and filtering were performed using QIAGEN Gene Globe Data Portal. Detailed variant concordance comparisons and mutational signature analysis were performed to investigate effects of FFPE samples compared to paired fresh frozen samples, along with different library preparations. In this study, we found that five times or more variants were called with FFPE samples, compared to their paired fresh-frozen tissue samples even after applying molecular barcoding error-correction and default bioinformatics filtering recommended by the vendor. We also found that QGR as an optimized FFPE-DNA extraction approach leads to much fewer discordant variants between paired fresh frozen and FFPE samples. Approximately 92% of the uniquely called FFPE variants were of low allelic frequency range (<5%), and collectively shared a “C>T|G>A” mutational signature known to be representative of FFPE artifacts resulting fromcytosine deamination. Based on control samples and FFPE-frozen replicates, we derived an effective filtering strategy with associated empirical false-discovery estimates. Conclusions Through this study, we demonstrated feasibility of calling and filtering genetic variants from FFPE tissue samples using a combined strategy with molecular barcodes, optimized DNA extraction, and bioinformatics methods incorporating genomics context such as mutational signature and variant allelic frequency.
Bioinformatics and DNA-extraction strategies to reliably detect genetic variants from FFPE breast tissue samples
No container title available | May 27, 2019 | Volume: No volume available | Issue: No issue available | Pages: No page available
Abstract Background Archived formalin fixed paraffin embedded (FFPE) samples are valuable clinical resources to examine clinically relevant morphology features and also to study genetic changes. However, DNA quality and quantity of FFPE samples are often sub-optimal, and resulting NGS-based genetics variant detections are prone to false positives. Evaluations of wet-lab and bioinformatics approaches are needed to optimize variant detection from FFPE samples. Results As a pilot study, we designed within-subject triplicate samples of DNA derived from paired FFPE and fresh frozen breast tissues to highlight FFPE-specific artifacts. For FFPE samples, we tested two FFPE DNA extraction methods to determine impact of wet-lab procedures on variant calling: QIAGEN QIAamp DNA Mini Kit ("QA"), and QIAGEN GeneRead DNA FFPE Kit ("QGR"). We also used negative-control (NA12891) and positive control samples (Horizon Discovery Reference Standard FFPE). All DNA sample libraries were prepared for NGS according to the QIAseq Human Breast Cancer Targeted DNA Panel protocol and sequenced on the HiSeq 4000. Variant calling and filtering were performed using QIAGEN Gene Globe Data Portal. Detailed variant concordance comparisons and mutational signature analysis were performed to investigate effects of FFPE samples compared to paired fresh frozen samples, along with different library preparations. In this study, we found that five times or more variants were called with FFPE samples, compared to their paired fresh-frozen tissue samples even after applying molecular barcoding error-correction and default bioinformatics filtering recommended by the vendor. We also found that QGR as an optimized FFPE-DNA extraction approach leads to much fewer discordant variants between paired fresh frozen and FFPE samples. Approximately 92% of the uniquely called FFPE variants were of low allelic frequency range (<5%), and collectively shared a “C>T|G>A” mutational signature known to be representative of FFPE artifacts resulting fromcytosine deamination. Based on control samples and FFPE-frozen replicates, we derived an effective filtering strategy with associated empirical false-discovery estimates. Conclusions Through this study, we demonstrated feasibility of calling and filtering genetic variants from FFPE tissue samples using a combined strategy with molecular barcodes, optimized DNA extraction, and bioinformatics methods incorporating genomics context such as mutational signature and variant allelic frequency.
Quantitation of CD11c+ dendritic cells normal breast tissue and benign breast disease.
Journal of Clinical Oncology | April 19, 2019 | Volume: 33 | Issue: 15_suppl | Pages: e22115-e22115
18 Background: Benign breast disease (BBD) is diagnosed in 1-2 million women/year in the US, and while these patients are known to be at substantially increased risk for subsequent development of breast cancer, existing models for risk assessment perform poorly at the individual level. Here, we describe a DNA-microarray-based transcriptional model for breast cancer risk prediction for patients with sclerosing adenosis (SA), a lesion found in ¼ of all BBD patients that is characterized by epithelial proliferation, disordered acinar architecture, and stromal fibrosis. Methods: A training set was developed from 86 patients diagnosed with sclerosing adenosis (SA), of which 27 subsequently developed cancer within 10 years (cases) and 59 remained cancer-free at 10 years (controls). A diagonal linear discriminate analysis (DLDA)-prediction model for prediction of cancer within 10 years (SA TTC10) was generated from transcriptional profiles of formalin fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) biopsy-derived RNA. This model was tested on a separate validation case-control set composed of 65 SA patients. Results: The SA TTC10 gene signature model, composed of 35 gene features, achieved a clear and significant separation between case and control with receiver operating characteristic area under the curve of 0.913 in the training set and 0.836 in the validation set. Conclusions: Our results provide the first demonstration that benign breast tissue contains transcriptional alterations that indicate risk of breast cancer development, and that essential precursor biomarkers of malignancy are present many years prior to cancer development. Furthermore, the SA TTC10 gene signature model, which can be assessed on FFPE biopsies, constitutes a novel prognostic biomarker for patients with SA.
Alterations in the Immune Cell Composition in Premalignant Breast Tissue that Precede Breast Cancer Development
Clinical Cancer Research | January 26, 2017 | Volume: 23 | Issue: 14 | Pages: 3945-3952
Abstract Background: Age-related lobular involution (LI) is a physiological process in which the terminal duct lobular units of the breast regress as a woman ages. Analyses of breast biopsies from women with benign breast disease (BBD) have found that extent of LI is negatively associated with subsequent breast cancer development. Here we assess the natural course of LI within individual women, and the impact of progressive LI on breast cancer risk. Methods: The Mayo Clinic BBD cohort consists of 13,455 women with BBD from 1967-2001. The BBD cohort includes 1115 women who had multiple benign biopsies, 106 of whom had developed breast cancer. Within this multiple biopsy cohort, the progression of the LI process was examined by age at initial biopsy and time between biopsies. The relationship between LI progression and breast cancer risk was assessed using standardized incidence ratios (SIRs) and by Cox proportional hazards analysis. Results: Women who had multiple biopsies were younger age and had a slightly higher family history of breast cancer as compared with the overall BBD cohort. Extent of LI at subsequent biopsy was greater with increasing time between biopsies and for women age 55+ at initial biopsy. Among women with multiple biopsies, there was a significant association of higher breast cancer risk among those with involution stasis (lack of progression, HR 1.63) as compared with those with involution progression, p = 0.036. Conclusions: The multiple biopsy BBD cohort allows for a longitudinal study of the natural progression of LI. The majority of women in the multiple biopsy cohort showed progression of LI status between benign biopsies, and extent of progression was highest for women who were in the perimenopausal age range at initial biopsy. Progression of LI status between initial and subsequent biopsy was associated with decreased breast cancer risk. Citation Format: Derek Radisky, Daniel W. Visscher, Ryan Frank, Robert A. Vierkant, Stacey J. Winham, Melody L. Stallings-Mann, Tanya L. Hoskin, Aziza Nassar, Celine M. Vachon, Lori A. Denison, Lynn C. Hartmann, Marlene H. Frost, Amy C. Degnim. Natural history of age-related lobular involution and impact on breast cancer risk. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 107th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2016 Apr 16-20; New Orleans, LA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2016;76(14 Suppl):Abstract nr LB-364.
Abstract 4395: Tissue stiffness and hypoxia regulate breast cancer stem cells through ILK
Cancer Research | July 26, 2016 | Volume: 76 | Issue: 14_Supplement | Pages: 4395-4395
Abstract The mechanical and chemical properties of the cellular microenvironment can influence the phenotype of cancer cells. The hypoxic conditions within solid breast tumors can contribute to invasiveness and the formation of breast cancer stem cells (CSCs). Integrin-linked kinase (ILK) is a critical mediator for mechanotransduction, a process that converts exogenous mechanical stimuli into biochemical signals. Yet, it is unclear how the physical properties of the tumor microenvironment, including matrix stiffness and hypoxia, integrate to direct the formation of the breast CSC niche. Using an innovative engineered culture model, we found that stiff and hypoxic microenvironments activate integrin signaling and a stem-like gene signature in breast cancer cells, suggesting that integrin signaling, matrix mechanics and oxygen tension cooperatively promote the formation of breast CSCs. Stiff and hypoxic microenvironments promote integrin signaling and the expression of CSC markers including CD44 and Nanog. Knocking down ILK reverts the CSC phenotype of invasive breast cancer cells on stiff matrix, and abrogates their ability to form mammospheres and colonies in soft agar. In contrast, ectopic expression of ILK enhances CSC properties. ILK promotes integrin signaling and the CSC phenotype through the PI3K/Akt pathway. Stiff microenvironments promote tumor formation and metastasis in ovo. ILK depletion significantly abrogates the tumorigenenic and metastatic potential of invasive breast cancer cells in ovo. Importantly, we found that breast cancer cells expressing ILK and the CSC marker CD44 were only present in the regions of tumors predicted to be stiff in breast cancer patient samples. Our data suggest that ILK act as an essential mechanosensor that regulates breast CSC phenotype in response to matrix mechanics and oxygen tension to regulate the formation of breast CSCs. Citation Format: Mei-Fong Pang, Melody Stallings-Mann, Michael J. Siedlik, Victor D. Varner, Siyang Han, Derek C. Radisky, Celeste M. Nelson. Tissue stiffness and hypoxia regulate breast cancer stem cells through ILK. [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 107th Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research; 2016 Apr 16-20; New Orleans, LA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2016;76(14 Suppl):Abstract nr 4395.