Thompson, R. Houston

What's known on the subject? and What does the study add? There is great variability in the utilization of partial nephrectomy, but the causes of these variations are not well understood. The present study underscores the already observed phenomenon of surgical volume influencing surgical planning and outcomes, but it gets at why this might be so. We observe that high‐volume renal surgeons have different thresholds of ‘technical feasibility’. Objective To investigate why there continues to be wide variability in the application of partial nephrectomy ( PN ) for treating small renal masses despite guidelines in the US and E urope stating that a PN is a standard of care for a patient with a T 1 renal mass. Patients and Methods In June 2009, 764 surgeon‐members of the A merican U rologic A ssociation ( AUA ) participated in a survey evaluating the management of renal masses. Renal mass complexity was graded by nephrometry score ( NS ). Multivariable logistic regression models with generalized estimating equations were constructed to evaluate how tumour, surgeon and practice‐setting characteristics influence the use of PN . Results The survey response rate was 19%. Each urological surgeon responded to eight scenarios, providing 6112 evaluable cases. Tumour NS ranged from 4 to 10, and each unit increase in NS was associated with 59% increased likelihood of a surgeon offering RN on multivariable analysis (odds ratio [ OR ] = 1.59; 95% CI : 1.52–1.64). When holding patient and tumour characteristics constant, the following surgeon and practice‐setting characteristics significantly increased the odds of offering a PN: increasing renal case volume ( OR = 1.57; 95% CI : 1.27–1.95), academic practice ( OR = 1.80; 95% CI : 1.42–2.29), increasing PN % volume ( OR = 3.7; 95% CI : 2.46–5.55) and younger surgeon age (≤40 vs >50 years) ( OR = 1.64; 95% CI : 1.35–1.96). Conclusion The characteristics of a surgeon and the setting in which he or she practices influence the utilization of PN , the adherence to professional guidelines, and the threshold of tumour complexity at which a surgeon stops offering PN .

Abstract Purpose: Release of inhibitory coregulatory proteins into the circulation may represent one mechanism by which tumors thwart immune responses. Our objective was to determine whether soluble B7-H1 (sB7-H1) levels in patients with clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC) are associated with pathologic features and patient outcome. Experimental Design: We developed an ELISA for quantification of sB7-H1 in biological fluids. Biochemical confirmation of the measured analyte as sB7-H1 was done by protein microsequencing using supernates from tumor cell lines. Biological activity of sB7-H1 was assessed in vitro utilizing T-cell apoptosis assays. We tested sB7-H1 levels in the sera from 172 ccRCC patients and correlated sB7-H1 levels with pathologic features and patient outcome. Results: sB7-H1 was detected in the cell supernatants of some B7-H1–positive tumor cell lines. Protein sequencing established that the measured sB7-H1 retained its receptor-binding domain and could deliver proapoptotic signals to T cells. Higher preoperative sB7-H1 levels were associated with larger tumors (P < 0.001), tumors of advanced stage (P = 0.017) and grade (P = 0.044), and tumors with necrosis (P = 0.003). A doubling of sB7-H1 levels was associated with a 41% increased risk of death (P = 0.010). Conclusion: Our observations suggest that sB7-H1 may be detected in the sera of ccRCC patients and that sB7-H1 may systemically impair host immunity, thereby fostering cancer progression and subsequent poor clinical outcome. Clin Cancer Res; 17(7); 1915–23. ©2011 AACR.