Longitudinal Genome Wide Analysis of Patients with Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia Reveals Complex Evolution of Clonal Architecture At Disease Progression and At the Time of Relapse
Abstract Abstract 2838 The combination of novel agents and chemo-immunotherapy (CIT) has led to a significant increase in both overall and complete response rates for chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL). There is, however, significant clinical heterogeneity in the overall effectiveness of CIT. Specifically, some patients are long-term responders who experience durable clinical remission while others, even though responding well initially, have less durable remissions. It is unclear if this heterogeneity is a reflection of an incomplete cytotoxic effect or whether certain leukemia sub-populations (i.e. subclones) are resistant to the effects of CIT. Comprehensive analysis of tumor cells has provided, in some malignancies, evidence of extraordinary genomic complexity and intraclonal genetic diversity. Conversely, little is known of the genetic architecture of the leukemic clone in CLL patients and the extent to which CLL tumor cells differentiate genetically at the subclonal level. In order to gain insight into the genetic architecture and clonal evolution underlying disease progression/relapse, we performed a sequential, longitudinal whole genome analysis by array-based comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) in 22 CLL cases with evidence of clinical progression and/or clinical relapse post therapy. These patients received standard purine analogue, cyclophosphamide and rituximab (PCR) for progressive disease. For the purposes of this study, we classified samples as; time point 1 (TP1) collected >6 months before starting first-line CIT for disease progression; time point 2 (TP2) consisting of tumor samples at the time of initial progression requiring treatment; and time point 3 (TP3) consisting of tumor samples collected >6 months after initial treatment but prior to subsequent treatments. Overall, aCGH assay was performed in 54 samples from 22 cases (2 to 4 time points analyzed per patient): 6 cases were analyzed at TP1 and TP2, 8 at TP2 and TP3, 2 at TP1 and TP3, and the remaining 6 cases were analyzed at TP1, TP2 and TP3. In cases showing genetic changes between time points, FISH analyses were performed in 32 additional samples to assess intra-clonal diversity and provide a quantification of the clone size. There was a small increase in genomic complexity in later time points with a mean of 4 (median 4, range 0–12) CNAs detected at the first time point for each patient, increasing to a mean of 5.3 (median 4.5, range 0–21) CNAs at the last time point analyzed. Diverse patterns of changes in genetic architecture were observed. The simplest change in genetic architectures was the linear sequence, found in 2 cases (9%) and characterized by the maintenance of the initial abnormalities and the subsequent acquisition of additional CNAs in the same subclone. The pattern of changes in genetic architecture in another 4 patients (18%) demonstrated marked heterogeneity including multiple genetic subclones evolving either in succession or in parallel. In all 4 cases with multiple subclones, a marked shift in the dominant subclone was observed at the time of disease relapse, with the minor subclones at TP1 and TP2 becoming the dominant subclones at TP3. In addition, the subclonal evolution continued following secondary therapies, and in all 4 cases the emerging subclone showed resistance to multiple treatments. This argues strongly in favor of subclones with specific genetic structures becoming dominant with the selective evolutionary pressure imposed by therapy. In summary, this sequential genetic study reveals that CLL leukemic B cells exhibit an unanticipated level of heterogeneity including a variable number of genetically distinct subclones, which display dynamic behavior in disease progression. The characterization of this intraclonal architecture is of critical importance to better understand the mechanisms of disease progression and relapse as well as to ultimately inform us of individualized treatment strategies. Disclosures: Fonseca: Consulting :Genzyme, Medtronic, BMS, Amgen, Otsuka, Celgene, Intellikine, Lilly Research Support: Cylene, Onyz, Celgene: Consultancy, Research Funding.
Monitoring Minimum Residual Disease In Multiple Myeloma Patients By LC-MS/MS
Abstract Proteomics with great sensitivity and specificity effectively analyzes proteins by prior tryptic digestion and subsequent analysis by LC-MS/MS of the tryptic digest. We have utilized this approach in the development of a LC-MS/MS method to characterize minimum residual disease in multiple myeloma. The abundant antibodies produced by multiple myeloma plasma cells are identical and appear as a spike (M-spike) upon protein electrophoresis. The M-spike and histological examination of the bone marrow constitute part of the myeloma diagnostic repertoire. Upon treatment, myeloma cells and the antibodies they produce are reduced in number and amount and become increasingly hard to detect. The bone marrow biopsy serves as the “gold standard” test for clinical remission. We have developed a sensitive test for the presence of the monoclonal antibody produced by the plasma cells which may serve as a substitute for invasive bone marrow biopsy. We have focused on tryptic peptides comprising the variable CDR regions of the Ig light chains that are unique to each patients antibody clone. Utilizing 2-5 µL of patient plasma/serum from the initial M-spike sample we have utilized SDS-PAGE to yield a crudely purified immunoglobulin light chain. The light chain band is isolated, reduced, alkylated and trypsin digested with subsequent LC-MS/MS analysis to identify CDR specific tryptic peptide(s). These can be identified as variable peaks (elution time and mass) in a base peak ion chromatogram where constant region peptides of either lambda or kappa light chains (clone dependent) serve as “internal standards” for identifying the CDR tryptic peptides. The peptide’s mass and its corresponding MS/MS spectra are unique to this CDR tryptic peptide and this patient’s clone. The unique diagnostic peptide is isolated in subsequent samples by immunoaffinity purification of the target kappa/lambda clone, SDS-PAGE separation and LC-MS/MS analysis of the light chain gel band. An extracted ion chromatogram is generated based upon the CDR peptides identified in the initial analysis of the M-spike sample. In patients in clinical remission the presence of a significant signal from the targeted peptides indicates that targeting a CDR peptide from the M-spike protein is more sensitive than currently available diagnostic tools including immunofixation. Comparison of this test to the gold standard bone marrow biopsy will be examined. Disclosures: Barnidge: Mayo Foundation: provisional patent application for technology, provisional patent application for technology Patents & Royalties.
Combination Chemotherapy with Pentostatin, Cyclophosphamide and Rituximab Induces High Rate of Remissions Including Complete Responses and Achievement of Minimal Residual Disease in Previously Untreated B-Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia.
Abstract The nucleoside analogue pentostatin has clinical activity in B-Cell Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL) and has shown significant activity and minimal toxicity when combined with cyclophosphamide for previously treated CLL. Building on this, we initiated a trial in 2002 of combined pentostatin (2mg/m2), cyclophosphamide (600 mg/m2) and rituximab (375mg/m2). Of the 33 enrolled eligible patients included in these analyses, seventeen patients were in the high Rai risk group, 25 were male, and median age for this cohort was 62 yrs (range: 40–79); 17 were non-mutated for the immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region gene, and the majority (67%) were CD38 negative. Only 5 patients had no detectable chromosomal abnormalities by FISH at baseline, 20 had a single FISH anomaly, and 8 had 2 or more FISH anomalies. Of all 28 pts with any anomaly, the following specific abnormalities were detected: 13q- (n=17), +12 (n=8), 11q- (n=7), 17p- (n=2), t(14;18) (n=1), 6q- (n=1), and MDM2 (n=1). Of the 33 patients, 22 had grade 3+ toxicity; 16 patients had non-hematologic toxicity wtih the most common symptoms being nausea (6) and vomiting (4). One patient died on study of grade 5 hypoxia as well as hypotension and this was deemed possibly related to treatment. Almost all patients (32/33; 97%) had a best response of PR or better. Including review of bone marrows done 2 months post-treatment, there were 11 CRs (complete response), 7 nPRs (nodal partial response) and 13 PRs. No differences were observed between type of response and mutation status or CD38+ status. Post-treatment FISH analyses were available on 27 patients; results for 25 patients became normal after treatment. Of the remaining 2, one patient was 13q- x1 and went from 94% to 27.5% abnormal nuclei after treatment; the other is the patient who died on study. To establish minimal residual disease (MRD) post-response, we used three color flow cytometry to detect CD5+/CD19+/CD79b− B cells. This approach found all patients had a reduction in CLL B cells with a median reduction of 91% (range: 5 – 100%). Of interest, all 3 response groups (CR vs. nPR vs. PR) had patients with significant reductions in CLL B cells (i.e., >90%). The nPR group was most variable in terms of MRD (median 47%; range: 5–93%) compared to the CR (median: 91%; range: 42–99.9%) and PR (median: 97%; range: 46–100%) groups. In conclusion this novel regimen of pentostatin, cyclophosphamide and rituximab has demonstrated significant clinical activity irrespective of risk stratification parameters with rapid induction of responses, achievement of minimal residual disease in some, and modest toxicity. Patients continue to be accrued to further explore correlative measures of response to treatment.
Clinical Significance of Homozygous D13S319 Deletion in B-Cell Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (B-CLL).
Abstract Background: In B-CLL, the observation of interphase cells with hemizygous D13S319 deletion at 13q14 (13q-x1) as a sole anomaly in blood is widely considered a favorable prognosis. The observation of cells with 11q-, +12 or 17p- has been associated with a relatively poor prognosis. Over the past 1.5 yrs, 16.2% (174/1,076) of patients (pts) referred for fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) testing for B-CLL in our clinical practice had a clone with homozygous D13S319 deletion (13q-x2), but the prognostic significance of this observation is poorly understood. Moreover, 39.3% (142/361) of pts with unfavorable FISH anomalies have 13q-x1 and/or 13q-x2 and the clinical significance of this observation is also unknown. Thus, we investigated pts with 13q- (with or without other chromosome anomalies) to establish the relative clinical significance of 13q- in B-CLL. Methods: We studied 333 pts with B-CLL sampled between 9/1999 and 6/2004 who had FISH performed on interphase nuclei from blood. The FISH probe set was designed to detect 6q-, 11q-, +12, 13q-, 17p-, and translocations involving IgH at 14q32. We classified pts into four groups: 13q-x1 only (group 1), 13q-x1 and 13q-x2 only (group 2), 13q-x2 only (group 3) and 13q-x1 and/or 13q-x2 plus other FISH anomalies (group 4). FISH groups were compared with gender, age, Rai stage, treatment status, time to treatment, CD38 and IgVH mutation. Results: Of the 333 pts, 171 (51.3%) had a 13q-: 71 were in group 1, 25 in group 2, 26 in group 3 and 49 in group 4. %CD38+ differed significantly across FISH groups; in pairwise analyses, the proportion of pts with >30% CD38+ was significantly greater for pts in group 4 vs. group 3 (p=0.0015) although no significant differences were observed for group 3 vs. group 1 or vs. group 2. Pts in group 3 were not significantly different from other FISH groups for Rai stage, IgVH mutation or gender. The median percentage of abnormal nuclei for pts with group 1 was 54.5% vs. 79.5% for pts in group 4 (p<0.0001). The median percent abnormal nuclei for pts in groups 3 and 2 was 72.5% and 68.5%, respectively. Median % abnormal nuclei for group 3 was not significantly different than the other FISH groups. Treatment status was available on 147 pts, where the proportion of pts who had treatment in each group was as follows: group 1, 15/66; group 2, 2/22; group 3, 4/21; and group 4, 9/38. Due to limited sample size and heavy censoring, any analysis on time to treatment is preliminary; however, these early analyses suggest group 4 pts have a lower median time to treatment (9 yrs) compared to groups 3 and 1 (12.3 and 13 yrs, respectively). Conclusions: This study has generated new information about the 13q- anomaly in B-CLL. First, known prognostic markers for B-CLL pts with 13q-x2 are not significantly different than for pts with 13q-x1 or 13q-x1/13q-x2. Second, 13q-x1 and/or 13q-x2 occurring with other unfavorable FISH anomalies have an unfavorable prognosis; i.e. potential benefits of 13q- are trumped when it is observed with unfavorable FISH anomalies. Thus, patients with any form of 13q- alone may have indolent disease while patients with 13q- and unfavorable FISH anomalies should be considered to be in a more aggressive phase.
A Phase II Trial of the Oral mTOR Inhibitor Everolimus (RAD001) in Relapsed or Refractory Waldenstrom's Macroglobulinemia.
Abstract Abstract 587 Background: The phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase/mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) signal transduction pathway controls cell proliferation and survival. Everolimus is an oral agent targeting raptor mTOR (mTORC1). The trial's goal was to determine the anti-tumor activity and safety of single-agent everolimus in patients with relapsed/refractory Waldenstrom's macroglobulinemia (WM). Patients and Methods: Eligible patients had measurable disease (IgM monoclonal protein >1000 mg/dL with >10% marrow involvement or nodal masses >2 cm), a platelet count ≥75,000 × 106/L, a neutrophil count ≥1,000 × 106/L, and a creatinine and bilirubin ≤2x laboratory upper limit of normal. Patients received everolimus 10 mg PO daily and were evaluated monthly. Tumor response was assessed after cycles 2 and 6 and then every 3 cycles until progression. Results: 50 pts were treated. The median age was 63 years (range, 43-85). The overall response rate (CR+PR+MR) was 70% (95% CI: 55-82%), with a PR of 42% and 28% MR. The median duration of response and median progression-free survival (PFS) has not been reached. The estimated PFS at 6 and 12 months is 75% (95%CI: 64-89%) and 62% (95%CI: 48-80%), respectively. Grade 3 or higher related toxicities were observed in 56% of patients. The most common were hematological toxicities with cytopenias. Pulmonary toxicity occurred in 10% of patients. Dose reductions due to toxicity occurred in 52% of patients. Conclusions: Everolimus has high single-agent activity with an overall response rate of 70% and manageable toxicity in patients with relapsed WM, and offers a potential new therapeutic strategy for this patient group. Disclosures: Ghobrial: Millennium: Honoraria, Research Funding, Speakers Bureau; Celgene: Consultancy, Honoraria, Speakers Bureau; Novartis: Honoraria, Speakers Bureau. Gertz:celgene: Honoraria; millenium: Honoraria, Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees. Richardson:Millennium Pharmaceuticals, Inc.: Consultancy, Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees, Speakers Bureau; Celgene: Consultancy, Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees, Speakers Bureau; Johnson and Johnson: Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees, Speakers Bureau; Novartis: Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees, Speakers Bureau; Keryx: Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees, Speakers Bureau; BMS: Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees, Speakers Bureau. Treon:Millennium: Honoraria, Research Funding, Speakers Bureau; Celgene: Honoraria, Research Funding, Speakers Bureau; Genentech: Honoraria, Research Funding, Speakers Bureau. Witzig:Novartis: Research Funding.
Molecular characterization of a case of atransferrinemia
Hereditary atransferrinemia is a rare but instructive disorder that has previously been reported in only 8 patients in 6 families. It is characterized by microcytic anemia and by iron loading, and can be treated effectively by plasma infusions. We now report the first case known in the United States. We determined the sequences flanking the exons of the human transferrin gene and sequenced all of the exons and some of the flanking regions of the patient's DNA and that of her parents. The patient's DNA revealed a 10-base pair (bp) deletion, followed by a 9-bp insertion of a duplicated sequence. There was also a G→C transversion at complementary DNA (cDNA) nt 1429, predicting that a proline was substituted for the alanine in amino acid position 477 (Ala 477 Pro). The latter mutation occurs at an evolutionarily highly conserved site; 704 control alleles were screened and this point mutation was not found. Each of the patient's transferrin genes contains one mutation, ie, the patient is a compound heterozygote for these mutations, because one was found in each of her parents. In addition to these mutations, which we regard to be causative in the patient's atransferrinemia, a silent polymorphism at cDNA 1572 G→C was found in exon 13 as well as 2 previously unreported polymorphisms at IVS8 + 62 c→t and IVS14-4 c→a. The mutation in nt 1572 and that in intron 8 were common in the general population; the intron 14 mutation is rare.
Comprehensive Analysis of BAFF Binding Receptor Profiles and Receptor Occupancy in B Cell Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia: Identification of Discrete Phenotypic Subgroups.
Abstract B cell-activating factor (BAFF) is known to regulate normal B cell development and homeostasis primarily by signaling through the high affinity receptor, BAFF-R, one of three BAFF binding receptors (BBRs). BAFF also binds two other receptors, BCMA and TACI with lesser affinity. We have recently shown that normal peripheral blood (PB) B cells express high levels of prebound soluble BAFF, which is lost upon B cell activation. Because of BAFF’s activity on normal B cells, we have been interested in the roles of BAFF and BBRs in B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL). We and others have demonstrated that BAFF promotes primary CLL B cell survival and that serum BAFF levels are elevated in some patients. Although CLL B cells are known to express BBRs, a comprehensive and quantitative analysis of BBR levels and CLL B cell capacity to bind BAFF has not yet been done. We began this study by characterizing the level of soluble BAFF bound to freshly isolated CLL B cells, measured by both western blot analysis and flow cytometry. To assess receptor occupancy, cells were incubated with or without exogenous BAFF before assessing anti-BAFF reactivity and changes in median fluorescence intensity (ΔMFI; defined by dividing the MFI of the anti-BAFF antibody by the MFI of the isotype matched control antibody) were calculated. Normal B cells have higher detectable levels of bound BAFF with a ΔMFI ranging from 16 to 35 (mean=22.2). Upon addition of exogenous BAFF, the ΔMFI range increased to 27–96.6 (mean=49.1; n=8). Thus, despite evidence of prebound BAFF, clearly not all BBRs were occupied on normal PB B cells. By contrast, the levels of prebound BAFF on CLL B cells were significantly lower with a ΔMFI ranging from 1 to 13.1 (mean=2.7; n=36). Of note, 10/36 patients did not exhibit increased anti-BAFF reactivity upon incubation with exogenous BAFF (mean fold induction=0.8) whereas 26/36 patients displayed a mean fold induction of anti-BAFF reactivity of 3.5. These observations prompted us to next quantitate CLL B cell BBR expression. All patient CLL B cells expressed BAFF-R but at significantly lower levels than observed in normal B cells (p=0.0009). When CLL patients were categorized into IGHV mutated (M; n=22) and unmutated (UM; n=24), UM patients were observed to express higher levels of BAFF-R (ΔMFI =8.9) than M patients (ΔMFI =5.24). Regarding TACI, we previously demonstrated that normal memory B cells uniformly express TACI (ΔMFI =12.7; n=10) and there is a small population of activated naïve B cells that express TACI at lower levels (ΔMFI =8.3; n=10). In our CLL cohort, 14/22 M patients were TACI+ (ΔMFI =7.0) and 19/24 UM patients were TACI+ (ΔMFI =4.7). Finally, whereas normal PB B cells completely lack BCMA expression, 7/22 M and 4/22 UM patients expressed BCMA. Thus, using the BBR profile and analysis of expression levels relative to normal PB B cells, the following subgroups of B-CLL can be defined: BAFF-R+; BAFF-R/TACI+; BAFF-R/BCMA+; BAFF-R/TACI/BCMA+. It remains to be determined if these BBR profiles correlate with aspects of clinical disease. In addition, given the putative importance of BAFF in this disease, it is interesting to note that in general, CLL B cells display overall lower levels of prebound BAFF. Current studies are focused on determining whether this reflects CLL B cell activation status, increased competition for BAFF, and/or reduced levels of BBR expression.
Early Results of Pentostatin, Cytoxan, Rituximab (PCR) Followed by CAMPATH-H (CA) for the Treatment of Relapse/Refractory Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL) in ECOG Protocol E2903.
Abstract Purine nucleoside combination therapy, with and without immunotherapy has become the standard treatment approach to CLL. Past approaches, other than stem cell transplantation, have not been successful in curing the disease. Inherent resistance of CLL precursors, impaired immune surveillance (T-cells, NK cells) and microenvironmental abnormalities may all play a role in the ability to effectively eradicate leukemia. PCR has been successfully employed for previously treated (Lamanna 2006) and previously untreated (Kay 2007) patients with CLL. In addition, CA has been added to FCR (Wierda 2006) to treat relapsed/refractory CLL disease. We designed a study to evaluate PCR followed by CA for relapsed/refractory CLL. This ECOG study includes, in addition to response criteria, molecular correlates (FISH anomalies and CpG karyotype), risk parameters analysis, including CD38, ZAP-70 and IgVH mutational status. We assessed the baseline and sequential changes in the angiogenic status of patients by measuring plasma VEGF, bFGF, thrombospondin and their immune status via T-cell repertoire. From September 2004 to September 2006, 32 patients with relapsed/refractory CLL were enrolled in the protocol. The protocol combined 2 regimens (PCR and CA). Step 1, PCR, was planned for 6 monthly cycles. Steps 2 and 3 consisted of short term CA (4 weeks) or standard CA (18 weeks) depending upon Step 1 response. There were 3 ineligible, 1 not evaluated, and 28 evaluable patients. FISH anomalies revealed that 8 patients had a homozygous or heterozygous 13q-defect, 9 had complex FISH defects (more than one FISH anomaly), 5 patients had FISH anomalies that included del(17p13.1), 4 patients had FISH anomalies that included 6q-and 3 had FISH anomalies that included 11q-. CD38 was positive in 10 patients, 11 were ZAP-70 positive and 12 of 19 patients tested had unmutated type clones. The planned 6 cycles of Step 1 (PCR) was administered to 14/32 patients (44%), the others receiving 0–5 cycles. All responses were considered partial responses (11/29; 37.9%), with 2 patients (6.9%) demonstrating progressive disease. However, patients receiving the planned 6 cycles of PCR, achieved a partial response of 71% (10/14) with 2 cases of tumor lysis syndrome. Toxicity (Step 1-PCR) was predominately myelosuppressive (Grade 1–4). A case of chronic idiopathic polyneuropathy and a case of “paraneoplastic pemphigus” were reported. There were 4 deaths. CMV reactivation was diagnosed in 2 patients, neither of which was fatal. During Step 2 (CA), short-term administration in one patient led to grade 3 skin toxicity, which limited administration. During long-term administration of CA (PR, PD, SD) (n=7), infectious complications occurred in 6 patients all of whom developed grade 4 lymphopenia. The median survival for the entire group was 15 months. In conclusion, a significant number of heavily pre-treated and poor prognosis patients with CLL will respond to PCR. Further analysis will determine whether a significant number of patients will achieve a higher level of response and longer survival after CA administration. Studies of association of outcome with the risk parameters are ongoing and will be presented with the clinical response data.
Assessment of Multiple Myeloma IGHV Intraclonal Variation by Massively Parallel Pyrosequencing
Abstract Abstract 1814 Multiple myeloma (MM) is an incurable hematologic disorder characterized by the accumulation of plasma cells (PCs) in the bone marrow (BM). Like normal B cells and PCs, MM cells express a distinctive immunoglobulin (Ig) molecular fingerprint resulting from heavy and light chain gene rearrangements and unique mutations introduced by the somatic hypermutation (SHM) process. Detailed examination of the Ig molecule may offer insight into the etiology of B cell malignancies as well as the ontogeny of malignant transformation and ongoing genetic evolution. Because prior studies of the Ig fingerprint of MM cells have been limited in size and scope, our current understanding of MM Ig repertoire is minimal. We used massively parallel sequencing of normal and malignant PCs to interrogate: 1) DNA versus RNA (cDNA) as starting material for studies of Ig repertoire; 2) the Ig repertoire of normal and malignant PCs; and 3) intraclonal heterogeneity in MM. Bone marrow PCs (BMPCs) from an untreated MM patient and from a normal control subject were isolated by magnetic bead separation. DNA and RNA were isolated from purified cells and amplified in a multiplex PCR reaction with primers designed to capture the entire IGHV region including the heavy chain complementarity determining region 3 (HCDR3) necessary for defining clonal cells. Using Roche 454 GS-FLX Titanium chemistry and a GS FLX Titanium Genome Sequencer, over 30,000 sequence reads were obtained from each sample. Following a detailed algorithm to minimize Taq and sequencing related errors and removal of non-Ig or non-productive Ig sequences, the resulting sequences were grouped based on HCDR3 amino acid identity. Each unique HCDR3 represented one member of the repertoire and all the sequences with the same HCDR3 defined the clone size. This measurement showed that there was nearly a five-fold higher level of unique HCDR3s in normal BMPCs when the starting PCR template was DNA vs. cDNA. Thus, DNA is clearly a better starting template for repertoire analysis using deep sequencing methods. Thorough analysis of the MM DNA sample identified PCs expressing 37 different IGHV genes, and predictably, the vast majority of sequence reads (83%) had exact nucleotide identity in the IGHV and HCDR3 region (IGHV3-74 with 18 mutations in the IGHV region) thereby defining the dominant MM clone. There were also ∼5000 additional sequences that either shared an identical HCDR3 region but varied within the IGHV3-74 gene sequence (n=3975) or were identical within the IGHV3-74 sequence yet varied within the HCDR3 (n=862). These sequences were further analyzed, with sequences not present 10 or more times or not found in both the 5' and 3' directions eliminated from further scrutiny. This process revealed a total of 64 putative subclones with single point mutations in the IGHV or HCDR3 region (10–56 copies of each unique sequence representing a total of 1583 clonally related sequences). When we used a more stringent subclone frequency of ≥0.1%, 22 subclones remained. Of note, conventional Ig repertoire analysis would require sequencing ≥1000 colonies to detect MM subclones present at this frequency. Finally, 11 subclones displayed a significant number of IGHV gene nucleotide differences from the dominant MM clone despite exhibiting an identical HCDR3 region. Notably, a number of these distinguishing IGHV gene mutations are silent and thus may preserve the antigenic specificity of these clonally related cells. These subclones failed our frequency criteria but the type and quality of deviations from the clonal sequence suggest that they are not artifact and warrant further investigation. Notably, all of the putative subclones were also found in the MM cDNA cohort providing further evidence as genuine subclones. The very large number of identical MM clonal sequences is consistent with the idea that MM is a post germinal center malignancy that can no longer undergo SHM. However, we present clear evidence of MM-related subclones albeit relatively small in number. The subclone sequence deviations discovered may reflect on-going genetic evolution independent of the formal SHM mechanism. Alternatively, these subclones may indeed reflect “sister” cells generated during the original germinal center reaction that resulted in the malignant clone. In summary, our studies demonstrate the extraordinary potential of this methodology to track clonal evolution in MM and its precursor conditions over time. Disclosures: No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.
Longitudinal Genomic Analyses In Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL) Patients Reveal Clonal Relationship and Genomic Evolution In Disease Progression and After Therapy
Abstract Abstract 3605 CLL is a malignant B-cell disorder characterized by the accumulation of small B lymphocytes with a mature appearance in blood, marrow and lymph nodes. Despite effective treatment options, all patients with CLL will eventually relapse after therapy. This could be due in part to the presence of subclones of the CLL cell population that harbor genetic abnormalities, which confer resistance to treatment. The aims of this study were to investigate the clonal evolution in longitudinal samples of CLL patients and to identify genetic alterations associated with disease progression and resistance to therapy. Sequential analyses were performed in 51 samples from 23 patients who were included in a previously reported clinical trial of pentostatin, cyclophosphamide and rituximab (PCR) given every 3 weeks for 6 cycles in previously untreated CLL (Blood 109:2007). In all cases the first sample analyzed was prior to therapy. In 5 of 23 patients, three time points were analyzed: >6 months prior to entry onto PCR trial (time point A), just before starting with the PCR regimen (time point B), and the time of relapse after PCR trial (time point C). Seven patients were analyzed at time points A and B; 9 at time points B and C and 2 at time points A and C. The median time between points A and B was 17.5 months (range 8–48 months) and between points B and C was 20.5 months (7–60 m). All samples were examined by array-based comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH) using the Agilent Sureprint G3 (1 million probe) array. aCGH findings were confirmed by interphase FISH using probes for D13S319 (MIR16–1/MIR15A), RB1, MDM2, CEP12, CEP6, MYB, TP53, NFKBIA, PERP and FGFR1 loci. Overall, we observed a small increase in the number of copy-number abnormalities (CNA) with disease progression. Twenty-two of the 23 patients with paired samples harbored at least one CNA that persisted in all samples, indicating clonal relationship between the sequential samples. In 15 of the 23 patients the tumor clone was stable and no CNA differences between time points were identified. Conversely, genomic evolution was found in 8 patients. In 3 cases the genetic differences were observed pre treatment (between time points A and B) and in the other 5 cases, the observed changes were found after therapy (between time points A and C or between B and C). One remarkable case with genome evolution exhibited two subclones sharing trisomies 12 and 19, but with several unique CNA confined to each subclone. The first subclone was characterized by deletions of 6q, RB1, MIR16-1/MIR15A and 3 other losses, while the second subclone showed homozygous deletion of MIR16–1/MIR15A and 5 other monoallelic deletions. The first subclone was predominant at time points A and B (60–70% of cells), but was present in only 10–20% of cells at time point C as confirmed by FISH. Conversely, the second subclone was observed in ~20% of cells at time points A and B and became predominant after therapy, found in ~80% of cells at time point C. Another case was characterized by deletion 11q32 (including ATM and others) as the sole abnormality at time point B. Significant genomic complexity was observed at time point C, including deletions of 11q32, 9p21 (CDKN2A), 9q12-q33, 14q13.2 (NFKBIA) and 17p (TP53), and gains of 2p16 (REL) and 9q34. Interestingly, the deletion 11q32 from both time points arose independently at each time point, as they exhibited different chromosomal breakpoints and copy number variants. Moreover, the other CNA found at relapse were not identified at diagnosis (confirmed by aCGH and FISH). For evolution of specific CNA, trisomy 12 was found in 5 cases at the first sample analyzed and was stable with no changes between time points. The frequency of deletions 13q14.3 (MIR16-1/MIR15A) and 17p increased at the later time points. Conversely, –6q decreased in frequency across time points (3 cases in time points A–B and 1 case in time point C). In summary, at least 35% of CLL patients exhibited clonal evolution and at least 9% showed evidence of multiple subclones. This subgroup of CLL patients provides an exceptional framework for comprehensive analysis of genome evolution during disease progression before and after therapy. Our observations also support the hypothesis of a common CLL progenitor cell can give rise to clonally related, but genetically evolving subpopulations of tumor cells. Finally, this study may bring novel information regarding the drug resistance pathways utilized by CLL B cell clones post therapy. Disclosures: Kipps: GlaxoSmithKline: Consultancy, Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees, Research Funding; Genentech: Research Funding; Celgene: Consultancy, Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees; Celgene: Research Funding; Genzyme: Research Funding; Memgen: Research Funding; Igenica: Consultancy, Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees; Sanofi Aventis: Research Funding; Abbott Laboratories: Research Funding. Fonseca:Genzyme: Consultancy; Medtronic: Consultancy; BMS: Consultancy; AMGEN: Consultancy; Otsuka: Consultancy; Celgene: Consultancy, Research Funding; Intellikine: Consultancy; Cylene: Research Funding; Onyx: Research Funding; FISH probes prognostication in myeloma: Patents & Royalties.