Bond, Kamila M.

Abstract The intra- and inter-patient heterogeneity in high-grade glioma (HGG) continues to contribute to its poor prognosis. Clinical biopsies are often harvested from limited regions and typically are not image localized. Thus, they fail to capture the diversity within tumor regions, immune expression or normal cell abundances that play key roles in tumor development. It is important to gain an understanding of these subpopulation ecologies, their spatial resolution, and interactions between them that may then be exploited for future therapeutic benefit. Further, these may differ by patient characteristics such as sex, age at diagnosis and treatment status. Using an ongoing image-localized biopsy collection protocol, we have so far evaluated the bulk transcriptomics of 202 multi-regional biopsies from 58 patients to characterize HGG heterogeneity. These samples were processed through Monocle, a reverse graph embedding algorithm that groups samples into states and orders them along developmental trajectories. Deconvolution methods were previously used to predict relative abundances of 7 normal, 6 glioma, and 5 immune cell subpopulations for each sample, which we have now overlaid on the Monocle graph. Monocle classified HGG into 4 main states along a three-pronged trajectory. These states reveal distinct population ecologies with associated enriched gene pathways. We also note significant immune pathway enrichments that differ between state and patient-reported sex. Together, these algorithms reveal a simple transcriptomic trajectory that helps us understand the development and evolution of HGG. Characterizing the in vivo diversity within and between high grade gliomas is important for understanding prognosis, stratifying future treatments and ultimately improving patient outcome.

Abstract High-grade glioma continues to have dismal survival owing in part to its intra- and inter-patient heterogeneity. Standard clinical protocol collects tumor samples with the aim of providing or confirming a diagnosis and determining the status of a few key genes (e.g. IDH1, MGMT). However, this protocol is unable to capture the diversity within tumor regions, immune expression or normal cell abundances that play key roles in the development of the disease. To overcome this, during surgery we collect image-localized multi-regional biopsies to characterize this disease heterogeneity. Data collection is ongoing, and we currently have 202 samples from 58 patients with available bulk RNA-Seq. With a single-cell reference dataset from Columbia University, we used CIBERSORTx, a deconvolution method, to predict relative abundances of 7 normal, 6 glioma, and 5 immune cell subpopulations for each sample. We used Cox proportional hazard models with first-order statistics (mean, minimum, maximum) of abundances within patients to determine whether these are prognostic, then used TCGA RNA-Seq data to validate these findings. We found that one glioma proneural subtype was significantly beneficial for patient survival relative to other glioma subtypes across all statistics (and showed significance in TCGA). Proliferative and mesenchymal glioma subtypes also showed significance for one or two of the calculated statistics. Oligodendrocyte progenitor cell abundances were consistently significantly beneficial for patient survival in our cohort, while an increased abundance of abnormal (reactive) astrocytes is associated with poor prognosis. We also ran these analyses within invasive margin and core tumor regions to determine location-specific population abundances associated with patient survival. In conclusion, understanding the in vivo diversity of cellular subpopulations within high grade glioma is important for treatment stratification and patient benefit.

Abstract AIMS High-grade glioma continues to have dismal survival with current standard-of-care treatment, owing in part to its intra- and inter-patient heterogeneity. Typical diagnostic biopsies are taken from the dense tumor core to determine the presence of abnormal cells and the status of a few key genes (e.g. IDH1, MGMT). However, the tumor core is typically resected, leaving behind possibly genetically, transcriptomically and/or phenotypically distinct invasive margins that repopulate the disease. As these remaining populations are the ones ultimately being treated, it is important to know their compositional differences from the tumor core. We aim to identify the phenotypic niches defined by the relative composition of key cellular populations and understand their variation amongst patients. METHOD We have established an image-localized research biopsy study, that samples from both the invasive margin and tumor core. From this protocol, we currently have 202 samples from 58 patients with available bulk RNA-Seq, collected between Mayo Clinic and Barrow Neurological Institute. Using a single-cell reference dataset from our collaborators at Columbia University, we used CIBERSORTx, a deconvolution method, to predict relative abundances of 7 normal, 6 glioma, and 5 immune cell states for each sample. RESULTS We find that these cell state abundances connect to patient survival and show regional differences. For example, proneural glioma states were higher in invasive regions, whereas proliferative and mesenchymal states were higher in the tumor core. CONCLUSIONS Our analysis demonstrates a need to characterize the residual tissue following glioma resection to better understand the recurrent disease.

Abstract Characterizing intra- and inter-tumoral heterogeneity of glioblastoma has historically relied on discrete classifications of malignant cell populations leaving immune and other cell populations, known to exist admixed with the malignant tumor cells, relatively neglected. Manifold learning algorithms can manage deconvolving multiple cell populations and are often used to track cell state transitions in single cell transcriptomics. We applied a manifold learning approach to TCGA microarray data (Nf525) and bulk transcriptomics of 134 image localized biopsies across 30 patients with primary and 9 with recurrent glioblastoma to further elucidate how to organize biopsies across a spectrum of possible tissue states. The algorithm revealed a low-dimensional manifold graph for which each biopsy lives across 3 polarizing tissue states - one that is associated with diffusely invaded brain, one that is enriched in mesenchymal genes, and one that is enriched in classical proliferative tumor signatures. We deconvolved the bulk transcriptomics of the image-localized biopsies to reveal the relative abundance of 18 malignant, immune, and other cell subpopulations in each biopsy. Overlaying the cellular decomposition onto the manifold graph visualizing the tissue state distributions revealed that transitions between states correlate with changes in cellular cohabitation composition. The tumor cellular cohabitation ecologies have the lowest diversity, as inferred by ecological measures such as Shannon entropy and evenness, at the distal poles of the graph when compared to the transitional arms. Further, we found that the relationship between imaging appearance of contrast enhancement on T1-weighted MRI and the biopsy cellular composition varies with sex and primary vs recurrent biopsy status. The limited spectrum of possible tissue states revealed by the manifold learning is suggestive of a limited continuum along which tumor and non-tumoral cell populations can cohabitate. Such a limited low-dimensional biological space may constrain the dynamics of tumor biology in a predictable manner.

Abstract Brain tumor associated edema is a significant cause of patient morbidity and mortality often requiring continual treatment with differing levels of success across patients. Edema is a broad term that can indicate increased local water as well as diffusely infiltrating tumor cells. Edema is visualized as hyperintense regions on T2-weighted (T2W) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and is typically associated with blood-brain barrier (BBB) breakdown and tumor aggressiveness. Understanding the molecular mechanisms driving imaging patterns of “edema” could provide insights into clinical imaging interpretation. We have an ongoing image-guided biopsy study that allows us to link biopsy molecular markers with locoregional MRI patterns of edema. Further, we previously developed a physics-based method to estimate edema abundance (i.e., edema map) from T2W MRIs. Our goal was to identify connections between BBB-associated molecular factors and edema abundance in brain tumors. Our cohort included 38 patients (female: 15, male: 23) with 129 image-guided biopsies (female: 62, male: 67). We correlated image-localized edema map values with the mean transcriptional frequency for 57 genes related to BBB function. Additionally, we examined correlations separately according to patient reported sex (i.e., male and female) and imaging phenotype (i.e., ENH: enhancing and NE: non-enhancing). We utilized multiple comparisons corrections with a 5% false discovery rate to determine significance. For the overall cohort, we observed significant positive correlations for the HIF1A (p< 0.001) and SOX2 markers with edema. For NE samples, significant correlations included APOE (p=0.001), HIF1A (p< 0.001), PIK3CA (p< 0.001), PTCH1 (p< 0.001), and SOX2 (p< 0.001). Amongst female samples, a significant correlation with PTCH1 (p=0.002) was observed. There were no significant correlations noted for male and enhancing sub-cohorts. Significant correlations between molecular markers of BBB and edema map values could lead to clinical biomarkers for edema or tumor aggressiveness.

Abstract Background Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) is the mainstay for neurosurgical oncology but not for informing us about glioma biology. An obstacle to developing MR-based glioma biomarkers is the absence of rigorous correlation between MRI features and glioma biology as assessed in multi-regional biopsies, within and across patients. Methods We directly addressed this obstacle by collating a unique cohort of 202 MRI-localized biopsies from 58 patients. We define a low-dimensional transcriptional pseudotime continuum along which heterogeneous high-grade glioma (HGG) samples organize both within and across patients. Results We observe three polarized transcriptional tissue states: infiltrated brain, immune/inflammatory, and proliferative associated with patterns of cohabitation of cellular subpopulations. The states and deconvolved populations show correlation with enhancement status on T1Gd MRI. Moreover, discrete MRI habitats, regions sharing common imaging features, defined as combinations of high or low signal intensity across multiparametric MRI revealed 14 MRI habitats. We order the MRI habitats according to the average pseudotime on the transcriptional continuum. We find that MRI habitats with low pseudotime (associated with early tumor development and diffusely invaded brain tissue) localized at the periphery of the tumor whilst high pseudotime either proliferative or immune/inflammatory states were towards the core of the lesion. We find that composition of MRI habitats are impacted by MGMT status and patient sex. Conclusion This suggests that ongoing aggregation of MRI-localized biopsies may augment our projection of biology onto MRI habitats to support tracking of the evolution of cellular ecologies within and across each patient’s tumor over time. Key Points Trajectory inference of HGG samples reveals a continuum connecting three polarized tissue states reflecting transitions in cellular population ecologies and gene set enrichment Combining multiparametric MRI features into regional MRI habitats reveal clinically-distinct patterns of cell co-habitation and tissue state MGMT methylation status shifts the cellular patterns of cohabitation within MRI habitats Importance of the Study Regional heterogeneity is a defining characteristic of high-grade glioma (HGG). Mapping the transcriptomic biology of multiregionally sampled MRI-localized biopsies from high-grade gliomas onto a low-dimensional space reveals a continuum between three primary tissue states: infiltrated brain, immune/inflammatory, and proliferative. Each state is associated with distinct cell cohabitation ecologies. Transitions between the tissue states coordinate with changes in tumor composition, revealing potential direct connections between tumor biology shifts and their manifestation on clinical imaging.

Abstract Background Accurate assessments of patient response to therapy are a critical component of personalized medicine. In glioblastoma (GBM), the most aggressive form of brain cancer, tumor growth dynamics are heterogenous across patients, complicating assessment of treatment response. This study aimed to analyze days gained (DG), a burgeoning model-based dynamic metric, for response assessment in patients with recurrent GBM who received bevacizumab-based therapies. Methods DG response scores were calculated using volumetric tumor segmentations for patients receiving bevacizumab with and without concurrent cytotoxic therapy (N = 62). Kaplan–Meier and Cox proportional hazards analyses were implemented to examine DG prognostic relationship to overall (OS) and progression-free survival (PFS) from the onset of treatment for recurrent GBM. Results In patients receiving concurrent bevacizumab and cytotoxic therapy, Kaplan–Meier analysis showed significant differences in OS and PFS at DG cutoffs consistent with previously identified values from newly diagnosed GBM using T1-weighted gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (T1Gd). DG scores for bevacizumab monotherapy patients only approached significance for PFS. Cox regression showed that increases of 25 DG on T1Gd imaging were significantly associated with a 12.5% reduction in OS hazard for concurrent therapy patients and a 4.4% reduction in PFS hazard for bevacizumab monotherapy patients. Conclusion DG has significant meaning in recurrent therapy as a metric of treatment response, even in the context of anti-angiogenic therapies. This provides further evidence supporting the use of DG as an adjunct response metric that quantitatively connects treatment response and clinical outcomes.