ABSTRACT 162 patients with relapsed secondary central nervous system lymphoma (R‐SCNSL) (median age, 65 years; male, 59.9%) including central nervous system (CNS)‐only ( n = 120) and concomitant CNS/systemic relapse ( n = 42) were retrospectively analyzed. Overall, 21.9% of patients were classified as high risk according to the CNS International Prognostic Index (CNS‐IPI). Several biological and clinical features were significantly associated with leptomeningeal involvement, including double‐ or triple‐hit (DHL/THL) status, MYC rearrangement, negative BCL6 expression by IHC, bone marrow involvement, and concomitant R‐SCNSL. Multivariable analysis showed that leptomeningeal involvement independently predicted inferior OS and was associated with a 98% increase in the hazard of death compared with parenchymal relapse (HR = 1.98, 95% CI: 1.20–3.26, p = 0.008). Based on anatomical localization, R‐SCNSL was classified into four subtypes: parenchymal‐only involvement (parenchymal‐CNS [P‐CNS], 68/42%) and parenchymal involvement plus systemic relapse (parenchymal‐concomitant [P‐concomitant], 17/10.5%); and leptomeningeal with or without parenchymal involvement (leptomeningeal‐CNS [LM‐CNS], 52/32.1%) and leptomeningeal with systemic relapse (leptomeningeal‐concomitant [LM‐concomitant], 25/15.4%). This anatomical classification significantly impacted OS and PFS ( p < 0.001). Two‐year OS and PFS were 58.2% and 29.1% for P‐CNS, 32.4% and 17.7% for P‐concomitant, 22% and 13.9% for LM‐CNS, and 7.1% and 0% for LM‐concomitant, respectively. ASCT showed a trend toward improved survival among patients with a response (CR/PR) in a 4‐month landmark analysis. These findings support the clinical application of the anatomical classification in the management of R‐SCNSL.