Background: The American Joint Replacement Research-Collaborative (AJRR-C) is a National Institutes of Health-funded P30 Core Center for Clinical Research and seeks to accelerate practice-changing arthroplasty research by leveraging the American Joint Replacement Registry (AJRR) and shared multicenter research infrastructure. The AJRR-C convened 2 complementary meetings to establish a scalable coordinated pathway from the identification of high-priority clinical questions to the initiation of prospective studies. Methods: In July 2025, leaders from The Hip Society, The Knee Society, the American Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons, the AJRR, the Orthopaedic Research and Education Foundation, and the broader research community identified and prioritized clinical research questions regarding infection, perioperative management, new technologies, surgical techniques, implants, and quality. In April 2026, orthopaedic surgeons, methodologists, and artificial intelligence experts reconvened to evaluate contemporary approaches for addressing these priorities. Results: A central theme of the meetings was the importance of utilizing a fit-for-purpose approach in which study design is tailored to the clinical question, available data, and potential sources of bias. Clinical questions with clear equipoise and feasible interventions may warrant randomization, whereas questions involving rare outcomes, rapidly evolving technologies, surgeon preferences, or long-term surveillance may be better addressed with observational studies. Participants emphasized the need for a robust, sustainable network for arthroplasty clinical trials that provides the shared infrastructure necessary for coordinated site engagement, standardized data definitions, reliable longitudinal follow-up, and AJRR linkage across multicenter trials. Two new AJRR-nested randomized trials arose from the priority-topics meeting, and their development demonstrates the potential of the AJRR-C consensus model to translate research priorities into practice-changing evidence generation. Conclusions: The AJRR-C established a coordinated pathway from the prioritization of research to the implementation of multicenter studies to address high-priority arthroplasty research questions. Sustaining this model requires continued collaboration among orthopaedic societies, investigators, methodologists, and the AJRR, as well as reliable funding mechanisms.