Evans, Christopher H.

Interest in using gene therapy to treat osteoarthritis (OA) is growing and a number of clinical trials have been initiated. This commentary identifies three intersecting areas that need to be addressed for the field to move forward expeditiously. The first relates to lowering the cost of manufacturing clinical grade viral vectors, addressing various aspects of their deployment, and overcoming immune barriers to dosing and re-dosing. The second area requires an improved understanding of the pathophysiology of OA, including its stratification by endotype and phenotype. Coupled to the development of reliable biomarkers, this will enable the creation of personalized gene therapies, facilitate patient selection, and aid the identification of additional molecular targets. Moreover, progress in the early diagnosis of OA will enable administration of gene therapeutics at a stage when they are most likely to be successful. Finally, important issues with regard to financing and regulation are discussed. Top line data from two pivotal Phase III clinical trials are expected to be released this year. The findings from these trials will exercise considerable influence on the future development of the field.

ABSTRACT This manuscript summarizes over 30 years of research that began with the novel concept of using intra‐articular gene transfer to treat joint diseases. A notable milestone in this journey was the first‐in‐human transfer of an exogenous gene to a joint, accomplished by the ex vivo delivery of cDNA encoding the interleukin‐1 receptor antagonist (IL‐1Ra) to joints of patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Responding to lessons learned from this study and the prevailing clinical landscape we next developed an in vivo gene delivery system based on adeno‐associated virus (AAV) with osteoarthritis (OA) as the target disease. The safety and efficacy of this vector, sc‐rAAV2.5IL‐1Ra, was demonstrated in the joints of rats and horses leading to a successful IND application to the FDA. In this clinical trial (ClinicalTrials. gov Identifier: NCT02790723) sc‐rAAV2.5IL‐1Ra was injected at escalating doses into the knee joints of nine patients with OA who were followed for 1 year. This trial met its primary outcome measure, safety, and demonstrated that sustained expression of transgenic IL‐1Ra was possible after a single injection of the vector. Patient‐reported outcomes improved, but without a control group it is not possible to determine the influence of a placebo effect. This and other unresolved matters are addressed in a recently‐completed Phase Ib trial (ClinicalTrials. gov Identifier: NCT05835895). Beyond OA, sc‐rAAV2.5IL‐1Ra has potential therapeutic value in a variety of degenerative, inflammatory, fibrotic and autoimmune conditions. More generally, gene therapy holds much promise in the field of regenerative medicine, including regenerative orthopaedics. Trial Registration: (ClinicalTrials. gov Identifier: NCT02790723, NCT05835895).

When long bones fracture, healing occurs spontaneously in about 90% of cases, while the remaining 10% result in non-union, presenting significant clinical challenges. The standard treatment for non-unions is autologous bone grafting, but this approach has limitations, including high complication rates, donor site morbidity, and limited graft availability. An alternative strategy involves using growth factors to promote bone regeneration, with recombinant bone morphogenetic protein-2 (rBMP-2) being the most common. Although effective, rBMP-2 requires supra-physiological doses that cause inflammation, poor bone quality, and severe side effects. Our previous work suggests that genetic delivery of BMP-2 may offer more controlled healing. We aim to develop a more effective therapy for non-unions using adeno-associated viral vectors. By lyophilizing the vector onto a scaffold, we also aim to increase treatment potency, reduce leakage, and improve transduction using cryoprotectant buffers.AAV6-GFP-Luciferase was used to compare the activity of AAV6 stored at −80°C versus lyophilized in cryoprotectant buffer. A rat critical-sized defect model was employed, as described in [1]. For standard storage, AAV was added to the collagen sponge before implantation into a 5mm defect. For lyophilization, AAV was mixed with cryoprotectant, loaded onto the sponge, and lyophilized. Rats were imaged at 7- and 10-days using IVIS. To assess therapeutic relevance, the experiment was repeated with AAV6-BMP2-IL1Ra, implanted into 5mm femoral defects on collagen sponges, with healing monitored by X-ray every 4 weeks (continuing through 12-weeks post-operation).The reporter and therapeutic vectors showed improved transduction efficiency with lyophilization. The reporter vector exhibited higher transgene expression at days 7 and 10. This boost in expression either remained significant through 4 weeks or continued to show better signal at that time, correlating with improved healing seen in the X-rays (Fig. 2).Preliminary data suggest that lyophilization could reduce the therapeutic dose of AAV needed for treating osseous nonunion with a bicistronic vector. Lyophilization offers various benefits: enhanced transduction efficiency, improved stability of the gene product at logistically feasible conditions, and reduced off-target effects due to less AAV leakage from the implantation site. While in vivo experiments with AAV6-BMP2-IL1Ra are ongoing, these findings warrant further investigation into lyophilized AAV therapies for this application.For any figures or tables, please contact the authors directly.

Abstract Bone morphogenetic proteins ‐2 and ‐7 (BMP‐2 and BMP‐7) are effective in treating large bone defects, but the required doses are high, resulting in side effects and elevated costs. Previously, this work has demonstrated that a chemically modified messenger RNA (cmRNA) coding for BMP‐2 induced rapid and reliable healing until consolidation in a bone segmental defect in rats. Here, this work shows that the simultaneous transfer of BMP‐2 and BMP‐7 cmRNAs to stem cells leads to increased osteogenic gene expression, extracellular matrix deposition, and mineralization, compared to single or sequential delivery of these cmRNAs. Using a murine model of ectopic ossification, this work finds that dual BMP‐2/BMP‐7 cmRNA delivery using collagen‐hydroxyapatite scaffolds, designed specifically for bone repair, ensured local BMP‐2 and ‐7 expression with abundant osteogenesis in the absence of adverse effects. This confirms the superior osteogenic potency achieved by local, controlled dual delivery of cmRNAs encoding BMP‐2 and BMP‐7, further enhancing the potential of this highly translatable technology for promoting bone healing.

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a major global health problem with no disease-modifying therapies. Interleukin-1 (IL-1) is a critical cytokine associated with the pathophysiology of OA and can be inhibited by IL-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra). Here, we tested the delivery of a gene therapeutic encoding the human IL-1Ra to the knee in a phase 1, open-label clinical trial that enrolled nine patients with radiographic knee OA. The IL-1Ra gene was delivered by a self-complementary (sc)–recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) serotype 2.5 (sc-rAAV2.5IL-1Ra) by intra-articular injection into an index knee at one of three doses: low [1 × 10 11 viral genomes (vg)], mid (1 × 10 12 vg), or high (1 × 10 13 vg). The primary outcome was safety. There were no serious adverse events (AEs) related to sc-rAAV2.5IL-1Ra. Two AEs occurred that were possibly related to the vector. Both were effusions with increased pain and resolved with conservative treatment. sc-rAAV2.5IL-1Ra did not cause changes in vital signs, physical findings, or clinical laboratory measures. Less than 1% of the injected dose of sc-rAAV2.5IL-1Ra vg was detected in circulation after 1 day and was cleared within a week. Titers of neutralizing antibodies to AAV2.5 rose in serum and synovial fluid. In all cases, IL-1Ra concentration increased in the synovial fluid, and IL-1Ra concentrations remained elevated after 1 year. Baseline pain and function scores improved during the study. Therefore, we found that intra-articular gene therapy with sc-rAAV2.5IL-1Ra was safe. The sustained increase in local IL-1Ra in human knee joints supports the further clinical examination of this therapy to provide therapeutic benefit in OA.

Aging is a major risk factor for osteoarthritis (OA), but the specific mechanisms connecting aging and OA remain unclear. Although chondrocytes rarely divide in adult articular cartilage, they undergo replicative senescence in vitro, offering a model to study aging-related changes under controlled conditions. OA cartilage was obtained from an 80-year-old male and a 72-year-old female, while normal cartilage was sourced from a 26-year-old male. Chondrocyte cultures were established and sub-cultured to their Hayflick limit. Bulk RNA sequencing on early- and late-passage human articular chondrocytes identified transcriptomic changes associated with cellular aging. Early-passage OA chondrocytes already showed senescent phenotypes, unlike normal chondrocytes. All three cultures underwent 30 population doublings before replicative exhaustion, at which point all cells displayed senescence. During this process, cells lost their ability to form cartilaginous pellets. Differential gene expression analysis revealed distinct transcriptomic profiles between early- and late-passage chondrocytes and between normal and OA-derived cells. Genes related to matrix synthesis, degradation, inflammation, and the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) showed significant expression changes. Despite being a small pilot study, these findings suggest that further research into the molecular and metabolic changes during chondrocyte senescence could provide valuable insights into OA pathobiology.

Abstract Objective Aging is a major risk factor for OA, but the specific mechanisms underlying this connection remain unclear. Although chondrocytes rarely divide in adult articular cartilage, they undergo replicative senescence in vitro which provides an opportunity to study changes related to aging under controlled laboratory conditions. Methods Cartilage was recovered from two knees with OA and one normal knee. Chondrocyte cultures were established and sub-cultured until their Hayflick limit. Bulk RNA sequencing on early- and late-passage human articular chondrocytes allowed identification of transcriptomic changes associated with cellular aging. Results One male (80 years old) and one female (72 years old) patient provided OA cartilage. The donor of normal chondrocytes was a 26-year old male. Early passage chondrocytes from the two OA samples already had the phenotype of senescing cells, unlike normal chondrocytes. Nevertheless, all three chondrocyte cultures underwent 30 population doublings before replicative exhaustion, by which point all cells displayed a senescent phenotype. During this process, the cells lost their ability to form cartilaginous pellets. Differentially expressed genes (DEGs) analysis confirmed distinct transcriptomic profiles between early- and late-passage chondrocytes, as well as between cells isolated from normal and OA cartilage. Various changes in expression of genes related to cartilage matrix synthesis, degradation, inflammation and the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP) were noted. Conclusions Although only a small pilot study, its data suggest that a larger and deeper study of the molecular and metabolic events accompanying the senescence of chondrocytes could provide important insights into the pathobiology of OA.

Intra-articular injection is a common way to deliver biologics to joints, but their effectiveness is limited by rapid clearance from the joint space. This barrier can be overcome by genetically modifying cells within the joint such that they produce anti-arthritic gene products endogenously, thereby achieving sustained, therapeutic, intra-articular concentrations of the transgene products without re-dosing. A variety of non-viral and viral vectors have been subjected to preclinical testing to evaluate their suitability for delivering genes to joints. The first transfer of a gene to a human joint used an ex vivo protocol involving retrovirally transduced, autologous, synovial fibroblasts. Recent advances in vector technology allow in vivo delivery using adeno-associated virus (AAV). We have developed an AAV vector encoding the interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (AAV.IL-1Ra) for injection into joints with osteoarthritis (OA). It showed efficacy and safety in equine and rat models of OA, leading to a recently-completed, investigator-initiated, Phase I, dose-escalation clinical trial in 9 subjects with mid-stage OA of the knee (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT02790723). Three cohorts of three subjects with mild to moderate OA in the index knee were injected intra-articularly under ultrasound guidance with a low (10e11 viral genomes) medium (10e12 viral genomes) or high (10e13 viral genomes) dose of AAV.IL-1Ra and followed for one year. The data confirm safety, with evidence of sustained intra-articular expression of IL-1Ra and a clinical response in certain subjects. Funding for a subsequent Phase Ib trial involving 50 subjects (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT05835895), expected to start later this year, has been acquired. Progress in this area has stimulated commercial activity and there are now at least seven different companies developing gene therapies for OA and a number of clinical trials are in progress.Acknowledgement: Clinical trial funded by US Department of Defense Clinical Trial Award W81XWH-16-1-0540.

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are short non-coding RNA sequences with the ability to inhibit the expression of a target mRNA at the post-transcriptional level, acting as modulators of both the degenerative and regenerative processes. Therefore, these molecules constitute a potential source of novel therapeutic tools. In this study, we investigated the miRNA expression profile that presented in enthesis tissue upon injury. For this, a rodent enthesis injury model was developed by creating a defect at a rat’s patellar enthesis. Following injury, explants were collected on days 1 (n = 10) and 10 (n = 10). Contra lateral samples (n = 10) were harvested to be used for normalization. The expression of miRNAs was investigated using a “Fibrosis” pathway-focused miScript qPCR array. Later, target prediction for the aberrantly expressed miRNAs was performed by means of the Ingenuity Pathway Analysis, and the expression of mRNA targets relevant for enthesis healing was confirmed using qPCRs. Additionally, the protein expression levels of collagens I, II, III, and X were investigated using Western blotting. The mRNA expression pattern of EGR1, COL2A1, RUNX2, SMAD1, and SMAD3 in the injured samples indicated their possible regulation by their respective targeting miRNA, which included miR-16, -17, -100, -124, -133a, -155 and -182. Furthermore, the protein levels of collagens I and II were reduced directly after the injury (i.e., day 1) and increased 10 days post-injury, while collagens III and X showed the opposite pattern of expression.