Citations 1497

Refinement of Neurofilament light Dynamics in CSF and Blood for familial Alzheimer’s Disease

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S14 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.078802

AbstractBackgroundDisease‐modifying therapies for Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) are likely most beneficial when initiated in the pre‐symptomatic phase. To track success of such interventions fluid biomarkers became instrumental, with neurofilament light chain (NfL) showing particular promise. We previously reported that serum NfL increases in pre‐symptomatic phases of familial (autosomal‐dominantly inherited) AD (fAD) and that within‐person rate‐of‐change in NfL is an earlier predictor of fAD symptom onset compared to cross‐sectional levels. The aim of the study at hand was to extend these initial findings in a larger cohort.MethodParticipants enrolled in the Dominantly Inherited Alzheimer Network (DIAN) with matched cross‐sectional and longitudinal cerebrospinal fluid (CSF; n = 962) as well as plasma (n = 1294) samples were used. NfL measurements have been performed on the SIMOA platform using commercially available assay‐kits. To investigate the influence of physiological factors independent from AD, we first analyzed whether age and body mass index (BMI) could account for observed variation in inter‐individual CSF and plasma NfL levels considering non‐carrier family‐members (NC) as a healthy control group. Next, utilizing estimated years to symptom onset (EYO) and previously published methods (Preische et al., 2019), we determined the point in disease course when baseline and longitudinal CSF and plasma NfL concentrations started to increase in mutation carriers (MC) relative to NC, after adjusting for age and BMI.ResultOur results reveal a tight correlation of CSF and blood NfL values within MC as well as NC (figure 1A‐B). However, within NC, after correction for age and BMI, some unexplained variability remained (figure 1C). Further, a decrease of the NfL plasma/CSF ratio over age was found after correcting for BMI (figure 1D). The discrimination of MC from NC was equally good for plasma compared to CSF, being possible on the group level as early as around ‐15 to almost ‐20 EYO depending on the modelling (figure 2).ConclusionOur results support plasma equivalently to CSF NfL as a clinically useful biomarker to longitudinally track neurodegeneration in fAD. The systemic factors influencing physiological NfL values in blood should be investigated in future studies to further improve interpretation of this biomarker.
Trajectories of plasma biomarkers of Alzheimer’s disease and neurodegeneration in the general population

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S14 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.077907

AbstractBackgroundPlasma biomarkers of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) and neurodegeneration have demonstrated diagnostic utility and associations with AD pathology. Our objective was to map the average trajectories over age of plasma biomarkers and more established biomarkers including cognition, amyloid PET, and hippocampal volume.MethodWe included 1731 cognitively unimpaired (CU) and 226 mild cognitive impairment (MCI) participants from the Mayo Clinic Study of Aging (mean age of 70.3 years; 46.3% female; 14.8 years of mean education) with one or more measurements of amyloid‐PET, MRI with hippocampal volume measurements adjusted for head size (HVa), and plasma biomarkers (Aβ42/40 ratio, p‐tau181, GFAP, and NfL measured using Quanterix Simoa assays). A global cognitive z‐score was created by averaging the z‐scores of memory, language, executive function, and visuospatial domains. Smoothing spline curves were calculated for the values of each variable over age and placed on the same plot. Since each variable has a different scale, the smoothed curves were centered at the predicted value at age 50 and scaled so that a value of 1 would be one standard deviation of the fitted values from ages 50‐80.ResultAt age 50, GFAP and NfL start to increase, and Aβ42/40 was observed to decrease. At age 55, amyloid‐PET and p‐tau181 had a smooth and upward‐curving increase. After age 70, the average values of p‐tau181 increased at a higher rate. Average cognition started declining after 55 years. HVa began to decline after age 60 and then showed a steeper decline at age 72.ConclusionThis study demonstrates that predicted values of plasma GFAP, NfL, and Aβ42/40 across participants begin to change at younger ages than cognitive decline or increases observed in amyloid PET. The changes observed during middle age in GFAP and NfL likely reflect non‐AD pathologies and aging processes, while Aβ42/40 may be a leading indicator of future cerebral amyloidosis. Predicted plasma neurodegenerative biomarkers (GFAP and NfL) begin to change at younger ages than a traditional biomarker of neurodegeneration (HVa). Predicted ptau181 increases were observed in tandem with amyloid PET likely reflecting current amyloid status.
Modeling the temporal evolution of plasma and PET Alzheimer’s disease biomarkers

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S14 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.077615

AbstractBackgroundKnowledge of the temporal evolution among plasma Alzheimer’s biomarkers and PET will inform disease pathophysiology and appropriate implementation of plasma biomarkers (Therneau, NeuroImage 2021; Betthauser, Brain 2022). This study investigates the relative timing of progression of plasma p‐tau181, p‐tau217, GFAP, and amyloid PET on individual and population levels.MethodWe included 957 participants from the Mayo Clinic Study of Aging with clinical diagnoses of cognitively unimpaired (n = 732), MCI (n = 205), and Alzheimer’s clinical syndrome dementia (n = 20). An accelerated failure time (AFT) model was fit with amyloid (PiB) PET, plasma p‐tau217 (Meso Scale Discovery, Lilly), plasma p‐tau181, and GFAP (Simoa, Quanterix HD‐X) as quad‐variate endpoints, and sex, APOE genotype status, and education as covariates. The model output included a per subject adjustment or time‐shift for each biomarker indicating how much earlier or later it was estimated to progress relative to the average participant, the correlation (R) between adjustments for each pair of biomarkers, and the impact of covariates on each biomarker’s timing. Secondly, we estimated progression at a given age for selected cutpoints.ResultTemporal trajectories for each biomarker are shown in Figure 1. Individual‐level adjustments between plasma p‐tau217 and amyloid PET were highly correlated, R = 0.69(0.64‐0.74); how early or late an individual progressed on plasma p‐tau217 explained 48% of the variation in relative timing of amyloid PET progression. Associations of plasma p‐tau181 and GFAP with amyloid PET individual adjustments were moderate and low, respectively (Figure 2). Using the chosen cutpoints, the estimated order of biomarker progression was GFAP, amyloid PET, plasma p‐tau181, and plasma p‐tau217 (Figure 3).ConclusionOn the individual level, the strong association of the relative timing of progression of plasma p‐tau217 and amyloid PET supports that these processes are mechanistically related. The relatively lower associations of the timing of p‐tau181 and GFAP with amyloid PET likely reflect a lower biological association and greater measurement noise for p‐tau181. The individual adjustments, the primary output of this model, are independent of cutpoints. On the population level, relative timing of biomarker change is highly dependent on the cutpoints applied. This true for any analysis that employs cutpoints, regardless of the approach.
Comparing approaches based on the global functional organization of the brain versus local connectivity to predict tau‐PET across the Alzheimer’s disease phenotypic spectrum

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S14 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.076768

AbstractBackgroundPredictive models of tau‐PET accumulation have largely relied on the functional connectome to estimate its spatial patterns in Alzheimer’s disease (AD). Patterns of global functional organization represent a promising avenue as they encapsulate many biological properties relevant to neurodevelopment, cognition and degeneration. We compared approaches based on local connectivity (from task‐free fMRI) and global organization (from FDG‐PET) to predict regional tau‐PET across AD phenotypes.MethodWe included 430 cognitively unimpaired (CU) individuals (214 A+T‐, 216 A+T+) and 62 amnestic mild cognitive impairment (aMCI), 64 amnestic AD, 21 dysexecutive AD (dAD), 41 logopenic progressive aphasia (LPA) and 49 posterior cortical atrophy (PCA) patients (all A+T+) from the Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center, Mayo Clinic Study of Aging, and Neurodegenerative Research Groups (referred to as “Mayo cohort”). The connectivity approach consisted of assessing the relationship between a region’s tau level and its functional connectivity to the region of highest tau (epicenter). The global organization approach consisted of 1) performing a principal component analysis on 3000 FDG‐PET images that did not overlap with the Mayo cohort, 2) projecting FDG‐PET images of the Mayo cohort onto the low‐dimensional space generated in Step 1 and extracting corresponding weighted values across the first 100 components, 3) using these weighted values as predictors of regional tau‐PET in a linear model and determining optimal parameters based on predicted R 2 values, and 4) using the parameters from the model built in Step 3 to predict tau‐PET in the ADNI cohort (n = 86) (Fig.2).ResultThe connectivity‐based approach yielded adjusted R 2 values ranging from 0.19‐0.45 across diagnostic groups (Fig.1). The global organization approach yielded averaged adjusted R 2 and predicted R 2 values of 0.71 and 0.63, respectively, in the Mayo cohort. Out‐of‐sample median R 2 in the ADNI cohort was 0.41 (range 0.10‐0.60) (Fig.3).ConclusionAn unbiased approach based on the global functional organization of the brain and using an imaging modality widely used in clinical settings outperformed a connectome‐based one to predict regional tau‐PET across the AD phenotypic spectrum. Patterns of tau accumulation may better relate to the large‐scale physiology of the brain underlying specific mental functions rather than local connectivity factors.
White matter changes with cerebrovascular disease and Alzheimer’s disease pathologies

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S14 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.075685

AbstractBackgroundWhite matter (WM) plays an important role in cognitive function and undergoes substantial changes due to aging and increase in AD and AD related dementia (AD/ADRD) pathologies. While recent work proposed measurement of global WM changes from diffusion MRI as biomarkers for Cerebrovascular disease (CVD) such as PSMD and free water, there needs to be a better understanding of WM changes due to AD/ADRD pathologies. The goal of our recent work was to understand white matter changes with CVD and AD – common pathologies in AD/ADRD ‐ utilizing data from Mayo Clinic Study of Aging and Mayo ADRC.MethodUsing diffusion MRI (dMRI) in 718 participants from Mayo Clinic Study of Aging (mean age = 71.1 years, 56% male), we investigated relationships between commonly used dMRI measures and vascular risk as well as global amyloid PET. In a subset of 233 participants who were amyloid‐PET positive and also competed Tau‐PET (flortaucipir) from Mayo Clinic Study of Aging and Mayo ADRC, we investigated associations between regional flortaucipir SUVRs in Braak stages and regional WM changes.ResultsWe found greater frontal lobe WM damage with increasing vascular risk across all dMRI measures. We previously validated the strong relationship between the genu of the corpus callosum (anterior interhemispheric connections) dMRI measurements made on antemortem scans and cerebrovascular pathology observed on postmortem tissue (Nguyen et. al. Acta Neuropathologica 2022) supporting the utility of genu of the corpus callosum dMRI measures as a potential CVD biomarker. Also, we found greater posterior WM damage with increasing amyloid burden. Among the 233 amyloid positive participants, we found spatially dependent WM degeneration associated with regional flortaucipir SUVRs in Braak stages with greater extent of posterior WM damage. Further, dMRI measurements of the WM damage provided complementary information about disease staging and progression of AD in addition to flortaucipir SUVR measurements.ConclusionsAnterior WM measurements may be more specific to CVD and posterior WM changes are seen with increasing AD pathological burden. Our results suggest that WM changes observed with CVD and typical AD may be different and have clinical utility for differential diagnosis and disease staging.
Gliovascular molecular alterations in Alzheimer’s disease: a cross‐tissue, cross‐species study

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S13 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.073806

AbstractBackgroundInter‐cellular communication within the gliovascular unit (GVU) is critical for cerebral blood flow regulation, and maintenance of the blood‐brain‐barrier (BBB) properties. The breakdown of BBB in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is well‐established, but precise underlying molecular changes remain unclear. Additionally, whether GVU molecular alterations observed in AD brains are also detected in blood from living patients is unknown. Further, these GVU molecular perturbations require further investigation in different model systems to identify both human brain‐specific and cross‐species conserved alterations. In this study, we investigated prioritized GVU molecules altered in AD brains for their conservation in blood and cross‐species model systems.MethodsWe performed single nucleus RNA sequencing (snRNAseq) of temporal cortex tissue in AD and control brains. We analyzed this data to detect cell‐specific GVU molecular perturbations and their interactions. We investigated molecular interactions between vascular and astrocyte clusters, the major cell types of the GVU of the BBB. To determine whether GVU transcriptional alterations detected in the brain are preserved in the blood, existing blood expression, genetic, and neuroimaging data from two longitudinal antemortem cohorts were analyzed. Using model systems, including mouse, drosophila, and zebrafish, we evaluated the cross‐species conservation of the top GVU alterations detected in AD brains.ResultsBrain snRNAseq revealed transcriptional profiles of 6,541 astrocytes and 2,210 vascular cells. The latter formed three distinct vascular clusters characterized as pericytes, endothelia and perivascular fibroblasts. We identified differentially expressed genes and their enriched pathways within these clusters and observed the highest levels of transcriptional changes within pericytes. Vascular targets that interact with astrocytic ligands have biological functions in cell signaling, angiogenesis, amyloid ß metabolism, and cytoskeletal architecture. We discovered that genetic variants influencing blood expression levels of some of the prioritized GVU genes were associated with neuroimaging burden of cerebrovascular disease in living human cohorts. Our ongoing studies in model systems revealed conservation of some of the top prioritized molecular perturbations across species.ConclusionOur findings prioritized by multiscale, cross‐tissue human data revealed GVU perturbations within interacting pericyte and astrocyte molecules, which are conserved across multiple cross‐species models. These results nominate new molecular targets and mechanistic insights for BBB disruptions in AD.
Continuous associations between remote self‐administered cognitive measures and amyloid and tau PET biomarkers of Alzheimer’s disease

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S11 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.082144

Abstract Background Easily accessible and self‐administered cognitive assessments that can aide early identification of individuals at risk for Alzheimer’s disease (AD) dementia are critical for timely intervention. Mayo Test Drive (MTD) is a remote, self‐administered, multi‐device compatible, web‐based cognitive assessment (Stricker et al., 2022). We investigated continuous associations between MTD and amyloid and tau PET biomarkers and compared the strength of association to PET biomarkers and in‐person cognitive measures. Method 556 adults from the Mayo Clinic Study of Aging participated (mean age = 70.6; mean education = 16.0 years; 50.7% female; 97.5% white). Participants were predominantly cognitively unimpaired (95.3%; 4.7% had a consensus diagnosis of mild cognitive impairment). Participants completed (1) brain amyloid and tau PET scans, (2) in‐person neuropsychological assessment including Mayo Preclinical Alzheimer’s disease Cognitive Composite (Mayo‐PACC) and Global‐z, and (3) remote MTD comprised of the Stricker Learning Span (SLS) and the Symbols test, which are combined into an MTD composite. Multiple regressions adjusted for age, sex, and education queried associations between imaging biomarkers [amyloid meta‐region of interest (ROI), tau meta‐ROI, and tau entorhinal cortex (EC)‐ROI)] and composite and subtest scores from remote and in‐person measures. Davidson‐Mackinnon J‐test compared R‐squared values of models with remote versus in‐person composites. Result Lower performances on MTD composite and Mayo‐PACC were associated with higher amyloid meta‐ROI (p’s<.05; Table 1). MTD composite was also negatively associated with tau meta‐ROI and EC‐ROI (p’s<.05). For memory measures, SLS sum of trials was negatively associated with tau meta‐ROI (p = .01) and EC‐ROI (p<.001) with no associations between AVLT sum of trials and PET (p’s = .06; Table 2). Among processing speed/executive function measures, worse Trails B performance was associated with higher amyloid meta‐ROI (p<.001). Symbols and Digit Symbol Coding were not associated with PET (p’s = .29). A multivariable model with MTD explained significantly less variance (p = .04) for amyloid meta‐ROI (adjusted R‐squared = 0.165) than a multivariable model with Mayo‐PACC (adjusted R‐squared = 0.176); remote and in‐person composite measures were comparable for other associations (p’s>.05). Conclusion MTD is associated with continuous measures of amyloid and tau PET biomarkers of AD, demonstrating criterion validity for MTD. Several associations were comparable to relationships between gold‐standard in‐person neuropsychological tests and imaging biomarkers.
Comparing associations of Alzheimer’s disease plasma biomarkers with remote self‐administered cognitive measures versus in‐person neuropsychological tests

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S11 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.082087

Abstract Background Brief self‐administered cognitive assessments deployed remotely and combined with plasma biomarkers of Alzheimer’s disease (AD) are well suited to assess clinical symptoms and underlying biology in large‐scale decentralized studies. We investigated whether associations of self‐administered cognitive measures and plasma biomarkers were comparable to associations of in‐person cognitive measures and plasma biomarkers. Method Participants included 327 adults from the Mayo Clinic Study of Aging (mean age = 70.8; 48% female; mean education = 16.0 years; 96.9% white). Most (94.5%) were cognitively unimpaired; 5.5% had consensus diagnosis of mild cognitive impairment. Participants completed Mayo Test Drive (MTD; Stricker et al., 2022), a remote, self‐administered, multi‐device compatible web‐based cognitive assessment comprised of the Stricker Learning Span (SLS) and Symbols test that are combined into a MTD composite. Participants also completed in‐person neuropsychological assessment (global‐z; Mayo Preclinical Alzheimer’s disease Cognitive Composite [Mayo‐PACC]) and fasting venipuncture. Plasma was assayed via HD‐X simoa platform for amyloid‐beta (Aß)‐42 and Aß‐40 to create an Aß42/40 ratio, glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP), and neurofilament light chain (NfL) using the N4PE Quanterix kit as well as phosphorylated‐tau protein 181 (p‐tau181). P‐tau181, GFAP, and NfL were log10‐transformed. Multiple regression analyses adjusting for age, sex, and education examined associations between plasma biomarkers and composite and subtest scores from remote and in‐person measures. Davidson‐Mackinnon J‐test compared R‐squared values of models with remote versus in‐person composites. Result Lower performances on MTD, global‐z, and Mayo‐PACC (Table 1) were associated with higher GFAP (p’s = .02), NfL (p’s = .003), and p‐tau181 (p’s = .04). For memory, worse SLS and AVLT sum of trials were associated with higher GFAP (p’s = .01) and NfL (p’s = .03). For processing speed/executive function, worse Symbols and Trails B were associated with higher p‐tau181 (p’s = .02). Worse Trails B and Digit Symbol Coding were associated with higher NfL (p’s = .02), and worse Digit Symbol Coding was associated with lower Aß42/40 (p = 0.03; Table 2). A multivariable model with MTD explained significantly more variance (p = .04) for NfL (adjusted R‐squared = 0.461) than a multivariable model with Mayo‐PACC (adjusted R‐squared = 0.447); remote and in‐person composite measures were comparable for other associations (p’s>.05). Conclusion Remote and in‐person composite measures showed comparable associations with AD‐related plasma biomarkers, supporting MTD’s criterion validity.
Plasma biomarkers of Alzheimer´s disease in the continuum of dementia with Lewy bodies

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S10 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.082040

AbstractBackgroundPatients with dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB) may have Alzheimer´s disease (AD) pathology. Plasma biomarkers of beta‐amyloid (Aß), phosphorylated tau (pTau), and neurodegeneration are sensitive to AD neuropathologic changes in AD dementia. While these plasma biomarkers are well tested in the AD continuum, their performance for concomitant AD pathology in the DLB continuum is still unclear.MethodWe included patients with isolated REM sleep behavior disorder (iRBD; n = 15), with mild cognitive impairment with Lewy bodies (MCI‐LB; n = 37), and with DLB (n = 70) from the Mayo Clinic Alzheimer’s Disease Research Center. Cognitively unimpaired individuals (CU; n = 100) included from the Mayo Clinic Study of Aging were balanced on age and sex. A panel of plasma biomarkers of Aß40, Aß42, p‐tau181, neurofilament light chain (NfL), and glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) measures was obtained. We calculated the ratio of plasma Aß40/42. Lower Aß40/42 indicates increased Aß pathology. Plasma Aß40, Aß42, GFAP, and NfL were measured using the Simoa® Neurology 4‐Plex E Advantage kit and pTau‐181 was measured with the Simoa® pTau‐181 Advantage V2 kit. Both were run on a Quanterix HD‐X analyzer. AD imaging biomarkers were assessed on PET using Pittsburgh compound B (PiB) for Aß and 18F‐Flortaucipir for tau.ResultHigher levels of plasma GFAP were observed in the MCI‐LB (p = 0.014) and DLB (p<0.001) groups compared to CU (Figure). DLB patients also showed higher levels of plasma pTau181 (p<0.001) and NfL (p<0.001). Higher amyloid and tau PET standardized uptake value ratio (SUVr) in the DLB continuum were associated with higher levels of plasma p‐tau181, NfL, and GFAP (p<0.001). After accounting for age, plasma Aß40/42 did not correlate with amyloid or tau PET SUVr.ConclusionIn the DLB continuum, abnormal levels of GFAP in plasma can be detected as early as the prodromal stages of the disease. Plasma pTau181 reached abnormal levels in the DLB stage. Higher plasma GFAP, NfL, and p‐tau181 are associated with higher amyloid and tau PET SUVr in the DLB continuum. Plasma biomarkers have the potential to contribute to screening and early diagnosis in the DLB continuum, which has implications in designing new treatments.
Concordance between visual interpretation and quantitative analysis of [18F]flortaucipir pet images

Alzheimer's & Dementia | December 25, 2023 | Volume: 19 | Issue: S10 | Pages: No page available

10.1002/alz.082007

AbstractBackgroundPositron emission tomography (PET) imaging with [18F]flortaucipir allows for in‐vivo visualization of aggregated tau in Alzheimer’s disease (AD). The FDA‐approved label for [18F]flortaucipir PET provides a standardized, clinically applicable definition of tau‐PET positivity by visual interpretation. Here, we studied the concordance between this visual interpretation and quantitative approaches employed in research.MethodWe included 2692 participants (cognitively unimpaired [CU] and impaired [CI, MCI or AD dementia]) from four cohorts (Mayo Clinic Study of Aging and ADRC, ADNI, A4, and A05) with available [18F]flortaucipir PET (mean age: 70.2 y, 50.0% females). Three trained readers assessed each [18F]flortaucipir PET scan according to the FDA‐approved method. Visual reads were compared to an established approach for defining tau‐PET positivity based on SUVR values in a temporal meta‐ROI (Jack, et al. Alzheimers Dement. 2017). Previously defined “lenient” (SUVR = 1.22) and “conservative” (SUVR = 1.30) cut‐points were explored. In addition, visual reads were compared to tau‐PET positivity as defined by a scheme based on the expected spatial progression of tau pathology from the medial temporal lobe (MTL) to the temporal neocortex (NEO) (Ossenkoppele, et al. Nat Med. 2022; cut‐points: SUVRMTL = 1.30, SUVRNEO = 1.37).ResultConcordance between visual and quantitative approaches was limited (Figure 1): the “lenient” and MTL‐NEO methods yielded high rates of quantitative‐positive, visual‐negative scans (73‐52% and 26‐18% for CU and CI, respectively), while the “conservative” cut‐point failed to detect 45% and 13% of the CU and CI visual‐positive scans, respectively. The prevalence of tau‐PET positivity in Aß‐negative individuals was highest with the “lenient” cut‐point (∼24%) and lowest with visual interpretation (∼3%) (Figure 2). Visual‐positive, quantitative‐negative individuals were more frequently Aß‐positive than visual‐negative, quantitative‐positive individuals (“lenient”: 86% vs 50%, p<0.001; “conservative”: 87% vs 58%, p<0.001; MTL‐NEO: 85% vs 70%, p = 0.005). Among visually‐positive participants, 164 (28%) showed a tau deposition pattern that deviated from the expected MTL to NEO progression (Figure 3).ConclusionVisual and quantitative methods for [18F]flortaucipir PET are non‐exchangeable. Tau‐PET positivity based on visual interpretation aligns better with Aß‐pathology. A significant number of visually‐positive participants showed a pattern of tau accumulation that deviated from the expected stereotypical spatial progression and was not detected by standard quantitative methods.