Back to Authors

Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L

0000-0003-3621-7335

Mayo Clinic

Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota, USA.

Citations 38

The mystery of assisted reproductive technologies
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Roberson, Elle C.

Molecular Reproduction and Development | December 5, 2018 | Volume: 86 | Issue: 2 | Pages: 121-121

10.1002/mrd.23094 Get It

Regenerative Prophylaxis In Utero
Ruano, Rodrigo , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Rivera, Paola E. Brana, Brana Rivera, Paola E, Ruano, Rodrigo , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Terzic, André

Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics | November 12, 2018 | Volume: 105 | Issue: 1 | Pages: 39-41

10.1002/cpt.1262 Get It

CD206‐positive myeloid cells bind galectin‐9 and promote a tumor‐supportive microenvironment
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Chatzopoulos, Kyriakos , Butterfield, John T. , Sutor, Shari L., Leontovich, Alexey A. , Nevala, Wendy K. , Flotte, Thomas J. , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Markovic, Svetomir N.

The Journal of Pathology | May 7, 2018 | Volume: 245 | Issue: 4 | Pages: 468-477

10.1002/path.5093 Get It

Abstract In patients with metastatic melanoma, high blood levels of galectin‐9 are correlated with worse overall survival and a bias towards a Th2 inflammatory state supportive of tumor growth. Although galectin‐9 signaling through TIM3 on T cells has been described, less is known about the interaction of galectin‐9 with macrophages. We aimed to determine whether galectin‐9 is a binding partner of CD206 on macrophages and whether the result of this interaction is tumor‐supportive. It was determined that incubation of CD68 + macrophages with galectin‐9 or anti‐CD206 blocked target binding and that both CD206 and galectin‐9 were detected by immunoprecipitation of cell lysates. CD206 and galectin‐9 had a binding affinity of 2.8 × 10 −7 m . Galectin‐9 causes CD206 + macrophages to make significantly more FGF2 and monocyte chemoattractant protein (MCP‐1), but less macrophage‐derived chemokine (MDC). Galectin‐9 had no effect on classical monocyte subsets, but caused expansion of the non‐classical populations. Lastly, there was a positive correlation between increasing numbers of CD206 macrophages and galectin‐9 expression in tumors, and high levels of CD206 macrophages correlated negatively with melanoma survival. These results indicate that galectin‐9 binds to CD206 on M2 macrophages, which appear to drive angiogenesis and the production of chemokines that support tumor growth and poor patient prognoses. Targeting this interaction systemically through circulating monocytes may therefore be a novel way to improve local anti‐tumor effects by macrophages. Copyright © 2018 Pathological Society of Great Britain and Ireland. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Immune checkpoint molecules soluble program death ligand 1 and galectin‐9 are increased in pregnancy
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Harrington, Susan M. , Creedon, Douglas J., Dong, Haidong , Dronca, Roxana , Ruano, Rodrigo , Dronca, Roxana S., Dong, Haidong , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Markovic, Svetomir N.

American Journal of Reproductive Immunology | December 5, 2017 | Volume: 79 | Issue: 2 | Pages: No page available

10.1111/aji.12795 Get It

ProblemPregnancy requires balance between tolerance to the haploidentical fetus and the mother's ability to mount immune responses. There are parallels to this phenomenon that occur in metastatic cancer. We assessed soluble program death ligand‐1 soluble PD‐L1 (sPD‐L1) and galectin‐9 in the blood of pregnant women during gestation as these molecules are highly involved in immune suppression during cancer.Method of studyMaternal blood was collected from 30 primigravida women at monthly intervals during pregnancy, delivery and 6‐week post‐partum. Blood was analyzed for sPD‐L1 and galectin‐9 concentrations by ELISA. Term placentas were collected in formalin and IHC was completed for PD‐L1 and galectin‐9 expression.ResultsMaternal blood levels of sPD‐L1 (0.438 ng/mL) and galectin‐9 (1976 pg/mL) were elevated early in normal pregnancies compared to non‐pregnant controls (0.242 ng/mL and 773 pg/mL, respectively). sPD‐L1 increased throughout gestation, whereas galectin‐9 remained elevated until parturition; both proteins returned to control levels post‐partum. Women carrying male fetuses had significantly higher galectin‐9 levels, but not sPD‐L1, than those carrying females (2263 pg/mL vs 1874 pg/mL; P = .0005). Trophoblast cells of the term placenta coexpress galectin‐9 and PD‐L1.ConclusionImmune‐regulatory molecules galectin‐9 and sPD‐L1 increased during pregnancy and may play a role in immune tolerance that is critical for the fetus.
Survival of cutaneous melanoma based on sex, age, and stage in the United States, 1992–2011
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Moser, Justin C. , Weaver, Amy L. , Brewer, Jerry D., Leontovich, Alexey A. , Shuster, Lynne T., Kottschade, Lisa A. , Olariu, Ariadna, Mansfield, Aaron S. , Dronca, Roxana , Dronca, Roxana S., Mansfield, Aaron S , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Markovic, Svetomir N. , Hieken, Tina J.

Cancer Medicine | September 7, 2017 | Volume: 6 | Issue: 10 | Pages: 2203-2212

10.1002/cam4.1152 Get It

AbstractWomen diagnosed with cutaneous melanoma have a survival advantage compared to men, which has been hypothesized to be due to difference in behavior and/or biology (sex hormones). It remains controversial whether this advantage is dependent on age or stage of disease. We sought to compare melanoma‐specific survival between females in pre, peri, and postmenopausal age groups to males in the same age group, adjusting for stage of disease. This is a retrospective population‐based cohort study using the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) database. Patients diagnosed from 1 January 1992 through 31 January 2011 with primary invasive cutaneous melanoma were included in our cohort. Melanoma‐specific survival was the main outcome studied. Of the 106,511 subjects that were included, 45% were female. Females in all age groups (18–45, 46–54, and ≥55) with localized and regional disease, were less likely to die from melanoma compared to males in the same age group. Among patients with localized and regional disease, the relative risk of death due to melanoma increased with advancing age at diagnosis; this increase was more pronounced among females than males. In contrast, we observed no female survival advantage among patients with distant disease and no effect of age on relative risk of death from melanoma. Females with localized and regional melanoma have a decreased risk of death compared to males within all age groups. Our data show no differences in survival between men and women with metastatic melanoma, indicating that the influence of sex on survival is limited to early stage disease but not confined to pre or perimenopausal age groups.
Galectin-9 modulates immunity by promoting Th2/M2 differentiation and impacts survival in patients with metastatic melanoma
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Nevala, Wendy K. , Holtan, Shernan G. , Leontovich, Alexey A. , Markovic, Svetomir N. , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Holtan, Shernan

Melanoma Research | July 23, 2016 | Volume: 26 | Issue: 5 | Pages: 429-441

10.1097/cmr.0000000000000281 Get It

Galectin-9, a β-galactoside-binding protein, is defined as a negative regulator of T helper 1 (Th1) immune responses, favoring Th2 bias. Systemic immunity in patients with metastatic melanoma is predominantly Th2 biased. We hypothesized that galectin-9 can modulate systemic immunity toward Th2 polarization in patients with advanced melanoma. The presence or concentration of galectin-9 was assessed in tumors and plasma, in patients with metastatic melanoma. The immunomodulatory function of galectin-9 was determined by exposing human peripheral blood mononuclear cells to galectin-9 in vitro. Galectin-9 was expressed in 57% of tumors and was significantly (3.6-fold) increased in the plasma of patients with advanced melanoma compared with healthy controls (P<0.001). High plasma galectin-9 concentration was associated with systemic Th2 polarization and reduced 2-year survival compared with low/no galectin-9 expression. In-vitro, galectin-9 reduced proliferation of healthy peripheral blood mononuclear cells, and promoted Th1 cell apoptosis, Th2-biased cell phenotypes, and cytokine secretion. Galectin-9 also stimulated monocyte differentiation toward an M2 macrophage phenotype, as assessed by chemokine/cytokine secretion and CD206 expression, observed both in vitro as well as in patients with metastatic melanoma. Elevated galectin-9 in patient plasma correlated with Th2 systemic bias and less favorable clinical outcomes for patients with metastatic melanoma. This Th2 bias appears to be not only a feature of the known mechanisms of Th1 apoptosis by T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin-domain containing-3 binding, but also mediated by myeloid cell differentiation toward an M2 phenotype, that favors tumor progression. These data support galectin-9 as a novel therapeutic target for patients with metastatic melanoma.
Growth Modeling of the Maternal Cytokine Milieu throughout Normal Pregnancy: Macrophage-Derived Chemokine Decreases as Inflammation/Counterregulation Increases
Holtan, Shernan G. , Chen, Yiyi , Kaimal, Rajani, Creedon, Douglas J., Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Nevala, Wendy K. , Markovic, Svetomir N. , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Holtan, Shernan

Journal of Immunology Research | March 17, 2015 | Volume: 2015 | Issue: No issue available | Pages: 1-11

10.1155/2015/952571 Get It

Several recent studies have shown differences in the maternal immune milieu at different phases of pregnancy, but most studies have been cross-sectional or of relatively few time points. Levels of 42 cytokines were determined using a multiplex bead-based assay on archived serum from a cohort of pregnant womenN=16at median of 18 time points tested, from the first trimester through to parturition, per woman. Unconditional growth modeling was then used to determine time-dependent changes in levels of these cytokines. Macrophage-derived chemokine (MDC, aka CCL22) decreases as pregnancy progresses. IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8, IL-12p70, IL-13, IL-15, IP-10, and FLT3-ligand increase as a function of gestational weeks, and IFNα2, IL-1ra, IL-3, IL-9, IL-12p40, and soluble CD40 ligand increase as a function of trimester. As pregnancy normally progresses, a maternal shift away from a type 2-biased immune response and toward an inflammatory/counterregulatory response is observed.
Fetal Sex‐Based Differences in Maternal Hormones, Angiogenic Factors, and Immune Mediators During Pregnancy and the Postpartum Period
Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L. , Nevala, Wendy K. , Creedon, Douglas J., Holtan, Shernan G. , Markovic, Svetomir N. , Enninga, Elizabeth Ann L , Holtan, Shernan

American Journal of Reproductive Immunology | August 4, 2014 | Volume: 73 | Issue: 3 | Pages: 251-262

10.1111/aji.12303 Get It

ProblemSeveral pregnancy complications have disparities based on the sex of the fetus. It is unknown whether the sex of the fetus differentially alters the maternal immune milieu, potentially contributing to the observed differences.Method of studyUsing maternal plasma collected during 38 uncomplicated pregnancies (19 males, 19 females), we compared levels of cytokines, sex hormones, and angiogenic factors throughout gestation and postpartum.ResultsMale fetal sex was associated with higher levels of proinflammatory cytokines (G‐CSF, IL‐12p70, IL‐21, and IL‐33) and angiogenic factors (PlGF and VEGF‐A) compared with female fetal sex at multiple timepoints. Female fetal sex was associated with higher levels of regulatory cytokines (IL‐5, IL‐9, IL‐17, and IL‐25). IL‐27 increased throughout pregnancy regardless of fetal sex. There was no fetal sex‐based difference in analyte concentrations at the postpartum measurement.ConclusionWomen carrying a male fetus exhibit a more proinflammatory/proangiogenic immune milieu than women carrying a female fetus.