Eisenach, John H.

In this article, we review how we interact with medical students in our efforts to teach blood pressure regulation and systemic cardiovascular control along with related elements of respiratory and exercise physiology. Rather than provide a detailed lecture with key facts, we attempted to outline our approach to teaching integrative cardiovascular physiology to medical students, which includes five major themes. First, focus on questions versus answers and facts. We believe that this offers both the learner and teacher a number of advantages. Second, avoid teaching dogma in the name of clarity (i.e., heavy focus on teaching “facts” that have not yet been fully investigated). This is especially important because of the way knowledge evolves over time. Third, include laboratory-based experiences in human integrative physiology. Fourth, provide students with intellectual frameworks versus a list of “facts” to serve as a platform for question generation. Finally, focus on the role of integration and regulatory redundancy in physiology and the idea that physiology is a narrative that can help. In this article, we discuss the philosophy behind the themes outlined above and argue that questions, and not answers, are where the action is for both research and education.

The vasodilator signals regulating muscle blood flow during exercise are unclear. We tested the hypothesis that in young adults leg muscle vasodilation during steady-state exercise would be reduced independently by sequential pharmacological inhibition of nitric oxide synthase (NOS) and cyclooxygenase (COX) with NG-nitro-l-arginine methyl ester (l-NAME) and ketorolac, respectively. We tested a second hypothesis that NOS and COX inhibition would increase leg oxygen consumption (V̇o2) based on the reported inhibition of mitochondrial respiration by nitric oxide. In 13 young adults, we measured heart rate (ECG), blood pressure (femoral venous and arterial catheters), blood gases, and venous oxygen saturation (indwelling femoral venous oximeter) during prolonged (25 min) steady-state dynamic knee extension exercise (60 kick/min, 19 W). Leg blood flow (LBF) was determined by Doppler ultrasound of the femoral artery. Whole body V̇o2 was measured, and leg V̇o2 was calculated from blood gases and LBF. Resting intra-arterial infusions of acetylcholine (ACh) and nitroprusside (NTP) tested inhibitor efficacy. Leg vascular conductance (LVC) to ACh was reduced up to 53 ± 4% by l-NAME + ketorolac infusion, and the LVC responses to NTP were unaltered. Exercise increased LVC from 4 ± 1 to 33.1 ± 2 ml·min−1·mmHg−1 and tended to decrease after l-NAME infusion (31 ± 2 ml·min−1·mmHg−1, P = 0.09). With subsequent administration of ketorolac LVC decreased to 29.6 ± 2 ml·min−1·mmHg−1 ( P = 0.02; n = 9). While exercise continued, LVC returned to control values (33 ± 2 ml·min−1·mmHg−1) within 3 min, suggesting involvement of additional vasodilator mechanisms. In four additional subjects, LVC tended to decrease with l-NAME infusion alone ( P = 0.08) but did not demonstrate the transient recovery. Whole body and leg V̇o2 increased with exercise but were not altered by l-NAME or l-NAME + ketorolac. These data indicate a modest role for NOS- and COX-mediated vasodilation in the leg of exercising humans during prolonged steady-state exercise, which can be restored acutely. Furthermore, NOS and COX do not appear to influence muscle V̇o2 in untrained healthy young adults.

We tested the hypothesis that adenosine contributes to augmented skeletal muscle vasodilation during hypoxic exercise. In separate protocols, subjects performed incremental rhythmic forearm exercise (10% and 20% of maximum) during normoxia and normocapnic hypoxia (80% arterial O2saturation). In protocol 1 ( n = 8), subjects received an intra-arterial administration of saline (control) and aminophylline (adenosine receptor antagonist). In protocol 2 ( n = 10), subjects received intra-arterial phentolamine (α-adrenoceptor antagonist) and combined phentolamine and aminophylline administration. Forearm vascular conductance (FVC; in ml·min−1·100 mmHg−1) was calculated from forearm blood flow (in ml/min) and blood pressure (in mmHg). In protocol 1, the change in FVC (ΔFVC; change from normoxic baseline) during hypoxic exercise with saline was 172 ± 29 and 314 ± 34 ml·min−1·100 mmHg−1(10% and 20%, respectively). Aminophylline administration did not affect ΔFVC during hypoxic exercise at 10% (190 ± 29 ml·min−1·100 mmHg−1, P = 0.4) or 20% (287 ± 48 ml·min−1·100 mmHg−1, P = 0.3). In protocol 2, ΔFVC due to hypoxic exercise with phentolamine infusion was 313 ± 30 and 453 ± 41 ml·min−1·100 mmHg−1(10% and 20% respectively). ΔFVC was similar at 10% (352 ± 39 ml·min−1·100 mmHg−1, P = 0.8) and 20% (528 ± 45 ml·min−1·100 mmHg−1, P = 0.2) hypoxic exercise with combined phentolamine and aminophylline. In contrast, ΔFVC to exogenous adenosine was reduced by aminophylline administration in both protocols ( P < 0.05 for both). These observations suggest that adenosine receptor activation is not obligatory for the augmented hyperemia during hypoxic exercise in humans.

As humans age, the tonic level of activity in sympathetic vasoconstrictor nerves increases and may contribute to age-related increases in blood pressure. In previous studies in normotensive young men with varying levels of resting sympathetic nerve activity, we observed a balance among factors contributing to blood pressure regulation, such that higher sympathetic activity was associated with lower cardiac output and lesser vascular responsiveness to α-adrenergic agonists, which limited the impact of high sympathetic activity on blood pressure. In the present study, we tested the hypothesis that older normotensive men would exhibit a similar balance among these variables (sympathetic nerve activity, cardiac output, and α-adrenergic responsiveness) but that this balance would be shifted toward higher sympathetic nerve activity values. We measured muscle sympathetic nerve activity, cardiac output, arterial pressure, and forearm vasoconstrictor responses in 17 older men and compared these with previous data collected in 14 younger men. Muscle sympathetic activity (burst incidence) was positively related to diastolic blood pressure in the older men ( r =0.49; P =0.05); this relationship was not observed in young men. In addition, there was no relationship between cardiac output and muscle sympathetic activity ( r =0.29; P >0.05) or between muscle sympathetic activity and vasoconstrictor responses in the older men (eg, norepinephrine: r =−0.21; P >0.05). Although our older subjects were normotensive, the relationship between muscle sympathetic nerve activity and diastolic blood pressure and the lack of “balance” among the other variables suggest that these changes with aging may contribute to the risk of sympathetically mediated hypertension in older humans.

Aging is associated with reduced endothelial function. There is indirect evidence for reduced prostacyclin (PGI 2 )-mediated vasodilation with aging, but it is unknown whether this is because of reduced dilation to PGI 2 or altered production. In addition, the contribution of endothelial NO to PGI 2 -mediated dilation is unknown. Using plethysmography to determine forearm blood flow, we studied the effect of PGI 2 in 10 older (61 to 73 years) and 10 younger (19 to 45 years) subjects using 3 escalating intra-arterial doses of PGI 2 (epoprostenol). PGI 2 was also administered after NO synthase inhibition with N G -monomethyl- l -arginine acetate. The percent of change in forearm vascular conductance (mean±SEM) from baseline after PGI 2 was significantly lower ( P =0.002) in the aging individuals (52±11%, 164±23%, and 221±27% versus 115±20%, 249±19%, and 370±35%). In addition, the group-by-dose interaction was also significant ( P =0.018). After NO synthase inhibition, the dose-response curve to PGI 2 was blunted in the young subjects but unchanged in the older subjects; the difference between the groups was no longer significant. Our data suggest that the reduced dilator effects of PGI 2 in older individuals are attributable to a reduction in the contribution of endothelial-derived NO versus alterations in the direct effects of PGI 2 on vascular smooth muscle.

Among young normotensive men, a reciprocal balance between cardiac output and sympathetic nerve activity is important in the regulation of arterial pressure. In young women, the balance among cardiac output, peripheral resistance, and sympathetic nerve activity is unknown. Consequently, the aim of this study was to examine the relationship of cardiac output and total peripheral resistance to muscle sympathetic nerve activity in young women. Multiunit peroneal recordings of muscle sympathetic nerve activity were obtained in 17 women (mean±SEM: age 24±3 years) and 21 men (mean±SEM: age 25±5 years). Mean resting muscle sympathetic nerve activity was lower in women compared with men (19±3 versus 25±1 bursts minute −1 ; P <0.05), as was mean arterial pressure (89±1 versus 94±2 mm Hg; P <0.05). Mean arterial pressure was not related to muscle sympathetic nerve activity in men ( P =0.80) or women ( P =0.62). There was a positive relationship between total peripheral resistance and muscle sympathetic nerve activity ( r =0.62; P <0.05) and an inverse relationship between cardiac output and muscle sympathetic nerve activity ( r =−0.69; P <0.05) in men. Unexpectedly, muscle sympathetic nerve activity had no relationship to either total peripheral resistance ( r =−0.27; P >0.05) or cardiac output ( r =0.23; P >0.05) in women. Our results demonstrate that men and women rely on different integrated physiological mechanisms to maintain a normal arterial pressure despite widely varying sympathetic nerve activity among individuals. These findings may have important implications for understanding how hypertension and other disorders of blood pressure regulation occur in men and women.

Patients with hypertension exhibit impaired energetic coupling between the ventricle and the arterial system, leading to reduced cardiac mechanic efficiency and exercise capacity. We tested whether blood pressure normalization with current antihypertensive therapy can improve arterioventricular coupling. Eighteen hypertensive patients without other cardiovascular disease were examined before and after antihypertensive therapy. Transthoracic echocardiography was performed. Central aortic pressure waveforms, including end-systolic pressure, were derived from radial artery applanation tonometry. Afterload was increased with isometric handgrip exercise. Central aortic end-systolic pressure and ventricular volumes at rest and handgrip were used to calculate ventricular elastance, effective arterial elastance, arterioventricular coupling (effective arterial elastance/ventricular elastance), and mechanical efficiency. After 142±67 days, systolic blood pressure decreased from 150.9±14.6 to 119.8±9.2 mm Hg ( P <0.00001), diastolic blood pressure from 85.9±14.8 to 68.8±8.4 mm Hg ( P =0.00002), and cardiac output from 5.8±1.7 to 4.9±1.8 L/min ( P =0.03). Resting left ventricular end-systolic volume, ejection fraction, and septal thickness did not change. Ventricular elastance increased from 1.7±1.0 to 3.2±1.4 mm Hg/mL ( P =0.00002), whereas effective arterial elastance decreased from 1.4±0.5 to 1.2±0.4 mm Hg/mL ( P =0.02). Effective arterial elastance/ventricular elastance decreased in all patients, from 1.1±0.8 to 0.4±0.2 ( P =0.0002). Efficiency improved at rest (72.9±5.8% versus 83.5±5.7%; P <0.00001) and during handgrip (63.5±7.8% versus 78.9±7.1%; P <0.00001). In hypertensive patients, optimal brachial and central blood pressure reduction shifts arterioventricular coupling from cardiac output maximization to ventricular mechanical efficiency optimization. This occurs before significant changes in ventricular geometry and may be responsible for early clinical improvements.

Patients with hypertension have a blunted sensitivity of baroreflex control of heart period. In these patients, baroreflex sensitivity is positively related to heart rate variability and inversely related to blood pressure variability. We hypothesized that this relationship would also be evident in healthy normotensive subjects and that individuals with higher baroreflex sensitivity would have lower ambulatory 24-hour blood pressure. Twenty-four-hour ambulatory blood pressure and heart rate were recorded in 50 healthy, normotensive, nonobese individuals (31 women and 19 men). The baroreflex was assessed using sequential bolus administration of sodium nitroprusside and phenylephrine, and baroreflex sensitivity was calculated as the slope of the relation between systolic blood pressure and R-R interval during the resulting blood pressure transients. Baroreflex sensitivity was inversely correlated to 24-hour average mean arterial pressure ( R =0.49; P <0.001) and positively related to daytime heart rate variability ( R =0.33; P =0.02). In contrast, no relationship was found between baroreflex sensitivity and 24-hour heart rate or blood pressure variabilities. We conclude that the relationship between baroreflex sensitivity and daytime heart rate variability was similar to that reported previously in hypertensive subjects. Furthermore, the inverse relation between baroreflex sensitivity and mean arterial pressure supports the idea that the baroreflex may exert longer-term effects on blood pressure than thought previously.

Background Previous studies suggest that intraoperative anesthetic care may influence postoperative pain and recovery from surgery. The authors tested the hypothesis that the addition of intrathecal analgesia to general anesthesia would improve long-term functional status and decrease pain in patients undergoing radical retropubic prostatectomy. Methods One hundred patients received either general anesthesia supplemented with intravenous fentanyl or general anesthesia preceded by intrathecal administration of bupivacaine (15 mg), clonidine (75 microg), and morphine (0.2 mg). Patients and providers were masked to treatment assignment. All patients received multimodal pain management postoperatively. Primary outcomes included pain and functional status over the first 12 postoperative weeks. Results Patients receiving intrathecal analgesia required more intravenous fluids and vasopressors intraoperatively. Pain was well controlled throughout the study (mean numerical pain scores < 3 in both groups at all times studied). Intrathecal analgesia decreased pain and supplemental intravenous morphine use over the first postoperative day but increased the frequency of pruritus. Pain and functional status after discharge from the hospital did not differ between groups. Intrathecal analgesia significantly decreased the duration of hospital stay (from 2.8 +/- 2.0 to 2.1 +/- 0.5 days; P < 0.01) as a result of five patients in the control group who stayed in the hospital more than 3 days. Conclusions The benefits of improved immediate analgesia and decreased morphine requirements resulting from intrathecal analgesia must be weighed against factors such as pruritus, increased intraoperative requirement for fluids and vasopressors, and resources needed to implement this modality. Further studies are needed to determine the significance of the decrease in duration of hospital stay.